Judy was fanttastic in this,I think she should have won the Oscar. And she look lovely.I would even say beautiful.She sure sang her heart out in this,as she did in most of her films.I am still so amazed at her limitless talent.
Remarkable job. I loved the way you subtly pulled in the the title of the proto-Star Is Born film "What Price Hollywood?" Personally, I may have have avoided showing the scene of Mason inadvertently slapping Garland -- this packs quite a jolt if you don't know it's coming -- but this is as impressive a job of fan construction as I've ever seen. It is far and away superior to any of the actual Star Is Born trailers!
@mckeldin1961 Kudos to you for spotting that!! :D And yes, I see a lot of things that I might have done differently now, but Mason slapping her seemed one of the better examples of his crumbling life. I appreciate your input!! Thank you very much. :D
This is my favorite Garland movie, as well as my favorite movie of all time. If that uncut version is released, I swear, I will jump for joy! And this trailer of yours is wonderfully done, as good or better than the real promotional trailer. Thanks a lot for this trailer, and for sending me the petition. There is no doubt that we will get to 1000 signatures!
@mr40sfan Thanks so much Logan for your support, I'll keep my fingers crossed about the signatures, we'll see what comes of it. Every single name counts, after all!! :)
I saw this film last night at Grauman's Chinese Theater for the TCM Movie Festival, and it was a fantastic experience. Older films oftentimes get strange comments from the audience, but not this one...Well, there was one when James Mason tells Judy her face is "just dandy!" Certain phrases do change in 60 years! Martin Landau sat in front of me, and he seemed completely engrossed in the film, and was moving in rhythm to the wonderful songs, especially "My Mammy" when Judy sang that song!
meg you really have a talent for this ive never seen in any other person trying to attain this kind of "trailer" look. its beyond stunning! when she walks out on the stage in the beginning, WOW!
Beautifully created and edited. I sure wish I could see the screening at the Chinese in Apri. I don't think I could afford those package prices though.
Judy was fanttastic in this,I think she should have won the Oscar. And she look lovely.I would even say beautiful.She sure sang her heart out in this,as she did in most of her films.I am still so amazed at her limitless talent.
Zander45 2 months ago
an excellent tribute to this wonderful film.....I LOVED James Mason & Judy Garland together....great editing job, thanks so much for sharing!!
MsJune54 3 months ago
A Star Is Born is a wonderful film, and you did it justice with this trailer. Really like the way you edited it!
AmidTheFallingSnow 1 year ago
faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabulous job
evry190 1 year ago
Great job my romantic man
Jeannekm126 1 year ago
OMG how lovely! Good work!
williefogle 1 year ago
A lovely tribute!! Better than the original trailer!!
FLBoy46 1 year ago
This is amazing. I have been searching for a HD trailer. Wow.
Thanks for this.
Brett :-)
bretty1975 1 year ago
Remarkable job. I loved the way you subtly pulled in the the title of the proto-Star Is Born film "What Price Hollywood?" Personally, I may have have avoided showing the scene of Mason inadvertently slapping Garland -- this packs quite a jolt if you don't know it's coming -- but this is as impressive a job of fan construction as I've ever seen. It is far and away superior to any of the actual Star Is Born trailers!
mckeldin1961 1 year ago
@mckeldin1961 Kudos to you for spotting that!! :D And yes, I see a lot of things that I might have done differently now, but Mason slapping her seemed one of the better examples of his crumbling life. I appreciate your input!! Thank you very much. :D
romantic2543 1 year ago
Terrific!!
BobbyRiversTV 1 year ago
Wow, this is really good! This is very professional! Two thumbs up!
fanofmusicals 1 year ago
@fanofmusicals Thank you very, very much.
romantic2543 1 year ago
I think your trailer is the best trailer I've ever seen for A Star is Born, and I've seen them all.
1dpoppyman 1 year ago
@1dpoppyman Wow, really?? That's quite a compliment, thank you.
romantic2543 1 year ago
This is my favorite Garland movie, as well as my favorite movie of all time. If that uncut version is released, I swear, I will jump for joy! And this trailer of yours is wonderfully done, as good or better than the real promotional trailer. Thanks a lot for this trailer, and for sending me the petition. There is no doubt that we will get to 1000 signatures!
--Logan
mr40sfan 1 year ago
@mr40sfan Thanks so much Logan for your support, I'll keep my fingers crossed about the signatures, we'll see what comes of it. Every single name counts, after all!! :)
romantic2543 1 year ago
Signed! :D
singingkid 1 year ago
By the way, the trailer is outstanding! Realized on second viewing that you made this yourself! BRILLIANT job! 5 stars! :)
singingkid 1 year ago
@singingkid Fantastic, thank you!!!
romantic2543 1 year ago
Man I love Judy Garland with all of my heart!
helenajesstarzak 1 year ago
@helenajesstarzak Trust me, so do I. :)
romantic2543 1 year ago
@romantic2543 why wouldent you?! :D :D
helenajesstarzak 1 year ago
I enjoyed this. I responded to the petition that you sent me.
---------Ellen
Shabannie 1 year ago
@Shabannie Thank you so much, I really do appreciate that. :)
romantic2543 1 year ago
I saw this film last night at Grauman's Chinese Theater for the TCM Movie Festival, and it was a fantastic experience. Older films oftentimes get strange comments from the audience, but not this one...Well, there was one when James Mason tells Judy her face is "just dandy!" Certain phrases do change in 60 years! Martin Landau sat in front of me, and he seemed completely engrossed in the film, and was moving in rhythm to the wonderful songs, especially "My Mammy" when Judy sang that song!
RICHARDDAVISMCLEOD 1 year ago
@RICHARDDAVISMCLEOD You are so lucky to have been able to attend that night, what a thrill!! It is such a beautiful film.
romantic2543 1 year ago
Judy was one of the greatest actresses of all times, and she could out sing her daughter Liza with one hand tied behind her back.
Sheri451 1 year ago
@Sheri451 Some people don't like it, but I definitely agree with you. Liza is talented, but Judy was simply spectacular.
romantic2543 1 year ago
AMAZING! BRILLIANT! This movie should have been nominated for Best Picture and Judy should have won Best Actress!
oscarlover100 1 year ago
meg you really have a talent for this ive never seen in any other person trying to attain this kind of "trailer" look. its beyond stunning! when she walks out on the stage in the beginning, WOW!
Garlandfan94 1 year ago
@Garlandfan94 Thanks, Trev - I always like to think of Judy as "timeless". :D
romantic2543 1 year ago
Hey Nutmeg, it's Kitkat!
Wow. Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow! This is professional! I wonder if you could sell it to be a commercial?
blueiydsoul 2 years ago
Thanks so much, KitKat!! ;) I'd love to do something like that, but for fear of copyright, I think that could be an issue.
Sent you a friend invite!
romantic2543 2 years ago
Really Loved It! :)
judygarlandfan94 2 years ago
FRIKEN GENIUS! I TELL YOU ,GENIUS! haha, this trailer should be on television
gosh I really enjoyed watching this, :D gahh I love this movie!!
GOOD JOB. <3
Lizawithaz1246 2 years ago
Thank you so very much - this film is one of my favorites. :)
romantic2543 2 years ago
Beautifully created and edited. I sure wish I could see the screening at the Chinese in Apri. I don't think I could afford those package prices though.
waynegabi 2 years ago
I'm right there with you about the screening and the cost. It will be a magical night, I'll be sorry to miss it.
romantic2543 2 years ago