My friend and I watch the 1939 movie quite often and we do catch many mistakes in the film with props or scenery but I don't think that it should ever be remade. The movie was ahead of it's time for the year it was made and it deserves much respect.
@IdLie32 YES! That would b amazing! Open with Wicked and whenever Dorothy comes in show the Cyclone scene and stuff like that! That would b an amazing movie/stage play!!
This was amazing! Did they do the MGM version of the Stage musical or the other one? There is another one out there but I can't remember, all I remember about it is it plays out like a cheap dollar store version of Wizard Of Oz. From the little bit of clips I saw in this video it looks like the MGM version.
@IdLie32 Once "Wicked" stops making $5Million per week on Broadway, then they'll make a film version of it. Universal Pictures already owns the rights to "Wicked".
However, "The Wizard of Oz" is a classic and still holds out against CG filled movies of today. I don't think they should ever remake it.
@agalant13 The 1939 version is a remake it was orignally done in black and white. There have been other remakes such as TheWiz (Black Actors) and for tv The tinman (on Syfy Channel formerly scifi Channel) and Oz on ice (ice skating version), has also had sequels and paradies on various shows such as That 70's Show with Jackie as Dorothy and Donna as the Witch, Also an episode of Dr. Oz and others.
@hydrolito - The 1939 version is NOT a remake to the extent that I was referring to earlier. The 1939 MGM version with Judy Garland was a musical adaptation of L. Frank Baum's book. The earlier silent films entitled Wizard of Oz were very very loosely based on the book (Dorothy never had a pet cow in Oz). So the 1939 version was not a remake of the silent film, it was a different interpretation of the novel.
The other examples you have given are also interpretations of that same book.
@hydrolito Also, the novel Wicked... is a imagining of Oz worlds. And Gregory McGuire paid homage to L. Frank Baum by naming the Wicked Witch of the West 'Elphaba' based on his name.
The concern expressed earlier was that Robert Zemeckis was going to take the MGM musical version (with all songs like "Over the Rainbow") and do a 3D animation version. That is UNNECESSARY! The original 1939 film still holds up today.
@IdLie32 no they shouldnt as much as i would like to see a remake its never the same they should just should leave it alone and in the high up in the spotlight like its been for over 70 years now in 1985 disney did a movie called return to oz the woman that played in the 1996 movie the CRAFT she plays as dorothy in return to oz which was her very first movie she was in its a pretty good movie i just got it on dvd for my kids to watch on ebay you can get it new for as low $5
@uglypunk16 - you mean remake the Wizard of Oz as a film today? Definitely not! The 1939 is not only a classic but even the FX still hold up after all this time.... can't say that about most early fantasy or Sci-fi films.
Mary Poppins is another film that still stands the test of time... yet I enjoyed what they did with the Broadway version.
@agalant13 Tell this to Warner Brothers. They are doing a remake with Rober Zemeckis directing it. They claim they are basing it closer to the original book. But the public may find this too ponderous and sluggish.
One of the things that the MGM classic did was to preserve the base of the story and enhance it for the motion picture medium. This is one of the times that a movie improved on a story. It works as a musical fanatasy. And it holds up because it has integrity and sincerity.
@agalant13 1933 King Kong was better than the Godzilla vs King Kong done many years later. Some other movies back then such as invisibleman(1933) Gone With the Wind (1939), It's a wonderful life which was originally a box off flop has been repeated numerous times on tv.
@uglypunk16 If you had taken the time to read the blurb under the video, you would have noticed that this was for a theatrical stage production; winning an award for incorporating Animation, Computer Generated FX, and Film Sequences in a live stage production. We clearly state that this was 2005 (making no claim to the original 1939 classic). In fact, in 2005, all but one of the actors from the 1939 MGM film were dead in 2005. Meinhardt Raabe (Munchkin coroner) died recently (April 9, 2010).
Fascinating! The transformation from Miss Gulch to The Wicked Witch was incredible for a stage show. I've always loved plays and movies and I like the behind the scenes stuff just as much. Maybe it's that fine balance between the imagination of the performance we see and get lost in, and the reality that made it happen....
Innovative!, and I like the song to, It's the version from the review "putting it together", that had julie andrews, who was latter replaced by carol burnet.
the songs originaly from "sunday in the park with george"
My friend and I watch the 1939 movie quite often and we do catch many mistakes in the film with props or scenery but I don't think that it should ever be remade. The movie was ahead of it's time for the year it was made and it deserves much respect.
rosiemon 3 months ago 3
@rosiemon I agree!
agalant13 3 months ago
a douche bag made this song... its so annoying!!! but everything it says is true when it comes to film making though
SLuMberMoOn7 4 months ago
Comment removed
SLuMberMoOn7 4 months ago
Sunday in the park to the wizard of oz..... nice.
ManBig4 5 months ago
Heck with the movie scenes ... this music does it for me ... i listen to this every day !
orioncon 5 months ago
I know Wizard of Oz is a classic but I think Peter Jackson or Quentin Tarrantino could pull it off
leegeorgeson 6 months ago
don't forget that spangles are expensive
TheLolifish 6 months ago
how they used green screen with that green face witch? :))
fundasuiuventus 7 months ago
They should NEVER EVEN THINK of "re-making" The Wizard of OZ...if they do it will be a POS compared to the original.
Discoboy504 9 months ago
@Discoboy504 They already remade the Wizard of Oz several times and the most famous version from 1939 was one of those remakes.
hydrolito 8 months ago
@IdLie32 YES! That would b amazing! Open with Wicked and whenever Dorothy comes in show the Cyclone scene and stuff like that! That would b an amazing movie/stage play!!
Red41658 9 months ago
This was amazing! Did they do the MGM version of the Stage musical or the other one? There is another one out there but I can't remember, all I remember about it is it plays out like a cheap dollar store version of Wizard Of Oz. From the little bit of clips I saw in this video it looks like the MGM version.
supahstah85 10 months ago
I feel like they COULD re-do The Wizard of Oz, with all the Wicked stuff combined. But should they?
IdLie32 11 months ago 5
@IdLie32 Once "Wicked" stops making $5Million per week on Broadway, then they'll make a film version of it. Universal Pictures already owns the rights to "Wicked".
However, "The Wizard of Oz" is a classic and still holds out against CG filled movies of today. I don't think they should ever remake it.
agalant13 11 months ago 11
@agalant13 The 1939 version is a remake it was orignally done in black and white. There have been other remakes such as TheWiz (Black Actors) and for tv The tinman (on Syfy Channel formerly scifi Channel) and Oz on ice (ice skating version), has also had sequels and paradies on various shows such as That 70's Show with Jackie as Dorothy and Donna as the Witch, Also an episode of Dr. Oz and others.
hydrolito 9 months ago
@hydrolito - The 1939 version is NOT a remake to the extent that I was referring to earlier. The 1939 MGM version with Judy Garland was a musical adaptation of L. Frank Baum's book. The earlier silent films entitled Wizard of Oz were very very loosely based on the book (Dorothy never had a pet cow in Oz). So the 1939 version was not a remake of the silent film, it was a different interpretation of the novel.
The other examples you have given are also interpretations of that same book.
agalant13 9 months ago
@agalant13 Even the 1939 version was loosely based on it I don't think any version was completely faithful to the original story.
hydrolito 8 months ago
@hydrolito Also, the novel Wicked... is a imagining of Oz worlds. And Gregory McGuire paid homage to L. Frank Baum by naming the Wicked Witch of the West 'Elphaba' based on his name.
The concern expressed earlier was that Robert Zemeckis was going to take the MGM musical version (with all songs like "Over the Rainbow") and do a 3D animation version. That is UNNECESSARY! The original 1939 film still holds up today.
agalant13 9 months ago
@hydrolito Haha that's funny because Mila Kunis is playing the Wicked Witch in Sam Raimi's upcoming film "Oz: The Great and Powerful".
cinemaker006 9 months ago
I don't usually like these self put together things, but this was good, I mean really good, I enjoyed the music as also. Well done
mumandauntyglad 3 months ago
@agalant13 I don't think they should do a remake of the musical, but I would love to see a well made movie of the book, with all the details.
Dragon1813 5 months ago
@IdLie32 no they shouldnt as much as i would like to see a remake its never the same they should just should leave it alone and in the high up in the spotlight like its been for over 70 years now in 1985 disney did a movie called return to oz the woman that played in the 1996 movie the CRAFT she plays as dorothy in return to oz which was her very first movie she was in its a pretty good movie i just got it on dvd for my kids to watch on ebay you can get it new for as low $5
grizzleybearz282004 5 months ago
LOL @ the witch.
nocturnallyinsane 1 year ago
were all on the same page that this never needed to happen at least not like this right?
uglypunk16 1 year ago
@uglypunk16 - you mean remake the Wizard of Oz as a film today? Definitely not! The 1939 is not only a classic but even the FX still hold up after all this time.... can't say that about most early fantasy or Sci-fi films.
Mary Poppins is another film that still stands the test of time... yet I enjoyed what they did with the Broadway version.
agalant13 1 year ago
@agalant13 Tell this to Warner Brothers. They are doing a remake with Rober Zemeckis directing it. They claim they are basing it closer to the original book. But the public may find this too ponderous and sluggish.
One of the things that the MGM classic did was to preserve the base of the story and enhance it for the motion picture medium. This is one of the times that a movie improved on a story. It works as a musical fanatasy. And it holds up because it has integrity and sincerity.
RayPointer 1 year ago
@agalant13 1933 King Kong was better than the Godzilla vs King Kong done many years later. Some other movies back then such as invisibleman(1933) Gone With the Wind (1939), It's a wonderful life which was originally a box off flop has been repeated numerous times on tv.
hydrolito 9 months ago
this is so dumb the original had no green screen
uglypunk16 1 year ago
@uglypunk16 If you had taken the time to read the blurb under the video, you would have noticed that this was for a theatrical stage production; winning an award for incorporating Animation, Computer Generated FX, and Film Sequences in a live stage production. We clearly state that this was 2005 (making no claim to the original 1939 classic). In fact, in 2005, all but one of the actors from the 1939 MGM film were dead in 2005. Meinhardt Raabe (Munchkin coroner) died recently (April 9, 2010).
agalant13 1 year ago
Why?
TheNeonRabbit 1 year ago
@TheNeonRabbit
Why what?
agalant13 1 year ago
is the witch played by a guy
VarietyRocks117 1 year ago
@VarietyRocks117
Ummmm.... no....
agalant13 1 year ago
oh ok np
VarietyRocks117 1 year ago
Amazing looks just like the real movie!
steezypictures 1 year ago
after hearing this music, thank god for rock and roll...
mohawksaresexy2 1 year ago
What the hell? lol
ageshero 1 year ago
fantastic! please could you give me some more details where it was played, when, how long etc.... thx! :) thumbs up!
SunnySunshine77 1 year ago
Awesome, is tihs a play..? For ours, we have real flying FX ( Strings LMAO) Although, we are professional.
mikesmikeisscool 1 year ago
Fascinating! The transformation from Miss Gulch to The Wicked Witch was incredible for a stage show. I've always loved plays and movies and I like the behind the scenes stuff just as much. Maybe it's that fine balance between the imagination of the performance we see and get lost in, and the reality that made it happen....
OKSteve 2 years ago
i love your costumes and your oz.
tylerbfw 2 years ago
i was there with my school
MrBoydLee 2 years ago
Innovative!, and I like the song to, It's the version from the review "putting it together", that had julie andrews, who was latter replaced by carol burnet.
the songs originaly from "sunday in the park with george"
cool morph from miss gulch to the witch.
etraig 2 years ago
What is the song at 2:34?
oOWickedRulesOo 3 years ago
It's still the song "Putting it Together" the music changes at 3:19 for the cyclone sequence.
agalant13 3 years ago
That's cool
LovettSweeney 3 years ago
the witch looks very awsome!
TheWizardofodd12 3 years ago