Added: 3 years ago
From: musicloveraustria2
Views: 337,036
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (281)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • He neve really had the choice to live his life the way he wanted - if you could ask his Mom she would tell you he was robbed. Anyone who questions the addict has never felt the pain. Just appreciate his music and pray no one you love falls into the downward spiral of mental disease.

  • Comment removed

  • Townes came from a very wealthy family in Texas. He just didn't care about money etc. He lived his life to the fullest. I have been following him, Gram, Steve Earle, Guy Clark, all of those wonderful musicians. I saw him and Guy Clark at a small club in NC. They were great!!!!

  • @sherelaine

    I love the man's music, but he was no hero and drank himself to death. I don't think, in the end, he lived life to the fullest. I have been around too many addicts and drunks to want to glorify that aspect of his life. And I think Steve would agree, now that he has been clean for years.

  • @darlincommitme He lived and died just like he wanted to; what's the problem?

  • @darlincommitme I was gonna say something ugly, but how can you while listening to TVZ

  • @GCandD

    I hope you didn't take what I said as negative... I love Townes' music and respect his artistic integrity. I just think it is dangerous to idealize the way he lived his life, and not recognize that he was deeply troubled. I have known people who use artists like Townes to justify their own self-destructive behavior, as if art requires it.

  • M.Jagger and K.R. always stated for the record that Townes was instrumental in the final cut of the song.they had thrown it around for a long time with no thread and Townes helped to tidy it up.I believe this to be true.

  • @jaxareback

    Do you have a source? I have heard Gram Parsons was involved, which makes sense since he was hanging around them then. I have never heard anything authoritative about Townes even meeting the Stones in 1970-71, much less being in London when they were recording. Townes was just scraping by, back and forth between Texas, Colorado and Nashville in the early 70s, from what I have read. I have also seen a interviews where Keith talked about the it without mention of Townes or Gram.

  • Thank you for posting this, musicloveraustria2.

  • He kinda looks like Roger Waters in this vid

  • Oh but you know I could never be alone.

  • sorry i totally posted that out of ignorance, honestly thought that tvz wrote it, never knew he paid tribute to the stones! i guess in my mind it sounded like something he wrote.

  • Comment removed

  • @towleyman

    What makes you think that the Stones didn't write Dead Flowers... especially when Townes attributed it to the Stones on the album. You seem like someone who cares about music, so you might want to do some research and start reading liner notes instead of trusting rumors.

  • THE DUDE ABIDES

  • One of the few performers who can do justicve to a Stones cover.

  • @jbstonesfan

    Steve Earle's cover of "Dead Flowers" is great as well.

  • Turn on, drop out, tune in.

  • I suspect we´re a few millions, most of us probably teens in the glorious heroic 60´s

    time of birth of the most important sociopolitical movement of the last 20 centuries......HIPPIES

    YEAHHH; RIGHT ON

    

  • @comaradella toot your own horn much? Most important? Maybe because they got so fucked up on drugs that they forgot that there was a world going on around them. Fuck the baby-boomers! It is their fault the world is in the shape it is in right now. Hippies were (and are still) the paradigm for social excess and mass disorder. They gobbled up "the man's" bait hook-line-and-sinker thinking the whole time that they were doing things on their own free will. All they did was confuse themselves.

  • @Ostehout

    You seem to be a very sorry person, probably lacking love or even not knowing how to please a lady.

  • you're not alone spinch

  • Is the second guitar player a complete midget, or is that the largest guitar ever built? Does anyone know the source of the live recording of this that has a semi-electric backing and has the crowd noise and breaking bottles in the background?

  • Townes at his worst is Townes at his best !! god we've killed them all.

  • @dannyknapp

    Much as I love his music... I think Townes is responsible for his own fate to a large degree (not to mention genetics).

  • up to pismo

  • Ugh... The song is not supposed to be sad.. Why do these "artists" always get that wrong?..

  • @roo7227

    needle and a spoon,funerals, dead flowers, another girl to take the pain away, seems pretty sad to me. But its good that we have a self appointed spokesman for the song to let the rest of us know how to feel about it.

  • @kingacree Yeah, and Mick is saying that all of this is still better than you!.. Which is why she keeps sending dead flowers, dummy..

  • @roo7227

    That is how you hear it... but it doesn't mean others interpretations are wrong. Yeah, it is a kiss off to the woman, but it is still a blues song musically and thematically. And if you have experience with dope, you wouldn't see this as a happy song.

  • And I would add that as one of the best country blues interpreters, Townes is a great interpreter of the song.

  • @darlincommitme If I have experience with dope?.. First of all, I've done enough "dope" to bring down a fricken elephant.. The point is, you and I have been speaking the same language since we were toddlers, and there's no mistaking what the point of the song is.. People just seem to latch onto a single verse in the song that was inserted at Keith's insistence.. The song is about a womanizer, not drugs..

  • @roo7227

    You are right, I shouldn't make assumptions about your experience. As for the rest, we have had that conversation. Your arrogance in is what irritates me. I have already said I think it is both a kiss off and a drug song. You might be right, but you don't "know" the meaning, or even that it was Mick's song with one line by Keith (there are also rumors it was Keith and Gram, with little from Mick) unless you are a friend of Mick's.

  • @kingacree listen up guys....we are just natures toys......so dont take it too seriously.........we're just passin thru so live it to the full. im 54 ride a 1000cc sports bike...why? cos why the fuck not. who wrote the rulebook of ilfe....you do,i do we all do....we write our own book. some just dont have the balls to do it or prefer to hide from it but guess what.....yeah right!!!! we are all dying ....just at different speeds.

  • @roo7227 no its sad...

  • @roo7227 It is indeed a VERY sad song. and also beautiful...comes to mind La Pietá a very sad sculpture by Michelangelo, shows the virgin Mary holding his dead son, sad AND beautiful, as art often is.

  • 4 dislikes? This aggression will not stand, man.

  • The kind ole drunken, glue sniffer could sure grab ya by the heart...I say that in the context of admiration as well as awe.

  • This is one of those songs only The Stones (greatest band ever) can play.

  • @DJBeastFromTheEast Towns Does damn good! and this is a stones fan talking.No one is making you watch this video,.......you can leave and stop acting like Nagging beatles fans acts.

  • @DJBeastFromTheEast

    Yeah, well, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

  • @DJBeastFromTheEast ordinarily i'd agree. check out the Big Lebowski. its a movie. as the credits role it plays a version of this song by Townes thats better than any Stones version i've heard. But i think they're both really good. Kieth and Townes are very similar except that Townes is cold dead and buried, and Kieth is cold dead and someone forgot to bury him.

  • ....Townes Lives!!!!

  • Fuck it dude, let's go bowling.

  • so hard to disentangle this song with the scene from big lebowski

  • stones' version is 100x better!

  • Thanks to the Stones - Love to Townes!

  • @nevillejking Yes! He is great and does a wonderful version

  • love this version.  RIP TVZ

    Screw the 4 dudes who don't abide.

  • 4 dudes don't abide..

  • Take it easy, Dude.. I know that you will..

    Yeah, well.. You know.. The Dude abides...

  • that's at De Melkweg in amsterdam, right? I've got the video tape, great show (1st part), then... some problmes. oh Townes, happt birthday!

    M

  • kinda disappointed he censored himself

  • intense

    

  • Donny der das Bowlen liebte...

  • The dude abides.

  • @Heff385 the dude certainly abides!

  • hey do you get teary eyed when you hear the late great townes van zandt sing or what or is it just me ???

  • @spinch1488 It's not just you man. Aside from the sad beauty of this song, the fact that it was the last song in the last scene of the Big Lebowski, which was played post Donny-death, gets me right in the heart.

  • Comment removed

  • @spinch1488 It is not just you spinch, if you have a pulse and you listen, you will choke up when you hear TVZ

  • @spinch1488 no he is the best all of his stuf is good

  • @spinch1488 Not just you, friend.

  • @spinch1488 Not just you, my friend. Not just you.

  • Townes forgot the lyrics in this song for 2 reasons. The first being he had memory problems due electroshock therapy, the second being he may have been drunk/high. In the documentaries about Townes, many of his friends stated that in his later years he often lost his place during song. On several occasions Blaze Foley would jump in and steer him back on the right course. Townes was a genius, but a troubled one. R.I.P.

  • what the fuck does anything have to do with vietnam?

  • @cspencer90 Dude Im sorry...

  • Best version. Great. Thanks for posting!

  • in the thumbnail he looks like dennis leary. anyone else think that?

  • I completely agree! The Dude Abides!

  • Why is there a gap in the lyrics from 2:13-2:20. The lyrics for that section are

    "Well when you're sitting back in your rose pink Cadillac

    Making bets on Kentucky Derby Day

    *Ah, I'll be in my basement room with a needle and a spoon*

    And another girl to take my pain away"

    What's up with that, people cuss and curse, mention sex here and there, but this song with a powerful expression of agony, loneliness and love lost is edited?

  • @pmarti1000

    Probably meant something to him, and he didn't want to sing it. Sometimes you avoid emotions.

  • @pmarti1000

    I don't think it is editingor that he was avoiding the emotions, I think Townes forgot the lyrics. He was certainly not someone to edit a song. He was a genius, but he was also an alcoholic who was not always the best on stage. There used to be a better version of this on youtube witht he sound synched properly, and it seemed like he was humming at that point.

  • @nilradem

    live music...you get what you get. Yer not in a studio. That's a large piece of the beauty part. Live performance. Performers are human. Whether he forgot the lyrics...or hummed 'em...as was mentioned...'cause he didn't want to sing 'em...what have you, however I don't personally think so. AND, I don't figure it was an editing thing. It's live.

    My thoughts are...yer over figuring it.

    Let it roll.

  • @MarchDad

    No need to be rude. I was simply responding to the comment that it was edited. I know it is live. No "over figuring."

  • clearly, "he doesn't roll on shabbos"......

  • This rascals awesome.

  • You tube is hilarious. this is quintessential Stones.. Sticky Fingers is an awesome album. This guy has covered the song very well .. but come on ! You're havin a laff if you're debating on here who wrote this song ! Embarrassing !

  • @HarryPowell7 It's funny, because when I heard the stones version I thought, "What a bunch of hacks," but then when I realized they actually wrote it, I was cool with Townes covering it. Who knows why. It makes no sense. It's just Townes. He can do what he wants and it's all cool.

  • What's this day of rest shit? This bullshit? I don't fucking care! It don't matter to Jesus. You may fool those fucks in the League Office, but you don't full the Jesus. Bush League psych-out stuff. Laughable man, Ha Ha!

  • This guy is a lousy lip-syncer.

  • me encanta esta versión, la hace propia

  • The Dude Abides.

  • Mick Jagger and Keith Richards may have wrote it. But Townes gave this song a real life feel like Jagger never could. He actually lived the song and to our loss he also died it.

  • Good job!

  • Everybody knows that it's a Stones song originally. So what, Townes never claimed it was his, he just made it his.

  • @jiggler64 You're an idiot. What the hell are you jiggling, jiggler64

  • @jiggler64 You're an idiot

  • Where does this rumor that Townes wrote the song keep resurfacing from? I have never seen anyone cite a source. I would think Townes fans would have the album, and Townes clearly attributes it to the Stones there. In fact, it is an album that is almost entirely covers. His liner notes say they are songs he wished he had written.

    And to jiggler64 - it is called a cover. Townes may not have written this, but he was one of the best sonwriters of his generation.

  • @darlincommitme

    I should add that I am not counting JimmyG's citing WIkipedia as citing a source. He is obviously a troll since he carefully took one line out of context. The article is clear the it is a Stones original. It says they recorded it in '71 but then stopped singing it live until 89.

  • The stones might have released it first but if you hear Townes version on the roadsongs album, you can hear that Townes perfected it.(just my opinion)

    \\// peace, love, happiness

  • It was the Stones who wrote this! And someone censored this version. They muted " a needle and a spoon" in the 2nd verse. I do think Townes does the best rendition.

  • @quatz52

    It's not censored - It is a live version, and Townes forgot the words - it is more clear when you see the video and audio synched. There used to be a better version up here.

  • @JimmyGtunes Before the Stones what??? If you read below you will see that the Stones put it on Sticky Fingers which came out in April 1971 .... Damn man if your not stupid how come you can't read the whole Wikipedia entry?

  • If anyone could find a way to sync up the video with the audio, this would be amazing. But, considering Townes was too messed up to remember the lyrics, I guess it's appropriate.

  • @JimmyGtunes Jagger and Richards wrote it dude. In 1970. Believe it or not, they did do a thing or two original. You probably think Johhny Cash wrote "Hurt" too. Talk about looking stupid...

  • It does'nt matter that it was written by someone else. All good songs get covered. That's why you hear so many artist covering Townes works. Just sit back and enjoy the soul coming through on every song that he sings.

  • this song was written by Townes Van Zant and the stones recorded it

  • @mytaylor310 wrong ...stones all the way .....

  • frankie miller does this song good :)

  • TOWNES

  • My hero

  • Man, Townes forgot that line, did you hear that?

  • @TheEndKing I'll be in my room, with a needle and a spoon!!! It was probably a TV show and they wouldn't let him sing it!!! Censoring b^$&*rds!!!

  • @TheEndKing Maybe he didn't want to say it.

  • Donny was a good bowler, and a good man. He was one of us. He was a man . Lord, you took him, as you took so many bright flowering young men at Khe Sanh, at Langdok, at Hill 364. These young men gave their lives. And so would

    Donny. Donny, who loved bowling. And so, Theodore Donald Karabotsos, in accordance with what we think your dying wishes might well have been, we commit your final mortal remains to the bosom of the Pacific Ocean, which you loved so well. Good night, sweet prince.

  • @ajarnbilly1 Everything's a fuckin travisty with you, what the fuck was that about Viatnam what does anything have to do with Viatname!

  • @ajarnbilly1 Awesome dude.

  • mick can make you sick, gimme Townes.

  • @ajarnbilly1 So here's to Donny, the good bowler and a good man. Those of us who survived Khe Sanh and the surrounding mountains, we have to pay our respects to our buddies who didn't make it back home. Goodbye Donny.

  • @ajarnbilly1 "he fixes the cable?"

  • @ajarnbilly1 WALTER!

  • @ajarnbilly1 Everything's a f*^kin' travesty with you, man!

  • @ajarnbilly1 ahhhhhhhhh. Shut The Fuck up Donny!!! You have no clue.I told that kraut a fucking thousand times that I don't roll on Shabbos!

  • @ajarnbilly1 Ha! Beautiful dude, love this movie!!!

  • @ajarnbilly1 such an awesome movie.

  • @ajarnbilly1 nice man, well said, write a line for me when I leave

  • @ajarnbilly1 fantastic

  • @ajarnbilly1 Fantastic, im Jacki Treehorn how is youse?!?!?!?!

  • Donny, who loved bowling. And so, Theodore Donald Karabotsos, in accordance with what we think your dying wishes might well have been, we commit your final mortal remains to the bosom of the Pacific Ocean, which you loved so

    well. Good night, sweet prince.

  • danahall5558 Incorrect murpleturkey is correct. Townes had covers too Roadsongs is an album released singersongwriter Townes Van Zandt in 1993.

    "These songs were recorded over a number of years in joints all over America. I wish I'd written every one. No such luck. This collection represents a lot of love and fun."This is off of the liner notes for Townes album Roadsongs. Note he says that he wishes that he had written every one of these songs but that he didnt. Dead Flowers is on here

  • #deadflowers

  • Dude.

  • Townes obviously understood the mindset behind this song!

  • one of the best songs ever written in my books. His version of it is better than the stones original.

  • love!!! greatest song writer of all time....

  • Did he write this song?

  • @gordondelma

    You will see people saying he did, but no, this is a Rolling Stones song, co-written by Richards and Jagger.

  • RIP Townes

  • Amazing one, so smooth, so soulful. And a perfect ending for a perfect film.

  • Hendrix forgot an entire verse of Like a Rolling Stone at the Monterey Pop Fest, and like he said, yeah I know I forgot a verse, so what....

  • who gives a shit who hears what where, I'm 23 but I've delved into the oldies over the past few months and artists like townes and blaze are impressing me more than most, timeless

  • you dont know it because its not in your age category. you get all your info from movies and wickpedia. this was our info. life talent. not video makeovers.

  • in his later years he was always doing shows under the influence of heroin

  • @joeyjobear yeah what we see as genius is often coupled with torturous thoughts...easily forgotten when one imbibes...there seems to be a cost for gifts bestowed...this was not just some drunk, some junkie, he was trying to get by...I think I can in a way empathize.

  • @joeyjobear this is a guy who suffered in life! absolute genius with poetry and music, not bad for someone on heroin & whatever else was going round, someone who'd been given electro shock therapy, thrown himself off a balcony...just to feel what flying felt like etc... if any of your clean shiney musicians who are straight outta drama school could pull the work of townes off, il eat my johnny cash finger!

  • Who gives a flying fig who stole/borrowed it? No one on here knows the truth that's for sure. They're both excellent songs and I'm too busy enjoying them to care

  • Sucks the only reason people know or like this song is because of a movie.

  • @metalmachineliar not me.

  • that aint the only reason i know it. Rolling Stone's Sticky Fingers is.

  • @metalmachineliar whatever dude, if yr talking about lebowski it's a good flick. and anyway townes is a legend. anyone who hears one song can see this.

  • skipped over the "needle and a spoon" line. on purpose...?

  • @mistermendola

    I doubt it - I think he forgot the lyrics. He seems a little out of it here.

  • very likely haha

  • i think hes just fucked up and forgot it.

  • Not sure if I am feeding trolls,,, but I have never seen any evidence that Townes gave or sold this to the Stones. No interview with Brian Jones and no claim by Townes or his estate. I don't think it was beyond the Stones to take a song and I am more a fan of Townes, but if you do a search, all you find is people repeating an unfounded rumor. It might be true that Parson's influenced the song, as he was hanging with the Stones. I suspect that the two have been conflated in this rumor.

  • i like this better than the stone's version. it might be that i grew watching big lebowski

  • The Rolling Stones did it first. Its on Sticky Fingers. Townes though makes it his own, so much so that many people believe that he wrote it about himself. Thats one mark of a great performer. He makes everything his own.

  • Gram Parsons was the same way. He came from a super rich florida family and decided to get supremely fucked up for the rest of his life.

  • I knew Townes enough to know that thompmb is exactly right. I

  • Jivezilla, he only had a hard life because he chose to. He was born with money and decided to walk away from it, and chose to drink heavily and use drugs. I'm a huge fan of Townes, but that's the truth. If I'm not mistaken, most of the Stones have had similar issues. It's a miracle that Keith Richards is still alive. And the Stones did write some really good songs.

  • Well, sort of made a decision. I think having shock therapy at a young age and having your memory erased might have had something to do with the "decision" to drink. Being what is now considered bipolar might have contributed to the way his life turned out.

  • jagger wrote most of the lyrics about getting old, keith chipped in. this is a cover. the real argument is whether its a richards/parsons song.

  • Dead Flowers" is a song written by Mick Jagger and Keith Richards of the rock and roll band The Rolling Stones off their 1971 album Sticky Fingers

  • @Jivezilla yeah, keith didnt lose a child, have a rough upbringing, have his gardener shoot himself in his bed with his gun after an affair with his wife, and no way did they have a lot of love for country music. townes didnt write his most famous song, fucking tragic huh? well thats life kids. the stones wrote KILLER songs.

  • @lysergicdeez , you are incorrect about the Stones and country music. You're also clueless about Townes' authorship of his most famous song.

  • rolling stones cover? Go kill yourself!!!

  • it IS a rolling stones cover. the stones wrote it and recorded it first.

  • @murpleturkey No, I am afraid you are incorrect. You may not realize it,but Townes Van Zandt is one of the two best songwriters in America. And he is gone.  The only one left is Bob Dylan.

  • @danahall5558 Yes, Townes was one of the greatest American songwriters, but no he did not write Dead Flowers. You have an internet connection, you have access to allmusic etc., go figure it out for yourself.

  • @danahall5558 dont forget Neil Young

  • @mytaylor310 Mr. Young is a canuck

  • @murpleturkey a canuck that has lived in the staes longer than he lived in CANADA. Still he does retain his citizenship in the Great white North.

  • @danahall5558 I think you forgot about Lou Reed. He's as great as Dylan and Townes IMHO..

  • @danahall5558 I believe you are forgetting Lou Reed.

  • @danahall5558 Well, it's a bit difficult to rank and quantify when it comes to art. I would put Springsteen head and shoulders above either you mentioned.

  • @murpleturkey Everybody knows that.

  • @murpleturkey Duh

  • @TalamoxSmith If you would take the time to read back a few comments you would see that no, not everybody knows that it's a Stones cover. In fact, many people think Townes wrote it. And I agree that Townes recorded the definitive version, so no need to get all indignant on everyone.