Tchaikovsky： Violin Concerto 3rd mvmt

[takumyama]

I have highly enjoyed and appreciated her performance!! however I have to say her interpretation appears a bit too much of uniqueness or rather simply her own originality...So it means at the same time it lacks the general "authenticity" as the greatest of masterpieces of our possible musical experiences.

[no1knowledge]

@takumyama

Viva la difference, modern musicians are taught to accent their own artistic interpretation of the music they are playing and Hyun Su-Shin plays this wonderfully well, I love her interpretation and it looks like many other youtube members do as well.

[Scotelgas]

Shin Hyun-Su of South Korea seems to be able to make her violin sing in such a vibrant way whilst playing this famous music, would love to see her play live .

[Scotelgas]

Wow and omg !

This is a fantastic piece of music played by the Lady violinist so well, just love it .

[lovesarahchang]

So Crisp and sharp and full of vitality , so very different to many other versions of this famous movement. I like This style of playing by Hyun Su- Shin so much.

[no1knowledge]

WOW, this is just such a great performance and deserves a standing ovation.

Its my favourite on youtube of this 3rd movement of Tchaikovskys Violin Concerto.

If the competiton had been judged on this music alone, then the talented Virtuosa,

Hyun Su-Shun would have won by a mile, Bravo ^^

[CLASSICAListheWAY]

What year was this masterpiece filmed?

[lovemetu]

@CLASSICAListheWAY

Its from the XII Tchaikovsky international violin competition, staged in the Moscow International House of Music between 12th June to 30th June 2007. This competition takes place every 4 years along with Piano, Viola and singing competitions.

Despite this wonderful performance Hyun-Su Shin from South Korea did not win, her finishing place was 5th.

The winner was another young lady, Mayuko Kamio from Japan.

[MssFlautista]

@lovemetu competition takes place every 4 years with piano, violin, cello and singing competitions

[lovemetu]

@MssFlautista

Yes of course you are very right. I am afraid my mistake was due to spending too much time late at night , in fact into the early hours on the pc causing over tiredness and a brain crashdown !! At least I answered the other persons Question of ' What year was this masterpiece filmed' correctly !!

Did you enjoy this performance by Hyun Su-shin ? I think it is wonderful and I would love to see her play live in uk.

[lovemetu]

@MssFlautista

By the way ,may I say that I just looked at your channel and its very good . Your downloads are very nice and I very much enjoyed enjoyed watching the Mozart Flute Concerto in G Major. Is that you playing ?

If so well done on your very fine performance !!

[MssFlautista]

@lovemetu Hey! I'm Portuguese.. sorry about my english. I must say that I think your channel was especially made for me xD I love your videos.. actually, I have watched all of them before I 'know' you, so... it's funny :D

yeah, it's me at the Mozart, and all of the other videos. I have one more video wuth orchestra (Malcolm Arnold - concerto for flute and strings) but I didn't upload it yet..

Nice you enjoyed my channel.. because I REALLY enjoyed yours!!!

mssFlautista

[lovemetu]

@MssFlautista

Well my channel is nothing special, just a few videos that I like of many varied tastes. I am not a musician like yourself !! Thanks for the compliment about my video choices, as you are now a friend I will send you a personal message soon !!

.

[lovemetu]

I would love to hear Hyun Su-Shin play more of the famous violin pieces eg the Bruch violin violin concerto, vivaldi 4 seasons, bach air on the g string etc to see how she matches against my favourite ' Sarah Chang' She is certainly shaping up to be up there with the top rankers on this performance. Well worth travelling a long way to see and listen to !!

[seomoonho]

She is a Amazing player who I have met^^

[lovemetu]

How did she not walk the competition after this performance, I have listened to the winner and I prefer Shin Hyun-Su by a mile, just love this version, fantastic lady violinist !!

[lovemetu]

Reminds me of the old beer advert............... to misquote,

'This refreshes parts that other violinist's dont reach'

Sharp, precise and vibrant and with plenty of bite, just perfect !!

[lovemetu]

Reminds me of the old beer advert............... to misquote,

'This refreshes parts that other violinist's dont reach'

[najune01]

she's feeling the music. it comes through her music. ahh.. this is so good

[85Pharmacist]

I love it. It tickles my brain.

[85Pharmacist]

This is superb.

[RaiderEleven]

Bravo. What a marvelous virtuoso who can get a distinctive expression from her violin. I've looked for her recordings, but no luck so far. Incredible musician and a great orchestra. The eventual winner was a young Japanese violinist named Mayuko Kamio, so you can see the competition was indeed challenging. Held in Moscow.

[ivthreadp1102]

You should of seen her play last night... She was amazing. I hope she wins the Indianapolis Violin Comp... winner is announced tonight at 11:15pm.

[lealee24]

who is performing this?

i really like her playing a LOT

[lovemetu]

Yes great performance,my favourite for this piece though is by Sarah Chang and that is on youtube and she was only 12 years old when she recorded that .Sarah is now 29 .

[bbbartolo]

a kind of bouncy syncopation I hadn't heard in other versions. altogether winning, though. another huge talent for the world's stage! cute too.

[serafinichess]

freeqwer's comment "a soloist needs to be subservient to the music, not the music.. to the player" reminds of that old Gilbert & Sullivan line "where the earth of a dusty today is the dust of an earthy tomorrow" and makes just about as much sense. (But gosh, it does sound profound if you just swallow it without thinking about it...)

[TitinioBayagbag]

Did she win?

[MyMemories19]

She's a great performer, but I think the ending needs to be more powerful and vibrant. It could have been played with triple forte. I love her phrasing and varying dynamics.

[hyeinee]

Her violin sounds fantastic... I wonder who the maker is....

[lflarry1]

@hyeinee I'm pretty sure that she plays a Guadagnini.

[jazzecca2007]

good job =). wow only 22 years old... we'll see more of her that's for sure.

[yukikoforevernoise]

haha . . . I must be learning a lot at the music school I attend; before attending I wouldn't have known The Rite of Spring from Adagio for Strings (exaggeration) but all of sudden I find myself realizing this was Tchaik without seeing the title, I thought I had clicked on her performance of the Stravinsky Concerto and at about 1:50 with all those big chords especially, I was thinking "man Stravinsky sounds an awful lot like Tchaik in this movement", haha . . .

[frankcisyarmi]

ella estuvo genial increible sonido y tecnica e interpretacion shin hyon su!!!!!!!

[freeqwerqwer]

Her bow strokes are fabulous, so much enjoyable to listen to. Her fast brush strokes are gorgeous, unlike anyone else. She doesn't let out too much sentimentality. She plays well but doesn't graps the russian soul of this concerto yet. Also, near the end, she is too controlling which, in my opinion, is too ego centric and a turn off to many listeners.. A soloist need to be subservient to the music, not the music subservient to the player.

[atrumdecretum]

constructive criticism, people giving this comment thumbs down should learn the difference.

[abonkaisou]

動き過ぎ。でも上手い。

[chumbaracing]

she rocks!

[takhirviolinest]

I'm not winner of competition I not participed but I suggest you listen my playing of Tchaikvovsky concerto

[takhirviolinest]

You did good job,

[PIPE3GUTI]

ella es la ganadora,siii win

[dalba44]

What's her name?

This is INCREDIBLE.

[joosangbai]

dalba; her name is hyon-su shin, born in 1987 in korea, violin prodigy, watch her playing "wieniawski variation" . yes INCREDIBLE.

[dalba44]

I just watched the Weiniawski Variation. She is unbelievable, her precision, timing, rhythm, passion... it's all there. Thanks for the reply.

[atrumdecretum]

my god she's my age, if only we could all be prodigies skush skush

[takhirviolinest]

Shin Hyon-Su she is Finalist of Xlll Tchaikovsky conpetition. I like her version more She play with out cut. Not like someboy (like winner's who paly with cut and not Tchaikovsky, Really Tchaikovsky is Boris Gutnikov's playing (Winner 2nd competition (I thin winner in 1962)

[xXLeafXNinjaXx]

i know its called the tchaikovsky competition and that the tchaikovsky violin concerto is amazing, but dont you think that the judges would get bored hearing the same piece OVER AND OVER again every year? brilliant performance though

[noaxioma]

I've been listening to this concerto for over 15 years, almost daily and I'm still not bored...

Indeed a fantastic performance!

She rules...

Take care

[tupa670]

the Tchaikovsky competition happens every four years so I think listening to it every four years is not much of a problem

[vlhere]

As long as new faces come up with new , fesh and diffrent interpretations, the judges and in fact the world wont cease to stop listening to classical music. Classical music is timeless, it will never die, not all may like it but it will alwayys be CLASSIC. Pop stars rise and fall and so does their music but never the works of such great Maestros.

[jason101other]

This is a truly wonderful performance. This performance is as good or better than a lot of the recordings of the Tchaikovsky that we have available to us.

[Painkilaxx]

chinese with violins suck

[jin12345678]

I like this interpretation very much. very nice.

[Penguines]

I love this movement.

[yellotheemcee]

she messes up somewhere around 530 sumshit...

[violinRL]

damn what are you talking about? i tried so hard to listen to her "mistake" what exact seconds and min?

[iluminada333]

Wow she is really amazing and whoever is making these bad comments about her are just trying to mess with her. Congratulations; even if you didn't get the first place you created such a beautiful thing ^_^.

[cageynerd]

should have won... ugh

[unclejuniorsoprano]

God Forbid! The concerto proceeds in a regular fashion, it is musical and not without inspiration, then crudeness again gains the upper hand. The violin is no longer played; it is torn asunder, beaten black and blue. This 3rd movement plunges us into the brutal, deplorable merriment of a Russian holiday carousal. We see savages, vulgar faces, hear course oaths and smell fusel-oil. The concerto brings to mind the hideous idea that there may be music which stinks to the ear.

Ed

[Drummin4theHighest]

oh wow.

you got heck of vocabulary there.

nice. haha

[ilyaseleznyov]

haha i think the summation of his paragraph can be achieved by a simple statement.

"I like slow music"

[calloffthedogs]

This comment is full of plagerism. be careful.

[yellotheemcee]

what the hell!!??!! this concerto is awesome to play

although it does get crappier at the end...

and you plagueraized like half of it...

how do you hate it??

[DrParkMD517]

@ calloffthedogs and yellotheemcee, at least he had the nerve to sign this comment with Eduard Hanslick's name.

But you unclejunior, I would assume that it were your ears that were torn asunder, beaten black and blue by savages with vulgar faces in that you cannot enjoy this classical masterpiece.

[violinRL]

why did everyone make this a negative comment? he is quoting its first reviews...

[vino122]

she is so beautiful

[homiji2003]

i love her dress, too!

and of course she is obviously an extremely accomplished player!

[mozartpaganini]

Le falta dominar algunos pasajes, ademas desafina, varias notas...

[xAnnaXP]

Um this isn't Tchaikovsky? Or I'm like pretty sure its not.

[mshakhz]

...no comment...

[zhoudaniell]

of course it is

[austinViolaboy]

LoL! no comment from too

[violinca]

yikes... is this comment really on this wall!?

[puccini4711]

big sonor sound,and very clear,is very good for this pice,very good perfomance.

[bobkytohago]

what?

i really like her interpretation of this movement!

its clear, technical and ROUGH!

i think it's just unfair to say that she stinks, and i do agree that there may have been some issues regarding the cooperation between the orchestra and the soloist..

anyway, GREAT JOB!

[alexongcs]

Not good! Her violin sounds like a Opera Singer, which doesn't suit this music at all! How could she even get 5th place?!? This is a failure. I am very shocked to see this in a Tchaikovsky competition!

[fraggleferret]

Doesn't have the technique, creativity, or stage presence to pull off soloing. Not impressed.

[dragonhidepker]

she placed 5th

[song54234]

she is good but her behind.. terrible... they are not listening each other..

[Drummin4theHighest]

weird; i think they were fine until 6:39 when they seems to have lost the tempo. Everyone here says that they did bad. iono. i love classical pieces but ain't sao knowledgeable about it. can anyone explain why it is so bad??

[masael255]

One thing I particularly noticed is the orchestra didn't play as if there were a soloist. As my conductor always said, "A whole orchestra against one isn't a fair fight." Next they're playing like it's a symphony not a concerto; they don't listen to her interpretation at all. My biggest gripe is they play very robotic. It's almost like a synthesizer is behind her.

[Sviolinist]

I agree masael, the orchestra is playing very loud during the solo passages, and is dominating in Forte tutti-ish passages. Good point, sir.

[violinRL]

i know the orchestra isn't the greatest, but its a competition. the tchaik competition. do you know how many time the orchestra must have to accompany a violinist? each one with his/ her own interp. it must be very repetitive to the orch. but yeah...they were a little too loud.

[masael255]

That's true and maybe that is part of the test too; learning to work with your group regardless of who they are. :P

[reinux]

The orchestra is god awful. It's not even particularly big, yet they seem not to hear each other at all.

I don't think that's why she lost though; I think it's probably because of the vanilla-ness of how she plays. Personally I don't like listening to over-decorated performances, but I think competition judges are always looking for people who try to one-up the composer.

[pianisteugene]

It is SO SO SO SO SO CLEAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[curlyman217]

where did she place?

[PIPE3GUTI]

ella deberia haber ganado

[violin03]

She deserved the top. Orchestra and conductor are the worst imaginable.

[freenightt]

very very clean playing!

[cornel999]

am i way off base here, or is this conductor forcing every violinist to make a retard in the very last measure against their will? i hate a retard there, and most fiddlers don't do it. it just throws a big wet blanket on the whole thing.

[ThaSchwab]

Dipshit...it's not "retard," it's "ritard(ando)."

[Sviolinist]

bahahahahahah

[lsder]

Wow...i thought she'd be a top 3 finisher for sure.

[masael255]

She is incredible...but somehow as I listen to her she just seems a bit too technical. She's absolutely great but just lacking the fire of this piece. She's almost a bit too docile like a butterfly dancing on a raging river.

[fsvgnfs640]

i agree