I am a Nepali.... and I felt this whole idea of taking a living a girl as a god totally disgusting.... angry with me? ... go send your daughter to be a kumari and destroy her life...if you don't dare, then you are just a bloody hypocrite... you so easily force a child to destroy her life so that you can fulfill your need of worshipping !
The figure of 80% Nepali are Hindus are from 1990's census. But as of today you are correct that only 35%-45% are Hindus as Nepalese are leaving Brahmanical religion (Hindusim). The dalits are becoming Christians, while Gurungs, Thakalis, Tamangs are predominately Buddhist. And certainly Rai, Limbu, Magar, Hayu, Jirel, Dhimal, Sunuwar, Yakkha, Tharu are going back to their ancient faith.
watch this video ---> " KIRATISM: Prayer of Earth And Nature " and you learn the oldest religion on earth.
The Dhali Llama was raised the same way, but it seems ok to honor a holy man but not a holy woman. I am sure the Dhali Llama had at least one hard on in his life but you don't see him being thrown out into the streets and stupid comments by ignorant watchers. Seems there is still discrimination of returning the Goddess back to the status of God or respecting females.
i have seen this child.i was often in nepal,one of my fav countries.thasnks for this vid.i got your message about countries and the unfairness of it all,causing suffering and pain.i will write a longer message for you explaining why.love from june x
the reason why india was never really conquered by foreigners except the brits who only help to shape india in to the world power it is today so traditions do help so who? gives a fuck anyway what you think' it is what it is !
If I see something that is wrong and I speak up it is a judgment? People have wrong idea about judging people, discernment is different. Tradition, culture and material does not make God happy, doing what God wants does. Not all religions are good at all. Infact I could narrow down most religions as coming from the same thing besides one.
she will be just fine. she has accumulated great merit for the sacrifices she has made for her people.
christian people should not make such horrible comments, maybe you should read what your teacher has said about loving kindness and compassion and not judging "others least ye be judged!"
What dramatic Western bullshit. We always act like we are above other traditions...and when we don't agree with or don't understand something, we act as if it's sinful or awful instead of worrying about our own problems.
And I suppose you are someone who has the authority and wisdom to question traditions that carry the weight of thousands of years. What humans should do to improve is maybe live and let live and realize that everything happens for a reason and everyone has a life ahead of them, that only with strong will and power can stray from the flux of the Universe.
Are you an atheist or a fake christian? No offence meant, I'm getting atheist vibe from this comment while one of your other comments were about christianity.
I believe All Child Goddesses should be brought up and educated well in all aspects whilst being kept safe like every other child within her own family unit. The she herself will never feel like an outcast and easily without predjudice be a Good Leader in Society which is her Divine Destiny. May Shiva protect her.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
these people are nuts, im a Christian and i dont agree with this madness. However, I do believe these people have schizophrenia and they need to seek clinical help quickly...
Well thank goodness for Americans, Westerners, and Christians with their decades old medical studies that quickly give their proud opinion about cultures that have existed for thousands of years. And here I thought Schizophrenia only existed in a small amount of people, when in actuality there are entire countries that are mentally ill! How right you are, proud Christian. Thank you for your wise and discerning opinion.
if you are christian then try to behave like christian. does christian not mean to be christ like? why would you say like this? it is very narrow-minded
In YOUR opinion, she hit the nail on the head. So? Who cares if you are a jew, who cares where you are from? The point is you are not Nepali, you are not HIndu or Buddhist so who are you to criticize?
Where do people get off criticizing such harmless traditions? and what do they know of the average Nepali girl's life? In fact, this girl is very privileged.
I understand both sides ~ the importance of traditions vs. human rights. I see the need for a support network of psychologits and teachers to surround the retired Kumari girls, in order to provide them with the skills they need to survive outside the palace. Just as soldiers coming from battle may need a lot of support, so do these young ladies... and their families as well. One thing is for sure, change is inevitable. So, I have great hope for these girls, if given the extra care they need.
That is ignorant to say there is only one God. Since when is your religion that much better? You see, thats the reason why people cannot get along. Too concerned over which God has the bigger dick.
Well, Islam has never had factual evisence to prove it. One guy said he was in a cave when he spoke to god, No witnesses, and he changed his ways from love to vengeance when no one would listen? Every archeologicl find has not disproven the bible itself.
Not one archeologist or scientist has disproven the word of God. You have your opinion, and that's fine, that what makes USA and God's free will awesome. I just disagre with you.
Don't act like Christianity (or people acing in the name of Christianity) has never interfered with the "freedoms of humanity".
And your mention of the USA has me wondering what your point is. It's not like citizens of the US are the only people in the world free to practice their opinions.
For one, I don't see VideoCritic5 saying anything about private parts so this shows where your mind is at. I would have to say his religion is better than yours, even thoug I don't know what religion he is. You have a perverted mind and if your religion was "better", you wouldn't mention perversion.
You call him/her ignorant for only believing in 1 god but you're not ignorant for believing in 9,000? I bet VideoCritic's religion doesn'r torture young girls or babies like hinduism does.
Before you assume what religious belief I have, ask first. Second, I don't mean to put people down but there is something called the real world, and you have to experience life to understand your beliefs are not set in stone. But you have to go through life first, to get it.
I'll readily agree that this tradition is unfair to the girls, but it's not quite so horrible as this video would have it seem. Former Kumaris receive a pension from the state of 6000 rupees per month ($80). This is around twice the official minimum wage and around four times the average income in this poverty-stricken country. Also, all of the living former Kumaris with exception of the youngest ones have married.
Very interesting video. Thanks for posting it! I just learned about this tradition from the article posted on Yahoo about a Kumari who lost her title because she traveled. I am glad I found this and was able to learn more.
hi, thanks for many posts, people. I'm not sure is this same Kumari as said on yahoo page. This one is already 15 and long gone. In the end of the my movie there is another small Kumari, but I'm realy not sure is this same as said on yahoo. I took this movie few weeks ago from National Geografic. Apologize again because bad sound.
hmmm...i just read the article about a kumari's title being taken away becaue she left the country so i decided to see what youtube had to offer on the topic, thanks for posting this doloreshaze1935 (how long ago was this on tv?)...i wonder if this the the same girl...
Yes but she will never be the same again. Here is the bogus part of the entire ordeal. In the end it will always feel unfair to her.
CrystalSStorm 4 months ago
I am a Nepali.... and I felt this whole idea of taking a living a girl as a god totally disgusting.... angry with me? ... go send your daughter to be a kumari and destroy her life...if you don't dare, then you are just a bloody hypocrite... you so easily force a child to destroy her life so that you can fulfill your need of worshipping !
barronisme 4 months ago
scribd (dot) com/nb812
DreamsofMajesty 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hinduism is a pretty messedup religion.
Ramshobraja 1 year ago
Hinduism is a pretty fucked up religon.
Ramshobraja 1 year ago
The figure of 80% Nepali are Hindus are from 1990's census. But as of today you are correct that only 35%-45% are Hindus as Nepalese are leaving Brahmanical religion (Hindusim). The dalits are becoming Christians, while Gurungs, Thakalis, Tamangs are predominately Buddhist. And certainly Rai, Limbu, Magar, Hayu, Jirel, Dhimal, Sunuwar, Yakkha, Tharu are going back to their ancient faith.
watch this video ---> " KIRATISM: Prayer of Earth And Nature " and you learn the oldest religion on earth.
diliprai 1 year ago
What horrifying child abuse, in the name of culture and religion.
Yesica1993 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheShotokanWarrior 1 year ago
The Dhali Llama was raised the same way, but it seems ok to honor a holy man but not a holy woman. I am sure the Dhali Llama had at least one hard on in his life but you don't see him being thrown out into the streets and stupid comments by ignorant watchers. Seems there is still discrimination of returning the Goddess back to the status of God or respecting females.
DeathShamans 2 years ago
aome get married to temple or temple tree, in the caste system. or devdasi system , they are sexually exploited by the hindu guru of the temples
quickfixyz 2 years ago
i have seen this child.i was often in nepal,one of my fav countries.thasnks for this vid.i got your message about countries and the unfairness of it all,causing suffering and pain.i will write a longer message for you explaining why.love from june x
june1932 2 years ago
not all christians are like that ' only probably only a traditional A hole!
hindu is an excellent religion in the eyes of true christians so peace.'
thenewend2012 2 years ago
the reason why india was never really conquered by foreigners except the brits who only help to shape india in to the world power it is today so traditions do help so who? gives a fuck anyway what you think' it is what it is !
thenewend2012 2 years ago
Hi there! Are you christian? If so, what sect? Much apprechiated
SkaRocksYea 2 years ago
If I see something that is wrong and I speak up it is a judgment? People have wrong idea about judging people, discernment is different. Tradition, culture and material does not make God happy, doing what God wants does. Not all religions are good at all. Infact I could narrow down most religions as coming from the same thing besides one.
tontotings 3 years ago
peace peace peace
all religions are good
all humans are good
love humanity
gorgeous5678 3 years ago
i do agree with you. but you have to admit what these people are doing to an innocent child is just plain wrong
jumar1281 3 years ago
it just a kid~ ar man poor thing yeah~~
08maplesea80 3 years ago
she will be just fine. she has accumulated great merit for the sacrifices she has made for her people.
christian people should not make such horrible comments, maybe you should read what your teacher has said about loving kindness and compassion and not judging "others least ye be judged!"
sunfighter86 3 years ago
What dramatic Western bullshit. We always act like we are above other traditions...and when we don't agree with or don't understand something, we act as if it's sinful or awful instead of worrying about our own problems.
snowwhiterosered 3 years ago
No religion is provable, no matter how many centuries old it is.
Liberate yourselves from organized religion. And liberate that poor child.
TwilightFalls 3 years ago
man i cant beleive the way ppl act sometimes
factanon 3 years ago
And I suppose you are someone who has the authority and wisdom to question traditions that carry the weight of thousands of years. What humans should do to improve is maybe live and let live and realize that everything happens for a reason and everyone has a life ahead of them, that only with strong will and power can stray from the flux of the Universe.
PrincessaGianna 3 years ago
Are you an atheist or a fake christian? No offence meant, I'm getting atheist vibe from this comment while one of your other comments were about christianity.
SkaRocksYea 2 years ago
the biggest idiots will realise their foolishness when ppl realise that we are ALL god
sanjesingh 3 years ago
I believe All Child Goddesses should be brought up and educated well in all aspects whilst being kept safe like every other child within her own family unit. The she herself will never feel like an outcast and easily without predjudice be a Good Leader in Society which is her Divine Destiny. May Shiva protect her.
PureFoxHeart 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
these people are nuts, im a Christian and i dont agree with this madness. However, I do believe these people have schizophrenia and they need to seek clinical help quickly...
thisaintjohn 4 years ago
Well thank goodness for Americans, Westerners, and Christians with their decades old medical studies that quickly give their proud opinion about cultures that have existed for thousands of years. And here I thought Schizophrenia only existed in a small amount of people, when in actuality there are entire countries that are mentally ill! How right you are, proud Christian. Thank you for your wise and discerning opinion.
PrincessaGianna 3 years ago 5
if you are christian then try to behave like christian. does christian not mean to be christ like? why would you say like this? it is very narrow-minded
sunfighter86 3 years ago
No she pretty much hit the nail on the head with that comment. I agree completely and I'm a jew. I'm also not american.
SkaRocksYea 2 years ago
In YOUR opinion, she hit the nail on the head. So? Who cares if you are a jew, who cares where you are from? The point is you are not Nepali, you are not HIndu or Buddhist so who are you to criticize?
sunfighter86 2 years ago 6
This is not true - the Kumaris can and do marry when they come of age. Please dont slander our traditions and spread misinformation about them.
sirensongsindia 4 years ago
Where do people get off criticizing such harmless traditions? and what do they know of the average Nepali girl's life? In fact, this girl is very privileged.
sirensongsindia 4 years ago
I understand both sides ~ the importance of traditions vs. human rights. I see the need for a support network of psychologits and teachers to surround the retired Kumari girls, in order to provide them with the skills they need to survive outside the palace. Just as soldiers coming from battle may need a lot of support, so do these young ladies... and their families as well. One thing is for sure, change is inevitable. So, I have great hope for these girls, if given the extra care they need.
schmooberry 4 years ago
And this God is a carpenter??? Please don't impose yr religion and ridicule others beliefs.
jessekoh121 4 years ago
That is ignorant to say there is only one God. Since when is your religion that much better? You see, thats the reason why people cannot get along. Too concerned over which God has the bigger dick.
Retro255 4 years ago
Well, Islam has never had factual evisence to prove it. One guy said he was in a cave when he spoke to god, No witnesses, and he changed his ways from love to vengeance when no one would listen? Every archeologicl find has not disproven the bible itself.
Not one archeologist or scientist has disproven the word of God. You have your opinion, and that's fine, that what makes USA and God's free will awesome. I just disagre with you.
Videocritic5 4 years ago
Don't act like Christianity (or people acing in the name of Christianity) has never interfered with the "freedoms of humanity".
And your mention of the USA has me wondering what your point is. It's not like citizens of the US are the only people in the world free to practice their opinions.
Aparanjita 4 years ago 2
For one, I don't see VideoCritic5 saying anything about private parts so this shows where your mind is at. I would have to say his religion is better than yours, even thoug I don't know what religion he is. You have a perverted mind and if your religion was "better", you wouldn't mention perversion.
You call him/her ignorant for only believing in 1 god but you're not ignorant for believing in 9,000? I bet VideoCritic's religion doesn'r torture young girls or babies like hinduism does.
SkaRocksYea 2 years ago
Before you assume what religious belief I have, ask first. Second, I don't mean to put people down but there is something called the real world, and you have to experience life to understand your beliefs are not set in stone. But you have to go through life first, to get it.
Retro255 2 years ago
I'll readily agree that this tradition is unfair to the girls, but it's not quite so horrible as this video would have it seem. Former Kumaris receive a pension from the state of 6000 rupees per month ($80). This is around twice the official minimum wage and around four times the average income in this poverty-stricken country. Also, all of the living former Kumaris with exception of the youngest ones have married.
Aparanjita 4 years ago
Very interesting video. Thanks for posting it! I just learned about this tradition from the article posted on Yahoo about a Kumari who lost her title because she traveled. I am glad I found this and was able to learn more.
klmanzur 4 years ago
hi, thanks for many posts, people. I'm not sure is this same Kumari as said on yahoo page. This one is already 15 and long gone. In the end of the my movie there is another small Kumari, but I'm realy not sure is this same as said on yahoo. I took this movie few weeks ago from National Geografic. Apologize again because bad sound.
doloreshaze1935 4 years ago
interesting but weird tradition
InfamouzRedzz 4 years ago
yup heard about it but forgot jus saw it on yahoo & decided to tube it also nice upload gonan watch it now
InfamouzRedzz 4 years ago
gyea same here i saw it on yahoo and decided to look it up ... goodness...their childhood is long gone...
DowNefulxSinz 4 years ago
Just read about this on Yahoo.....thanks for the visual....I feel sorry for those girls.....what a dumb tradition.....
DreSoul 4 years ago
hmmm...i just read the article about a kumari's title being taken away becaue she left the country so i decided to see what youtube had to offer on the topic, thanks for posting this doloreshaze1935 (how long ago was this on tv?)...i wonder if this the the same girl...
sherrycay 4 years ago
WOW. Her life is lost to god-hood...
FemmeBleu 4 years ago