They are both amazing, but Leona's voice lacks a richness that Kelly's has; Kelly's voice has an extra dimension that just makes her more fun to listen to.
@TheSupershooter we meet again superfucker.. in anyform of musicality.. kelly can demolish leona's thin belting registry.. when it comes to power, fluidity resonance.. haha
Leona has beautiful runs, falsetto, and face....Kelly slaughters her. You can barely hear Leona is this video and just because she has a "pretty" voice, does not mean she is the better singer. kelly clearly has way more power, control, and depth than Leona. Stop sucking up just because she can hit one high note.
@JumperSC for the record.. leona never hit any note higher than kelly.. on belting kelly can belt up to c6, thats 5 notes higher than leona's g5, and in superhead leona just hit eb6, kelly can go up to f#6 2 notes higher.. btwa ur right kelly rules!!!!
Kelly has not stopped lol. She came later so what? They are comparing earlier vids so they are just as equal in experience. HELL Kelly was only 18 or so when she got on American Idol soooo yeah. It doesn't matter really when she has always been amazing and if Leona was good she'd be good.
Leona has better vocal look cause she always sings boring, typical and so monotonous ballads where she used scream too much. Kelly herself, has much higher vocal range, she sings higher notes and holds them much longer plus she sounds wonderful in various musical genres. That's why she is higher than monotonous Leona, Beyonce, Aguilera, Underwood etc
@carshe209 what's wrong with being British? You already took our language and don't spell our words properly, and picture every British the same yet your idea of British is completely different. Although, I do have to agree Kelly wins hands down as well as all american idol stars, anyone over Leona, most the people (British) I know would agree as well
@JoshLNeville I know your comment is old and you were probably just ticked off by a troll but cmon
"our language"
"our words"
Hm? I don't understand how a British person can spell better when we share the same literacy rate and besides, I have seen many British users with horrid spelling so to fight stereotypes with more stereotypes seems like it kind of backtracks the progress in eliminating them.
but in this comment section, i don't know why the comment of people saying leona is better receive too many negative comments. lol..it seems like kelly fans clicked thumbs down to every single comment of such kind. haha, but anyway, it's obvious that kelly is miles better than leona in belting.
@argenies141 LEONA is better in x-factor days, she's gotten WORST AND WORST EVERYDAY, SHE START TO LIPPED F5'S AND G5'S haha,, kelly doesnt lipped any performance ever! OMG LOVE KELLY, leona SUCKS! HAHA
Kelly walks all over Leona in the examples provided (although I think they were probably weak examples of Leona). Still, Leona sounds pitchy in several of the clips. Her voice sounded frail (though pretty) and Kelly hit the notes with resounding power and clarity. No contest.
@nfscarbonultra you're so fuckin worthless moron matey, LEONA HAS BEEN COMPARED WITH MARIAH,WHITNEY,CELINE.. COZ SHE IS COPYCAT, SHE IMMITATES MC,CD,WH, HAHA!
while kelly is NAMED! AT THE SAME LEAGUE WITH CELINE DION MARIAH CAREY, NAMED! NOT COMPARED! NAMED WITHIN THE SAME LEAGUE, NOT COMPARED... HAHA? WERS KELLY NOW? SHE JUST RECENTLY PERFORMED AT CMA'S, HAD A SUCCESSFUL WORLD TOUR INCLUDING WEMBLEY AT U.K. most of all she's busy with her FIFTH ALBUM, now wheres leona
@carshe209 leona was compared because she was on x factor u idiot, which millions of people have seen her performances each week. Kelly was touring in UK? wow, i didnt even know . Leona has just finished her sellout tour, she sang the theme song for Avatar and contributed to the soundtrack of Colored Girls, she also broke up with her bf and doesnt look as fat as kelly. No one even knows Kelly in the Uk anymore, where as in the US everyone knows Leona is the voice of our generation NOT KELLY
@nfscarbonultra haha, we all know that christina aguilera was named the voice of our generation not leona, or kelly.. haha.. plus kelly never lip synchs like leona, and besides leona is just an less talented and uglier version of MRAIAH CAREY, theres nothing unique and original about her.. hahaha and avatar was good (the movie) the song? no! hahahaha sucha shame compared to CELINE'S TITANIC SONG HAHAHA FAIL! NOW NEXT
@carshe209 and Everyone in the US loves Leona, Oprah and Ellen even said she has a great voice. The fact is Leona will be around in 10 years to come, for Kelly? shes soo over. X Facta comin to US to show all the losers of American Idol how its done. Wagner is probably better than half the winners that have come from American Idol. Oh and Leona>Kelly.
@nfscarbonultra haha.. seriously.. x factor has nothing on IDOLS, WHO IS ALEX BURKE COMPARE TO JEN HUDSON? WHO IS WAGNER,MCELDERY, COMPARE TO CLAY AIKEN OR DAUGHTRY? REMEMBER, X-FACTOR RECYCLES SONGS FROM IDOL,, WHATTA SHAME.. AND SPEAKING OF X-FACTOR..BRITISH! AMERICANS WILL SHOW YOU HOW ITS DONE IN USA, JUST LIKE ON POP IDOL, HAHA KELLY DEMONSTRATE TO WILL YOUNG HOW AMERICAN'S KELL BRITISH TALENTS.. AND LEONA FOR GOD SAKE LETS NOT TALK ABOUT CONSTIPATED LION BELTING ABILITIES
@carshe209 Everyone in the entire world knows that the most successful singer to come out of a reality tv singing contest is Leona Lewis. Fact you cant deny this!!
@nfscarbonultra FAIL, you should have known that KELLY CLARKSON product of any talent competition on planet, she sold more than LEONA, and CARRIE, plus she had way more awards than both, you can ask everyone about your delussion! count their album and single sales... LMFAO,
@nfscarbonultra haha, stop being mongoloid, haha.. such a worthless moron, kelly had all the major music awards, that leona can only dreamed of haha.. OWNED!
Dear friend...i am also afraid that the fact kelly knows to belt 5 notes higher than LEONA doesnt mean that she is better than her....in my opinion...Leona has more passion...and better character
@3arianaras dear friend if it was not the notes you hit with your technique then who the fuck IS WHITNEY HOUSTON, ARETHA FRANKLIN, CELINE DION AND MARIAH CAREY..? plus kelly is more versatile than leona.. and kelly has a talent of co/writing AND writing her SONGS, AND KELLY CAN REINVENT HER MUSIC UNLIKE LEONA.. UNFORTUNATELY HER SONGS ARE ALIKE.. BLEEDING LOVE THE BLOOD IS ALREADY DRAINED.. LEONA IS GONE AND FADED AWAY WHILE KELLY IS STILL HERE.. HER CAREER IS TIED FOR ETERNITY..SORRY FRIEND
@3arianaras LOL, IM AFRAID TOO .. thats your opinion,,, but a solid fact that kelly BELTS 5 NOTES HIGHER THAN LEONA.. WITH MORE POWER , RESONANCE AND FLUIDITY.. LOL
Kelly just has a stronger voice than leona. Leona has a beautiful voice but can get whiny and weak at times but can deliver. Kelly just has a powerful yet beautiful voice, she is just better. None the less the two are great.
OK PEOPLE HERE'S A QUICK COURSE IN HOW U CAN TELL WHO IS THE BETTER VOCALIST...PAY ATTENTION TO THE FACIAL EXPRESSIONS...KELLY CLARKSON IS FAR MORE EFFORTLESS SINGER THAN MOST DIVAS SHES BEIN COMPARED TOO! CHRISTINA EVEN LOOKS LIKE SHE'S TRYING TOO HARD SOMETIMES IN PERFORMANCES! IT'S NOT ABOUT NOTES AND RANGES IT'S ABOUT WHO SINGS IT WITH THE MOST EASE...
@DanScot19 LEONA HITS C6 IN HEAD, WHILE KELLY HITS IT ON CHEST... LOL... leona's c6 is sweet,smooth,effortless, but no power.. just smooth and sweet, unlike whitney's and mariah's
@Davines27 yah sure bout eb5? leona just touches it for 1sec. and kelly hitted it for 7 seconds, sustained! with vibrato... and you'll preffer leona's eb5... hmmm lol...sounds weird
@Davines27 that eb5 for god sake is very very whiny compare to kelly clarkson... very thin and very heady.. plus the vibrato waves like hell... very very slow
@WhitneyElizabethH Kelly doesnt destroy her ok??? even kely is not compared to mariah and whitney and u're gonna say opinions are based on nothing..but all the judges compared her to celine dion and mariah carey who asked leona to replace her in her concert..i think these are enough to show who's better
@khoukhoun lol, so is kelly.. simon and randy named kelly in the same league as mariah carey and celine dion, not once but twice.. kelly has been NAMED! NOT COM PARED WITH SUCH GOOD DIVAS LIKE THEM.. BEACAUSE LEONA COPY THEIR STYLE AND SING THEIR SONGS.. WHILE KELLY DOESNT REMIND PEOPLE OF ANYONE FAMOUS UNLIKE LEONA.. KELLY DESTROYS HER IN ANY WAY, BELTS,ORIGINALITY, VERSATILITY, PERSONALITY,AWARDS,POPULARITY, except FALSETO THE ONLY GOOD THING ABOUT LEONA, whiche she tend to OVERUSE
@dcfan2222 watch i surrender by kelly with judges comments.. where simon put kelly with the same league with DION AND CAREY, and i cant find it here on youtube but i watched it a year ago, interview with simon,paula,randy,ryan in GOOD MORNING AMERICA , WHERE SIMON asked who's the best american idol and said that KELLY CLARKSON BY MILE, and she's up there with such great singers like celine dion
kelly. i mean, yeah leona has a lovely voice, but kelly has more range and has a warmer voice. and she contects to her songs a little better. wat was that song kelly sang @ 0:30?
I think Leona Lewis is an excellent singer but she can't touch Kelly Clarkson who is far more versatile, a far better performer and more importantly, a far better singer. I doubt Leona will ever have an album that sells as much as Breakaway.
Kelly all over, not bieng biased she is actually a much better singer!!! All I have to say really is lisin 2 the highest notes (F5 and above), Kelly has alot more power, control, sustains them, uses pure/full chest and hits them clear everytime, leona doesn't do any of them!!!
kelly. she has her own style of singing. leona is to much of mariah wonnabe. leona voice is annoying. kelly is better live becuase her voice is better. she can sing anything.
Kelly Clarkson's voice is much more sweet and better. Leona is ugly screamer no more. Kelly can sing pop, rock, country, soul, blues, classical folk unlike Leona
KELLY CLARKSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Her voice is extremely powerful and she's very versatile. When that loser leona lewis tries to belt a horrible whine comes out of her mouth instead. So actually you cant even compare that mariah carey wannabe to the AMAZING KELLY CLARKSON!!!!!!!!! theres absolutely no competition. Kelly definitely wins
obviously ,,kelly clarkson is the best singer of all time,,,leona was a second kelly clarkson bcoz she sing a moment like this by kelly c.,,,so ,,i like most kelly clarkson,,
another reason why Kelly Clarkson is wayy better than leona lewis is because of her knowledge of a lot of music genre, which she incorporates into her music, she has way whole lot of versatility/she can choose to be pop country soul blues rock classical folk and etc....she can sing anything!!!
she even beat mariah carey and gwen in grammy and ama.. lols that rocks! !
and lastly leona's vocals is limited.. she just keep on holding long screechy notes and overuses her falsetto's and weak vibrato.. leona's songs and style always the same and wont never ever change.. so bye bye leona! rest in peace! one hit wonder!
and obviously you dont know what u talking bout and dont know much about music..
soul, lyrics, vocal range, song, video, creativity etc. which leona has got?
as far as im concern kelly's songs was farrrr waaaay! emotional.. inspirational.. meaningfull! and the lyrics was extraordinary.. lots of metaphors and jargons..
what about leona? soul? all she know is to sing keep keep bleeding love.. and her blood is already drained..
its about soul, lyrics, vocal range, song, video, creativity etc. which leona has got
leona would destroy kelly singing in higher key anyday
leonas material is authentic and she has written a lot of her own pieces
if leona is a one hit wonder then she is one hell of a one hit wonder selling 7 million in under a year and album/single being number one in 20 countries
leona sing higher and destroy kelly? how come stupido? well kelly would not just destroy leona but she can kill and burried leona anytime anyday.. leona cant even belt an g#5 a5 and c6 in full chest.. and her f5's and f"#5 sound like giving birth on stage.. lols.. kelly every night since 2002 hitting g5 g#5 a5 in full chest.. which leona cant..
and besides leona's highest live whistle was just an eb6.. while kelly hit an f#6 and c7.. so howcome leona sing higher?
leona authentic? oh please.. she's just a mariah carey wnnabe.. kelly never immitated anyone.. and doesnt remind people of anyone famous.. she's unique.. unlike leona..
and leona write a lot of pieces and stuff? since when asshole? what song of leona she wrote and released .. nothing right?.. so you are 3x asshole..
kelly write ''because of you'' and made it a worldwide hit! she even wrote all her songs in her entire my december album! so thats what i call
i read the first couple lines and i cant be bothered to finish. its obviously bullshit from a dilusional child who knows absolutely NOTHING. everyone knows leona is a better singer. why else would she be signed to clive davis. end of discussion
who cares with leona and clive davis? lols! ''kelly clarkson '' herself.. refuses multi million offer of clive davis in her album ''my december'' loooools! stuuupid!
and nowadays clive davis and simon cowell is desperate to promote leona's new album.. coz its going to be a massive flop! ovbiously.. ur the one who dont know much.. and majority of leona vs kelly videos here in youtube.. says kelly is hell better so get the hell ovah it..
@nfscarbonultra come talk to me if leona won grammy beating mariah carey, gwen stefani, and beatle paul mccartney, call me when you heard leona belting a g#5 a5 b5 bb5 and c6 in chest like kelly... haha.. and call me again if you heard leona hitting f#6 live like kelly then we can talk seriously, haha, leona's blood is already drained coz of keep keep bleeding to much, kelly for sure will be there in next decade, i dunno bout leona ROLLING STONES SAID THAT KELLY'S CAREER IS TIED FOR ETERNITY,
@carshe209 Leona came 4 yrs afterr kelly..so dnt compare concerning the awards..leona beletd g#5 in many of her performances...kelly hit f#6 live okk but she hits it very rarely..leona hit f#6 in studio and she has th epotential to go higher cz she practices opera..so dnt judge a singer on thh firstt of the road..just wait and see the difference by urself..get of the hatred...wht the fuckk
@khoukhoun kelly has been longer, if i'ts not fair enough for you compare them kelly from 2002-2006 leona 2006-2010, still leona didnt even achieved half of kelly's achievements in 4 years.. lmfao, leona hitted g#5 for about 10 to 12 times in her entire career, very very thin.. and heady.. kelly hitted g#5 for about hundred times since 2002 lmfao.. and i'ts chest dominant and more powerful than any g#5 that will come from leona's mouth, today leona starts to lipped her g5's and g#5's pathetic
@nfscarbonultra WERS KELLY? HAHA.. BUSY DOING HER FIFTH ALBUM AND, HAD RECENTLY PERFORMED AT THE CMA'S .. AND KELLY UNKNOWN IN UK? WHAT IS WEMBLEY CONCERT? THE BIRMINGHAM CONCERT, BOTH SOLD OUT? HAHAHA... BETTER GET STRAIGHT TO YOUR FACTS.. MATEY.. AND LEONA BROKE UP WITH LOU, PATHETIC JUST TO FOCUS ON HER LOUSY CAREER, SHE SACRIFICE LOU TO BACK AT THE TOP OF CHARTS BUT IT WAS AN EPIC FAILURE... HAHAHA... SUCHA DESPERATE MOVE.. KELLY SLAYS LEONA.. FACT.
leona's g#5 is definately a only a g5 and its forced as well. do a video of there 2008-2009 best belts and dont be biased it must be there best belts and do every note even if 1 singer cannot hit it, like kelly has give us a sustained C6 in full belt with vibrato recently while leona cannot even go that high but still include it!!!
KELLY OBVIOUSLY!!! no offense but i dont really like leona or her voice, its to whiney and has nothing to it and she can only sing balads!!! kelly can sing everythin
also kellys voice is more raw and powerful yet so much more natural and i only actually watched this video becuase i was going through sum of kellys most watched belting competitions and so far kelly has won them all by far. the only singer that came close was nicole but me and most other youtubeers think the video is highly biased against kelly!!! and thats not just my ipinion, on all videos about 1/8th of people vote for the other person exept for nicole, she get almost 1/2 but not quite!!!
well I love both of them and i fully support kelly here but to even the playing field just a tad... leona is also the first female british singer to top the US in 20 years and has gone to number one in over 20 different countries... they're both amazing
this is bullshit..lets compare their success in the same year leona from 2006 to 2009 7 million cd sales ama loser grammy loser brtit award loser 1 number one in billboard kelly 2002 t0 2006 thankful sold= over 3 million breakaway sold ove 14 million 2 major grammy awards 1 ama
kelly's first album sold only 3 million coz during 2002 american idol doesnt have wider audience and kelly's manager didnt focused on her career leona's spirit album sold 7 million coz of a hit single bleeding love. with good mangement and too much promotions! but kelly's 2nd album alone will blew leona awaaaaay! 14 million sales 2grammy awards 4ama 3mtv awards peoples choice award and many more.. in other words spirit is a ''SHIT'' compare to breakaway album of kelly!
KELLY RULES! Kelly's voice is so much stronger and tonally better than Leona's. Leona's voice sounds too thin in the higher notes, and I don't like her tone at all. She should stick to the lower registers.
Kelly sounds best here
leandrooalmeida11 3 weeks ago
i love both
Rikki92s 1 month ago
They are both amazing, but Leona's voice lacks a richness that Kelly's has; Kelly's voice has an extra dimension that just makes her more fun to listen to.
mizhandle 1 month ago
KELLY my opinion!
WeLoveBellaThorne 2 months ago
leona's...
watch?v=ejpvBd8QBe0
hihello121 2 months ago
Leona is way better :D
HarelShmoaly 2 months ago
oh Americans(Im american too) but truth be told K got nothing on L
TheSupershooter 2 months ago
@TheSupershooter we meet again superfucker.. in anyform of musicality.. kelly can demolish leona's thin belting registry.. when it comes to power, fluidity resonance.. haha
carshe209 2 months ago
Leona has beautiful runs, falsetto, and face....Kelly slaughters her. You can barely hear Leona is this video and just because she has a "pretty" voice, does not mean she is the better singer. kelly clearly has way more power, control, and depth than Leona. Stop sucking up just because she can hit one high note.
JumperSC 4 months ago
@JumperSC for the record.. leona never hit any note higher than kelly.. on belting kelly can belt up to c6, thats 5 notes higher than leona's g5, and in superhead leona just hit eb6, kelly can go up to f#6 2 notes higher.. btwa ur right kelly rules!!!!
carshe209 4 months ago
kelly kelly !!!!!!! is the best kelly is not forced
friends4ev3r 4 months ago
kelly kelly !!!!!!! is the best
friends4ev3r 4 months ago
Kelly Slaughters.
musicguy713 6 months ago
Kelly. Can't yoh hear her? Her notes are amazing and her voice unique. Leonas also good but she doesnt sound as special as kelly.
MissPianoNotes 6 months ago
Leona
DanScot19 6 months ago 2
leona:)
brigitaification 7 months ago 2
Kelly was 20 when she was on Idol. :)
carolinagirl009 7 months ago
Kelly has not stopped lol. She came later so what? They are comparing earlier vids so they are just as equal in experience. HELL Kelly was only 18 or so when she got on American Idol soooo yeah. It doesn't matter really when she has always been amazing and if Leona was good she'd be good.
tracycookable 7 months ago
LEONA
nfscarbonultra 8 months ago
i think that leona can do more with her voice =)
prolet19 8 months ago
leona lewis is the best so shut it
1leonalewisfan 8 months ago
Kelly's voice is much stronger and better than leona
remy979 8 months ago 2
Lol um Kelly haha
dcfan2222 9 months ago
I really thought leona would wooop kellys butt but listening to them next to each other, kelly is way better
Jared95C 9 months ago
There's really no comparison, Leona has a very beautiful voice but Kelly is one of the best singers in the world.
happyfeetxxo 10 months ago
leona lewis is the best
1leonalewisfan 10 months ago
Leona has better vocal look cause she always sings boring, typical and so monotonous ballads where she used scream too much. Kelly herself, has much higher vocal range, she sings higher notes and holds them much longer plus she sounds wonderful in various musical genres. That's why she is higher than monotonous Leona, Beyonce, Aguilera, Underwood etc
ViolaXZ 11 months ago
@ViolaXZ omg !!! again? ... Leona isn't boring <3
lsasori22 10 months ago
Kelly Clarkson ALL THE WAY!
8remy5 11 months ago
Leona has more "vocal elegance" than Kelly.
shacks29 11 months ago
@shacks29 Bwhahahaha
kellyclarksonismygod 11 months ago
@carshe209 what's wrong with being British? You already took our language and don't spell our words properly, and picture every British the same yet your idea of British is completely different. Although, I do have to agree Kelly wins hands down as well as all american idol stars, anyone over Leona, most the people (British) I know would agree as well
JoshLNeville 11 months ago
@JoshLNeville I know your comment is old and you were probably just ticked off by a troll but cmon
"our language"
"our words"
Hm? I don't understand how a British person can spell better when we share the same literacy rate and besides, I have seen many British users with horrid spelling so to fight stereotypes with more stereotypes seems like it kind of backtracks the progress in eliminating them.
JRV95 7 months ago
but in this comment section, i don't know why the comment of people saying leona is better receive too many negative comments. lol..it seems like kelly fans clicked thumbs down to every single comment of such kind. haha, but anyway, it's obvious that kelly is miles better than leona in belting.
kelvinpyaeko 1 year ago
KC FOREVER!!!
SosOBadass 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
go to /watch?v=YJ2sJH6HLLk
abbc6085 1 year ago
this is leona as an amateur
i want it to be compare by now
argenies141 1 year ago
@argenies141 LEONA is better in x-factor days, she's gotten WORST AND WORST EVERYDAY, SHE START TO LIPPED F5'S AND G5'S haha,, kelly doesnt lipped any performance ever! OMG LOVE KELLY, leona SUCKS! HAHA
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 agree!
kelvinpyaeko 1 year ago
LOVE KELLY!!!!!!!!
tnredneckgirl81 1 year ago
Kelly walks all over Leona in the examples provided (although I think they were probably weak examples of Leona). Still, Leona sounds pitchy in several of the clips. Her voice sounded frail (though pretty) and Kelly hit the notes with resounding power and clarity. No contest.
musicfan808 1 year ago
and by the way i Love Jennifer Hudson, she did a duet with Leona Lewis on the Sex and The City soundtrack. They sound hot together.
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
well kelly is the better singer... but i stil prefer ... listening to the voice of leona
kstylerz 1 year ago
Leona is compared to Whitney Mariah and Celine, Kelly wasnt, and besides, where is kelly now?
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra you're so fuckin worthless moron matey, LEONA HAS BEEN COMPARED WITH MARIAH,WHITNEY,CELINE.. COZ SHE IS COPYCAT, SHE IMMITATES MC,CD,WH, HAHA!
while kelly is NAMED! AT THE SAME LEAGUE WITH CELINE DION MARIAH CAREY, NAMED! NOT COMPARED! NAMED WITHIN THE SAME LEAGUE, NOT COMPARED... HAHA? WERS KELLY NOW? SHE JUST RECENTLY PERFORMED AT CMA'S, HAD A SUCCESSFUL WORLD TOUR INCLUDING WEMBLEY AT U.K. most of all she's busy with her FIFTH ALBUM, now wheres leona
?
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 leona was compared because she was on x factor u idiot, which millions of people have seen her performances each week. Kelly was touring in UK? wow, i didnt even know . Leona has just finished her sellout tour, she sang the theme song for Avatar and contributed to the soundtrack of Colored Girls, she also broke up with her bf and doesnt look as fat as kelly. No one even knows Kelly in the Uk anymore, where as in the US everyone knows Leona is the voice of our generation NOT KELLY
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra haha, we all know that christina aguilera was named the voice of our generation not leona, or kelly.. haha.. plus kelly never lip synchs like leona, and besides leona is just an less talented and uglier version of MRAIAH CAREY, theres nothing unique and original about her.. hahaha and avatar was good (the movie) the song? no! hahahaha sucha shame compared to CELINE'S TITANIC SONG HAHAHA FAIL! NOW NEXT
!
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 and Everyone in the US loves Leona, Oprah and Ellen even said she has a great voice. The fact is Leona will be around in 10 years to come, for Kelly? shes soo over. X Facta comin to US to show all the losers of American Idol how its done. Wagner is probably better than half the winners that have come from American Idol. Oh and Leona>Kelly.
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra haha.. seriously.. x factor has nothing on IDOLS, WHO IS ALEX BURKE COMPARE TO JEN HUDSON? WHO IS WAGNER,MCELDERY, COMPARE TO CLAY AIKEN OR DAUGHTRY? REMEMBER, X-FACTOR RECYCLES SONGS FROM IDOL,, WHATTA SHAME.. AND SPEAKING OF X-FACTOR..BRITISH! AMERICANS WILL SHOW YOU HOW ITS DONE IN USA, JUST LIKE ON POP IDOL, HAHA KELLY DEMONSTRATE TO WILL YOUNG HOW AMERICAN'S KELL BRITISH TALENTS.. AND LEONA FOR GOD SAKE LETS NOT TALK ABOUT CONSTIPATED LION BELTING ABILITIES
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 Everyone in the entire world knows that the most successful singer to come out of a reality tv singing contest is Leona Lewis. Fact you cant deny this!!
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra FAIL, you should have known that KELLY CLARKSON product of any talent competition on planet, she sold more than LEONA, and CARRIE, plus she had way more awards than both, you can ask everyone about your delussion! count their album and single sales... LMFAO,
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 Ye i totally agree KELLY WINS when it comes to winning kids awards....
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra haha, stop being mongoloid, haha.. such a worthless moron, kelly had all the major music awards, that leona can only dreamed of haha.. OWNED!
carshe209 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra Kelly is so much better BY FAR!!!!!!!!!!!
tnredneckgirl81 1 year ago 2
Kelly Clarkson THEN DIRECTLY Leona :D
TheFear1611 1 year ago
kelly is the best hands down lol
dcfan2222 1 year ago
OMG! Kelly is almost a legend, Leona is not even near Kelly! Kelly all the way! Especially after F5's, Kelly humiliates Leona!
EDDsp2009 1 year ago
Dear friend...i am also afraid that the fact kelly knows to belt 5 notes higher than LEONA doesnt mean that she is better than her....in my opinion...Leona has more passion...and better character
3arianaras 1 year ago
@3arianaras dear friend if it was not the notes you hit with your technique then who the fuck IS WHITNEY HOUSTON, ARETHA FRANKLIN, CELINE DION AND MARIAH CAREY..? plus kelly is more versatile than leona.. and kelly has a talent of co/writing AND writing her SONGS, AND KELLY CAN REINVENT HER MUSIC UNLIKE LEONA.. UNFORTUNATELY HER SONGS ARE ALIKE.. BLEEDING LOVE THE BLOOD IS ALREADY DRAINED.. LEONA IS GONE AND FADED AWAY WHILE KELLY IS STILL HERE.. HER CAREER IS TIED FOR ETERNITY..SORRY FRIEND
carshe209 1 year ago
lol..i am afraid..that LEONA is way better than kelly....
3arianaras 1 year ago
@3arianaras LOL, IM AFRAID TOO .. thats your opinion,,, but a solid fact that kelly BELTS 5 NOTES HIGHER THAN LEONA.. WITH MORE POWER , RESONANCE AND FLUIDITY.. LOL
carshe209 1 year ago
Kelly just has a stronger voice than leona. Leona has a beautiful voice but can get whiny and weak at times but can deliver. Kelly just has a powerful yet beautiful voice, she is just better. None the less the two are great.
musicguy713 1 year ago
Kelly Slays Leona in Belting but Leona slays Kelly in Headvoice...overrall I prefer Leona coz she has way more voice elegance than kelly!
shacks29 1 year ago
this video cracks me up lmao kelly smashes this chicks weak belts,and yup americanidolfan is right its not a G#5 leona hasnt hit a G#5 its a G5
KellyFan4Lyfe08 1 year ago
OK PEOPLE HERE'S A QUICK COURSE IN HOW U CAN TELL WHO IS THE BETTER VOCALIST...PAY ATTENTION TO THE FACIAL EXPRESSIONS...KELLY CLARKSON IS FAR MORE EFFORTLESS SINGER THAN MOST DIVAS SHES BEIN COMPARED TOO! CHRISTINA EVEN LOOKS LIKE SHE'S TRYING TOO HARD SOMETIMES IN PERFORMANCES! IT'S NOT ABOUT NOTES AND RANGES IT'S ABOUT WHO SINGS IT WITH THE MOST EASE...
theonlyraynemichael 1 year ago
KELLY, all the way! plus i know for a fact than leona's Eb5 is slightly flat
JoshLNeville 1 year ago 16
KELLY, all the way
JoshLNeville 1 year ago
I like both but Kelly is better.
lizzyvance 1 year ago
leona's G5/G#5 is definitely a G5, nowhere close to G#5.
americanidolfan55 1 year ago
Leona all the way x
CherryBradshaw 1 year ago
Leona wins every note. Kelly is amazing but she just isnt on par with leona lewis.
DanScot19 1 year ago
@DanScot19 lol... deaf? leona is good from c5 to d5, but she whines, she screech notes eb5 above...
pritykazy 1 year ago
@pritykazy Shes still better than Kelly admit it :)
DanScot19 1 year ago
@DanScot19 lol call me when leona belting g5,g#5,a5,bb5,b5 and c6 effortlessly like kelly.. her belts stop with g5, lol..
and call me again if you heard leona hitting f#6 live like kelly does.. then we can talk that leona is better
pritykazy 1 year ago
@pritykazy Are you mad leonas c6 is the best of all time.
DanScot19 1 year ago
@DanScot19 LEONA HITS C6 IN HEAD, WHILE KELLY HITS IT ON CHEST... LOL... leona's c6 is sweet,smooth,effortless, but no power.. just smooth and sweet, unlike whitney's and mariah's
pritykazy 1 year ago
@DanScot19 hahah this comment shows your ignorance. that you ignore solid facts and just pretend your opinion is a fact.
americanidolfan55 1 year ago
@americanidolfan55 Nah I do like kelly n think shes amazing but just think leonas way better, entitled to my opinion. bye
DanScot19 1 year ago
@pritykazy Even if kelly hits more notes..it doesnt mean that she's better than leona....it's all about the voice and talent...
khoukhoun 1 year ago
C5: Leona
C#5 & D5: Tie
Eb5:Leona
Leona's E5 is a D5
E5(all by myself):Leona
F5-G#5: Kelly
Davines27 1 year ago
@Davines27 yah sure bout eb5? leona just touches it for 1sec. and kelly hitted it for 7 seconds, sustained! with vibrato... and you'll preffer leona's eb5... hmmm lol...sounds weird
pritykazy 1 year ago
@pritykazy Leona sustains 12 seconds a Eb5 in Over The Rainbow, she is better in Eb5!
Davines27 1 year ago
@Davines27 that eb5 for god sake is very very whiny compare to kelly clarkson... very thin and very heady.. plus the vibrato waves like hell... very very slow
pritykazy 1 year ago
kelly is just...WOW :)
rebeca1304 1 year ago
Some of there aren't Kelly's best clips- I've never been a huge fan of that C5 (the C#5, on the other hand, is just WOW).
Either way,
Kelly's worst > Leona's best
There's no competition. Kelly rules.
BollyGee 1 year ago
kellly.
livetodancexox 1 year ago
Oh MY GOD
Kelly Clarkson!
Leona has an Amazing Voice, Especially the head register
But Kelly destroys her!
WhitneyElizabethH 1 year ago
@WhitneyElizabethH Kelly doesnt destroy her ok??? even kely is not compared to mariah and whitney and u're gonna say opinions are based on nothing..but all the judges compared her to celine dion and mariah carey who asked leona to replace her in her concert..i think these are enough to show who's better
khoukhoun 1 year ago
@khoukhoun
My comment was 4 months old. Desperate much?
WhitneyElizabethH 1 year ago
@khoukhoun lol, so is kelly.. simon and randy named kelly in the same league as mariah carey and celine dion, not once but twice.. kelly has been NAMED! NOT COM PARED WITH SUCH GOOD DIVAS LIKE THEM.. BEACAUSE LEONA COPY THEIR STYLE AND SING THEIR SONGS.. WHILE KELLY DOESNT REMIND PEOPLE OF ANYONE FAMOUS UNLIKE LEONA.. KELLY DESTROYS HER IN ANY WAY, BELTS,ORIGINALITY, VERSATILITY, PERSONALITY,AWARDS,POPULARITY, except FALSETO THE ONLY GOOD THING ABOUT LEONA, whiche she tend to OVERUSE
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 would you by chance have those links for me thanx
dcfan2222 1 year ago
@dcfan2222 watch i surrender by kelly with judges comments.. where simon put kelly with the same league with DION AND CAREY, and i cant find it here on youtube but i watched it a year ago, interview with simon,paula,randy,ryan in GOOD MORNING AMERICA , WHERE SIMON asked who's the best american idol and said that KELLY CLARKSON BY MILE, and she's up there with such great singers like celine dion
carshe209 1 year ago
@carshe209 thank you i remember this being said a couple times but i just wanted to watch it again thank you
dcfan2222 1 year ago
kelly clarkson = hits the notes perfectly and holds them with grace
leona lewis = barely ranges them (if at all) sounds like a wine as if she's a child in a temper crying
dermotm9 1 year ago 15
@dermotm9 fuk you i'd to see you sing !!!!
hezronfekitoa 1 year ago
Leona's E5 is a D5 ._.
yahiie 1 year ago 2
kelly. i mean, yeah leona has a lovely voice, but kelly has more range and has a warmer voice. and she contects to her songs a little better. wat was that song kelly sang @ 0:30?
ItalianVampire64 1 year ago
@ItalianVampire64 up to the mountain i think
kdogmich15 1 year ago
I think Leona Lewis is an excellent singer but she can't touch Kelly Clarkson who is far more versatile, a far better performer and more importantly, a far better singer. I doubt Leona will ever have an album that sells as much as Breakaway.
welshjoe21 1 year ago
Kelly all over, not bieng biased she is actually a much better singer!!! All I have to say really is lisin 2 the highest notes (F5 and above), Kelly has alot more power, control, sustains them, uses pure/full chest and hits them clear everytime, leona doesn't do any of them!!!
JoshLNeville 1 year ago
haha are u kidding me Leona is nothing compared to the ammazing kelly clarkson !!!
JZ311995 1 year ago
Comment removed
afliksinas 1 year ago
@afliksinas i think ur the only 1 that commented and said leona was better. kelly clarkson is a better singer in my opinion
grovepar 1 year ago
Kelly blows Leona off the stage with the pitch of her voice, all leona could do is run & hide
Kassey963 1 year ago
Leona ftw!
tammyland 1 year ago
Kelly by a mile. Kills every single note in this video.
musicfan808 1 year ago 10
kelly of course!
pameclarkson 1 year ago 2
leona is just a immitator and a flop singer...
kelly is miles better!!
msUniverse4lyf 1 year ago 2
kelly. she has her own style of singing. leona is to much of mariah wonnabe. leona voice is annoying. kelly is better live becuase her voice is better. she can sing anything.
lizzyvance 1 year ago 3
not kelly!! she sounds so different when she's doing LIVE SHOWS. like completely bloomers. LURV LEONA!! LEONA ROCKS THE HOUSE!!!
xoiheartleonaxo 1 year ago
Leona has nothing on kelly clarkson kelly blows her away there is no reason to even compare them
kellyclarksonfan100 1 year ago
Kelly Clarkson's voice is much more sweet and better. Leona is ugly screamer no more. Kelly can sing pop, rock, country, soul, blues, classical folk unlike Leona
ViolaXZ 1 year ago 3
Leona Lewis wins.
MichaelWard555 2 years ago
these X factor clips do not compliment leona's vocals at ALL. leona as grown so much since then!
LingLingRox 2 years ago
kelly has power, leona has agility. They have totally different singing styles. It's all down to preference
LingLingRox 2 years ago 4
kelly also has agilty, a lot
Fabiuguz 2 years ago
@Fabiuguz heck yeah she does, her agility is actually better than leonas...
musicmylife0809 1 year ago
KELLY CLARKSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Her voice is extremely powerful and she's very versatile. When that loser leona lewis tries to belt a horrible whine comes out of her mouth instead. So actually you cant even compare that mariah carey wannabe to the AMAZING KELLY CLARKSON!!!!!!!!! theres absolutely no competition. Kelly definitely wins
seanievortex 2 years ago 3
obviously ,,kelly clarkson is the best singer of all time,,,leona was a second kelly clarkson bcoz she sing a moment like this by kelly c.,,,so ,,i like most kelly clarkson,,
jeidric0916680 2 years ago 22
@jeidric0916680 agreed
kelly is the best singer of all time!!!!!!!!!!!!
kaldude8 2 years ago 2
another reason why Kelly Clarkson is wayy better than leona lewis is because of her knowledge of a lot of music genre, which she incorporates into her music, she has way whole lot of versatility/she can choose to be pop country soul blues rock classical folk and etc....she can sing anything!!!
8remy5 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LEONA to win forever!!! she is purely the best
liljase1 2 years ago
kelly. leona is a mariah wonnabe.
lizzyvance 2 years ago 6
she even beat mariah carey and gwen in grammy and ama.. lols that rocks! !
and lastly leona's vocals is limited.. she just keep on holding long screechy notes and overuses her falsetto's and weak vibrato.. leona's songs and style always the same and wont never ever change.. so bye bye leona! rest in peace! one hit wonder!
raphee13 2 years ago 2
and obviously you dont know what u talking bout and dont know much about music..
soul, lyrics, vocal range, song, video, creativity etc. which leona has got?
as far as im concern kelly's songs was farrrr waaaay! emotional.. inspirational.. meaningfull! and the lyrics was extraordinary.. lots of metaphors and jargons..
what about leona? soul? all she know is to sing keep keep bleeding love.. and her blood is already drained..
she's like a robot.. no emotion! 4x asshole..
raphee13 2 years ago
Leona Lewis
Dscot18 2 years ago
I highly suspect that Leona is one of the best female artists the world has ever known.Leona is in a whole different league than Kelly
MichaelWard555 2 years ago
lols.. leona is just a one hit wonder.. less talented uglier version of mariah carey!
she cant even belt an g#5 a5 and c6 in chest ..kelly in any day can destroy leona in belting battle..
raphee13 2 years ago
mariah carey aint attractive, she looks like she belongs in planet of the apes
mrjacob1000 2 years ago
but its not about belting is it?
its about soul, lyrics, vocal range, song, video, creativity etc. which leona has got
leona would destroy kelly singing in higher key anyday
leonas material is authentic and she has written a lot of her own pieces
if leona is a one hit wonder then she is one hell of a one hit wonder selling 7 million in under a year and album/single being number one in 20 countries
how many 1 hit wonders does that? idiot
jungleizmasivv 2 years ago
leona sing higher and destroy kelly? how come stupido? well kelly would not just destroy leona but she can kill and burried leona anytime anyday.. leona cant even belt an g#5 a5 and c6 in full chest.. and her f5's and f"#5 sound like giving birth on stage.. lols.. kelly every night since 2002 hitting g5 g#5 a5 in full chest.. which leona cant..
and besides leona's highest live whistle was just an eb6.. while kelly hit an f#6 and c7.. so howcome leona sing higher?
raphee13 2 years ago 4
leona authentic? oh please.. she's just a mariah carey wnnabe.. kelly never immitated anyone.. and doesnt remind people of anyone famous.. she's unique.. unlike leona..
and leona write a lot of pieces and stuff? since when asshole? what song of leona she wrote and released .. nothing right?.. so you are 3x asshole..
kelly write ''because of you'' and made it a worldwide hit! she even wrote all her songs in her entire my december album! so thats what i call
''real singer songwriter''
raphee13 2 years ago
leona record breaker,, so asside from chart topping bleedinglove british girl..etc what else?
kelly had way more record breaking moments..
a moment like this stay 14 days at the billboard top smashing legendary beatles record
'
she broke an 50 year old record in billboard.. for making '' my life would suck w/o u.. '' having the largest leap on music history
she even smash celine dion record in adult cntemporary chart
breakaway is the 4th album in history to stay at top 20 in a year
raphee13 2 years ago
i read the first couple lines and i cant be bothered to finish. its obviously bullshit from a dilusional child who knows absolutely NOTHING. everyone knows leona is a better singer. why else would she be signed to clive davis. end of discussion
jungleizmasivv 2 years ago
who cares with leona and clive davis? lols! ''kelly clarkson '' herself.. refuses multi million offer of clive davis in her album ''my december'' loooools! stuuupid!
and nowadays clive davis and simon cowell is desperate to promote leona's new album.. coz its going to be a massive flop! ovbiously.. ur the one who dont know much.. and majority of leona vs kelly videos here in youtube.. says kelly is hell better so get the hell ovah it..
raphee13 2 years ago 24
@raphee13 Where is Kelly now. Leona walks all over Kelly when it comes to Talent and looks
nfscarbonultra 1 year ago
@nfscarbonultra come talk to me if leona won grammy beating mariah carey, gwen stefani, and beatle paul mccartney, call me when you heard leona belting a g#5 a5 b5 bb5 and c6 in chest like kelly... haha.. and call me again if you heard leona hitting f#6 live like kelly then we can talk seriously, haha, leona's blood is already drained coz of keep keep bleeding to much, kelly for sure will be there in next decade, i dunno bout leona ROLLING STONES SAID THAT KELLY'S CAREER IS TIED FOR ETERNITY,
carshe209 1 year ago 2
@carshe209 Leona came 4 yrs afterr kelly..so dnt compare concerning the awards..leona beletd g#5 in many of her performances...kelly hit f#6 live okk but she hits it very rarely..leona hit f#6 in studio and she has th epotential to go higher cz she practices opera..so dnt judge a singer on thh firstt of the road..just wait and see the difference by urself..get of the hatred...wht the fuckk
khoukhoun 9 months ago
@khoukhoun kelly has been longer, if i'ts not fair enough for you compare them kelly from 2002-2006 leona 2006-2010, still leona didnt even achieved half of kelly's achievements in 4 years.. lmfao, leona hitted g#5 for about 10 to 12 times in her entire career, very very thin.. and heady.. kelly hitted g#5 for about hundred times since 2002 lmfao.. and i'ts chest dominant and more powerful than any g#5 that will come from leona's mouth, today leona starts to lipped her g5's and g#5's pathetic
carshe209 9 months ago
@nfscarbonultra WERS KELLY? HAHA.. BUSY DOING HER FIFTH ALBUM AND, HAD RECENTLY PERFORMED AT THE CMA'S .. AND KELLY UNKNOWN IN UK? WHAT IS WEMBLEY CONCERT? THE BIRMINGHAM CONCERT, BOTH SOLD OUT? HAHAHA... BETTER GET STRAIGHT TO YOUR FACTS.. MATEY.. AND LEONA BROKE UP WITH LOU, PATHETIC JUST TO FOCUS ON HER LOUSY CAREER, SHE SACRIFICE LOU TO BACK AT THE TOP OF CHARTS BUT IT WAS AN EPIC FAILURE... HAHAHA... SUCHA DESPERATE MOVE.. KELLY SLAYS LEONA.. FACT.
carshe209 1 year ago
@raphee13 Well you was obviously wrong.
charmedjames 11 months ago
@raphee13 haha i dont think so..
raphee13 11 months ago
leona's g#5 is definately a only a g5 and its forced as well. do a video of there 2008-2009 best belts and dont be biased it must be there best belts and do every note even if 1 singer cannot hit it, like kelly has give us a sustained C6 in full belt with vibrato recently while leona cannot even go that high but still include it!!!
KELLY OBVIOUSLY!!! no offense but i dont really like leona or her voice, its to whiney and has nothing to it and she can only sing balads!!! kelly can sing everythin
joshnevrox 2 years ago 3
also kellys voice is more raw and powerful yet so much more natural and i only actually watched this video becuase i was going through sum of kellys most watched belting competitions and so far kelly has won them all by far. the only singer that came close was nicole but me and most other youtubeers think the video is highly biased against kelly!!! and thats not just my ipinion, on all videos about 1/8th of people vote for the other person exept for nicole, she get almost 1/2 but not quite!!!
joshnevrox 2 years ago
i like both....love leona!!
MsLalamomo 2 years ago 2
kelly is better , she's most natural than leona
mimi7135 2 years ago 5
well I love both of them and i fully support kelly here but to even the playing field just a tad... leona is also the first female british singer to top the US in 20 years and has gone to number one in over 20 different countries... they're both amazing
IdolReady 2 years ago
Leona is OK but Kelly is on much higher level in music industry. Kelly Clarkson is unique singer - Future Legend!!!
Victoria3243 2 years ago 21
and also the note that says G5/G#5 of leonas is just a G5 she doesnt touch the G#5 kelly does with ease
KellyFan4Lyfe08 2 years ago
that isnt a E5 that leona hit its a D5 lol,kelly wins by miles and miles
KellyFan4Lyfe08 2 years ago
Clarkson is more diverse
and moped the floor with Leona
Leona is limited compared to Clarkson
Clarkson is underrated Clarkson shoud be compared to J Hudson Beyonce and Aguilera!
InfinityNebula 2 years ago 3
i listen to leona more but kelly MURDERED her in this video. those xfactor performances were so whinny!
rearea718 2 years ago 5
Breakaway = 4th album in history that stayed in the top 20 for a whole year.
Platinum 6times
2Grammy's
4American Music Awards
3 mtv music awards
11Billboard music awards
A people choise award
And I honestly don't know about Leona but I'm sure Spirit hasn't done that well like Kelly's Breakaway
Lovekellycl 2 years ago 7
raphee13 2 years ago
u cant compare success on awards alone. leona has broken many records, here are a few to date.
best album of the year 2008 uk
fastest download ever in uk
number 1 in over 20 countries
first female in over 20 years to debut at number 1 with single and album in U.S
leona sold over 7 million albums on her first album, its not easy for a new artist to do that.
kellys first album has been out for ages and still only has about 3 million sales
jungleizmasivv 2 years ago
raphee13 2 years ago 5
So you can say Kelly is more succesfull and popular in my country.
Lovekellycl 2 years ago 3
That E5 from Leona was a D5. Anyway, Leona's belts aren't as strong as Kelly's.
Devotedlamb19 2 years ago 3
leonna, i like kelly too, but i just think leonas voice is great
nikkidabest812 2 years ago
Having a 'wider range' is not an opinion, it's a fact. Kelly's range is wider. Fact.
nrhgardner 2 years ago 2
kelly, but both are awesome
fruitx4yay 2 years ago 2
their both very talented but kelly owns all!
KELLY ROCKS!!
49annie1 2 years ago 2
Kelly ownz all. Leona sucks. Carrie not much better. AC/DC rock. Argument Over.
acdcjacko 2 years ago 3
kelly wins
markjowell72 2 years ago 2
KELLY RULES! Kelly's voice is so much stronger and tonally better than Leona's. Leona's voice sounds too thin in the higher notes, and I don't like her tone at all. She should stick to the lower registers.
rockoutsf 2 years ago
leona lewis pretty much beat kelly
phillip92h 2 years ago
As if. Harder, better, faster, stronger = Kelly.
nrhgardner 2 years ago 2
My all time fav is Kelly and alwayz will be!!!!
But Leona is pretty amazing too!!!
FullofAwesomeness101 2 years ago
i definately think Kelly is sooo much better than Leona
withyouiam18 2 years ago