The Logical Song Roger Hodgson w Orchestra

[08boranda]

ABSOLUTAMENTE MAGICO..

[rmroby79]

in gioventu' mi avete fatto sognare con la vostra musica, ma ancora adesso provo le stesse emozioni che dirvi

FANTASTICI

[antiacandy]

AWESOME

[hourglass14]

excelente OwO

[orlando0999]

this is best! love supertramp, im so looking forward to SUNDAY FEB 26th, 2012 i going to see Roger at the wild horse pass casino in Gila River, love it!

[iloveGranada]

Magnífico!

[titidij2]

Nine extraterrestrials blurred the frequencies.

[BULLTRONHERO]

Fucking beautiful orchestration, perfectly done.

[amandawooning]

ARE you kidding me!!!!! I LOVE THIS SONG!!!Love it

[aliasolive]

When is the next one? Come on.....we will fill the stadium Roger!

One more time. Please

[haddara]

9 illogical guys!

[konstantinaki97]

totally love it!!!!is there a lyrics video?thanks<3

[lecharlo93]

God, this arrangement is just outstanding ! The orchestral part is perfectly written, it doesn't overwhelm the original version but it adds something that I can't get out of my head.

Is there a 320kbps mp3 version of this performance ?

[kevinbland]

England embraced all of thecultural minorities like blues, reggae and classic show tunes and they knew how important lyrics were.

[aeonflux67]

@kevinbland They should have avoided embracing the "other" cultural minorities such as muslims, Africans, East Europeans etc as they are a pain in the a**

[MrStreets5]

Me Gusta! I love it :D

[Dalew0k]

Toward the end you can see the what dangers of poor orchestral rock performance. The tempo needs to swing like a skiff, and the orchestra toward the end, is a massive oceanliner lumbering along at its own stodgy pace. Compare to Procol Harem's Conquistador for a great orchestral performance

[leticia539]

The beginning of the song fits so well with him nowadays!!! "when i was young..."He used to be so handsome everytime i watch his old supertramp videos i just fall in love with him!!! Not only with him but with his amazing talent, i just love him and always will!!! eventhough he`s definitely not the beauty he used to be!!! but for sure his inner self is still beautiful and that will always remain beautiful!!!

[maggitymagzmag]

9 people are too logical

[smartysandys]

Thanks to my dad I like this song. But its just sad that not so many kids even know about them enymore. They only know about the remake of the old songs sang by new, younger artists, and they would never know or even care where the original came from. And those remade songs are not even good.

[ralphalphascout]

@smartysandys i force all my friends to listen to the classics lol, they all like them 2

[pepepollo7740]

UN GRANDE DE TODOS LOS TIEMPOS, MUCHOS SON LOS LLAMADOS POCOS LOS ELEGIDOS

[littlegreenjason]

I love this song but I can't help cringing a little bit when he sings about the birds in the trees. It's just so cheesy. Otherwise, a great song.

[martandboo]

bloody marvellous indeed, the real sound of supertramp!!!!!!

[kevinbland]

I just love when they orchestrate a classic song like this. I bought this album in the early 80's when it frist came out. This album helped to save the record industry back then.

[pinkbutterflypoo]

Man, unfortunately I just found out Britney Spears ripped part of this song off. The song is called Criminal. I can't stand that they didn't give credit to Supertramp!

[SgtWatts1]

9 people are a radical, liberal, fanatical, criminal.

[prekrcac]

9 people Bieber fans !

[GHEIL2011]

Great!

[extracrispyz]

His voice, while still good, is much weaker than when he was with Supertramp. Its a shame there couldn't have been a full reunion tour.

[metyuewb]

Am I deaf cause I can't hear a single string

[faawn4]

nice song 

[meloncron]

Bloody marvelous!

[trendyjon1]

Don´t you just love real music,,,that was exellent

[sharkdavil]

Don't be a frickin douche bag dudebearcow. It's Roger Hodgson of Supertramp fame. HE is a dude. And an extremely talented one at that.

[CorruptCatalystVids1]

Scooter :D oh wait it's the original EVEN BETTER!!!!

[skatingagain]

woow .. thats all i got to comment

[tonyvu60]

This is why I turned off the radio and MTV for the last 20 years.

[bernardrevel]

this is beautiful

[catomember]

Well said Nadigo! The sad thing is that the promotional dollars will go to where the quick buck will be made...and teens certainly know how to spend their parent's cash!

The best we can do is support wonderful artists like Roger Hodson by buying his CDs and DVDs and spreading the word of his musical genius through YouTube.

BTW -- I kick myself for letting the chance to see Supertramp back in 1982 up front and personal! Argh, what a dumb mistake!

[nadigo]

what pains me the very most is that this video has a meanly 500 thousand views... and the justin bieber video have nearly 600 million views... and I found myself thinking what is wrong with the musical world nowadays and where will this creative hole we are in is going to end.

[DudeBearCow]

She can sing.

[ablocksi]

i like this song so much i cry, without fail ... or shame! EVERY time! i kid you not!!!!



[jdhamiltonx2]

I met Roger in 1994 and he is a musician's musician. A very talented man !

[sharkdavil]

@jdhamiltonx2 That is awesome for you. I would love to meet Roger, he seems like he would be a really down to earth, and humble man.

[sweetgypsy100]

one of the saddest sweetest songs on the planet. The orchestra is wonderful--Roger's voice as lovely as a soft pillow...brilliant composition. "The questions run so deep"......

[Aliof]

Legend and imortal are the words that come to mind.

[ralphalphascout]

at 0:45, when he says world, his voice was so good and it changed my world. :o

[rudy664]

I just turned 16 and this is one of my favorite songs to bad they don't make songs like this anymore.none of today's music doesn't have any meaning. nothing like this anymore

[TheNickNuttall]

I'd say what I think of the highest rated comment, but that'd start a youtube fight. And nobody like those. Especially Roger Hodgson. Let's just enjoy a kick-butt song.

[tarp11z]

Gen X's national anthem.

[raiderdanCA]

I agree with kenmabie ... if you choose to look deep into Roger's lyrics, you'll see an individual who the world has stripped almost bare -- who is literally crying out the words "... please tell me who I AM "

It's topical, sad, but ultimately beautiful ... and above all, it's given to us in a command performance by this musical genius.

[Weezeganja]

the orchestra just tops it off

[Weezeganja]

everytime i hear that sax solo... its awesome

[jfsa380]

what DOESN'T sound better with an Orchestra?

[lesleyaspects]

yes indeed it good

[andywho2002]

The pain is palpaple. Great artists can translate that. Thank you.  I can now deal with it..

[regprob]

such a classic! boy do i missed these great years!!!!

[choicesman2000]

amazing how a song sung years ago resinates now so much thanks roger 

[JarnBjorn72]

This has been one of my #1 favorite songs for so long now! Long live Supertramp!

[AGT0M]

Who's Justin Bieber, again?

[DCLACE]

Did you already see Roger's "cover" with real Supertramp? The guy performs and sings like an amateur, Rick should let him grow before accept him in the band. He's good, but when we see him with the others, it's weird.

[DCLACE]

What's this Justin Bieber crap? A fly? What we're watching here is one genious, if you someone wants compare this presentation with anything else, compare with a real musician, pls!

[Elizabeth13134]

Wonderful song from when i was 12. Love it!!!

[lovehorses03]

totally awesome!! thanks!

[adyswh]

See the dislike bar?

Yeah, me neither.

[raiderdanCA]

An absolutely beautiful singing performance ... and the violins and cellos drive me up the wall ... CLASSIC

[chpnlzt]

@hamilton1776

DON'T FORGET ABOUT JEFF LYNNE - THE GENIUS BEHIND ELO AND THE TRAVELING WILBURYS ETC. ETC.

AND SOOO MANY MORE LIKE ROBERT PLANT ETC. ETC.

[DCLACE]

@chpnlzt Agree!!! ELO another great band, there was music and musicians in the Earth. Now, unfortunatly, we're watching them go, little by little, and what's left for the new generation is Justins, Ladies and fakes.

America, Eagles, Supertramp, Bee Gees, Beatles, Tears for Fears, Peter Frampton, Genesis, etc, etc, etc... I miss them!

[chpnlzt]

THE BIGGEST STAR IN THE WORLD OUTSIDE OF THE MAINSTREAM - HE CREATED HIS OWN STREAM.......

[spindrifter2]

@chpnlzt Absolutely right the biggest star out of mainstream. This man never got the recognition he deserves! Brilliant muso. Seen him twice in the original Supertramp in Oz and once in London.

[KlondikeBarFTW]

where they send you is school. sure you have friends but... they hold you down, make you "sensible, reliable, and especially a vegetable".

[miami1000111]

This song means soo much now a days and im 14 and this song speaks to me :D

[hamilton1776]

Roger Hodgson..John Lennon..Paul McCartney...Elton John...WHAT was in the water in the UK that permitted them, and the other musical genius to flourish -- and WHAT did we do to be stuck with the garbage that we are forced to listen to today??

[ilackedtheheart]

@hamilton1776 not to mention bands like Led Zeppelin, the Who, and Queen. The British kicked the crap out of our music across the Atlantic during the late 60's-80's.

[hugobvo]

@hamilton1776

[YAHOOOGIRL1]

@hamilton1776 Believe me, i've been asking myself the same question for the last 3 years.

[gordoxium]

@hamilton1776 your not forgetting about Freddy Murcury surely....

[tbscrazy12]

@hamilton1776 If you open up your mind, and turn off the radio. Human beings make music not corporations. Turn off the TV and open your mind- you may be surprised.

[mabisuatar]

@hamilton1776 You had forgot Cat Stevens.

[Pwnzor024]

@hamilton1776 you forget george harrison, led zeppelin, the who, pink floyd, the rolling stones, queen, and many other bands and artists ;)

[pookdaffodil]

ชอบๆๆๆๆ



[OakMoB510]

8 ppl never thought life was wonderful as a kid ahah

[emdob]

stop talking about Justin Bieber!!!!! It doesn't even compare

[loveyhoet]

Talk about illogical ... this tune was playing in my ear when I woke in the morning. I said to myself, self? You know this song ... All of a sudden, the melody and lyrics were surfacing in my mind - I began to sing it out load. Still, I had no title of the song. I tried to sing bits from the verse and bits from the Chorus, hoping I'd recognise the name of it. So, when I had the chance to jump on line ... I heard the words, 'logical and magical' come to me.  Wellah! There you have it ...

[LanceLange]

Roger is a gift to us all, I am very grateful for him! Going to see him in October for the first time!!!

[Thaepae]

but with all the blabla here we still do not know who play the saxophone !!!

[xaedmon]

When we were a child....our thoughts were sweet & manner mild...Joy of life was ours everyday....until it came time to send us away....according to state rules we had to be sent to public schools...to be judged & catagorized by how well we memorized....& after the years of being tested & graded our secret joys slowly faded....So our "education" came at great cost.....as with every test taken, a piece of ourselves was lost.

[allaroundthemorning]

What year is this from?

[PaulLBerriman]

A WONDERFUL song, and sounds really great with the orchestra!

[extremesoul666]

damn i got chills during the sax solo

[myapocolypse1]

That is one hell of a sax dude, man that thing was talkin!!

[yankeesstink27]

Who's the sax player?

[Tobbe999999999999999]

sounds so much better with an orchestra, trully a masterpiece, really pwns all modern pop and hip hop.

[FunkyWhitePimp]

This blows all the rap shit out the water...

[newey1965]

@FunkyWhitePimp  right on dude!!!!!!

[777derevo]

on the waves of my memory

[bellezafiro]

the best of the best

[muniama1]

Nobody else can ever sing this song like Roger Hodgson himself...but then Supertramp and Roger Hodgson is ONE. Supertramp isn't complete without Mr Hodgson nor he is doing that great either without the band. Life is really too short to have all these whatever that has gone on between Rick and he to stall anymore. I love Supertramp and it saddens me that the breakup happened

[TheMrFinneth]

a vegetable!

[pedroca2424]

Why would anyone bring Justin Bieber to this video?

Cmon, let him be and let's enjoy one of the best songs ever made...

[bonofreak18]

Justin Bieber can't sing for shit. I heard he just lipsinks, and the vocals for his live shows come off the P.A speakers because his singing is that bad. And I would kill him if he sang the logical song. He would kill this song entirely.

[nonavarium]

E P I C!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[MrGualazz]

AHHHH, La escuche en Europa y Mèxico. Mi juventud.

[ZiWooKie]

for some reason, im spamming this music xD

[juaneco333]

 La mejor parte de mi vida .... Gracias .

[juaneco333]

...

[3083janice]

wow, i was in the edmonton concert somewhat 28 years ago. it is sooo goood. can't get enough of it especially the lyrics.

janice mar 18,2011

[cjenkins73]

Great British music :)

[forrestwirt]

Who the f..k is Scooter!!

[TheBlackstone123]

guys both are Definable like Scooter version and that one ... (Danish)

[SouthendGamer]

wow how different does this sound to Scooters version

[possitivlystoned]

God he makes singing this song look so easy...

[siri0te]

Fucking awesome!

[beroth77]

No more comments about Bieber please.He's not worthy.Some people said some nonsense things about him and all this new crap just to annoy fans of real musicians and laught when get angry answers.So no more Bieber please ol!!! Peace!

[The1erREC]

I totally agree! And I really wonder how many people here don't even have just a blink of knowledge how awesome the influence of this man got through millions of songs the following decades after his visionary work. Justin who? Isn't this kind of a teen-furt? After he RH left the band, Supertramp became insignificant even their fantastic art-work still lives on.This is what happemns to all those great bands like The Beatles, Pink Floyd, Genesis (B-for their Re-Union), Led Zeppelin or Sex Pistols

[nursegina13]

I'm lost here! Roger Hodgson was never in Supertramp!............He was Supertramp!

[JamaicaGold1]

ABSOLUTELY EPIC!!!

[choicesman2000]

Thanks roger for all the songs all I am saying

[alalas66]

i keep wondering how we cannot have good singers, writers and principally songs like this. Why should we stay accpeting some bullshits like eminem, akon, bieber and other trashes??? were our youth been lost??? where did we make the mistake??? is there anyway to pull them back to the reality of the good things in life?? these are the questions which do not stop to come up to my mind!!! HELLP!!!

[Gasparcota]

Este tema dos Supertramp, para além de ser um ícone dos anos 80, está aqui mais uma vez impecávelmente bem arranjado. A orquestra dá um brilho ao brilhante Roger Hodgson. Parabéns!

[LAN70X000]

Night of the Proms, conducted by R. Groslot ...Antwerp, Belgium

[bhite41]

keith partridge has nothing on roger hodgson

[alexmagall]

Incrível! Nunca imaginei que veria uma música preferida tão maravilhosamente interpretada. Obrigado, bradrndavis. É tudo profundamente emocionante!

[kenmabie]

Watch what you say they'll be calling you radical, a liberal, fanatical , a criminal...

those words mean more now than ever...

[JCMJFCM]

@kenmabie Uneducated people have a need to label things.... when ultimately we are who we are. Why can't people just live and let live. :)

[GroenGeleSer]

@kenmabie it's scary how relevant to today this is 

[kenmabie]

@kenmabie look you little preteen shits, bieber is nothing, he is davey jones and the monkees to john lennon john lennon and the beatles, do you understand? no ? of course not i wouldnt expect you bitches to know good music

[kenmabie]

who the fuck is talking about bieber? and seriously ? is this going to happen on every music file now, stupid ass preteen girls talking about how bieber is soooo good? look you little preteen shits, bieber is nothing, he is davey jones and the monkees to john lennon john lennon and the beatles, do you understand? no ? of course not i wouldnt expect you bitches to know good music

[kenmabie]

who the fuck is talking about bieber? and seriously ? is this going to happen on every music file now, stupid ass preteen girls talking about how bieber is soooo good? look you little preteen shits, bieber is nothing, he is davey jones and the monkees to john lennon john lennon and the beatles, do you understand? no ? of course not i wouldnt expect you bitches to know good music

[franklin56534]

this is music

[1122Mateo]

Viva Roger Hodson vaya voz que tiene sobretodo en dreamer

[LadyDark000]

God... stop talking about this babyshit Bieber!

Just listen this excellent song

[Choefoe]

@LadyDark000 you just joined the conversation yourself;-)

[emmulator]

why would everyone who plays sax needs to look like they had bad motives...?

[alxazazel]

Poor quality thouhg :( Such a pity for such a phenomenal masterpiece!

[ryanneary1234]

James may looks like him

[erikasales1]

That's beautiful! I love this guys!!

[jethrowhite]

sumstance and so much content perfect holy music for the soul to rejoice

[Ununpentium]

6 users have no youtube-plugin

[peter007taylor]

Probably one of the Top ten best songs ever written...Epic Performance..

[PoetaEu]

Acho que algumas coisas ficam na memoria, passam a fazer parte da vida dagente. Uma marca incrustada na cabeça , na pele, os cheiros os sonos, tatuagens da paixão!

Valew, valew porque eu vivi estes momentos, e ela sabe disso!

[gregaroo329]

Is Supertramp playing or just Roger? Great song!  Thanks for posting!

[316Ratllesnakeye]

@gregaroo329 just roger, see the name of the vid, it says Roger hodgson With Orchestra, not supertramp.

[Hueyham]

so joyfully indeed

[GuANtMeN]

the besssssst!

[pooriaekabir]

Great song and brilliant orchestral arrangement. 

[bernardomatute]

excelente

[KaiLuley]

LoL ... Justin Bieber will never in his life beat this ... he is just a poor promoted little Boy, who´s not able to sing one correct note without the help of electronic solutions. He is simply not allowed to sing a masterpiece like this one.

Listen to this really fantastic piece of music. Only the chords alone are genius ... Love it

[EpicFluffmiester]

@KaiLuley As much as i dont like this music If you actually do your research. Justin Bieber is actually a decent musician and If he had been picked up by someone decent(NOT USHER) he might be popular in a good way. THe kid can play Piano, Guitar, and he has a decent voice. Not by any circumstance do i promote listening to that piece of shit "My World".

[callmeDante]

@KaiLuley "Only the chords alone are genius"? Oh, how I so earnestly disagree. The deep and meaningful lyrics, the orchestral arrangement that Hodgson helped to write, the man's ability to play AND sing? There is far more than genius than just CHORDS in this masterpiece.

[Morumt]

@KaiLuley Realy love the the chords, specialy in this song. Very fantastic. And justin bieber does not write his own music either, he wrote one song, and pay'd others to write for him, he's a giraf.

But all in all. Supertramp along with Toto are the best bands from the past i think. They have the best writn music, and the best chords and melodies.

[Morumt]

@KaiLuley

Realy love the the chords, specialy in this song. Very fantastic. And justin bieber does not write his own music either, he wrote one song, and pay'd others to write for him, he's a giraf.

But all in all. Supertramp along with Toto are the best bands from the past i think. They have the best writn music, and the best chords and melodies.

[andacg1]

@KaiLuley DID he sing it? If not I see no reason for this comment

[mannyR37]

@KaiLuley Justin who?

[lizbrennerurrutia]

@KaiLuley Please don't compare SHIT with a real musician. That Bieber is only a way of manipulating the new generations, or let say to keep them DUMB in order to manipulate them.

[ArtisticwithaK]

@KaiLuley Justin Bieber will never beat anything, my friend.

[sophiapuppy]

This is AWESOME. Listen up 2011 Recording Artists...

This is how it's done.

[mazeltov11]

best damn lyrics evar

[veckyr]

Wow wow wow !!!!

[jammmon]

WOW! 3:00

I love that moment when the drummer stops playing for a second and everything seems to fall apart

[Kwontumn]

He always seems so happy, and he's always really into his songs. Great performer!

[dappstarr]

He sings so well and in tune, this guy is the real talent behind these songs.

[Blooman27]

This version is too awesome for words.... who needs supertramp? Not this guy...

[Conqueror441]

WOW I have just discovered I new Band that I have to add to my Youtube Favorites.

LMAO!!

[pocketmnstr11]

One of the best songs Roger wrote at the time, but talking of later times are any interested in "Talking Heads". ?? WOW !!.