Feels like the drummer needs to lose the click track - the guitars are pushing ahead to try and up the tempo a bit but it doesn't go anywhere . . . still, a very good version of XTC's classic. Again, probably very good choice to cover this song - thumbs up from me.
As a longtime fan of geek pop (XTC, They Might Be Giants esp), it's still a little weird to see a 'hot girl' sing some of these sarcastic nerd-classic lyrics.
I've been an XTC fan for a long time, and I'm not, and don't think I'll ever be a fan of Mandy Moore. That being said, any female singer that likes XTC enough to make a cover of one of her songs has my admiration. Surely she didn't do it because of the "huge commercial success" of the song, and her version is not bad, looks to me like he enjoys the song.Andy agreed to it because, I think, he has an open mind and doesn't consider his music sacred. I happen to think the same way.
I think it's quite appropriate that Mandy left the "turds and treasure" bit out of her song because I think if this cover teaches us anything it's that Mandy herself cannot tell the difference.
I love Mandy Moore, she's such a mixed bag - married to Ryan Adams, amazing taste in music, Tangled is awesome, her other films might not life changing, but she's never claimed to be the best - she's took her incredibly cheesey music career and turned it around, her last albums are pretty solid and on top of that, totally hot.
Don't know much about mandy moore, but she does sing this great song really well and good for her for choosing a song that might have been written before she was born.
The only cover I want from her is the one's coming off her bed! This is fucking embarrassing! Someone actually convinced her this sounded good! Damn on the bright side I guess I can do a fucked up cover,and get on TV! Rubbish!
there's something blasphemous about this... next? bieber performs making plans for nigel...
c02shows 1 week ago
No use bashing Mandy or any other singer or musician because, when compared to XTC, all are rubbish.
illinoisan 2 weeks ago
hack job of a good song
balor7 3 months ago
1:17 boobs? BOOBS? nope... :(
Nick1120NR2003 4 months ago
Well done mandy. Great cover version
monosound81 4 months ago
well, she didn't completely destroy. I more impressed she even knows who XTC is.
crisesdog420 4 months ago
She looks like Haley Kiyoko
AndiBasit 5 months ago
Feels like the drummer needs to lose the click track - the guitars are pushing ahead to try and up the tempo a bit but it doesn't go anywhere . . . still, a very good version of XTC's classic. Again, probably very good choice to cover this song - thumbs up from me.
Nealo81 5 months ago
really?
mymgftube 7 months ago
As a longtime fan of geek pop (XTC, They Might Be Giants esp), it's still a little weird to see a 'hot girl' sing some of these sarcastic nerd-classic lyrics.
DrGrumbles612 8 months ago
It's cool that she covered an XTC song, but this arrangement is horrible and over-produced...
lush89 9 months ago
small minded bunch
soizic1969 10 months ago
i like the different flavour of this childhood favourite.What would be the point of doing it the same as XTC.......
soizic1969 10 months ago
WTF WAS SHE THINKING???
artgonewrong 10 months ago
All the tension and buildup is gone from this version. Still, I'm glad she has the taste to choose this song to cover.
AshMonday 10 months ago 3
You guys, come on, who cares if Mandy Moore's version is not very like the original. That is what a cover means. Plus she is fun to look at :).
I like how she turns the scary parts into jam band time instead.
llcdrdndgrbd 10 months ago
Mandy, I dig your personality but this is "passing a stone" painful.
comradevodka 11 months ago
She left the turds out because she must have known they would show up to comment against her here anyway, thereby completing the song.
lafingnome 11 months ago
I've been an XTC fan for a long time, and I'm not, and don't think I'll ever be a fan of Mandy Moore. That being said, any female singer that likes XTC enough to make a cover of one of her songs has my admiration. Surely she didn't do it because of the "huge commercial success" of the song, and her version is not bad, looks to me like he enjoys the song.Andy agreed to it because, I think, he has an open mind and doesn't consider his music sacred. I happen to think the same way.
lafingnome 11 months ago 10
This represents everything that's wrong with the music industry. Only thing worse than the backing band is Mandy.
gorillaurine 11 months ago
I think it's quite appropriate that Mandy left the "turds and treasure" bit out of her song because I think if this cover teaches us anything it's that Mandy herself cannot tell the difference.
Nemspy 11 months ago
Wow, this may be one of the worst things I've ever seen. Another great song rendered "meh" by Mandy Moore.
exlibriscat 11 months ago
Doesn't youtube have policy against posting video of people defecating on things?
TheKnightwhisper 1 year ago
I love Mandy Moore, she's such a mixed bag - married to Ryan Adams, amazing taste in music, Tangled is awesome, her other films might not life changing, but she's never claimed to be the best - she's took her incredibly cheesey music career and turned it around, her last albums are pretty solid and on top of that, totally hot.
steshimmie 1 year ago
Don't know much about mandy moore, but she does sing this great song really well and good for her for choosing a song that might have been written before she was born.
or not much after
mullwharchar 1 year ago
The only cover I want from her is the one's coming off her bed! This is fucking embarrassing! Someone actually convinced her this sounded good! Damn on the bright side I guess I can do a fucked up cover,and get on TV! Rubbish!
gahloot 1 year ago
Impeccable taste in music...
milesanddizzy 1 year ago
A Star Search level performance.
justingeist 1 year ago
@hbwc13 this 1 should be!!!
ruoldenuff 1 year ago
COVERS SHOULD BE ILLEGAL.
hbwc13 1 year ago
This would be perfectly acceptable without the stupid "wicky-wicky" scratch fx.
itstolaugh 1 year ago
I prefer the original, but this cover's OK
Laurent75017 1 year ago