Yoshiki wrote this song, hide wrote guitar lines ( solo) for this song, taji didn't like the bass lines so he rewrote one for himself. pretty much they all worked together for this song.
This is one of the greatest masterpieces of all symphonic metal in history. The whole thing was composed by Yoshiki, even the orchestra parts. They needed no additional composer, everything was there. And watch that bass! It's symphonically awesome and coherent with the orchestra!
@alejandronova Hideto "hide" Matsumoto or also known as Hide-sama is the Composer of Rose of pain not Yoshiki. Allthough Yoshiki organized the Orchestra, Hide is the Composer of this song. Just thought you'd like to know.
Hide has also composed other songs featured in X-Japan Albums such as Scars, Tears and Art of life. and many many more, some are yet not released =)
@CaptainnKarizmaa Yoshiki wrote Rose of Pain, Art of Life and Tears, not hide. Yoshiki's songs have a sophisticated melancholy and are full of roses, death, suicidal musings, narcissism and violence. hide's X Japan songs, like Celebration and Joker, were rambunctious, silly, angry, and not particularly reflective. It's amazing that you would confuse the two.
@rizikm I kinda see where you're coming from... But the way you put it makes it sound like Hides songs are crap. He was quite the musical talent himself. Even if his material wasn't as "sophisticated" as Yoshikis.
I would have loved them to play art of life with live orchestra : ' (, but still, this is fucking epic, kickass, and whatever other word you can put to describe how awsome this song sounds!!!!
@kennyng1124 It's probably because this song has a darker sort of feeling to it, so they stuck with that sort of feeling when they applied the lights. That's my guess.
Can you really bank $43,945.75 in 30 days with ZERO investment? Here's what I know about it. People will do it with... Passive Income Advice [dot] com.
Taijiの髪ってなんでいつも、ひらひらなびいてるの?素敵過ぎる!!惚れ惚れしてしまいます...
alcall0914 3 weeks ago
メタルもオーケストラも同じ音楽なんだなと思った局です
burakkin7 1 month ago
YOSHIKI天才だわ。
なんというか、次元が他のバンドと2つほど違う。
mtsakurajima1117 2 months ago
ROSE OF PAINは20年以上聴いているが未だにいちばん好きな曲だ。
このツインとベースラインは本当にしびれる。
doraebon1000 3 months ago
GREAT .LEGENDARY. So Much More Than Word Can Say . . .
bytoitoi 3 months ago
Toshis voice here is really good
rampage222555 4 months ago
やはり、Rose of Painは、アコギバージョンよりこっちのほうが断然良い。
doiko33 5 months ago
X最速の曲はオルガズムやsteb me in the backではなく実はこの曲です
Glitnil 7 months ago
RIP Taiji, you'll still living in our heart!
CSNK2008 7 months ago 4
Taiji is no longer with us...i dunno what more to say... RIP.
phodem12pm 7 months ago 2
TAIJI's groove really rocks
model23girl23 8 months ago 2
best
Noisy0fficial 10 months ago
art of life & rose of pain are both epic!!!
ML1412 10 months ago
@ML1412
add one more, orgasm ^^
reifukaiyukikaze 8 months ago
This band should tour Europe and participate on mayor metalfests like Wacken Open Air and Graspop Metal Meeting
Djedefra 11 months ago 5
The energy that the drummer gives to this song it's epic!!
enrealidad 1 year ago
i think if they ever play this song live again, the drumming would be too much of a strain for yoshiki
Roxcee88 1 year ago
лучшие!!! единственная группа от которой бегут мурашки по спине.
SergeyWilliams 1 year ago
i love this song
TheJmetal 1 year ago
EPIC SONG!!!
Kreits50 1 year ago
Yoshiki wrote this song, hide wrote guitar lines ( solo) for this song, taji didn't like the bass lines so he rewrote one for himself. pretty much they all worked together for this song.
phodem12pm 1 year ago
It's good
jaksith 1 year ago
This song was composed by Yoshiki.
And Tears, Art of life too
3030hirosu 1 year ago
@3030hirosu No. Hide composed 7 songs for X-japan
CaptainnKarizmaa 1 year ago
@CaptainnKarizmaa tears was writed by yoshiki for his father hide composed celebration miscast love replica scars and sadistic desire
palkiasmaster235 1 year ago
@CaptainnKarizmaa
・・・YOSHIKI wrote this song
This song and Art of life are so powerful and beautiful songs written by YOSHIKI
3030hirosu 1 year ago
@Jujumasta: This live is from December '91 not '89
4433528534 1 year ago
20年以上前になるのか…。
こんな格調高い曲を89年に。YOSHIKI天才。
夢でいいからこの会場で生で見てみたい。
ogobbb 1 year ago 3
One of my favourable song from X Japan besides Art of Life
kuanyuehshen 1 year ago 2
taijiのベースタッピング見たかった・・・。
しかしこの曲はやっぱ最高!
lowrider1995 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
FF8EDEN8 1 year ago
Motherfucking masterpiece for the ages.
ChevalierAguila 1 year ago 11
Yoshiki you are so greatest drummer.....
can you teach me how to play a drum???
MrToletta 1 year ago
Toshi can't sing it again!!
modelsdreamcom 1 year ago
Perfect performance. I question the validity of this video. These guys are one hell of a talented group.
Dpickle3 1 year ago
@Dpickle3 This vid was a long time ago. In 91'
crazyotaku4ever 1 year ago
This is one of the greatest masterpieces of all symphonic metal in history. The whole thing was composed by Yoshiki, even the orchestra parts. They needed no additional composer, everything was there. And watch that bass! It's symphonically awesome and coherent with the orchestra!
alejandronova 1 year ago 7
@alejandronova Hideto "hide" Matsumoto or also known as Hide-sama is the Composer of Rose of pain not Yoshiki. Allthough Yoshiki organized the Orchestra, Hide is the Composer of this song. Just thought you'd like to know.
Hide has also composed other songs featured in X-Japan Albums such as Scars, Tears and Art of life. and many many more, some are yet not released =)
We Are X -
CaptainnKarizmaa 1 year ago
@CaptainnKarizmaa Thanks! I'll keep this in mind. So Hide composed this...
alejandronova 1 year ago
@CaptainnKarizmaa Yoshiki wrote Rose of Pain, Art of Life and Tears, not hide. Yoshiki's songs have a sophisticated melancholy and are full of roses, death, suicidal musings, narcissism and violence. hide's X Japan songs, like Celebration and Joker, were rambunctious, silly, angry, and not particularly reflective. It's amazing that you would confuse the two.
rizikm 8 months ago 4
@rizikm I kinda see where you're coming from... But the way you put it makes it sound like Hides songs are crap. He was quite the musical talent himself. Even if his material wasn't as "sophisticated" as Yoshikis.
tobbaddol 3 months ago
@tobbaddol Yeah I was probably too hard on hide. I'm a big fan of his solo work, and his version of Celebration from New Years Eve 1994 was amazing.
rizikm 3 months ago
@CaptainnKarizmaa
Not sure if troll...
Everyone's answer the mistakes of this post. I have nothing more to contribute.
Mangasama 7 months ago
PATAかっこいい!
maxryopu 1 year ago 5
sounds to much like Europe for my taste !
jayfirev 1 year ago
this is god~~~
hayaku~running to put this on my long song list apart from Art of Life and Orgasm
XD
reifukaiyukikaze 1 year ago
I would have loved them to play art of life with live orchestra : ' (, but still, this is fucking epic, kickass, and whatever other word you can put to describe how awsome this song sounds!!!!
DaenThunderKnight 2 years ago
why didn't they put spotlight on taiji?
but doesn't matter, he rules
kennyng1124 2 years ago 35
@kennyng1124 It's probably because this song has a darker sort of feeling to it, so they stuck with that sort of feeling when they applied the lights. That's my guess.
Dyingbreed1990 1 year ago
Comment removed
mura0210 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this band, sucks
YDumFock 2 years ago
dude.... we dont care what you think! why are u even here looking and writing then?
and i can see why u think them suck when u listen to a sucky band like metallica haha
bohemianraphsody 2 years ago 3
pataのギターではじまるとこがいい
hosizora22s 2 years ago
The Bass lines sound so beautiful.
colongil 2 years ago 7
@colongil if u learnt bass you'd realise how hard it is too xD
GottaXLoveXBou 1 year ago
@GottaXLoveXBou Emmm, i'm not saying is NOT HARD. Of course if it is. Why the comment?
colongil 1 year ago
@colongil jst to show how hard it is, been learning it for 4ish months -_- lol
GottaXLoveXBou 1 year ago
I can't tell for sure who wrote this (always thought it was yoshiki) but I agree on it being their best fucking song ever.
TheFourthDefender 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
exeter 2 years ago
@exeter Yoshiki wrote this bro.
thenewtitle26 2 years ago 3
I think the tension with Taiji was more about Voicless Screaming.
Parabellum13X 2 years ago
equally bad ass and amazying
exeter 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
You are full of shit.
colongil 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can you really bank $43,945.75 in 30 days with ZERO investment? Here's what I know about it. People will do it with... Passive Income Advice [dot] com.
BrittPhillips 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is it symphonic metal?
beautyerica 2 years ago
ベースラインがほんとヤバイ。カッコよすぎる!
snowgroove 2 years ago 7
both versions are great!! even the piano one :) they were so great!
MikuBouSunday12 2 years ago
this song was never made to be an acoustic song.
thenewtitle26 2 years ago 7
They should've added to kick ass solos into the acoustic version
chingvang559 2 years ago
マジ最高!
badmintonlove325 2 years ago 7
BTW:
Taiji owns on the bass.
colongil 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
colongil 2 years ago
I love you Yoshiki
Genavieve4077 2 years ago 4
taijiのベースラインすごい!めっちゃカッコいい!!
snowgroove 2 years ago 41
TAIJIIIIII!!!!!
HTBLH 2 years ago 7
I love this song <3 X 4ever!
TheUnforgottenHide 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
So Beautiful ♥
MelesAnakuma 2 years ago
they need to re-record this song...or atleast start playing it live again
chingvang559 2 years ago
They do... They only play certain songs anymore at lives. Playing some of their classics would be nice...
Toshikihito 2 years ago
もはや マジで天才集団
bigdaygroup2 2 years ago 6
サンクス フォー アップロード。
bigdaygroup2 2 years ago 3
taiji最高
bigdaygroup2 2 years ago 3
great!
wbcmans 2 years ago 3
*0*
Franciscso 2 years ago 4
Terrific song !!!
Thx for sharing !!!
excxhxo 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
come check out my x japan guitar solos compilation
chingvang559 2 years ago
woot a full version awesome song =)
aquaYsnorkel 3 years ago
what an epic masterpiece...
kennyng1124 3 years ago 7
はじめてみました。最高
slash19931231 3 years ago 4
AWESOME !
EscaladeStyleZ 3 years ago