A goodperformance, overall. Probably is much better watching it live. I'd love to sing it with a choral group backing up one of the many sopranos in the Asheville, NC, USA,
My favorite recording of this piece is on a CD with the great Cheryl Studer doing this and many other pieces in the repertoire with religious themes. Good posting! Thanks!
Good performance, Sophie Yelland. The acoustics rather spoil it but that is not your fault.
It's a shame that you've had such silly remarks. When YouTube started we had Americans with a mental age of 10, saying 'this sucks' to everything they didn't understand but now we have so-called experts proving what smart-arses they are at the expense of good efforts like this. I think I prefer the 10yo yanks.
Far too much vibrato - it's not natural, sounds odd, and doesn't work for this piece. It's also too slow and partly because of this, sung with a complete lack of any feeling or passion. Doesn't really sound like iniquity and hatred are being cast upon them!
Its terrible with a soprano... The solo should always be sung by a treble (in my opinion). We're singing it again on Sunday, and our treble is fantastic... He was the runner up of the chorister of the year competition!
A bit too much vibrato for my liking from the soloist, and the rubato style singing again isn't to my fancy. Our chapel choir did this in our college a couple years back (I'm a tenor in our choir) and it is a marvelous piece.
I agree. One of the most beautiful pieces ever written. And I also think that the Soloist has a little too much vibrato, but since I sing base I could not do any better. All in all it is well performed.
On some points our choir sang it a little faster. But it is still good.
Well, the soloist, if you look closely, has 2 ponytails, and no boy has that much vibrato, you'd have to be a man to have that much vibrato, and by then, you wouldn't be a soprano any more...in most cases.
And from 5.34, the solo bit is what I'm doing for my church choir audition in 4 days, on Friday.
The video is complete; the remainder of it is in part 2 as there is a time limit for videos. However, thanks for alerting me to the mp3 on my site, it does finish a few seconds early. I will fix that soon.
The vibrato is absurd.
PalmerJennie 11 months ago
A goodperformance, overall. Probably is much better watching it live. I'd love to sing it with a choral group backing up one of the many sopranos in the Asheville, NC, USA,
My favorite recording of this piece is on a CD with the great Cheryl Studer doing this and many other pieces in the repertoire with religious themes. Good posting! Thanks!
OperaBuff1935 1 year ago
Superb. Even a Yank can appreciate this.
jblacktree 1 year ago
Good performance, Sophie Yelland. The acoustics rather spoil it but that is not your fault.
It's a shame that you've had such silly remarks. When YouTube started we had Americans with a mental age of 10, saying 'this sucks' to everything they didn't understand but now we have so-called experts proving what smart-arses they are at the expense of good efforts like this. I think I prefer the 10yo yanks.
DavidMJordan 2 years ago
they're amateurs lol give them a chance
vernon361970 2 years ago
We did this in choir - Warrington Musical Society. I love this piece <3 xx
flowerfaerie087 2 years ago
who wrote this????
360dabomb1 2 years ago
Mendelssohn
PuffBall6 2 years ago
Mendelssohn
u7alll 2 years ago
too much vibrato...doesnt work.
good otherwise
lloydino 2 years ago 3
Far too much vibrato - it's not natural, sounds odd, and doesn't work for this piece. It's also too slow and partly because of this, sung with a complete lack of any feeling or passion. Doesn't really sound like iniquity and hatred are being cast upon them!
vickerini 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
為了表達我的憤怒我要用母語再說一次
拜託你們不要從頭到尾出白聲!!!!!!很不好聽!!!!!!!好想大叫!!!!!!!
頭腔多用一點!!!!!!
嘴型大一點!!!!!!
加油,好嗎?
好啦我太激動了 只是點誠心的建議
但我真的很誠心= =
sevenmetre 2 years ago
Well and when I hear the chorus.........everything seems like getting worse= =
More room for resonance, please!
sevenmetre 2 years ago
Sound like the solo drews her voice too backward in oral cavity and the retroflex is terribily obvious.....
My opinion. Pardon me if I offend anyone.
sevenmetre 2 years ago
Its terrible with a soprano... The solo should always be sung by a treble (in my opinion). We're singing it again on Sunday, and our treble is fantastic... He was the runner up of the chorister of the year competition!
woodsxxii 2 years ago
i think the recit is done abit quick
livandjazz 2 years ago
the soloist's singing is a little bit too throaty, but it's quite good overall
jacquelinart 3 years ago 4
My favourite version is Kiri te Kanawa with the Mormon Tabernacle Choir.
georgebur 3 years ago
A bit too much vibrato for my liking from the soloist, and the rubato style singing again isn't to my fancy. Our chapel choir did this in our college a couple years back (I'm a tenor in our choir) and it is a marvelous piece.
vintoe 3 years ago
I agree. One of the most beautiful pieces ever written. And I also think that the Soloist has a little too much vibrato, but since I sing base I could not do any better. All in all it is well performed.
On some points our choir sang it a little faster. But it is still good.
8Ryuk8 3 years ago
To be a boy soprano, he is very good. My respect!
elinorberg 3 years ago
i'm pretty sure it's not a boy soprano... forgive me for being frank but how many boys do you know called Sophie?
DuckInABowl 3 years ago 2
Well, the soloist, if you look closely, has 2 ponytails, and no boy has that much vibrato, you'd have to be a man to have that much vibrato, and by then, you wouldn't be a soprano any more...in most cases.
And from 5.34, the solo bit is what I'm doing for my church choir audition in 4 days, on Friday.
stad97 3 years ago
A shame that here (and on the download from your link) the song isn't recorded untill the finish:(
eumhpie 3 years ago
The video is complete; the remainder of it is in part 2 as there is a time limit for videos. However, thanks for alerting me to the mp3 on my site, it does finish a few seconds early. I will fix that soon.
musicedworld 3 years ago
awesome!! it's really good both the soloist and the choir! respect!!!
eumhpie 3 years ago
Great we loved it.
Langagirl1 4 years ago
Nice solo. My choir did this for my installation as a treble.
Langagirl1 4 years ago