@mishmoshable There the closest thing as not having titles. They are made that way so that way you can imagine them into anything that you like. There's no pretense going into it saying that this is the reason it sounds like this or anything like that.
When i first listen the deluxe edition of ghost I-IV, it was pretty good track. i still have the album version of nine inch nails with no bonus tracks, so i like both version of ghost I-IV. it's a peaceful music. A+
@DirtyDickDiesel - Electronic - certainly. It would be impossible to associate Reznor with any one genre in particular. Trent has incorporated everything from classical, alternative, experimental rock, electronic, and one that he pioneered - industrial. The man's a genius, and has continuously shifted and shaped my perception of music as a medium and an art form.
@MagnitudePerson trent said "enjoy the first four albums of ghosts" he said FIRST four. i really dont know, but according to sources thats what he said. so it sounds like there is
reminds me of demon seed, i bet it is n early version, or parts of this were taken, either way trent u r a god keep it up, i hope u dont retire any time soon
You would be correct (mostly) on that one. Demon seed does have some of the same tracks (or parts) from this song. But yes, hell fucking awesome regardless..
Not bad at all. Trent, he's basically on his own at this point, is good at singing, guitar and keyboards (plugged and unplugged) but sometimes he really EXCELS at programming. This is one of those times. His sense of beat timing from breakdowns to crescendos is impeccable. Reminds me of the Opal Mix of Head Like a Hole.
I think, instead of being a mix, it was one of two bonus tracks found on the vinyll version of Ghosts. The vinyll ablum was included with the limited editio, super-mega-deluxe-whatever edition that you could buy for a small fortune within the few first minutes ghosts was released.
Demon Seed to Ghosts 38 are to me like "Blue Monday" to "The Beach" by New Order. The vocal version is cool just because of the lyrics and the neat stuff that happens there, but the instrumental version is much more complex and intricate.
The only thing that's the same between the two is the beat. I wouldn't call this one an "instrumental version", or even a "version", since it just contains a few components of Demon Seed. It's a completely different song, although it appears to be somewhat related. Completely different mood and instrumentation, though.
I admit that would be really cool to see the progression, however, I also believe that some of the Ghosts songs are just pure gold. I wouldn't have them any other way, as - in a selfish manner - I don't want them to change.
They're all experiments, and for Trent to actually willfully show us the progression and the amount of change a song can go through, I'm pleased.
I concur, Kaoritsukino. The progression of that instrumental album is astounding, and I love to hear a more experimental, less structured NIN sound. The whole album is very atmospheric.
I hate it when I see retarded comments like this. Trent isn't PRO torrenting his music, it still pisses him off that people steal his music, he just recognizes that bitching about it isn't going to be productive.
And you know this how? Trent has made it clear that he doesn't mind anymore. Hell, he uploaded Closure & a few other bits of his music onto torrents ( under a secret name for obvious reasons)
I think it's a combination. Trent isn't happy that people steal from him, but he's also very understanding of the fight with the music industry and their gags to rip off their consumers. He despises that the industry is only focused on making a buck, so he has tried to encourage fans to "rip" the music industry off. I wouldn't say he'd tell you straightforward to always steal from him, but moreover, steal the music that you're being ripped off by - the music from under the labels.
Yeah that's a possibility as well. Though in recent shows he's said "Go ahead steal my music but buy theirs" He supports the upcoming bands so he doesn't want you to steal it all. But he did upload Closure & two "NIN Greatest Hits" albums onto torrents
Yeah, of course he says "buy theirs." He wants you to support artists. I don't think he'd say that about another band, "Hey, yeah, you like me, and it's alright if you steal my music, so go ahead and steal theirs." It seems to be his own way of using his music and popularity with his fans to get back at the industry - in other words, it's his music, so he's using it as almost a tool to get back at the industry as well as give his own artistic expression.
It's one thing that gives me enormous amounts of respect for Renzor. He belives in the music, and it is his art form, like paintings, which he just wants people to see and listen too. (IMO)
To get a better perspective, I ran across a recent article that's mostly Trent talking about his views - almost rambling, actually. Because I can't post URLs, google "SN&R exclusive Trent Reznor interview", and it should be the first.
They're not really comparable, because they're very, VERY different. The beat is the same, yes (although it has some minor differences), but everything else is for the most part completely different.
@bunone4billy Not at all, man. Demon Seed wasn't a very good song in my opinion. >.> I have everything he publicly put out so far, and Demon Seed is one of the three songs I'll skip off of all the other tracks.
@NIN99Koala DemonSeed isn't a good song? I've listened to it probably over 50 times now and my neck muscles are pulled from nodding my head to the beat. Speak for yourself.
The start and end sample, infact any off the samples are pure gold, but this one gotta be my favouriite sound sample, its like someone who goes into a bed and dreams or wakes up, you know what i mean. ;)
:P Sorry! I was actually surprised by how slowly people were reacting to it. I would have thought someone would have uploaded something much sooner than I had.
Comment removed
majin033 3 months ago
I wasn't even aware these existed. Thank you, internet.
AyaTeien 5 months ago
So - who can't wait for "The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo" soundtrack?
JesusCristo2002 5 months ago 8
is this the last ghost track song???
joseantoniopastrana 7 months ago
DEMON SEED REMIX!!!! FUCK Yeah
Zorvi4 8 months ago
@Zorvi4 not a remix, this song came before Demon Seed.
originalcoolstud 5 months ago 2
@originalcoolstud did not know. thanks
Zorvi4 2 months ago
@originalcoolstud didn't know. thanks.
Zorvi4 2 months ago
Comment removed
originalcoolstud 5 months ago
Comment removed
originalcoolstud 5 months ago
I think I here a modular synth at 1:35 and on! Does anyone know the deal Trent titling all his tracks with a number and Ghost?
mishmoshable 8 months ago
@mishmoshable There the closest thing as not having titles. They are made that way so that way you can imagine them into anything that you like. There's no pretense going into it saying that this is the reason it sounds like this or anything like that.
heretherenothing 7 months ago in playlist blha gho
@heretherenothing Open to interpretation hey.
mishmoshable 7 months ago
the abrupt stop at 2:57 was quite unnerving
ExpertiseGamer 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is really scary
ExpertiseGamer 9 months ago
2:20 I love how it has the power of a fucking electric guitar solo but the uniqueness of the industrial noise.
STVYT 11 months ago
is demon seed!!!! remixed
479lucho 11 months ago
When i first listen the deluxe edition of ghost I-IV, it was pretty good track. i still have the album version of nine inch nails with no bonus tracks, so i like both version of ghost I-IV. it's a peaceful music. A+
allremixedup01 1 year ago
if it was not for trent, alot of electronic music would not exsist
DirtyDickDiesel 1 year ago
@DirtyDickDiesel - Electronic - certainly. It would be impossible to associate Reznor with any one genre in particular. Trent has incorporated everything from classical, alternative, experimental rock, electronic, and one that he pioneered - industrial. The man's a genius, and has continuously shifted and shaped my perception of music as a medium and an art form.
JesusCristo2002 10 months ago
o_O Epic shiz there.
CustomSongCharter 1 year ago
sounds like he's raping the guitar
Paesguud 1 year ago
I could imagine trent soloing onstage for 5 mins with that sweet beat in the background...would be epic compared to demon seed
rdloop 1 year ago
Awesome, will there be more Ghosts albums? please...
MagnitudePerson 1 year ago
@MagnitudePerson trent said "enjoy the first four albums of ghosts" he said FIRST four. i really dont know, but according to sources thats what he said. so it sounds like there is
RetardedAndRandomTV 1 year ago
This song has made me realize exactly who I am. Now I know what it's all about.
GreenShark4 1 year ago 2
This track always puts a smile on my face.
metalgearcolin75 1 year ago
@metalgearcolin75 your comment + song makes me smile too :)
Couscous1985 1 year ago
Thank You Very Much !!!
emmanuelborja 1 year ago
I could imagine Miles Davis liking this.
gsarrells 1 year ago
really GEIL!!!!
theNINrocker 1 year ago
JESUS!!!!! this shoulda been on the fuckin regular album.dammit!
brix42 1 year ago
@brix42 I KNOW!
RetardedAndRandomTV 1 year ago
I want to download this awesome ghosts for a long time....
Staphylin 2 years ago
Can u make a link to download for this song??
mattheweirk777 2 years ago 2
there's a link for them in the ghosts 1-4 section of the NIN forums, u need to look really closely tho
METALHEAD975 2 years ago
This on a AKG K240 MkII sounds kick ass.
TwistedShrapnel 2 years ago
I'm glad that he didn't put it on the ghosts. It sure sounds great, but too many people would have whined because it kinda sounds like demon seed.
LingLingX8 2 years ago 5
I think people would have complained that Demon seed sounded too much like this.
crossraiyne 2 years ago 4
so what this is still a good song
METALHEAD975 2 years ago
The noise synth solo is awesome, it's like Jimi Hendrix on a synthesizer
badjesus666 2 years ago 8
Wow, simply, wow. I can't decide which track I like better, "Demon Seed" or "Ghosts 38". Pure genius.
MadeToBeGray 2 years ago 8
Il prefer this ghosts than many other on the ghosts I-IV album.
Staphylin 2 years ago 7
GOD SOUNDSCAPE @ END+GOOD INDUSTRIAL BEAT CONSTRUCTURE+GOOD RHYTMIC NOIZE SOLO'S!!! wow im a fanboi.. :P REAL-Industrial ftw.
MagnitudePerson 2 years ago 2
reminds me of demon seed, i bet it is n early version, or parts of this were taken, either way trent u r a god keep it up, i hope u dont retire any time soon
1curt12 2 years ago 12
You would be correct (mostly) on that one. Demon seed does have some of the same tracks (or parts) from this song. But yes, hell fucking awesome regardless..
vanriver11 2 years ago 4
Trent Reznor at his FUCKING best!!! :D
OhMyGodMuffins 2 years ago 31
i love this. shouldnt have been excluded from Ghosts I-IV
dtc5793 2 years ago 5
Yeha, and he shouldnt gavem ade mnore off the inviduels "sounds" periods.
3:57 Should have been an own tcomplete ambient track on itself, dont misinteprate the soundscapes X)''
MagnitudePerson 2 years ago
i totaly should have made my friend nick buy the box set
bryan11stewart 2 years ago
I love you. Thanks for these. I don't want to put out all that cash, but Ghosts are (is?) amazing. 37 is one of my favorites.
tabularasa000 2 years ago
sort of sounds like the end of Head Down
metalgearcolin75 2 years ago 2
They're in the multitracks on the deluxe edition of Ghosts I-IV. Too bad, because this ones one of my favorites.
seraph086770 2 years ago
Kind of sounds like Demon Seed, then more manipulated later... I like it though
tvsuicide4 2 years ago 3
Not bad at all. Trent, he's basically on his own at this point, is good at singing, guitar and keyboards (plugged and unplugged) but sometimes he really EXCELS at programming. This is one of those times. His sense of beat timing from breakdowns to crescendos is impeccable. Reminds me of the Opal Mix of Head Like a Hole.
Yapostadodat 2 years ago
Is there anyway I can get a mp3 for this song? It's amazing.
RockFanatic319 2 years ago
get a firefox addon that lets you d/l it
ajpatter210 2 years ago
i love that the synth sounds a fair bit like an old dial-up modem.
one of the best ghosts, in my opinion.
baacardi 2 years ago
Great mixing, great song. NIN music truly is an art.
TheSwordedge 2 years ago 3
I like this song ill have to admit. But demon seed is jus a bit better. They musta been trippen when thay made this though. lol
warrier91 2 years ago
i like demon seed better
ReesesMonkeyXP 2 years ago
But guys remember, This came first.
So its like an originall.
jamesusillXD 2 years ago
demon seed with some random synths thrown in. lol
thanks for the upload though.
Evanmileus 3 years ago 6
Why do you think it never made it on the official tracklisting? :P
TheBeautyIsFake 2 years ago
big demon seed presence
ScrewLimbBizkit 3 years ago 6
ohh Thanks ^^
Jobana 3 years ago
Sounds of drums like pre-Demon Seed from The Slip ... Nice Track!
fredmentor 3 years ago 5
hey you should watch the perfect drug parody!
angie4josh 3 years ago
it sounds like a mix of most of the tracks on the album
FWEvilWhiteBoy 3 years ago
I think, instead of being a mix, it was one of two bonus tracks found on the vinyll version of Ghosts. The vinyll ablum was included with the limited editio, super-mega-deluxe-whatever edition that you could buy for a small fortune within the few first minutes ghosts was released.
LEot128 3 years ago
hey thanks this is a great song!!
yahbyj 3 years ago
good upload!
soupsmoke 3 years ago
Demon Seed to Ghosts 38 are to me like "Blue Monday" to "The Beach" by New Order. The vocal version is cool just because of the lyrics and the neat stuff that happens there, but the instrumental version is much more complex and intricate.
ElitePirateUpsilon 3 years ago
The only thing that's the same between the two is the beat. I wouldn't call this one an "instrumental version", or even a "version", since it just contains a few components of Demon Seed. It's a completely different song, although it appears to be somewhat related. Completely different mood and instrumentation, though.
ProjectSmammi 3 years ago
Thanks for uploading it :D
aenimalogy 3 years ago 3
I admit that would be really cool to see the progression, however, I also believe that some of the Ghosts songs are just pure gold. I wouldn't have them any other way, as - in a selfish manner - I don't want them to change.
They're all experiments, and for Trent to actually willfully show us the progression and the amount of change a song can go through, I'm pleased.
But I take Ghosts for what it is, and I love it.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago 7
I concur, Kaoritsukino. The progression of that instrumental album is astounding, and I love to hear a more experimental, less structured NIN sound. The whole album is very atmospheric.
ProjectSmammi 3 years ago 2
@kaoritsukino this sounds a lot like the audio for "Demon Seed" actually...
Chimerafou 10 months ago
@kaoritsukino the great thing about ghosts. they are powerful tracks with some very soft and unique sounds. very relaxing
gundambob646 9 months ago
this is sooooo much better than demon seed. go ahead asshole thumb down my comments but its true
bunone4billy 3 years ago 31
Don't have to start calling the obscenities. I wouldn't thumb you down for a pure opinion. If you're arrogant about it, I would. xDD
^-^
Glad you like Ghosts and this. I love both Demon Seed and 38 Ghosts V for their different attributes.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
You don't know how right you are about demon seed and this. I don't want to make the song, but I really want to download it. NOT TORRENT.
oneUNITED7SS 3 years ago
Actually given Trent's pro torrent stance,I don't think he would mind.
SimonRivas 3 years ago
I hate it when I see retarded comments like this. Trent isn't PRO torrenting his music, it still pisses him off that people steal his music, he just recognizes that bitching about it isn't going to be productive.
punkoffgirl 3 years ago
And you know this how? Trent has made it clear that he doesn't mind anymore. Hell, he uploaded Closure & a few other bits of his music onto torrents ( under a secret name for obvious reasons)
SimonRivas 3 years ago
I think it's a combination. Trent isn't happy that people steal from him, but he's also very understanding of the fight with the music industry and their gags to rip off their consumers. He despises that the industry is only focused on making a buck, so he has tried to encourage fans to "rip" the music industry off. I wouldn't say he'd tell you straightforward to always steal from him, but moreover, steal the music that you're being ripped off by - the music from under the labels.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
Yeah that's a possibility as well. Though in recent shows he's said "Go ahead steal my music but buy theirs" He supports the upcoming bands so he doesn't want you to steal it all. But he did upload Closure & two "NIN Greatest Hits" albums onto torrents
SimonRivas 3 years ago
Yeah, of course he says "buy theirs." He wants you to support artists. I don't think he'd say that about another band, "Hey, yeah, you like me, and it's alright if you steal my music, so go ahead and steal theirs." It seems to be his own way of using his music and popularity with his fans to get back at the industry - in other words, it's his music, so he's using it as almost a tool to get back at the industry as well as give his own artistic expression.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
It's one thing that gives me enormous amounts of respect for Renzor. He belives in the music, and it is his art form, like paintings, which he just wants people to see and listen too. (IMO)
GarethW09 3 years ago 4
To get a better perspective, I ran across a recent article that's mostly Trent talking about his views - almost rambling, actually. Because I can't post URLs, google "SN&R exclusive Trent Reznor interview", and it should be the first.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
Heh yeah i've read that. Mentions the thigh website. I love the last part of the interview "Oh come on you know that's not the right thing to do."
SimonRivas 3 years ago
They're not really comparable, because they're very, VERY different. The beat is the same, yes (although it has some minor differences), but everything else is for the most part completely different.
ProjectSmammi 3 years ago
@bunone4billy demon seed wasn't that bad actually.
xCyberFang 1 year ago
@bunone4billy Not at all, man. Demon Seed wasn't a very good song in my opinion. >.> I have everything he publicly put out so far, and Demon Seed is one of the three songs I'll skip off of all the other tracks.
NIN99Koala 1 year ago
@NIN99Koala DemonSeed isn't a good song? I've listened to it probably over 50 times now and my neck muscles are pulled from nodding my head to the beat. Speak for yourself.
STVYT 11 months ago
@bunone4billy No need to argue here. %99.9 of what Reznor does is epic. Both Demon Seed and this song is amazing.
Grayscaleband 7 months ago 3
The start and end sample, infact any off the samples are pure gold, but this one gotta be my favouriite sound sample, its like someone who goes into a bed and dreams or wakes up, you know what i mean. ;)
KillingSpreeFreesBee 3 years ago 2
I can't wait for the other ghosts volume
nineteensixty9 3 years ago 7
Thanks for putting this up... aaah, yeah very reminiscent of Demon Seed. I like it a lot.
thiswasnotmeantforme 3 years ago 6
Yep i like it!
ckop6a 3 years ago 3
Probably where he got the idea for demon seed!
same drum beat.
cheers for uploading these :)
godman1234567890 3 years ago 7
how did u put it all together???
JLPIII 3 years ago 3
Wow, this sounds so much like Demon Seed which is like one of the best tracks from the slip.
musefan26 3 years ago 4
It's in the multi-tracks he gives. You actually have to piece the whole song together.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
*** NINE INCH NAILS *** F A N T A S T I C !
Trondyard 3 years ago 6
Trent sampled his dial up.. nice.
CharlieLeek 3 years ago 10
i'm not a big fan of instrumentals but this was really cool!
slashvrfan07 3 years ago 5
Thanks so much for uploading this and 37 Ghosts!
pugnaxacies 3 years ago 8
Yep. ^^
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
Thanks for much uploading the two deluxe Ghosts tracks.
ORL177 3 years ago 5
Yep. Glad I could help. ^^
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
Deemon Seed (Demo) I Guess
mtlns 3 years ago 9
same beat as demon seed, but still amazing
Onihalo 3 years ago 6
u beat me...
PicturesForMyMom 3 years ago
:P Sorry! I was actually surprised by how slowly people were reacting to it. I would have thought someone would have uploaded something much sooner than I had.
kaoritsukino 3 years ago
I'm guessing it's because there's been a lot of mystery about the Big Announcement on May 5th...
But it's now over so let's move on!
PicturesForMyMom 3 years ago