destiny's child - independent woman live @ world musc awards

[011azr]

beyonce is too dominant. It's a good step to get out from destiny's child cause beyonce look so selfish and arrogant in every song and performance.

[2009MINORITY]

Why did they shorten Kelly's pre-hook verse for? Probably to give more shine to Beyonce. Smh. The verse is suppose to go... "The rock i'm rockin' (I got it) Cause i depend on me, If i wanted it, the watch your wearing (I'll buy it) the house i l live in (I've got it)..."

[breybrey2dajizzay]

i love Beyonce's voice!!! gos! and i love when she has blonde hair

[MrMTA1987]

ОТЖИГАЛОВО

просто отжигалово

[charmed880]

bee hair is flawless

[parasanders1]

They are lipping lol! That's a first, they only lip the chorus!

[chriscarter17]

@parasanders1 yea Beyonce would never lips sing now tho she better then that but im shocked they lip sing on here but michelle in elly always lip sing they is juz beyonce back up singers lol...

[xMrDifficultyx]

And in Kelly second verse they realized they had her mic turned on, you see how the second verse was lip synced. lol

[xMrDifficultyx]

I actually like this performance of this song.

[MissLalaland89]

Probably the first time I ever saw Beyonce/DC lipsynch so much of a song!

[demon81818]

it seems like they're miming?

[thalialuvmx]

@demon81818 who cares!?!

[rockisbetter]

micheles dress with those boots are a cool match

[kinganthoney]

i like michelle dress

[25asiaboo]

for everyone who keep sayin beyonce and just those two girls are just mean just because beyonce wrote and produce most of the song and her dad is the manger and mom is the stylist doesnt mean kelly and michelle are just invisable woman backin beyonce up with out them two there would be no destinys child and they are as wonderful and good singers as beyonce the groep is not all about beyonce its about all three of them so i think ya need to think agian.

[emilyxdaniels]

After watching her most recent performances, this performance seems unremarkable.

[dalvarad87]

what a strange performance

[MultiLovely77]

BEYONCE IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!

I LOVE HER!!!!!

AWESOME

GORGEOUS

MAGNIFIC

TERRIFIC

JUST

HER!!!!!!!!

[denistaha10]

@MultiLovely77 BUT WHO EAT IS JAY-Z. hahaha

[MultiLovely77]

@denistaha10 My dear you´re right. he´s the lucky one hahahaha

[denistaha10]

@MultiLovely77 hahahaha is a big lucky eat this pussy ooooh beyoncè yes,yes,yes,,

[DiscoWilliams817]

u can clearly tell that the beyonce verses were lip sang. But the adlibs were not

[JonathanGardnerTV]

Wow, Michelle looks immaculate! Good performance, would have been nice to hear Kelly's live vocals better and actually hear Michelle sing live on this one :\

[katatoniccatalyst]

ugh god first off its LIP SINGING not lip synching and second, no shes not.

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@katatoniccatalyst No...it is lip syncing...because you mime in SYNC to the pre-recorded vocals but I agree that they're not lip-syncing the lead vocals

[ineslovverke]

yeahhh bey!!!!! love u DCC kelly michhh!! xx

[misrensen]

Perfect! Hope they will come back together soon!!!

[vonte327]

she is singing with the music thts why it sound like she is lip syncing!!!

[parasanders1]

why did beyonce always lip synch her part in independent woman when they performed!

[vonte327]

@parasanders1 no she didnt she never do tht

[cchllover]

why would they wear them long ass dresses to perform in???

[tdotwisker2]

its beyonce and her back up dancers,,, this was never a group

[77fisto]

beyonce's vocals were amazing in this performance.

[redegel1985]

idk if anyone noticed but all three of them were lip syncing throughout the entire song, EVEN BEYONCE on the first and second versuses... listen to it, esp the 2nd verse!! The only time beyonce isn't lip syncing is when she was talking in the beginning and when she ad libs during the chorus.

[yomismodc]

@redegel1985 You're right. Desitnys child used to lipsync some songs (lose my breath, bootylicious...) and this one too.

[chantoya17]

Question: Why are they performing this in their evening gowns?

[mac48203]

@chantoya17 ...LOL

[DwellsinDubai]

@chantoya17 idk they used the same outfits at the Grammys press conference afterthey won as well. I guess they werent big enough and at those times they reused a lot of their outfits. They bangin anyway!

[rakela10]

i miss dc :(

[croatia93]

@bboywonder69 me too :P

[TheCrazygirldiana]

beyonce is the best!

[majshkdt]

beyonce is amazing!!!!!!

[Tarig93]

At least Kelly and Michele Remembered the Choreography lol.

[jimmychooshoes0512]

i love DC but this wasnt a good performance. But these days they all on fire.

[astrogliding]

dang she's so far ahead of the two on that stage! LMFAO.. why are Kelly & Michelle miming the chorus!?!? Damn, is Michelle's mic even on?

[hrick92]

I looove Beyonce, but this performance it's just her. It's totally "Beyoncé and the other two".

[da12nvmp]

i love black on Michelle!!!

[jonafie123]

i really like beyonce's hair here

its blond she looks very beautiful with blond hair

NICE SONG!!!!!!It Will Be Nice if they are in the cast of charles angels

gi Destinys Child!!!!

[Leinard04]

@jonafie123 I like that idea, even just a cameo....

[PotentialFashionista]

it waas soo obvious that she was lip synching in the second verse..

[jemz9481]

STUNNING

[theb0ss4eva]

amazing, michelle is still my fave tho

[pok3rfac]

its not beyonces fault not only did she write songs but her dada was der manager soo..put that together and it shud hav bin called Beyonce and those two girls u dnt know and dnt care about

[Aarikaisinlove]

the beyonce show..... dang since when did michelle and kelly become "back- up dancer..... wow like dang i would have rather just been the person to run across the stage with a mob to clean up.... would have got more attention or rather a chance to be seen as a real person.

[TheQuinn555]

Michelle!!!!! :)

[prosperabovehaters]

all my independent women where u at come on.

[navigator012007]

I think it's bull that beyonce intruded so much into the group and made is so much about "her." You can even hear her in the backing tracks in the live performances! Why was that necessary? I doubt that Kelly and Michelle even ever sang live without backing tracks from Beyonce, but, if they truly had what it takes, they would have made it by now.

[Soetjoo]

love dc!

[gloomyoutlook]

lol... they took "clap your hands" literally.

[bookshika]

this my favorite live independent woman performance

[thebestnextbeyonce]

i love the bounce at the begging. that was a hot performance. get it girls. love DC lol :D

[canvoodoo]

The band on this incredible

[mizzdiamond56]

I love michelle Dx

[serarc17]

mich's da greatest

[ishragaibrahim]

Wow, beyoncee's reeeli GDD

[amasya82]

blond fits her best.....wooooooow..

[IddyB]

Hells no. Try the hairdo in Austin Powers Goldmember. That's fucking hot.

[brea13e]

I love D.C very much i am their biggest fan

[brownbead]

amazing

[kuku818]

love it!

[Streaky1986]

cool! =D

[spoggythekid]

AW MICHELLE LOOKED FLAWLESS

[katsutinn]

めっちゃKAWAII

[arianna513]

never seen this i liked it it was ok

[PureWillpower1]

sucks

[Onusoj]

i miss this michelle, she's way skinny now :(, but she's still beautiful

[kenfy4]

the end is so amazing

[uhyeahshuddup]

isnt one of them beyonces sister

[TheDesperateHodges]

LMAO, no.

[TheBeyonceuniverse]

i like the part @ 2:34 when she hits that power note.

[TheBeyonceuniverse]

the older beyonce got the more she came out of her shell

[moviestaaaar]

what do you mean ?

[TheBeyonceuniverse]

early when beyonce was in the group she seemed to hold back a little...and this performance showed that there was a girl in there dying to come out of her shell completely.

[moviestaaaar]

in good way or a bad way XD ?

[TheBeyonceuniverse]

ofcourse a good way...i mean when you look at beyonce now all you see is perfection on stage because she came out of her shell...anytime anyone comes out of their shell its mostly always a good thing you know...unless your perez hilton.

[moviestaaaar]

haha :D , i understand what you mean now :D ,

[kuku818]

so true lol sasha fierce finally came out

[TheGleisdreieck]

@TheBeyonceuniverse yeno

[brenden718]

wow I remember it was like 2001 or 2002 and I had recorded this performance on my "VCR" and I learned the chereo and used it as a Karaoke Performance! Love DC, but admire Beyonce till death!!!

[lucious2sweet]

I don't like how michelle don't get much solo parts but damn she was rockin that dress

[hrick92]

Beyonce is always rocking out!!!!

[Soetjoo]

JUST LOVE IT!

[vonte327]

BEYONCES VOICE WAS SO BEAUTIFUL AND GOOD!!! the best singing i ever heard, using nice runs!!!! luv ya

[itslipe]

@vonte327 shes lip synchin

[vonte327]

@itslipe no she is not she is singing live i dnt know why yall think tht?? can you hear?? u can clearly hear her!!!!

[vonte327]

@itslipe lol the second verse she did i aint gne lie lol

[CPatt4519]

@vonte327 they all good but i could die within beyonce's voice!!!

[amandablasques]

Omg!

Bey looks SOOOOOOoo gorgeouss!

as always :P

[Norav18]

OMG I LOOOVE Michelle! Voice is soo beautifuL!

[bibipassos10]

beyoncé is the best!

[airodump]

wow very nice!

come to Israel it will be great!

[HUGOM2C]

Beyoncé is gorgeous :D

[Booklover26]

At the 2:59 to 3:00 min mark their fire works did not go off as planned, 1 barely blazed and the others were blank.

[Jamez9481]

i think it was fine. there was another flame that was on , that was symmetrical to it

[airodump]

yes there wa another flame on the right!

[trinigyal4sure]

why r they miming?? they sing better live!

[Booklover26]

Kelly & Michelle usually mime their parts, which is the background vocals. I guess this is easier than setting up a whole band.

[Jamez9481]

yeah, artists usually just fake the chourus and background. coz usually the backings are too intricate to recreate live.

[Jamez9481]

they actually were singing, with the backing track

1:14 - 1:24, u can hear kelly

[Rakim8]

Na they're lip syncing the chorus but the mikes are on to ad-lib, hence why you can hear Kelly. Her voice is too weak to notice though over the live band.

[lilmissashleym]

the dc girls rating

beyonce - body and voice

kelly- gorgeous face and smile

michelle- nice face

[eugenehilter09]

let me upgrade that

beyonce-body and voice and got her daddy as manager

kelly-gorgeous smile,skin and humor also beautiful voice and face

michelle-underrated shes funny ass hell and does have an nice face and voice and shes goofy

[skylie0]

this time i think Michelle looks nicer and classy!!!

[bibipassos10]

bee is the best

love her

[Kaykay24yo]

Go to the Bobovanwiliz channel when you subscribe to them you'llg et 5 subs back! For real no joke!

[Faibylicious]

Michelle is beautiful in this sexy dress <3

[in18]

Please read this because it acually works!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1.Put both of your hands on your chest

2.Think of someone thatyou like......

3.Tommorow that person will ask you out or say i love you.

4.Heres the catch just send to 5 more videos

[JEIWILBER]

Beyonce is Tasty ! ! !

;-P~

[lucious2sweet]

atleast they could've given michelle a solo part to sing........

[dadreamzworld]

Damn do you all have to always find something to complain about?

[eugenehilter09]

michelle is so underrated im sorry i luv dc3 and kelly but kelly is a suck ass 2 bee camp and bee i used 2 ignore the rumors but now something dont seem right in the picture but i still luv all of them

[jaymoragne]

so tacky outfits...uuhhck

[jaymoragne]

beyonce the only one singing foreal everyone else is lip synchin lol..she lipped it on some parts too.... but it was a good performance

[XxchrisbrownloverxX]

so good love them!

[beryoberyo]

beyonce love you haha aber auf dem video siehsch echt geil aus beschde

blond alla beyonce ist einfach nur die beste loe you

[laKeishaMichelle]

im in a big band and we do this weekly. we have tracks with the back ground vocals on it already we sing along just not as hard but of we do our lead parts. it gets breathy and takes a toll on you when you are dancing and tryinfg to hit every note. but yea michelle has it easy!!! OMG

[KissyKeish]

weresz the audience ?

[Mitchi135]

she sound so much better dan beyonce

VERY MUUUUUUCH!!

[Lordfinese19]

SIKE....no she don't but she sounds good

[dadreamzworld]

Hating whores like you always fail!

[MiZzNadZz]

I love be´Z Hair

[BlyueMOON]

100% lipsynched-300% fabulous!!!

[Rakim8]

Only the verses are, all the ad-libbing Beyonce's doing is live. The other 2 are singing nothing live. The band is also live.

[thefrozencharles]

haha, woo!

[claudioxblackxmusic]

hermosas

[kerry12121]

i feel like if everyone is complaing about how bey sings lead all the time and the other girls arent complaing why should you if they like it i love it

[wdcox]

I agree....the other girls did not complain about not being able to sing. I think it's just the public, who blew everything out of whack.

Let's be real...obviously all of the girls can sing....they are, or were Destiny's Child....lol....they just had one person to keep things in order and to make sure everything looked good....

[ReyStylez]

Well actually its not that they lip sync, they had a play back playing, me being in the industry, ive learned that you cant dance and perform a fast paced song, I worked with DC3 and really its not an easy thing to do, but its more so kelly and beyonce singing live cause in other performances Michelle is always lip sync which i think its some bull!

[wdcox]

This is because Michelle did not have any solo vocals?

As you could see, B and kelly did most of the singing for a long time. We did'nt really hear Michelle until they were about to all go solo. Maybe michellle could not sing and solo at the same time like B and kelly, maybe she was not fully confident in that until the end of D child....

[wdcox]

I think most of the time you see michelle singing solo....she is for the most part still.....and not really moving.

[bktmali]

la beyonce estaba mas wapa cuando era mas joven, pero vamos igualmente es una super diva la tia!!! y tiene una voz.... inigualable!!!!

:DDDDDDDDD

[vickysirdofsky]

I love u B.. so much!!!!

[yeadime]

solange back in the day

[windchimex]

best vocals in my opinion!...from the one and only B!

[b00tylici0us04]

jaimer bien kan ell eété blonde comme sa serai cool kel le redevienne

[xKeyshia18x]

what year awards was this 2001 or 2002?

[Soetjoo]

dc (l)

[rwzal]

great bodies and voices!!

[loftenmoreno]

ti sbureri in culo con amore

[reformer666]

They look soooo beautiful.

[kellyrowlandfan]

those chicks are the coolest ever.

[lunaticpacino]

put1 la beyonce cété une grosse grosse bombee!!:!!!!!!!

[Lucasdeluxeedition]

nunca vi esse video, como beyonce mudou hein!

[aninhaodcpt]

beyonce has a powerful voice!

[lucious2sweet]

love michelle's look in this performance

[bsktplaya52]

yaew she should make her hair black because now in 2009 its red.

[123treehillfan]

beyonce sounds good,looks fabulous and perfroms great!!

[rockyfabion]

B was kill'in it at the end

[abouthemusic]

Beyonce looks too good here man.

[jjalldae]

Throw Yo Hands Up At Me Baby... They Was Gettin' It!!! I love Destiny and her Child.

[caramelchick06]

I thought they wore those dresses at the grammys??

[Pw13k]

They did

[zpcd]

i love when they say all my independent woman where u at come on

[leem9966]

U MEAN WHEN BEYONCE SAY all my independent woman where u at come on . THAT ABOUT THE LIVEST PART OF THE PERFORMANCE CAUSE THEY LIP SINGING THE VERSES CAUSE BEYONCE SOUND JUST LIKE THE ALBUM UNTIL SHE HYPE THE CROWD IT

[dpespiri]

From :18-:20, kelly almost tripped on her own dress

[dpespiri]

from :18-:20, kelly almost tripped on her dress

[piperelopez]

Sorry I know this is old but from :18- :20,kelly didn't almost trip on her dress she was trying to keep on track with beyonce's movement,as you can see her look at beyonce's feetm, like michelle should do sometimes.

[DARIUSWALKER9]

SH*T THAT'S HOTT...

[aljee20]

check the one under my favorites with them in gold thats the best

[aljee20]

great performance i miss these chicks

[CassidyWifey95]

I don't like Beyonce's outfit..

[nico11570]

I lovE dEstiNy'S CHild !!

[Pruedence19]

yeah....thats a real great performance. full of energie. girl power!! Beyonce rock the house!!