Twilight vs Harry Potter

[1SnitchsAndSeekers8]

LUPIN LUPIN LUPIN LUPIN!!

[TheJessanell]

Harry Potter is best period.

[KlassicwitaK]

I love Harry Potter! I will happily reread them books over and over again! Twilight however, I've read through three of them and I've had enough. I vote for Harry Potter because it has a better storyline, better characters, and I just love Harry Potter. It's one of the best book series ever!

[kmi961]

HARRY POTTER FOR EVER!!!!!!!!!!

[ghostchic17]

HARRY POTTER IS BETTER THAN TWILIGHT ANYDAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Miarosefan12]

I like both but I have to say Harry Potter

[purecrystalshine]

You're kidding me, right? Bella vs DUMBLEDORE!!!! Dumbledore is one of the smartest literary characters of all time, classics included. Bella is a drone-ish Mary Sue who's so called "imperfections" are mere add-ons by Stephanie Meyer so that everyday girls could "relate" to her. The fact is, if someone as clumsy as Bella actually existed, they would not live past the day they learned how to walk.

[1991corina1]

umm.... bella is the smartest person in twilight?

huston, we have a problem

=)))))))

[Gabbycat38]

1 thing:

Harry Potter: 2 oscar nominations

twilight eclipse: 9 razzie nominations. better know like the anti-oscar or THE WORST OF HOLLYWOOD AWARDS!!!!

[Edward03able]

1) Edward Cullen 2) Hermione Granger 3) Remus Lupin 4) New Moon 5) Edward and Bella 6) Edward Cullen 7) Albus Dumbledore 8) Professer Trelawney 9) Victoria 10) The battle of hogwarts According to my answers, I love them both.

[TGTITU2]

@Edward03able I don't like Twilight but I'll agree with you on most of those but number 9) Lord Voldemort easily is the evilest of all times, victoria hasnt done anything compared to the dark lord

[reba38491]

I don't know what kinda crazy your talkin about. But the craziest person in Harry Potter is

Bellatrix Lestrange. She is a pshycotic loose cannon.

[reba38491]

You have to admit, Jacob is good looking, But Remus Lupin is a more realistic and

classic werewolf. Remus wins category 3

[kmi961]

@reba38491 Totally, is just, twilight is more like a love story and bla bla, well I watch it, it's like the sort of movies that u see, and u say 'well I like it' but it's not like... WOWWWW I LOVE IT!!! (like it happens with HP!)

[JenniferFly2]

Why compare Harry Potter and Twilight? They are both such different stories.

Harry Potter has a brilliant story, everything fits like one gigantic puzzel.

Twilight is just about love, but that is enough, you don't miss the action.

I enjoyed both stories. Especially Harry Potter.

But you can't say Twilight isn't a good story, I coulnd't stop reading it.

I just don't like the film twilight, there isn't enough action in the book for a film, though the book is very good.

[MrWaffle136]

the harry potter series is way better that the twilight saga thumbs up if you agree

[knightofjustitia]

@MrWaffle136 well snap did not really beat him draco did

[Lilynettemiel]

Humm...Smartest Person? Bella versus DUMBLEDORE???? Are you kidding me? Firstly, nobody can beat Dumbledore (except Snape, apparently, but then again...). Secondly, what is Bella even doing THERE?!

[potterbond]

in complete honesty, hermione is actually better looking than bella. main reason: hermiones not a pale ass bitch.

[HarleycheriseQuinn]

Harry Potter is deffinately got a better story line as J.K Rowling is a genious!! and Harry Potter has stuff like Magic and fantasy more on the other hand Twilight is about Vampires and where wolves and the story is kind of slow and not exciting enough.So Harry Potter and it's characters has gotta win this one :) xx

[Vampiricshow]

lol you should've just put the title as 'Why Harry Potter Epicly Wins Against Twilight' :D

[FantasticFlutist]

HARRY POTTER! That useless shit Twilight is the BIGGEST joke in the history of pop culture................Ugh. I would BITCH-slap Bella if she were real; TRULY, I would. And then beat the crap out of Edward and such. Really, I would.....

[Princess0Starfire]

1.Harry Potter 2.Hermione Granger 3.Remus Lupin 4.Harry Potter and The Half-Blood Prince, J.K. Rowling 5.Harry and Ginny, Hermione and Ron 6.Cedric Diggory 7.Albus Percival Wulfrie Brian Dumbledore WOOT! 8.Prof. Trelawney 9.You-Know-Who, Lord Voldemort, Tom Marvolo Riddle,BELLAtrix LeSTRANGE 10.Battle Of Hogwarts PERIOD! no contest cuz the winner is HARRY POTTER! WOOT!

[ThinkerThingamabob]

1. only symbol in the series and total Gary Stu vs. oppressed, flawed, loving hero

2. selfish idiot who doesn't act like a real person vs. close-minded, loyal, loving book-worm

3. a character who is a SHAPE SHIFTER (honestly, put him against Tonks instead) vs. a cursed, torn, suffering, amazing man

4. a movie whose biggest attraction is a shirtless boy vs. a movie during a war with real pain and hope and joy and suffering

[ThinkerThingamabob]

6. stalker and selfish girlfriend vs. heroes who didn’t just lust after each other and knew more than just the other’s name and species before being “in love”

7. As Edward, his hair can’t move, his eyes are a weird color, he sparkles, he looks sickly, and he’s always frowning. As Cedric, he had more emotions (fear, confusion, triumph- although this reason may all be because Cedric is more dimensional than Edward) and he looks healthy.

[ThinkerThingamabob]

8. Bella says that she’s smart, but she never proves it. She sure does make idiotic decisions and hardly ever thinks before acting. Dumbledore- I don’t even understand how anyone could compare Bella to him- he’s experienced things. He has wisdom. Plus, he’s actually book-smart. I mean, look at his chocolate frog card.

[ThinkerThingamabob]

9. No one in Twilight? Everyone obsesses over an utterly boring girl who doesn’t care about them, Bella thinks that she’s an invulnerable old woman, Edward stalks people…and they aren’t crazy?

This is the only one I can fit it on. Note that I am a Harry Potter fan. I have read all the books in both series except for Stephenie Meyer's new novella (which is a total rip-off).

[ThinkerThingamabob]

10. James and Victoria accomplish virtually nothing. They did not negatively impact the characters. Voldemort kills and tortures. He’s an evil genius! While James and Victoria weren’t discreet at all about what they were doing, Voldemort was and left the wizarding world in a state of chaos and confusion. As for Draco Malfoy, he isn’t truly a villain. He’s not pleasant or to be trusted, but he was forced into something. He is an impressionable child. He wouldn’t really kill anyone.

[ThinkerThingamabob]

11.  In Twilight, the only person bleeding is Bella. One person dies, and he has one person that cares about him. In Harry Potter, let’s list some known characters who die: Fred, Colin, Remus, Tonks, Voldemort, Bellatrix, Crabbe, et cetera, et cetera. There are countless nameless fighters (good and bad) who got hurt or died, not counting those who suffered with the loss of those they cared about. It went on for hours, not minutes, and involved trickery and betrayal and hard decisions.

[ThinkerThingamabob]

I'm going to have to separate my answers to get them within the 500 character range.

[Callen259]

Dumbledore is soooo much smarter then bella, Voldemort is such a better villain than James and Victoria (and Riley) combined. R-patz is better as cedric diggory.

HP all the way!

[MALISH1234]

Harry Potter's Better Than Twilight. Sorry peeps!

[MALISH1234]

HA\/\/\/\/Y P\/\/OTTA BETTA DAN T\/\/\/IGHT! :P

[Pigfarts42]

Potter all the way!!!!!! were they seriuos with the Bella or Dumbledore cause i couldnt stop laughing

[S15A07A94]

great video

[kitty2ism]

twilight is better

[AmericanGirl7212]

HARRY ALL CATAGORIES

[bellsal15]

TWILIGHT!

[SunFlamexD]

1. Edward

2. Bella

3. Jacob

4. New Moon

5. Edward and Bella

6. He look the same.

7. Bella Swan

8. No one in Twilight

9. Vicoria

10. The Twilight fight.

[labbiabbi]

for craziest person in twilight you should have put alice or emmett lol aniway... 1# EDWARD! 2# BELLA! 3# how could you not choose JACOB? 4# both of the films have come out and ive seen them both but the best one was NEW MOON! 5# BELLA AND EDWARD 6# CEDRIC DOGGORY! 7#DUMBLEDORE! 8# NO ONE IN TWILIGHT simply because i have no idea who Professor Trelawney is. 9# VICTORIA what about the volturi? :( 10# THE BATTLE OF HOGWARTS!

[hpbetterthantwilight]

harry potter is better in every way

[AnimeStargrl15]

6. Ceeedrrrriiiiccccc! What a cutie!

7. (Bella's SMART and Hermione's NOT? What world are YOU living in?!) Well, I guess I have to pick Dumbledore. He's the best wizard in the world, DUH!

8. Ha ha ha... Trelawny!

9. I'm not stupid, VOLDEMORT AND DRACO!! (You didn't really match up the people correctly, sorry...)

10. Battle of Hogwarts... A lot of people died...

[AnimeStargrl15]

1. Harry Potter

2. Hermione Granger

3. Remus Lupin

4. Half Blood Prince!! (SOOO much better than dumb New Moon! Well, if you like guys taking their clothes off I guess you'd like it)

5. Harry and Ginny (Love 'em!)

[redriveryuri]

For the smartest person Hermione should have been nominated. I've seen both movies and Hermione would win the smartest person hands down.

[hrrypttrfn]

(continued)

9. Voldie (Ralph Fiennes is scary as hell here)

10. Battle of Hogwarts (was an actual battle)

[hrrypttrfn]

1. Harry Potter (is not a dead stalker)

2. Hermione Granger (could kick Bella's ass even in vampire form) :)

3. Remus Lupin (had a baby with color-changing hair)

4. shouldn't vote here since they're both out, but Half-Blood Prince (saw New Moon, and my friend had to elbow me becaure I fell asleep)

5. Harry Ginny (with the three cutest kids as well)

6. Cedric (he looked like he bathed at this point)

7. do I even need to answer this one?

8. I guess there is only one choice

[Rand0mT3chn0]

I just think people should judge AFTER they read the books. There is no way you can compare Twilight and Harry Potter if you havent read both series.

Love, HP fan.

[SallySteel]

I think the Harry Potter story is more complex and magical than twilight, but twilight is much more emotional. both storys are extremely captivating on their own ways, so it´s really hard for me to decide wich one i prefer. I love both! ;-) But I have to say dazzling Edward is my favourite character out of both storys, though I like Ron, Snape and Hermione a lot, too, but, as you can imagine, on other ways. ;-)

[Alexa93artaker]

1. Harry Potter

2. Hermione Granger

3. Remus Lupin

4. Half Blood Prince

5. Harry and Ginny

6. Cedric Diggory

7. Albus Dumbledore

8. Bella

9. Voldemort

10. The Battle of Hogwarts

[haeron16]

WIZARDS RULES!!

vampires are so scary!

LOL

LOL

[ghylltootx]

i love edward ,, i think harry is so nerd but edward is so hot !!

[Rand0mT3chn0]

how is harry a nerd?

[AnimeStargrl15]

@Rand0mT3chn0

I know! I ROFL everytime someone calls Harry a nerd. He's not very smart, doesn't he always need Hermione to do his homework? I don't see anyone calling HER a nerd!

Having glasses doesn't make you a nerd. I have to wear glasses for school because I'm near sighted, and I think that is very hurtful.

Plus, twitards just say that to make you think that Harry is ugly. (Which he's not!! He's totally hot!)

[hrrypttrfn]

Try using proper english when bashing a well-written piece of literature... you make your entire fan base look that much worse.

[Cashdog26]

HARRY POTTER ROKS!

[kezup]

1. Harry Potter

2. Hermione Granger

3. Jacob Black

4. Half-blood prince

5. Harry & Ginny

6. Cedric

7. Dumbledore

8. Voldemort

9.Battle of Hogwarts

[mtai97]

haha...i like ur answers!!!

[isl7319]

1.harry potter

2. hermione granger

3. remus lupin (awesome!)

4. HBP

5. harry & ginny

6. cedric

7. albus

8. bella is crazy cuz she's into stalkers.

9. voldemort

10. battle of hogwarts (EPIC).

[sofiefg]

1. Harry Potter

2. Hermione Granger

3. Remus Lupin

4. Half Blood Prince

5. Edward and Bella

6. Edward Cullen

7. Dumbledoor (Even Edward is smarter than Bella....)

8. Voldemort

9. The Battle of Hogwarts

[Sully192837465]

its category not catogory

[josielovegood]

Harry potter all the way through without a single doubt!!!

[JillyBoan]

1.harry potter

2. hermione granger

3.remus lupin

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

[mtai97]

I vote - 1. Harry Potter 2. Hermione Granger 3. Jacob Black 4. Half Blood Prince 5. Harry and Ginny 6. Cedric Diggory 7. Dumbledore (no competition) 8. I think JANE is loco (even though she wasn't a choice) 9. I vote for the Vulturi becaue they're true evil 10. idk....both were pretty good battles

[xEmmaCharlotteWatson]

How can they both be pretty good battles? Harry Potter is already better than twilight, and even any twilight fan would agree the battle at the end of the seventh HP book was far better, JK has such captivating writing, everything was fantastic, the fight at the end of twilght was hardly a battle, if it wasn't for the movie i wouldn't have even considered the thing a fight, Steph didn't even describe the fight, she just ranted on about Bella!

[mtai97]

Well...sooorrryyy! I thought we were suppoe to be sharing opinions but I GUESS NOT!!! I said that because I havn't read Harry Potter. I still like HP better then Twilight but HP didn't hold my concentration as well as Twilight did. I only know what the battle in Twilight was like. I don't know what the HP battle is like!

[hrrypttrfn]

how can you share your opinions about which series if better if you have not completed one yet... That seems a tad bit biased if you ask me. If you are not versed on both sides of the discussion, it would probably be more appropriate to keep your thoughts to yourself.

[mtai97]

y r u guys being so mean 2 me?? i dont know what the twilight battle is like either......even if i did.......i thought we were suppose 2 b aloud 2 share our opinions.....i didnt realize that im suppose 2 think exactly like u

[AnimeStargrl15]

@mtai97

You shouldn't judge them if you didn't read either series...

[mtai97]

all i did was share my opinion and u guys r being totally rude. telling my that i shouldnt watch/share my opinion on the video. wats wrong with u people. just leave me alone!! i wrote that 5 months ago and im still getting messages on it. its annoying and i dont care if u disagree with my decision. when i wrote that i wasnt perpously (idk how to spell) trying to piss u off. i was thinking wat a fun video it was. u guys just wanna argue for some reason. STOP!!!

[AnimeStargrl15]

@mtai97

Relax. I'm just saying that if you haven't read either series, you shouldn't argue about which one is better because you don't know the whole story...

[mtai97]

but i just wanted to watch the video and u guys r being so mean 2 me!!!! y cant people just leave me alone!!!! :'(

[AnimalsInMyHeart]

1. Harry Potter

2. Hermione Granger

3. Remus Lupin

4. HBP (even though I hated the book)

5. Hate both couples (seriously, H/G?! H/HR FOREVER <33)

6. Cedric Diggory

7. Dumbledore of course

8. Trelawney

9. Lord Voldemort (DRACO IS NOT EVIL! He's just misunderstood...)

10. The Battle of Hogwarts

[hrrypttrfn]

Where the heck do the books ever hint at a possible Harry Hermione romance? They seem to be completely incompatible for each other.

[mtai97]

its not really the books its the movies that make em look like theyre perfect 4 each others....honestly i figured they wouldnt end up 2gether i just didnt know who he would end up with

[AnimeStargrl15]

@AnimalsInMyHeart

LOL Sorry but I think you're in denial. xD It's Harry and Ginny.

[AnimalsInMyHeart]

I know H/G is canon, but I hate them together.

H/Hr, R/Lu, N/Lu and D/G <3.

[AnimeStargrl15]

@AnimalsInMyHeart

I like Neville and Luna, and I also like Dramione. Draco and Hermione would make a cute couple wouldn't they...?

[ChappStickMan]

The smartest person made me burst out laughing when it suggested Bella. Alos, because there are NO CRAZY PEOPLE IN TWILIGHT, that's pretty sad. Bloodiest Battle also made me laugh agreeingly.

[arisheps100]

1. Harry Potter.

2. Bella Swan.

3. Remus Lupin.

4. Half Blood Prince.

5. Edward and Bella.

6. Edward Cullen.

7. Dumbledore, that was really easy.

8. Voldemort, also really easy.

9. The Battle of Hogwarts

[manxxx95]

Robert plays in both of them :))

[mtai97]

i like him as cedric better then edward though.....wat about u???

[Hikaru4Ever852]

@mtai97 I prefer Cedric because he was first. Twilight is just left overs.

[animefreakallday]

what's the song that's with the credits?? you know the song at the end?? i need to know!!! i love it!! please tell me =D

[Hikaru4Ever852]

Pumpin' Up the Party by Hannah Montana.

[Burning2day]

many songs...can you say the titel and the singer of this songs ---> the are great. ;-)

[jopissa]

understand...i agree they r hot!!!!

[jopissa]

CRAZIEST PERSONS at hp are fred and georg totally...hp is much better for sure...twilight is childish...

[Hikaru4Ever852]

Fred and George are not the kind of crazy I was talking about. I was talking about insane crazy. Fred and George are hot.

[danitichenor97]

@Hikaru4Ever852 yes they are

[kmi961]

@Hikaru4Ever852 They r sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooo hot!!!!!!! I LOVE THEM SO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And yes, trilony is really crazy!!!! hahahahaha

[kmi961]

@jopissa OMG I'm TOTALLY agree with u!!! Actually, it sorprised me fred and george weren't in thet category!!! Id chosen them before I saw this.. hahahaha