This version sucks! it´ts a sad and quiet song, so her "star performance" doesn´t fit. I think it ruins all emotions. Maybe she doesn´t get the message of the song...
You have to keep it simple when singing this song. Big time fail. I hated this performance. Minnie Driver is incredible because she understands the song.
Okay. Here's what I'm gonna say. She has a beautiful voice (she's one of my favourite singers) but this song is a bit too deep for her voice. There I said it. Her voice is a bit too high. And what gjang2008 said. Her voice is a bit too breathy for this song but it's okay.
she sang it very tasteful and beautifully this is just a boring as song ,,,but that little run in falsetto at the end was magic ,,so sweet ,,so subtle ,,it was orgasmic lol
This version sucks! it´ts a sad and quiet song, so her "star performance" doesn´t fit. I think it ruins all emotions. Maybe she doesn´t get the message of the song...
HeartWitch61 6 days ago 4
I love The Phantom of The Opera and love this version too.
rhythmoftheoceann 2 weeks ago
WOW!!!!!!!!! Can you imagine this is the same woman who sings "Video Phone" lol....She is like two artist in one.
MrDane1911 2 weeks ago
B E A U T I F U L :)
nolaa64 2 weeks ago
You have to keep it simple when singing this song. Big time fail. I hated this performance. Minnie Driver is incredible because she understands the song.
calpaycetin 2 weeks ago
@calpaycetin
Agree, simple is better for this song
XenonVirgo 1 week ago
i like this version, Beyonce is stunning, but the original version with Minnie Driver is my all-time-favourite
sofie8needs8more 3 weeks ago
Okay. Here's what I'm gonna say. She has a beautiful voice (she's one of my favourite singers) but this song is a bit too deep for her voice. There I said it. Her voice is a bit too high. And what gjang2008 said. Her voice is a bit too breathy for this song but it's okay.
cathead772 3 weeks ago
I will miss her at 2012 Oscar.
ocpmarcelo 3 weeks ago
OUTSTANDINGLY DONE BEYONCE :-)
SuperGirlEbony 1 month ago
Phantom!
SuperPhantomlove 1 month ago
I love POTO and I love Beyonce!
SuperPhantomlove 1 month ago
Her voice was way too breathy for this song... and what's with all the caressing of her jewels. As if we couldn't see them. Lame.
gjang2008 1 month ago
@gjang2008 man you suck dick! stop hattin so much....
jaiyson 3 weeks ago in playlist Liked videos
I just raped the replay button.
icelemyer 1 month ago
andrew lloyd webber is a musical genius and queenB did an outstanding job.
IlluminatedFox 1 month ago 2
Hi Kisses Beyonce 2 TIME WOWOWO !!<3<3
KingPacIloveu 1 month ago
Oo Man She's QUEENBEYONCE <3
KingPacIloveu 1 month ago
Wow. I never pictured Beyonce singing this song before, but she was very good! What is this footage from? I don't think I've ever seen it before.
CaptainHooksGirl 1 month ago
@CaptainHooksGirl the OSCARS!
AmBiTiOusBRITTANY 1 month ago
There really are only 3 versions of his song: Minnie Driver's, Gerard Butler's and Beyonce...and this is clearly the best
dohaperson 1 month ago 2
she sang it very tasteful and beautifully this is just a boring as song ,,,but that little run in falsetto at the end was magic ,,so sweet ,,so subtle ,,it was orgasmic lol
willik19 1 month ago
andrew lloyd webber
flemae 2 months ago
She is so beautiful and talented - you don't need all that makeup, beyonce
twiwonder 4 months ago 4
i really wanted to sing this for a concert at school but the original is so short, so i'm singing this definitely
OnlyPerfect1 4 months ago
beautiful
Mary8753 5 months ago 2
another unforgettable song
blackrose4ur 1 year ago 24
@blackrose4ur Yes beautiful memory
ChannelMultimusic 1 year ago 9