This is definitely live(I think)~ u can compare it with the cd version one, there's difference in there. Plus, you can hear her breath in, and there is gap when she sings the chorus. and she has made some changes in this song. and the high note if u listen to the cd one, it is edited, and this one is natural one..haha>.< will her be so freaking free to sing and record another version of Hate You to fit in this show? I don't think so..so it's live.(^_^)
I think that Mariah is one of the best female singers of all time. I've been to most of her comcerts. She will always be the best with that five octive range!!!!
@Mannequin2009 Lol That was not lipped cause you dont necessarily have to move your mouth .. Its what you push through yo diaphragm .. True Musicians know that .
@Mannequin2009 This is NOT lipped....this is NOT exactly how it is on the album...you can tell where she sang faster than the music on the Bridge (..a matter fact I think Im moving away). Mariah is just THAT good that she tricked you into thinking she was lipping. This is an obvious 100% live version.
Lol No darling MCC LOVES music devoted to it for 20 yrs almost 21. She's gonna slow down but she's still gonna be working anyone who is a fan knows she loves singing and writing its just what makes her happy. We probably won't get an album every year know but expect more in the future. She's pregnant and doing rigorous promo she doesn't know the word stop haha.
Love, love, LOVE Mariah! But I just hate how she sings with her hands. And is it just me or does she really look like she's having a hard time singing....maybe the baby is just pressing on her vocal cords, haha.
@cmethrough lmao, i think she's directin the backing singers with it, listen to haw they respond and it helps her get thru it, shes like 4O somethin and preg lol
Mariah most of the time sleeps until the afternoon..so she doesn't sleep 2 hours lol ..she sleeps all through the day and work the night..she has said it herself.
During her very long tour "Memoirs of imperfect angel Tour" she sounded very strong and clear..so why?
I think she just needs a big rest...nobody 's voice can survive over-singing and whistling during 20 years.
Personnaly i don't care of her range...i prefer her to sing low and soulful...not nasal,out off key
@lalettre79 If she got them removed she probably couldn't sing anymore, at least it would be a risk. That's what got Julie Andrews. Leave em there until there's no other choice pretty much is the only option..
@LADYDIVAA Okay. Thank you for your opinion. I know how much I love Mariah and how much I love it when she sings things properly, live, and well rested. I'm not a hater. I am a dissapointed fan. Have a great evening.
This is a great song.. I dont understand why she didn't sing it live on tv.. She killed it on The today show.. ya here it was okay its like did she forget .. song.. but still She just stop promoting the song,.. I mean why didnt you sing this on tour..? but whatever still love the song and the high notes..
i love her, but she needs to rest her voice or get her loges removed or something, (but that is risky) i doctors say have loges to and im only 18 so if that tells you anything. but i gives us an airy sound which can be nice, but we cant sing all time! if we sing everyday day in and day out are voice cracks a lot and are range shrinks. until we rest again for a bit.
@MyTalkShow1992 thanks 4 advised.i can whistle but of course not as good as mariah...and i use it evryday..and there are times that when i sing my voice cracks...
@Sj2690 np, its not really so much if you can whistle if that have loges though. its that if you have an airy sound to your voice like mariah has had since, butterfly (i think) but i believe on her Day Dream album her loges where forming because you could hear voice a little getting airyer. i really dont care because i love airy sounding singer now. but because mariah sings so much (like i do at times) i dont give her time to rest her voice, so all the power leaves to. See a doctor theyll tell u
omg some of u guys can be so freakin rude she probably is tired or just lost her voice it doesnt mean she sucks live now she just needs a break shes overly tired so leave her alone i bet she can sing ten times better than most of u anyways
i agree with misicallyuiquitos. she is a great singer. she is probably the best singer ive ever heard. she does not lip synch. she did pretty good on this. song yah there were some rough spots but before u start hatin u better find the reason y she had a hard time., i bet u cant hit those high notes. shes a great singer so get a life and stop criticizing her.
i think that she's lame by now. she can't sing like before. what happed to her? maybe she stop trying. shame couse i loved her voice once but i must admit that the higher parts are still greath.
she is the most talented singer of all time , no one can do what she can, her voice is tired, and i give her mad respect. Even after all the years of singing she can still hit those high notes!!!!!!!!!!!!! I saw her live and she was amazing! She is and always will be the BEST!!!!!!
Fuck off hater, just cuz you can't sing & you got nothing to do with your life but hate on Mariah Carey. Feeling bravev behind your pc yeh, we aint watching you we watching MC soo piss off in a corner!!!
Yea she deffanatly did not lip this song.....she's got a beautiful voice so you should know that it's really her singing....every part of it....she can hit high notes, but she does struggle alittle.....only a little bit....but other than that she did really good....
i love that she sang live. i honestly think her problem is nerves and she doesnt use propper breathing. and yes the whistle notes are pre-recorded. and the "i can do" at 2:25 is also lol she is insane
u guys need to stop hatein jus cuz mariah carey has mre talent in here then u cud ever imagine to hve it is live n piss off cuz if u tried to hit any of those notes it wud sound lik bloody murder CUZ ITS NOT HER FAULT SHE BETTER N SOUNDS BETTER THN U N THIS IS A LIVE PERFORMANCES SO THERE U HATERS GO
i wish that people would just stop hating on mariah she is an amazing singer and from what i can hear the song is totally live and all the high notes she hit was pitch perfect . i would admit that there were a couple of notes that she struggled through but she got through it and delivered she is hitting higher notes than in her early years mariah rocks and i love her and her God given voice
@hunt44 coz there's a great possibility that she wont be able to hit whistle notes anymore.. and its not 100% sure that when she had her nodules remove her voice will come back.. i know this coz my sister have nodules too..
@F7whistle Her whistle register has been fine its her mid and upper chest that have been suffering....and having them removed couldnt possibly make it that much worse I mean I hope they arent Julie Andrews bad
I'm so glad u mentioned the pre-recorded high notes cuz there was 1 part where the notes started before she took a breath and I couldn't figure out if she was lip-syncing or not. Thanks
@Mannequin2009 i kinda believe u.. :)) it was a lil bit obvious coz of opening of her mouth.. but in whistling.. u can make it sound "o" even if u dont open ur mouth o-ish.. haha f*** sorry cant explain it more.. :))
@Mannequin2009 one more thing.. even if those high notes are pre-rec its still hers ryt?.. even if its a bit edited to sound better.. but its still hers.. :)
Try being a singer and travel every damn day of the week and then try to sing this song. It isn't easy. Different climates and traveling affect your voice. Jet lag, so many other things. She has vocal nodules; that's already been said. But she has had them since she started singing, not just 5 years ago. You can't expect your voice to be perfect every day of the week. We all have off days. She's still a good singer.
@MusicallyUbiquitous Stop making excuses for her...wtf does traveling have to do with her voice. she just can't sing this song live. this is the only performance where she sings this live and sh failed. its ok...not that serious, but you will not keep making excuses for her voice,
@Mannequin2009 hey bitch, u should watch she performed at NYC stripped. Yeah, New York is the best place for her, because she lives there and the weather is great for her to sing beautifully. watch it and stop those fucking comments here.
@Mannequin2009 Actually, traveling has a lot of effects on the voice. Change in temperature, weather, and also you're often tired while traveling, which has a very strong effect on the voice.
@MusicallyUbiquitous Exactly..not to mention people don't realize this show is taped early in the morning but obviously airs at night. She isn't an early person and no one sounds great in the morning.
i think somewhere it was lipped but it would be better for her if she lipped it all cause really that was a disaster. i never thought i would say that about her performance
this was not lipped...i mean really ppl if shes going to lip it would not sound this bad...this is the worst performance of this song...voice really weak...if u want lipped watch it in japan but other than that all live
im not 100% but watching other performances, thats usually where the pre-recorded track comes in again, so unless it was ment to come in and didnt, or she forgot that she had to sing it, and then made up for it lol
wat does one have to do with the other...she just lost her breath (which is very hard to keep while singing in the whispery tone) have to do with her whistle notes?
i dont think its that, i think it has to do with her voice being tired because if you go to "Mariah Carey Live Performance Of Hate U In New York! she sings it perfectly!
I love Mariah, but her voice was not good that day... At 2.29 she missed the "hate you" and almost missed the pre-recorded wistle, but she is really good lipping.
BUT!!! AFTER 2:50 the emotion an agony i loved in this perfrmance. but like sum ppl said b4 she is sining a lot live and does need to rest the voice which is affecting her live shows.
thats because she has been doing whistles for bout 20 years now she said they come so natural and easy now a days she says its almost as easy as talking
Not her best performance, but her FIRST 100% live performance of HATEU, so I am very happy to see her singing and giving us an emotional interpretation. I prefer something imperfect but sincere/true, than something faked and partially recorded to make like it it was flawless and perfect, which it is never the case in a live version..
It's not 100% live people. learn to be more analist. Watch 2:31 where she makes it more noticeable that she lipssyncs her high notes, that's whay the verses of the song sound like shit and the high notes so perfect
whitneys voice is worser than mariahs. whitney performences is sung by her backup singers not her that is why she has like 5 backup singer. so shup up!
You always know when she's not as strong because her background singers sing a LOT more parts than they should, which is NEVER that way on album versions.
Mariah! Mariah! Mariah! Lord! What was this? Please go and rest your voice! This was one of the worst performance I have ever seen or heard from a diva. Just rest your voice please!
Now you know that was not one of Mariah's greatest performances. For a singer of her calibar it was bad. She clearly should rest her voice and body. She's one of the greatest vocalists of all times. She can do waaayyy better than this!!!
I Think This performance it's incredible ...she gave me so many emotions singin' with imperfection...here she sings with her heart & soul...and she's great!
I agree with most of you, she needs some rest and that's all, she's been doing a lot of album promotion lately, so she must be tired. But anyway, I'm glad she sang this live (and believe me, that's a 100% live) cuz the other performances were totally lipped, that's why they sounded so PERFECT, but hey, she's an imperfect angel, and I don't think it sounded that bad, it's a very very hard song to sing
All she needs is some vocal rest. No singing for a week and keep talking to a minimum. After her album promotions she should go and get some much-needed vocal rest.
LOL......she caught lipping...."hat!.hate you" <---- she actually wanted to lip this but the playback wasnt playing she thought she was fast enough mimes the whistle notes, sadly but, NO...oh my..i love when u mimes mariah, u showed that u always sings live b4 and miming is hard for ya!...cheers!
OMG i can't just stop watching this!!!! the whistle were so smooth!!! goodness!
lobregatsean24 1 month ago
This is definitely live(I think)~ u can compare it with the cd version one, there's difference in there. Plus, you can hear her breath in, and there is gap when she sings the chorus. and she has made some changes in this song. and the high note if u listen to the cd one, it is edited, and this one is natural one..haha>.< will her be so freaking free to sing and record another version of Hate You to fit in this show? I don't think so..so it's live.(^_^)
TheAngelyFoo 3 months ago
incredible
colombiatm 8 months ago 3
The best!!always #1
luisboricua9 9 months ago
I think that Mariah is one of the best female singers of all time. I've been to most of her comcerts. She will always be the best with that five octive range!!!!
darrell19781 9 months ago
:( wasnt feeling this performance. I'm glad she recovered her voice
TrGreaves2090 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The high note at 2:32 was so amazing like Mariah herself. And the one at 3:07 and the one at 3:27.
lish2014 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The high note at 2:32 was so amazing like Mariah herself. And the one at 3:07
lish2014 10 months ago
The high note at 2:32 was so amazing like Mariah herself.
lish2014 10 months ago
@lish2014 now you already know that entire high not was lipped. look at her mouth smh but it was amazing just not live
Mannequin2009 7 months ago in playlist voice
@Mannequin2009 Lol That was not lipped cause you dont necessarily have to move your mouth .. Its what you push through yo diaphragm .. True Musicians know that .
LeilaniMonroe 1 month ago
@LeilaniMonroe i'm sorry but it was lipped. it sound exactly the same in every live performance. the last high note wasn't lipped though
Mannequin2009 1 week ago
@Mannequin2009 This is NOT lipped....this is NOT exactly how it is on the album...you can tell where she sang faster than the music on the Bridge (..a matter fact I think Im moving away). Mariah is just THAT good that she tricked you into thinking she was lipping. This is an obvious 100% live version.
eastcoastthriller 3 days ago
@eastcoastthriller i dint say those parts were lipped i said the high notes were lipped except for the last one
also on the 2nd verse pre-recorded notes were on
Mannequin2009 43 minutes ago
catastrophiqueeeeeeeeeee
fleurdorient33 10 months ago
wow
d3blh01 11 months ago
EVERYONE TYPE IN THE NAME Kathlean Lobban TO HEAR MY REMIX OF THIS SONG. HOPE YOU ALL ENJOY IT. :)
matrixklo 1 year ago
this gotta be her last album, shes gonna have a baby and move on, still good but she JUST gets thru this lol
aidimcc69 1 year ago
Lol No darling MCC LOVES music devoted to it for 20 yrs almost 21. She's gonna slow down but she's still gonna be working anyone who is a fan knows she loves singing and writing its just what makes her happy. We probably won't get an album every year know but expect more in the future. She's pregnant and doing rigorous promo she doesn't know the word stop haha.
Miyuri687 1 year ago
Love, love, LOVE Mariah! But I just hate how she sings with her hands. And is it just me or does she really look like she's having a hard time singing....maybe the baby is just pressing on her vocal cords, haha.
cmethrough 1 year ago
@cmethrough lmao, i think she's directin the backing singers with it, listen to haw they respond and it helps her get thru it, shes like 4O somethin and preg lol
aidimcc69 1 year ago
The vocal nodes! The VOCAL NODES!
twinqletwinqle 1 year ago
@twinqletwinqle Exactely..Tht plus+no rest=this...
Not good, but not terrible, just raw
ArtisticProdigy09 10 months ago
it was all live, i think it was aamazing!
mcboypower 1 year ago
@mcboypower Lol i thought I was the only one lol
ArtisticProdigy09 10 months ago
TRY TO GET NODULES AND SING & WRITE SONG ALL NIGHT LONG GO AROUND THE WORLD FOR TOUR 3 NIGHTS PER 1 COUNTRY
SLEEP 2 hours WORK FULL DAY & NIGHT
THIS IS FOR HATERS
drunkdivamariahcarey 1 year ago
@drunkdivamariahcarey
Mariah most of the time sleeps until the afternoon..so she doesn't sleep 2 hours lol ..she sleeps all through the day and work the night..she has said it herself.
During her very long tour "Memoirs of imperfect angel Tour" she sounded very strong and clear..so why?
I think she just needs a big rest...nobody 's voice can survive over-singing and whistling during 20 years.
Personnaly i don't care of her range...i prefer her to sing low and soulful...not nasal,out off key
lalettre79 1 year ago
SHE IS SINGING WHEN SHE WAS A KID
SHE IS STILL SINGING & WRITING & TOURING & MORE SINGING & NEW ALBUM
SINGING FROM 1989 Demo - 1990 Star is Born
AND PRESENT, NON STOP!!! ONLY MARIAH
I FOLLOW HER STEP AS SINGER SONGWRITER
drunkdivamariahcarey 1 year ago
Still a good performance though.
ThePharaoho 1 year ago
She seems to have a hard time controlling her voice and range here. She lipped some of the high notes.
ThePharaoho 1 year ago
the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pepeq30 1 year ago
singing this song is actually incredibly difficult, that whispery effect on voices is dangerous, because its so easy to just break.
SERTYG 1 year ago
i think this song is very deep, too bad it didn't do that well.
as for mariah's performance, well it was good, not amazing like most of her other performances. and yeah, what the hell happened at 2.29??? dang :/
TheGirlInADress 1 year ago
MusicallyUbiquitous Other big voices also travel so why they can still sing???
Ok Nodes... She refused to get them removed only for the whistle...it's stupid!!!
lalettre79 1 year ago
@lalettre79 If she got them removed she probably couldn't sing anymore, at least it would be a risk. That's what got Julie Andrews. Leave em there until there's no other choice pretty much is the only option..
DarlingTinaSheep 1 year ago
@LADYDIVAA Okay. Thank you for your opinion. I know how much I love Mariah and how much I love it when she sings things properly, live, and well rested. I'm not a hater. I am a dissapointed fan. Have a great evening.
KwameKOcran 1 year ago
This song is hard u know!
RaciouS91 1 year ago
This bitch lipped from 2:20-2:45. UGH!
KwameKOcran 1 year ago
@KwameKOcran ur momma shoulda lipped instead of spittin out a loser baby hater like u
LADYDIVAA 1 year ago
This is a great song.. I dont understand why she didn't sing it live on tv.. She killed it on The today show.. ya here it was okay its like did she forget .. song.. but still She just stop promoting the song,.. I mean why didnt you sing this on tour..? but whatever still love the song and the high notes..
babymariah 1 year ago
she's so incredible!
whatisntfun 1 year ago
she verry good and the sad part she and her 40's
dominecha 1 year ago
Freakin Awesome...
masguilaro 1 year ago
Mariah in her 40s past her prime is still better than these new young kids "singing" on the radio today. I love her for still going and going
gabysucks26 1 year ago
i love her, but she needs to rest her voice or get her loges removed or something, (but that is risky) i doctors say have loges to and im only 18 so if that tells you anything. but i gives us an airy sound which can be nice, but we cant sing all time! if we sing everyday day in and day out are voice cracks a lot and are range shrinks. until we rest again for a bit.
MyTalkShow1992 1 year ago
@MyTalkShow1992 thanks 4 advised.i can whistle but of course not as good as mariah...and i use it evryday..and there are times that when i sing my voice cracks...
Sj2690 1 year ago
@Sj2690 np, its not really so much if you can whistle if that have loges though. its that if you have an airy sound to your voice like mariah has had since, butterfly (i think) but i believe on her Day Dream album her loges where forming because you could hear voice a little getting airyer. i really dont care because i love airy sounding singer now. but because mariah sings so much (like i do at times) i dont give her time to rest her voice, so all the power leaves to. See a doctor theyll tell u
MyTalkShow1992 1 year ago
@MyTalkShow1992 i can that too..!so thats maybe the reason why voices cracks!!!
Sj2690 1 year ago
if ur a Musician, you would know that the song was really hard to sing. with all the changing ranges, placements and tones of the song, o c'mon!
Kudos for her!
gofckofndie 1 year ago
its the tight girdle!!!
marikitna 1 year ago
omg some of u guys can be so freakin rude she probably is tired or just lost her voice it doesnt mean she sucks live now she just needs a break shes overly tired so leave her alone i bet she can sing ten times better than most of u anyways
Stohgeleletaleswind 1 year ago
i agree with misicallyuiquitos. she is a great singer. she is probably the best singer ive ever heard. she does not lip synch. she did pretty good on this. song yah there were some rough spots but before u start hatin u better find the reason y she had a hard time., i bet u cant hit those high notes. shes a great singer so get a life and stop criticizing her.
bazketbalizmylife 1 year ago
i miss the old mariah..
iPHANN 1 year ago
........ouch
pfatti333 1 year ago
i like the crystal microphone.
the09conradz 1 year ago
I can wait to hate u
thebdm3 1 year ago
She sucks live now
CertainExtent27 1 year ago
Oh Buddy! Oh Budd-Y! Oh Bud-DY!
stylestar07 1 year ago
i think that she's lame by now. she can't sing like before. what happed to her? maybe she stop trying. shame couse i loved her voice once but i must admit that the higher parts are still greath.
natilj1 1 year ago
HATERS have been TRYING HARD to put MARIAH DOWN since DAY ONE of her CAREER...but the BIG QUESTION IS DID THEY EVER WIN? DEFINITELY NOT!!!!!!!!!!
the REALITY still SLAPS on their FACES that AS LONG as MARIAH EXISTS, NO SINGER WOULD EVER HAVE A CHANCE TO BE ON HER THRONE...
GO MARIAH... we love you and keep on giving us such wonderful music...
God bless you.../
vladz2485 1 year ago
she is the most talented singer of all time , no one can do what she can, her voice is tired, and i give her mad respect. Even after all the years of singing she can still hit those high notes!!!!!!!!!!!!! I saw her live and she was amazing! She is and always will be the BEST!!!!!!
336tootsie 1 year ago 24
@336tootsie It can be argued between Mariah and Whitney.
ThePharaoho 1 year ago
@336tootsie A completely ridiculous statement.
tenor220 11 months ago
She's a great singer but she didn't sound amazing here.
jameszhao00 1 year ago
Fuck off hater, just cuz you can't sing & you got nothing to do with your life but hate on Mariah Carey. Feeling bravev behind your pc yeh, we aint watching you we watching MC soo piss off in a corner!!!
VivaLaVidaBeBe4eva 1 year ago
mariah mariah mariah,,
panget mo mag live....
wala ka talagng kwenta mglive..
hai..
very disappointing..
cutejing06 1 year ago
@cutejing06 sama naman.. :(
bogieroo03 1 year ago
this song is really nice for a frist timme listener.......
jp7970 1 year ago
That Was Not Impressive Dnt Get Me Wrong I Love Mariah Carey ButShes Slacking And Them 'Scream' Notes Are Not Live Sorry People !
Vocalsz 1 year ago
sounds good live
Passionrose132 1 year ago
i really just wanted to hug her and say "you dont have to sing for us. go rest. you deserve it. take a break mimi we love you"
syanez5 1 year ago
that was painful
MrBurritoSupreme 1 year ago
Yea she deffanatly did not lip this song.....she's got a beautiful voice so you should know that it's really her singing....every part of it....she can hit high notes, but she does struggle alittle.....only a little bit....but other than that she did really good....
DestinyGirl1228 1 year ago
Not her best performance but nice to see her singing HATE U live.
whitireia 1 year ago
LOVE IT!!!!
dya76tube 1 year ago
@jjoocmariah !This is a very hard song to sing though! If she struggles with her own songs what makes u think nobody else would struggle with this???
malcolmjs1993 1 year ago
poor thing so nervous .. pumped it though
filitrateme 1 year ago
i love that she sang live. i honestly think her problem is nerves and she doesnt use propper breathing. and yes the whistle notes are pre-recorded. and the "i can do" at 2:25 is also lol she is insane
joeyvoh 1 year ago
And right after the "I can do", @ 2:28, she thought that the "hate you" was pre-recorded, that's why she came in late. Get it together Mariah!!
JayCroix 1 year ago
lol yeah, i kinda figured thats what happend. She is crazy lol
joeyvoh 1 year ago
this song is juz tooo hard to sing..
alienash 1 year ago
this is definitely her worst performance ever....
senyum76 1 year ago
she really struggled in this performance. :)
Choco2341 1 year ago
mariah is might the best singer on earth but her personality is just silly
kalifa1231 1 year ago
u guys need to stop hatein jus cuz mariah carey has mre talent in here then u cud ever imagine to hve it is live n piss off cuz if u tried to hit any of those notes it wud sound lik bloody murder CUZ ITS NOT HER FAULT SHE BETTER N SOUNDS BETTER THN U N THIS IS A LIVE PERFORMANCES SO THERE U HATERS GO
ishastalented2013 1 year ago
i wish that people would just stop hating on mariah she is an amazing singer and from what i can hear the song is totally live and all the high notes she hit was pitch perfect . i would admit that there were a couple of notes that she struggled through but she got through it and delivered she is hitting higher notes than in her early years mariah rocks and i love her and her God given voice
kmollah1234 2 years ago 6
why doesnt she get her nodules removed
hunt44 2 years ago
@hunt44 coz there's a great possibility that she wont be able to hit whistle notes anymore.. and its not 100% sure that when she had her nodules remove her voice will come back.. i know this coz my sister have nodules too..
F7whistle 1 year ago
@F7whistle Her whistle register has been fine its her mid and upper chest that have been suffering....and having them removed couldnt possibly make it that much worse I mean I hope they arent Julie Andrews bad
hunt44 1 year ago
@F7whistle do nodules due to over singing? or is it just there naturally?
stewardlie 1 year ago
@stewardlie it can be inborn but in sum cases they just got it becoz of "over singin"
F7whistle 1 year ago
she may not be lipping, but those are pre-recorded high notes.....i watch this performace everyday cause i know for a fact its live lol
Mannequin2009 2 years ago 3
I'm so glad u mentioned the pre-recorded high notes cuz there was 1 part where the notes started before she took a breath and I couldn't figure out if she was lip-syncing or not. Thanks
lpurvis 1 year ago
yup just pre-recorded...but she still sounded good though
Mannequin2009 1 year ago
@Mannequin2009 i kinda believe u.. :)) it was a lil bit obvious coz of opening of her mouth.. but in whistling.. u can make it sound "o" even if u dont open ur mouth o-ish.. haha f*** sorry cant explain it more.. :))
F7whistle 1 year ago
lol....true
Mannequin2009 1 year ago
@Mannequin2009 one more thing.. even if those high notes are pre-rec its still hers ryt?.. even if its a bit edited to sound better.. but its still hers.. :)
F7whistle 1 year ago
yup...its cool with me she still sounded good.
Mannequin2009 1 year ago 4
She is not lipping this one...you can her the struggle when she sing this song. By the way it is a hard song to sing live.
yclub2k2 2 years ago 3
the notes were live and even the best of singers can be pitch perfect all the time your voice does not always work like that
kmollah1234 2 years ago
the whistle after she did the long belted note sounded live but the others are indeed pre-recorded
pok3rfac 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i watched this movie at W W W . TV-Video . us
ankenmanbecky 2 years ago
why is everyone saying it was bad? for me, it was good.
gustavojoris 2 years ago
Try being a singer and travel every damn day of the week and then try to sing this song. It isn't easy. Different climates and traveling affect your voice. Jet lag, so many other things. She has vocal nodules; that's already been said. But she has had them since she started singing, not just 5 years ago. You can't expect your voice to be perfect every day of the week. We all have off days. She's still a good singer.
MusicallyUbiquitous 2 years ago 35
Exactly what I be sayin'. People forget that though.
ICANDIGUOUT 2 years ago
@MusicallyUbiquitous well look at celine she alsway on top
lucasode 1 year ago
@lucasode - That's because she has a penis.
MusicallyUbiquitous 1 year ago
@MusicallyUbiquitous Stop making excuses for her...wtf does traveling have to do with her voice. she just can't sing this song live. this is the only performance where she sings this live and sh failed. its ok...not that serious, but you will not keep making excuses for her voice,
Mannequin2009 1 year ago
@Mannequin2009 - Blah blah blah think what you want.
MusicallyUbiquitous 1 year ago
@MusicallyUbiquitous THANK YOU I WILL
Mannequin2009 1 year ago
@Mannequin2009 hey bitch, u should watch she performed at NYC stripped. Yeah, New York is the best place for her, because she lives there and the weather is great for her to sing beautifully. watch it and stop those fucking comments here.
hoangkieuco 1 year ago
@Mannequin2009 i dont know why its matters that people make excuses for her .. she didnt sing this song that bad .. i want to see you do better !
ddavid134 1 year ago
@Mannequin2009 Actually, traveling has a lot of effects on the voice. Change in temperature, weather, and also you're often tired while traveling, which has a very strong effect on the voice.
padfootreturns92 1 year ago
@MusicallyUbiquitous Exactly..not to mention people don't realize this show is taped early in the morning but obviously airs at night. She isn't an early person and no one sounds great in the morning.
zusman84 1 year ago
shes on her monthly here when your on it the vocal chords swell (inlarge) thats why she sounds like shes struggling
steviegohard100 2 years ago
LOL
MusicallyUbiquitous 2 years ago
lol thats what she said
steviegohard100 2 years ago
possibly...that is true...
1dreamlover1 2 years ago
i think somewhere it was lipped but it would be better for her if she lipped it all cause really that was a disaster. i never thought i would say that about her performance
butterfly1ob 2 years ago
this was not lipped...i mean really ppl if shes going to lip it would not sound this bad...this is the worst performance of this song...voice really weak...if u want lipped watch it in japan but other than that all live
1dreamlover1 2 years ago
poor her.. I mean in the best way... when I see this kind of performances of her I just feel nervous
mikhel000 2 years ago
and cause of this accident u can see high notes are playback
butterfly1ob 2 years ago
ok i love her, really but i'm terrified, what happend at 2:29???????????????
butterfly1ob 2 years ago 3
im not 100% but watching other performances, thats usually where the pre-recorded track comes in again, so unless it was ment to come in and didnt, or she forgot that she had to sing it, and then made up for it lol
JamieCleaton1 2 years ago
wat does one have to do with the other...she just lost her breath (which is very hard to keep while singing in the whispery tone) have to do with her whistle notes?
1dreamlover1 2 years ago
Comment removed
butterfly1ob 2 years ago
@butterfly1ob She Still Sounded EXTREMELY Beautiful !
MangaMc91 1 year ago
Yikes. She's losing her voice, too. Just like Whitney. Guess it's just a matter of getting old.
whitneyfan72 2 years ago
i dont think its that, i think it has to do with her voice being tired because if you go to "Mariah Carey Live Performance Of Hate U In New York! she sings it perfectly!
1991STARSKY 2 years ago
She's not loosing her voice the song is just really low.
witch26071 2 years ago
i love how even her not so great performances, sound 100 times better then some of these artists out today who try and perform live.
stylestar07 2 years ago 3
I love Mariah, but her voice was not good that day... At 2.29 she missed the "hate you" and almost missed the pre-recorded wistle, but she is really good lipping.
NekoPetrovsky 2 years ago
She sounds like she has breathing problems.... like always running outta breath. Mariah, do some cardio.
generation159 2 years ago 3
lmao... well its called vocal nodules... it makes it hard to keep your pitch and breathe right... it happens when you yell too much and shit
AndrewJamesYo 2 years ago
BUT!!! AFTER 2:50 the emotion an agony i loved in this perfrmance. but like sum ppl said b4 she is sining a lot live and does need to rest the voice which is affecting her live shows.
TheNessaVanessa 2 years ago
there r bettr performances of this. But her hubby will hosting the morning show on 923NOW FM! I AM EXCITED
TheNessaVanessa 2 years ago
what makes me laugh is how she strugles a little on everything but the really high notes
lol i dont understand
hesmybreath 2 years ago
that's cause the high notes are pre-recorded. Look closely at 2:31 when she makes it obvious she lipsyncing her high notes.
mireles00 2 years ago
well dont you think you know everything??
news flash you dont
live with it
hesmybreath 2 years ago
thats because she has been doing whistles for bout 20 years now she said they come so natural and easy now a days she says its almost as easy as talking
steviegohard100 2 years ago
THIS IS LIVE!!!!
rain03x 2 years ago
love her
wilfredo77alvarez 2 years ago
I cant even watch this.
She cant sing live anymore.
What a shame.
Oh Mimi!
prisonnersdilemma 2 years ago
what an amazing song and performance. i prefer this over a perfected lip synced one... the best performance yet i would say
mollygifford 2 years ago 3
mariah can sing but she cant perform for shit
thatchanelbitch 2 years ago
Anymore, but look at her performance at Letterman's from 2005.
inspireradavstatyer 2 years ago
why all backup singers are black?
samgee2007 2 years ago
she always had black backup singers,the boy is Trey Lorenz,one of her best friends
NatureBoyPabbs 2 years ago
Because we're not living in the 1950s with segregation and Jim Crow laws anymore :|
R0ntay3 2 years ago
I Loved The Performance!
FoxyBrownFan1 2 years ago
Not her best performance, but her FIRST 100% live performance of HATEU, so I am very happy to see her singing and giving us an emotional interpretation. I prefer something imperfect but sincere/true, than something faked and partially recorded to make like it it was flawless and perfect, which it is never the case in a live version..
aaxlm 2 years ago 4
It's not 100% live people. learn to be more analist. Watch 2:31 where she makes it more noticeable that she lipssyncs her high notes, that's whay the verses of the song sound like shit and the high notes so perfect
mireles00 2 years ago
Comment removed
whitneygreatest123 2 years ago
she just had a bad day at work like everybody else
athol26 2 years ago 4
agreed
slurpie12poo 2 years ago
get off our site you are not a fan
brendalovesmariah 2 years ago
whitneys voice is worser than mariahs. whitney performences is sung by her backup singers not her that is why she has like 5 backup singer. so shup up!
L4L
mariahfan3277 2 years ago 2
Funny joke!
inspireradavstatyer 2 years ago
I like this one - at least it's live.
J2Cam85 2 years ago 2
You always know when she's not as strong because her background singers sing a LOT more parts than they should, which is NEVER that way on album versions.
WorldChanger81 2 years ago
first time i'v ever seen her make a mistake
athol26 2 years ago
This performance is amazing, I love it <3
correctordj 2 years ago
this was an AMAZING performance !
i refuse to hear otherwise
iluvmylay 2 years ago
Mariah! Mariah! Mariah! Lord! What was this? Please go and rest your voice! This was one of the worst performance I have ever seen or heard from a diva. Just rest your voice please!
ThePharaoho 2 years ago 3
ur an ASS!!!
F7whistle 2 years ago
Now you know that was not one of Mariah's greatest performances. For a singer of her calibar it was bad. She clearly should rest her voice and body. She's one of the greatest vocalists of all times. She can do waaayyy better than this!!!
ThePharaoho 2 years ago 2
it sounds horrible, like an animal dying. i cant breathe
shellbsd23 2 years ago
i actually liked it... :)
F7whistle 2 years ago
I Think This performance it's incredible ...she gave me so many emotions singin' with imperfection...here she sings with her heart & soul...and she's great!
elettrick83 2 years ago 5
I COMPLETELY AGREE :)
F7whistle 2 years ago
Her mic was too low
Abstractionant 2 years ago
dam dis performance was so beautiful...
93sexcii 2 years ago 4
I love her outfit that night and her voice as well.
christambb01 2 years ago 5
she did a fucking great job its a fucking hard song to sing and she did it live props
Antboogie0828 2 years ago 7
or is it her belt that is to tight that she cant really sing that night?
stewardlie 2 years ago
I am wondering if MC has a vocal coach? I was thinking nope..maybe a vocal rest teacher...
stewardlie 2 years ago 2
I agree with most of you, she needs some rest and that's all, she's been doing a lot of album promotion lately, so she must be tired. But anyway, I'm glad she sang this live (and believe me, that's a 100% live) cuz the other performances were totally lipped, that's why they sounded so PERFECT, but hey, she's an imperfect angel, and I don't think it sounded that bad, it's a very very hard song to sing
jessica12mc 2 years ago
All she needs is some vocal rest. No singing for a week and keep talking to a minimum. After her album promotions she should go and get some much-needed vocal rest.
HeyJimmyDeannn 2 years ago 3
LOL......she caught lipping...."hat!.hate you" <---- she actually wanted to lip this but the playback wasnt playing she thought she was fast enough mimes the whistle notes, sadly but, NO...oh my..i love when u mimes mariah, u showed that u always sings live b4 and miming is hard for ya!...cheers!
MsBrowse 2 years ago 3