Added: 7 months ago
From: cokestudioatmtv
Views: 111,593
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (223)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • original coke studio is far more better than this one these people r just trying to earn money than creating music..still last but not the least work hard to make it better at least in the name of music

  • See the irony... Wearing western clothes singing classical ghazals

  • you are awesome Ramu! keep going..:) the countdown for 1 million hits..very soon..

  • OK. Ramya, that's bloody brilliant! Go forth and conquer. Amazing!!

  • its embaressing man coke studio india is full of shit!

    fukkk

  • Fantastic! wonderful rendition of a timeless classic.would love to see more of ramya iyer!

  • I loooooove this song! She has sung it with soooo much soul. Beautiful.

  • Boring Original is better..... Coke studio Pakistan is Much more mature.... 

  • seriously, rohini ravada was better than that..come on man.. fusion does not allow you to screw a particular song.

  • total bakwas!

  • waste!

  • coke cola wasting their investment in indian studio....lol

  • hahhaha......bad very bad

  • Damn try practicing Farida Khanum first !!!

  • Comment removed

  • O MY GOD! what an absolute disaster!

  • in indian music lots glitz and glammer but no creativty, no art,no artistic freshness..... lot of new expensive instruments, lot of noise, lot of glammer..poor music direction no real music

  • now this makes me wanna leave this song and go watch the original Farida Khanam's song..

  • OMG....... lady u raped this beautiful ghazal......... what were you thinking........

  • Thumbs 'Up' for Ramya

  • its rubbish

  • can anyone share any Indian song sung in CokeStudio Pakistan?

    We should be thankful that boundaries are being removed here,,,'

    Enjoy the Music....

  • nangi kion ho k gaati hain ye ? dont knw why they want to be westernized fools

  • hud hogyi bgair music k hi gaa dia sara :S

  • lant hay yaar kam se kam original song ko hee sing kar looo kia bakwas sing kar rahi hay ........... saree mod ke maa bahan kar ke rakh dee hay ... original song sunne ke baad ye sunna ayesa hee hay jasee vigra khanee ke baad banda green dhanyia pee layee...

  • yar for god sake koi aur singer nahi mila tha kia itnay achay gany ki wat lagadi thats not fair yar ....!

    song ka clibre dekho poetry dekho pehlay jin logon gaya hai unka sunoo koi methi awaz nai mili thi kia pakistan se bhi agar koi ye krta to wo bhi ibhi alfaz ka haqdar hota...! that's a limit

    Now i wonder why coke studio india didn't made a buzz ...!

    sari umeedon ka bhaji pala kerdya !!!

  • shit yaar maine kitni umeedon se es video pe click kiya..but stating is not gud enough...gud try but esse bhut acha ho sakta tha...lyrics ka jawab ni....

    koi ni hota hai...

  • such a disgrace to Farida Khanum... bohat hi bakwas

  • it is ART dat transcends frontiers n boundaries...dis India,Pakistan stuff is foolish but folks lemme tell u very honestly there cud never ve been a better way to WASTE dat beautiful beautiful ghazal than dis absolute crap........no way dat its even 5% of original despite latest gadgets n techniques.........Whosoever made dis shit is requested not to throw da RICHNESS of sub continental music like dis...pl have sum respect 4 music.....

  • Very well sung and touches the soul! In my opinion comparisons are not needed as this is sung in a very different way and has been done very well!

    Secondly, to bound music by boundaries, like ye India and ye Pakistan is foolish, we should have a bigger heart and more tolerance as far as music is concerned, so chill and enjoy!

  • Hello Indians maan jaoo pakistani boohat aage hai bs wasail nahi hai :) Kuch kaamo main pakistan aage or kuch main indian aage but koi bhi bura nahi :)

  • indian hr cheez hi copy kr lety hein :D

  • fazulllllllllllllllll aik dam 3rd class starting

  • fck studio

  • ye kesa coke studio hai jis main music he nahi hai?

  • please don't mess with the legends!!!

  • Nooooooooooo!!!!!! total fLOooop!!!

  • wah...wah...nice...different.

  • awful!!!!

  • Uhhh..no. Not as good as the original, not even as good as the version by Shankar Tucker. She's trying but she's off. Don't waste your time.

  • wtf??????? her scale was sooooo off!

    

  • Why is Coke Studio spoiling such great hits: Shame on MTv and shame on this stupid singer-they should find something else to do in their life, India is after all a land of opportunities, Music is not meant for them!!!!

  • this is a roondi version. very well sung but cant listen to it again!

  • Until now Indian studio has been a disappointment, camper to Pakistan studio, which I am a great fan of, but what a stunning comeback. Sluggish back ground music, allowed singers to do the magic with their voice and lyrics. Most beautiful interpretation of the most beautiful gazel. Pakistan studio has produced spectacular female voices recently, but this one is nothing less. Keep up the good work

  • chawal hi hai .. lol

  • Like if you wish people could enjoy music for its beauty and not make ignorant comparison.

    "Love wins" :)

  • Please listen original first there is lot of efforts required to perform like Farida gi aur Habib sb.

  • FLAWLESSS and simply BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!

  • ok .. no ... i liked how it started but i was waiting for a surprise.. there was no surprise... coke studio pakistan always has a surprise element that just makes you go .>OMG REPLAY

  • silky song :) heart gets nourished :)

    

  • Poet's name is Faiz Ahmad Faiz saab

    

  • SUbhan ALLAH..MAno Ruh ko chu ke nikli ho.....

  • the intro HAHAHAHAHAHA

  • @nadia12398 yea ........4 heavens sake ... wot was that!!

  • True my pakistani brother Coke Studio India has to put in some more hours but if you talk about creativity then i guess our filmy music of bollywood and classical music is much better than pakistan but then if you talk about individual music its much better in pakistan , so there should not be any shame in learning from each other , let us learn from each other and ler us not take any potshots on each other..

  • @r22102 " LOL........ALL THE CLASSICAL GHARANAAS ARE IN PAKISTAN...LOL YOUR GOOD IN UR BOLLYWOOD LIKE SONGS...AS MUNI BADNAAM ,,,SHELA KI JAWANI...LOL HA H

  • @BABADAANG11

    dude get your facts right.... which gharanas are you talking about? I agree when it comes to Ghazals and sufi songs Pakistan is way ahead.... But when it comes to Classical Vocal/Instrumental India miles ahead. Agree a lot of Pakistani ustads were there in the past but dont see this thing continued today..... suggest you check out Sangeet research academy..... you will know

  • @r22102 Well said friend,both countries have produced legends in music who are beyond comparison,indian film music is way ahead of pakistan,it was comperable till the 70s but then the curse of military regime destroyed everything but still the hard work and commitment of artists kept music alive in pakistan,i totally agree with you that there should be no harm or shame in learning from each other,,peace from a music lover.

  • @r22102 hey dude, your filmy music sucks, yes some of your classic music is good no doubt about that.

  • @r22102 true brother im from Pakistan and appreciate the indian talent :) 

  • Music is beyond the boundaries....Please do not make it an INDO - PAK issue.....Comparing these singers with Farida Khanum would be a mistake....Farida Khanum is as much adored in India as She is in Pakistaan ....This one may be a good attempt but I didn't like it much.....

  • \m/

    

  • great

  • I think the Paki's are being way to racist because a young girl was able to justify this song !!!!! Make an attempt to listen to this song in dim lights & just listen to her voice !!!! You'' know its magic........I think everybody....Farida/Asha they all have sung it well and this is a different approach to the song which i think should be appreciated

  • one of my fav songs sung by coke studio india.. hmm! 

  • hahaha i appreciate ur efforts but still need much hard work to get to the level of coke studio pakistan..

  • @walkingdead93 chod naa yaar kya india pak lagaaa rakhha hai.... "aaj jaane ki zid naa karo" :P

  • @walkingdead93 Hmmm...but this version is so soothing .

  • @walkingdead93 well said!! there is lot more to do!

  • Wat a Mess..............Screwed up da whole beauty of the gr8 ghazal....

  • I don't why these jealous bitches whining here. I loved this rendition of the song just as much as I liked Farida's ghazal. Its sung in very different way. Among many bad compositions I reckon this one stands out for MTV CS. Well done ladies!

  • JOKE STUDIO

  • Garbage .

  • be teri ma bhosada garbage

  • @twinklerohit9 fuck you asshole ?

  • Very slow,like singing in front of family members.Just to impress them.

  • the bitch sucks..

  • @rhfarooq beta ji ye ghareebi pakitsan me bhi achuki hai :P, btw this version is gud, but fareeda made it classic, and u cant beat classics :p

  • flawless singing!!!! cannot be any better!!! full respect.

  • I'm a huge fan of this ghazal and to be honest, I didn't think anyone could screw it up but she has. What the hell is this?

  • India main ghurbat kitni ho gai hai, aurton ko dhakney key liye kapra nahin milta hai lagta hai.

  • @rhfarooq yaar fir tu tu kehle k america may bhi badi gurbat hai , europe may bhi badhi gurbat hai, wahan bhi kam kapde pehente hain.. abe apne se matlab rakh, hame jo pehen na hai pehen lenge, tum apne desh ki halat pe dhyaan do ham apna dekh lenge and btw bahut acha gaana gaya hai... aur apne allah k naam par please zabardasti hame neecha dikhane ki koshish na karo.. nafrat faila rakhi hai har jagah tum pakistaniyon ne!!! baaz aa jao plz, music ko toh baksh do!! huh

  • @golaharsh I'm going to call it like I see it my dear friend, if you don't like what I have to say, then that's too bad. The song is crap, it has nothing to do with nationality. When a Pakistani (or Bengali/American/South Korean) sings like a braying donkey, we should note it. This song is beyond pathetic, it rings phony. That is my opinion and I am entitled to it. If you don't like it, shove it where the sun don't shine brother!

  • Comment removed

  • guyz...get above ur sick arguments...plzzz....dnt malign music ...music has no boundries...n no 2 singers can be alike!! even if dey r twins :P so plz behave sensibly ? !

  • very sweet voice... alomost as good as original track..

    NICE!!!!

  • I'm sorry, didn't get it right. Is this a song or rhyme? Not a song for sure! And the background music is a complete alien!! Re-creation is not meant to be different like this shit!!! I'm so shocked!!!!!!!!!! Hope i'll forget it soon.

  • Excellent.

  • 3:55 - 5:59 sung so beautifully...sounds tender yet haunting....woman i luv ya!!

  • AWESOME :D i love the poetry and the feeling of the SINGER :D

    *super sexy*

  • brilliant stuff!!

  • awesome singing...regards from Pakistan

  • loved it... btw... i believe if its good, then it should be liked rather then making silly comparisons....

  • original song is from pakistan. she ruined it. Type " bollywood plagarised pakistani songs" on u tube and thn see.

  • she is good but no match to the original ghazal by Farida Khanum. I think the problem is this artist has slowed down the rythm too much as opposed to the origninal version by legendary FARIDA KHANUM from Pakistan. Maybe she has slowed it down because she cannot carry note at that high pitch.

  • dard kahi se fir se ubhar aaya iss aawaz ko sunke...jite ji fir se jaan si nikal gai iss lavz ko sunke...fir se khamoshi ki gaherai o me le gai hai teri yeh aarzoo muze...bus vahi pe marna hai yu hi khamosh bethe hue teri panah me...

  • what music? there is no music just Ooooo Ooooo Oooo! Bullshit!

  • awesome!!!!!

  • SUB-MEDIOCRITY - these singers should be sent to Tihar jail.

  • Damn! Coke studio India really sucks bad! Whoever is responsible for this horrible attempt at fusion or whatever you want to call it, should be re-educated. Seriously, this is woeful, how on earth did Coke Studio agree to this senseless slaughter?? bloody hell, arrangement, musicians, singers, lame!

  • She has destroyed a classic song sung by Habib wali Mohammad.

  • She seems young but very very deep with her voice ! Amazing talent :)

  • she'll have to learn another 100 years to sing even close to this invaluable deathless song...... singing slow might just create some environment, but it doesn't make her up to the mark...... doesn't cut it even close.....

  • @sadsayeed1 AS IF YOU KNOW PORKISTANI

  • @206Eclipse

    what do u think....!?! do I?!?!

    /watch?v=wqbbILfdw94

    /watch?v=c2wMHBH8xrA

    watch these, and tell me whether Ramya & Rupmatii could ever be close to such legends.....!! let's see what u understand about music.....!!

  • How dare you to sing this beautiful song itaisi n joke studio,,,,,

  • tabla was formed from mridang...a totally INDIAN instrumnt and sitar from VEENA ...which is carried by Devi Saraswati.

    And yes we recognize persian influence , but what has Pakistan to do with it.it is crossbreed of 2 great civilizations...Hindu India and Pesia.

    Apna to kuch nhai hai tumhare pass...

  • rula diya yaar!

  • she tries to copy sara raza khan.....and sings a legendry singer's song......triyng to get emotions of tina sani............lyrics from a pakistani poet............lesle and this girl are tring to fight with classics................rohail hayat sy tution ly lo meri jan

  • beautifully sung...((:

    By a Pakistani....xD

  • hayeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee mar jayengeeeeeeee .....hum to luttttttt jayengeeeeeee .........aisi batein kiya naaaaa kroooooooo ...... she hv a seductive voice lolzzzzzz

  • superb!!! she has sung it very nicely!! and guys there is no division in music. I know Farida jee has sung it very nicely but let these new talents on the block get their due. Music is universal, and good music should always be appreciated.

  • chutiya singer and bakwas music from coke studio

    this ghazal originally sung by malika-e-ghazal fareeda khanam even asa bhoslay is nothing in front of

  • NICE SONG with Good Composition.. Love FROM Pakistan.. its just keep on getting better and better.. GooD work INDIA..

  • @AaBeautifulTruth: Fayyaz Hashmi was born in Calcutta, Habib Wali Mohammed in Bombay...last time I checked they were both India....your classical music was born in Gwalior or Agra or Jaipur or Patiala etc. all in India....Pakistan was born 60 years ago...India 5000 years ago.....Why do you have to make such comments....there is nothing called your music....it is all common to this great land of ours...stop being divisive and be respectful....I respect Pakistanis but not idiots like you.

  • @patbusy1 All the good good things in india are donated by us Muslims of persian decent. Architecture, food, music, poetry, good manners... everything was given to India by Muslim culture that ruled India for 1000 years. Even the instruments like Sitar and tabla were created by Amir Khusro. India should respect Pakistanis because our forefathers gave India so much. But instead of giving us respect you people like to steel everything. You people are a very cunning and cheap nation.

  • ha ha ha ...al the gud things given by muslims...there was hindu empire b4 ure forefathers came here...n we did have beautiful civilaization then...they looted us...they dont say this in ure history books in pakistan..ha ha ha and they are not your forfathers...u are bloody converted ass...and the fact is this is bothering you...as u dont have anything left in ure shitty country..so u come here and comment...sad for u mate...knw the history better...go wikipedia...not paki history books...

  • @AaBeautifulTruth You are a laughing stock. Please think outside your state sponsored history. How can you be stupid enough to think that Persians came to India and created a music, which is no more found in Persia, and gave most ragas very distinctly Hindu names?There is a part of India, larger than Pakistan, called South India, which was never invaded by anybody, bar the British, and they have the same raga system as the North. This music predates Islam even.

  • @patbusy1 - Yes some of the comments are true but it was composed by Sohail Rana a veteran music director from Pakistan. No offense.

  • Pakistani poetry, Pakistani composition, sung by Pakistani legend singers. When will India stop steeling Pakistani master pieces !!! Joke Studio at mtv

  • @AaBeautifulTruth

    If you feel music then yu may come to conclusion that it has no boundaries. India and Pakistan was not created by musicians. but by politicians who desired power. Musicians just desire love and appraisal in return for what they honestly feel compose and sing. Sir/Mam true love and true music has no demarcations. Its free from such evils.. Thats why its still divine. Thats y every true heart is able to fall in love with it.

  • Brilliant

  • Why does she have to try her hands on a classic.Why didnt Lesle gave him something fresh to sing.

  • Okay guys give her due credit. I think she has done a real good cover as compared to any contemporary Indian or Pakistani singer I've heard so far. If someone's trying and you can see the effort is being duly put in, it should never be discouraged, neither should talent be.

  • The lady speaking at the beginning and end is acting overacting not feeling the words, artificial delivery.

  • Okay,,,Guys only for my brothers n sisters from India n Pakistan n from anywhere,,plz listen to Farida Khanum's original one...this song does not stand anywhere....A real Thumri by Farida Khanum... Please check that...

  • Coke Studio India sucks.. I know its a great effort but a fact is a fact. The lady has sung this well, but she doesnt have the continuation in her verses...just listen to Farida Khannum , u'll understand.

  • guys the earlier versions of the song sung by Iqbal Bano and Habib wali Mohammad (from Pakistan) are way more melodious. This version is kinda below average.

  • I liked Pakistan's Coke Studio more... From India...

  • here is the original ...

    /watch?v=0cJi4e76iHs

  • Girl is trying to copy the vocal of Pakistani Singer Tina sani .... imitation is imitation... From U.S.A

  • Tina sani`s cover is not on youtube.. but do watch Ashal Bhosle`s version.. that is equally good..

  • boht aalaa.. I attended a live Tina Sani session a few months back.. she is a class act.. but this cover is awesome... other then this.. the first season of coke studio India was below average.. hope it will improve next year..

  • wow!

  • she sings from her heart and it is heart touching sound lovely voice.

  • bakwaas

    

  • SAtya Nass kar Dyaa Itnay Baday song Ka Please Listen Original Guys From Pakistani Singer Please

  • SAtya Nass kar Dyaa Itnay Baday song Ka Please Listen Original Guys

  • Nice music, but where are the musicians? It was a real frustration watching this video of the corporate logo, with the singer off to one side, often out of focus. This is crass corporatism displacing the music, rather than a celebration of the music supported by the sponsors. More music, please, and visible musicians, with less advertising. It was nice to hear something from India that was not Bollywood trash. But it would be nicer to hear some proper pieces.

  • good work coke studio india .. love and regards from pakistan ..

  • Hear the original one please!!!!!

  • The poet of this song is Faiz Ahmed Faiz and it is originally sung by the Legend - The great Fareeda khanum from Pakistan... the composition, the tune every thing is stolen from Pakistan.. did not like it.. try to produce your own creativity! Good luck next time - A viewer from Pakistan.

  • @mehmaan100 - The poet is Faiyaz Hashmi not Faiz Ahmed Faiz.

  • pahlian asha bhoslay nay chori shuda gana gaya ab coke stodio nay iss ganay ki maa baich di....

  • Comment removed

  • ramya niceee

    lik it lik it totally like it

  • she is literally moaning like she is a porn star why fuck this ghazal ??? simply irritating u cud have listened to farida khanum first then sung it by copying her but wtf :S :S :S :S :S :S :S

  • good ramya, i love the this

  • wowed us! so much better than the bollywood trash- keep up the effort

  • more melodrama than singing.....singers please lern to sing in Sur.....Drama is ok for a while but good singing is winner at the end.....

  • A---maazing! both thumbs up to the singer!

  • @uditoshiq I dunno how long u have not been laid for...but sincerely I dont see the erotica in this one. and y do u compare...music is music...its a language..if u understamd..well..good for u..if u dont..well..wat can i say..

  • you have added erotica to the lyrics, the melody. this is against the soul of the song. you have almost ruined one of the greatest songs ever. coke studio shouldnt have dared touch this song knowing their capabilities. Its a sad moment for music. Stop ruining the legends. i suggest try the simplest songs for this is what you are adept to do.

  • This Pakistani song if performed in Pakistani Coke studio would have much better.

  • coke studio is the best

  • So far Best from Coke Studio India.......No Words to describe Heavenly and soulful....

  • whats with that erotica feeling in this song? 

  • Well i shud not say this but Coke Studio India shudnt take part in coke studio...Pakistan has outclassed the Indian Coke Studio or its musicians..one shud c the creativity in Pakistani studio...and the usage of modern instruments with the amalgamation of traditional instruments...Plz smeone convey this message to someone...This song cud have been presented in a very diff. way...check out Arif lohar's Jugni....wat a transformation of a traditional fold to a modern rock....a dissappointed Indian

  • WTF......well sung but a little rock touch to the song would have been awesome...like all songs have been re created in coke studio pakistan...this leslie is a dumb composer...god save coke studio india

  • <3

    

  • i loved this ! two thumbs up .

  • Need standing ovation ! Just Brilliant. @cokestudio India. You are doing brilliant job. Do not worry about the negative comments below. You know your music well. Ppl who understand music are with you. Great job Mr.Leslie.

  • Good effort. Still cannot beat Fareeda Khannum

  • Comment removed