As a composer, I would dislike seeing someone perform my song differently than how I would. I would even dislike someone playing my song at all unless that person also plays a completely original piece of their own during the performance. That is an action I can fully respect. It is like a compliment and a fair trade. It is also an interesting statement of where their living style is and is going for the moment.
I mean it makes sense right? Why would anyone learn anything the wrong way or half-assed? I am not trying to be mean or anything like that, ok? It goes with anything anyone learns. If I am going to be tested on the periodic table of elements, I would have to learn all the info to all 88 to 94 naturally occurring elements. Half assed or the wrong way would be learning just the names, or atomic numbers, or failing to learn all 88 to 94 of them. When it comes time for the exam, would I pass? No.
You know, today people, on youtube is proud to show, and say something like "hey look, i've done it bymyself ! i'm really skilled don't i ?" Or, "i've done it by ear".
But this kind of people does not know that we're looking for brahms, not their poor adaptation. Ok, sometimes it's cool, but must of the times it suck.
I think first, before doing an adaptation, they should interpretes the real-one, and then, if this one is perfect, maybe tryna do their own try.
I couldn't have put it better myself. I totally agree. I mean I can play some of Chopin's Etudes but you don't see them on Youtube for a reason. I need more practice. And I wouldn't substitute ANY interpretations for the real versions, or else they wouldn't be his Etudes, right?
I don't speak french, although a bit latin, so I have a basic understanding of what you said, but just for "measures" what did you say? (ok you got me, I didn't understand too much of that... except that you speak arabic and you *something* egypt)
Somehow your video is not able to capture the movements of your hands and the sounds correctly. I realised that your hands are a bit slow as reflected on the video while the music is already ahead.
However, despite of the few minor mistakes in your playing, it was good!
that's really very much simplyfied... too bad I think..
lottoformulier 1 year ago
You are skilled!
As a composer, I would dislike seeing someone perform my song differently than how I would. I would even dislike someone playing my song at all unless that person also plays a completely original piece of their own during the performance. That is an action I can fully respect. It is like a compliment and a fair trade. It is also an interesting statement of where their living style is and is going for the moment.
bethfetterman 1 year ago
I think your timing is not so good...correct me if im wrong...
gregbboy619 2 years ago
Comment removed
gregbboy619 2 years ago
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
zwaantijn 2 years ago
nice rendition but I think all the time you put into making your version could have been put into learning the real one.
ibanezgrind 2 years ago
@ibanezgrind
Lol clearly
SoldierSid3 2 years ago
I mean it makes sense right? Why would anyone learn anything the wrong way or half-assed? I am not trying to be mean or anything like that, ok? It goes with anything anyone learns. If I am going to be tested on the periodic table of elements, I would have to learn all the info to all 88 to 94 naturally occurring elements. Half assed or the wrong way would be learning just the names, or atomic numbers, or failing to learn all 88 to 94 of them. When it comes time for the exam, would I pass? No.
ibanezgrind 2 years ago
@ibanezgrind
You know, today people, on youtube is proud to show, and say something like "hey look, i've done it bymyself ! i'm really skilled don't i ?" Or, "i've done it by ear".
But this kind of people does not know that we're looking for brahms, not their poor adaptation. Ok, sometimes it's cool, but must of the times it suck.
I think first, before doing an adaptation, they should interpretes the real-one, and then, if this one is perfect, maybe tryna do their own try.
SoldierSid3 2 years ago
I couldn't have put it better myself. I totally agree. I mean I can play some of Chopin's Etudes but you don't see them on Youtube for a reason. I need more practice. And I wouldn't substitute ANY interpretations for the real versions, or else they wouldn't be his Etudes, right?
ibanezgrind 2 years ago
For sure yeah.
SoldierSid3 2 years ago
this is the best of all hungarian dances. also good arrangement, congrats.
theentpic 2 years ago
Comment removed
GAkingkhanGA 2 years ago
Oh, I like this music, you can play it very good, and the sound of the piano is very specialy, very cool
GAkingkhanGA 2 years ago
??? ur not actually playing this
LipaEuro 3 years ago
Its just not synchronized very well.
Chrisjuchniewicz 2 years ago
za szybko
korycinski108 3 years ago
FAKER FAKER FAAAKER!
MSMcFLYSyndrome 3 years ago
this is the simple version the real version is a knuckle buster...
thebrickinator 3 years ago
you play in brass or trumpet? it is not piano sound
takhirviolinest 3 years ago
Yes that is piano sound. And a trumpet is a brass instrument... really good,anyways!
bzzzzbzzzzbzzzz 3 years ago
can some tell me where i could find the note for Hungarian Dance No.4
SonaSmartChild 3 years ago
Try freescores(dot)com, and btw its called sheet music ;) You from germany? Its "notes" in many other languages ;)
bzzzzbzzzzbzzzz 3 years ago
Monsieur, I'm from Egypt, Cairo. I was played but this playing is not good, Mersi pour commentaire
takhirviolinest 3 years ago
You're welcome, but what do you mean? And why do you speak french, and say mersi instead of merci?
bzzzzbzzzzbzzzz 3 years ago
S'il vou plé je suis désolée, Je suis l'Egypte, Je Parle Arabic, Plus de intonatione, rimt, tempo. Merci pour toi Commentaire
takhirviolinest 3 years ago
I don't speak french, although a bit latin, so I have a basic understanding of what you said, but just for "measures" what did you say? (ok you got me, I didn't understand too much of that... except that you speak arabic and you *something* egypt)
bzzzzbzzzzbzzzz 3 years ago
wow! good piano playing..if thats even u..i wish i could play like that:)
wadge08 4 years ago
you should learn the original cause this isn't
tonyzebologna 4 years ago
playback ---.---
songokullo 4 years ago
as a king
han444 4 years ago
Somehow your video is not able to capture the movements of your hands and the sounds correctly. I realised that your hands are a bit slow as reflected on the video while the music is already ahead.
However, despite of the few minor mistakes in your playing, it was good!
Dragonslayerwx 4 years ago 6
You are not boring, your piano sounds like it is incapable of contrast. Find a better piano and re-record!
mudyar 4 years ago
Das ist erstens Playback und zweitens ne Katastrophe, Tut mir echt leid. 1 Stern.
diekken 4 years ago 3
you are boring not the song
hardcape 4 years ago
made the song more exciting than normal.
321sukcur 4 years ago
good talent. boring song. played song greatly. ugly pink nail polish
BalisticBean 4 years ago
i thought it was good. but i agree with the nail polish.. sorry =]
rayazn9 3 years ago
wonderful. Thanks for posting.
als98 4 years ago
control your camera, it got too excited :). very good played. practice a bit, just a bit more on the ending scales. thats it :)
harrymegdugal 4 years ago
good talent
put more
i enjoy
jinkoo 4 years ago