I think the accompioing musician is scaring the most scary of them all... Jeff Mangum. Great version, even with the pychotic snake charmer lead break. Thanks for posting.
Please, please, please check out my video to in the aeroplane over the sea on my channel. I really want to get it to 1000 views! It'll be worth it, there's a beautiful girl in the vid!
@lknowyourrootsl my immediate assumption was that you were saying THIS was a cover. I was so indignantly angry before I realized it was probably a generalization about all the not-Jeffs that have covered this song.
Yeah if you like the sound of fingernails scratching chalkboard. The guy regulary misses high notes which turns into pig squealing. Really painfull to listen
@nino555 Pig squealing? there's no pig squealing. i'll admit he isn't the best singer in the world, but he doesn't pig squeal but i know what your talking about anyway.
This is really one of the best songs ever written...by the way, couldn't they hire a fucking good flugelhorn player? This one fucks up everything...I mean...tuning...timing...notes...
There's an intangible quality to all these New Year's videos...it's as if they exist in a world other than this. Jeff Mangum is the only thing that has saved my life. I met him once and he is not incredible. He is a human being. He boils his macaroni like us all. He was almost ashamed of his talent and fans. I believe he sang to save his life...but it ended up nearly costing him said life. He is, without question, my eternal, incomparable influence.
i don't get this. you say he is not incredible and yet you romanticize his existence and make him sound like some ethereal being. i dislike how people treat jeff(or anyone really) like some holy being purely based on their songwriting ability, none of you know him and probably never will.
@johnmorisi8 I love how he starts bouncing right after... and how the next line is "What a beautiful face..." like that one moment lifted his whole spirit up from the sadness of the previous verse
It's so odd to hear him talking in a normal voice and then suddenly he starts singing-- such a rapid transition between a regular voice and the voice of a god.
I just realized that I almost played this song out! Aw, shit. I did the same thing to "War Pigs" and "Stairway to Heaven." Now, I need to wait a few years to listen to anything from this album. Fuck!
En los 90's, yo crecí! escuchando esta banda : NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL, al igual que JOY DIVISION, que CODEINE; dos discos fueron suficiente para crear todo un mundo increible . . .
@LP7SIETE34 i have literally no idea what you've said but NMH and Joy Divison are my two favourite bands, so you autmoatically get a like (unless you're saying they're shit, then you get a 'hit' put on your head)
@thomdibble jajaja! in short, grew up listening to these three great bands, and are part of my obligation to listen, always. Love JOY DIVISION, NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL and CODEINE. And yes, it's fucking not knowing a certain language, and certainly the music breaks that barrier. Greetings!
I love NMH, but what's with this performance? There's low-fi and then there's low-talent... and the trumpet player especially comes dangerously close to the latter. Jeff is pretty pitchy too
@YTspacecadet I get the feeling that these songs aren't created for other people to listen to. Im happy that somehow they got recorded, released, and made their way to my ears.
But I wouldn't be surprised if he didn't prepare much for his shows. He doesn't seem to be into the whole rock star thing - and as such I am willing to forgive him in areas where I would hold other bands to a higher standard. really, I just feel lucky to have heard anything he's created.
@Heffe6 Totally agree....it's an honour and a pleasure to listen to this. Neutral Milk Hotel were unlike anything else before or after...there are imitators but only one Jeff and only one N.M.H.
Such a beautiful song! I tried my best to do it justice in my own rendition. Give it a listen and let me know what you think. Just search "Blane Clark."
Rockin that beard Jeff. I kinda hope that the Whitest Kids U'know would do an NMH based sketch because Trevor Moore looks just like Jeff. That may be a dumb wish, but I'd laugh.
The Bros: New Indie right out of New Orleans. Listen if you like Neutral Milk Hotel, Death Cab for Cutie, Belle and Sebastian. We'd appreciate it if you gave us a listen. Thank you!!!!
Playing saw solo.
Those words alone make this song amazing.
hellucardlord 3 days ago
The brass kinda sucks.
MegaBaloonz 3 days ago
Great live performance. The notes were right on.
rminitials 1 week ago
GREAT VOICE PLEASE JEFF COME TO ATHENS GREECE FOR A CONCERT
Bilararas13 1 week ago
I think the accompioing musician is scaring the most scary of them all... Jeff Mangum. Great version, even with the pychotic snake charmer lead break. Thanks for posting.
xwhite2020 2 weeks ago
Fuck yeah, only 99 days left until I'll see him!!!
TheAndy011 2 weeks ago 2
coachella :)
poggyproductions 2 weeks ago
he is PLAYING @ COACHELLA!
shiningbritte 2 weeks ago
Oh shit! Holy shit!
hairyoldman89 2 weeks ago
Wherever you are, we miss you.
GoreyOr 3 weeks ago
Exactly the day and year is was born!
TheShadowFog 3 weeks ago
@TheShadowFog Happy belated birthday!
Saskatchewan00 2 weeks ago
It is very hard to classify music as beautiful, but this is definitely something I would classify as beautiful.
unkommon2001 4 weeks ago
Does he have a beard or is it just a shadow?
MrCorrectUsername 1 month ago
@MrCorrectUsername 1:39 .99,9% it's a beard
vorchun19 2 weeks ago
Is he still alive and i want a reunion?!
manxind 1 month ago
@manxind he is alive and starting to perform again
eoj11 4 weeks ago
@eoj11 im glad to hear it :D
manxind 4 weeks ago
What a beautiful face, I have found in this place...
lukerr87 1 month ago
thats how u sing a mothafu#k&.
BITRBUFFALO30 1 month ago
ahhh, to be a rich kid in athens, ga.
hmillernin 1 month ago
oh my gosh....... his sweater is amazing! im so jealous!
wildrumpus7 1 month ago
Hooray! Top comment! I'm officially successful!
erbot123 1 month ago
For the longest time I thought that his name was Magnum... not Mangum
penisonfiregarth 2 months ago 46
@penisonfiregarth HOLY SHIT.
fuckingcabbage 1 month ago
@penisonfiregarth Agreed. I felt real stupid when I finally noticed.
HerrZwist 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
earth angel earth angel
ulacitfilm 2 months ago
Winter sweaters are sexy.
ohmycaribou 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
NMH are fucking great. Timeless!
Please, please, please check out my video to in the aeroplane over the sea on my channel. I really want to get it to 1000 views! It'll be worth it, there's a beautiful girl in the vid!
AllAroundTheSun 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great song
Read my review of Jeff Mangum at
allsoundsmusic.blogspot.com/2011/11/resurrection-of-jeff-mangum.html
The1TCM1 2 months ago
He's extraordinary live.
GuillotineGirl6663 2 months ago
simply brilliant
ScrollerRoller 3 months ago
Because it is so beautiful.
lknowyourrootsl 3 months ago
@lknowyourrootsl except mewithoutYou
clwoody76 2 months ago
I wish people would not make covers of this song.
lknowyourrootsl 3 months ago 6
Comment removed
jrlsth 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lknowyourrootsl my immediate assumption was that you were saying THIS was a cover. I was so indignantly angry before I realized it was probably a generalization about all the not-Jeffs that have covered this song.
At least, let's assume that.
jrlsth 2 months ago
i need to know what this is filmed on. it looks beautiful.
EdwardTheGentleman 3 months ago
@EdwardTheGentleman A video camera... from the 90s.
CrazyLazySnazzyJazzy 3 months ago 3
LOVE DIS SHIT! F N BEAUTIFUL'-
AAAASMAR 3 months ago
<3
benjaminrichardshoop 3 months ago
i love videos where all the comments are positive. it seems like less mainstream music has those; neutral milk hotel, guided by voices
domesticcaribou 3 months ago 4
i'm seriously going to cry that was fucking beautiful. she was playing a sawwwwwwwwwwwwwww
ddevotchkaa 3 months ago
@ddevotchkaa THAT sir, is a dude, just sayin.
stude444 3 months ago
anyone know where i can buy a sweater like that???
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago
@TendingToTheCorpses 1998. Not where, its When ;)
EclipseStrife 3 months ago
@EclipseStrife i need itt! it seems to be the source of his powers! xD
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago
I don't know how anyone can dislike neutral milk they are amazing and Jeff has one of the most haunting beautiful voices i've ever heard
humouriseverything 4 months ago
iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii looooooove youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu Jeeeeeeeefffffff Manguuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuummmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Jeeeeffffffff Manguuuuuuuuuuummmmmmmmmm Iiiiiiiiii loveeeeeeeeee youuuuuu yes i dooo
owloeil 4 months ago 59
Comment removed
owloeil 4 months ago
what a beautiful song!
whenhereturns 4 months ago
17 jerk's just want to tick us off who dose not like neutral milk hotel
slowrider1978 4 months ago
oh crap, 17 people accidentally clicked the dislike buttom
yourcrapsweak1 4 months ago
box set coming soon,according to npr.would bob boilen lie to you?
dobbsiancant 5 months ago
at 1:32 he saw anne frank.
euterkapuze 5 months ago 6
@euterkapuze daaaaaaaaaaaamn
SomethinRofl 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
his voice is fucking awful
nino555 5 months ago
@nino555 I think it's epic
yohkoGaming 5 months ago
@yohkoGaming
Yeah if you like the sound of fingernails scratching chalkboard. The guy regulary misses high notes which turns into pig squealing. Really painfull to listen
nino555 5 months ago
@nino555 I know he doesn't sing that good, I just think he has a awesome voice. I love to hear him sing even if he fails at high notes.
Same thing with Robert Smith. Love his voice, but the man can't sing...
yohkoGaming 5 months ago
@nino555 Pig squealing? there's no pig squealing. i'll admit he isn't the best singer in the world, but he doesn't pig squeal but i know what your talking about anyway.
rdcpatches0 4 months ago
@nino555 Get out
antelopebabyable 2 days ago
beautiful.
Shavy8312 5 months ago
Watching this has had me feel the same magic I felt when I heard this song for the first time.
ringostarrlove 5 months ago 2
I have a sweater, but it's not as good as his.
MrPumpkins1979 5 months ago 3
I want that sweater.
emilygibbous 5 months ago
Jeff really resembles Jesus in this one.
joesmomisdead 5 months ago 2
Love this song
Ukelelehumpanddump 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
16 people HAVE ears!
dariussquared1 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@dariussquared1 > Implying In the Court of the Loveless Radioheads by Neutral Milk Collective isn't the best post-avant jazzcore album ever
wombat989 5 months ago
that sweater is soft and sweet.
nickgderp 5 months ago 5
Greatest song off the greatest album of the 90s. Actually fuck that, greatest song off the greatest album ever.
patrickhinea 5 months ago 6
Oooooh the 90's.....
maddyp52095 5 months ago
16 people don't have ears.
fourteenstorieshigh 5 months ago 5
Epic.
dady73 6 months ago
whats the other kid playing????????????
heyfriend631 6 months ago
@heyfriend631 Singing saw i believe.
AyNoobyNoobers 6 months ago
soft n sweet
icnclt 6 months ago
Play that f**king saw!!!!!!
verucasalt13 6 months ago 3
this is so cool
kevinjr101 6 months ago
Love that facial hair on him. :)
tfcbart 6 months ago
I get to see Jeff live in Boston!!!!!!
mula1234321 6 months ago
@mula1234321 I'm so jealous, ugh.
fourteenstorieshigh 5 months ago
I love neutral milk hotel but what a way to go into the new millennium.
kellowjo 7 months ago
>December 31st 1998<
I guess this is the best way to celebrate New Year.
s1ayd 7 months ago 5
Why are there always people chatting away in the background?!
Everyone should be dead silent and focused on Jeff's genius!
CrazySchool09 7 months ago 2
Musical saw is fucking awesome. Julian kicks ass.
ChrisnSnoop 7 months ago 3
1:24 is the best part and then the look he gives after that howl. ahaha this is awesome
chicagocubbies11 8 months ago
@TheMacMillanPage lol I see
Tunnelzzzzz 8 months ago
This is really one of the best songs ever written...by the way, couldn't they hire a fucking good flugelhorn player? This one fucks up everything...I mean...tuning...timing...notes...
Tunnelzzzzz 8 months ago
@Tunnelzzzzz I could swear that's a french horn, but yeah i agree with you, it was pretty bad haha xD
bobuo7 7 months ago
There's an intangible quality to all these New Year's videos...it's as if they exist in a world other than this. Jeff Mangum is the only thing that has saved my life. I met him once and he is not incredible. He is a human being. He boils his macaroni like us all. He was almost ashamed of his talent and fans. I believe he sang to save his life...but it ended up nearly costing him said life. He is, without question, my eternal, incomparable influence.
erbot123 8 months ago 38
@erbot123
i don't get this. you say he is not incredible and yet you romanticize his existence and make him sound like some ethereal being. i dislike how people treat jeff(or anyone really) like some holy being purely based on their songwriting ability, none of you know him and probably never will.
snousings 7 months ago
@erbot123 That was beautiful! Thank you.
enroserie 2 months ago
@enroserie No, thank you :)
erbot123 1 month ago
That saw solo, I lost it.
Arathnis 8 months ago
Sarcasm generally does not fly on the internet. Just a PSA.
Ihateironman 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I made a music video for this incredible song- please check it out on my channel.
AllAroundTheSun 9 months ago
wow his phone really has a cheap cam quality ....
H8iZ1337 9 months ago
@H8iZ1337 this was 1998, there were no camera phones
joesmomisdead 9 months ago
@joesmomisdead o rly? thanks for the info bro!
H8iZ1337 9 months ago
@H8iZ1337
are you trolling? this video is from the late 90's.
aznxtasy341 8 months ago
I am 576 years old and I've been listening to this music since I was a fetus.
Can you beat that? no one gives a fuck how old you are.
brownteal21 9 months ago 10
free jeff
StoneAgeAbortion 9 months ago 5
mangum partyin' like it's 1999.
marktrenkle 9 months ago 6
Question to Jeff Mangum: WHERE THE HELL ARE YOU?!
GivepeaceachanceJL 10 months ago 2
i used to play css: surf with a guy that named himself after these guys... now they are one of my favorites...
hxv0dka 10 months ago
why couldnt i have been here?
lvillecards12 10 months ago
3:56
"holy Shit!"
ibanez456189 11 months ago
i will be seeing this in person. still hard to believe.
PenguinJockey 11 months ago
@PenguinJockey I tries to get tickets, they sold out as soon as they went on sale... feelsbadman
IvanladTM 11 months ago
@IvanladTM there are still tickets available for the jersey city show on 11/6. loew's theater is a great venue.
PenguinJockey 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PenguinJockey I tried to get tickets, they sold out as soon as they went on sale... feelsbadman
IvanladTM 11 months ago
@PenguinJockey When? How?
joemunkey30 10 months ago
He just announced a short solo tour for late this year
DrFotherMucker 11 months ago
@DrFotherMucker Think he'll play in Athens GA?!
shwat17 11 months ago
Comment removed
aethertrebs 11 months ago
His voice is actually coming out of that sweater.
aethertrebs 11 months ago 93
@aethertrebs It is the source of his powers.
firetruckgreen 6 months ago
holy shit. he sings so awesome live
limosince2007 11 months ago
it gives me chillls
"I'll be laughing out loud
I'll be laughing with everyone I see
Can't believe how strange it is to be anything at all"
tacojuan 11 months ago
neutral milk hotel. one of my most favourite bands ever
thomdibble 1 year ago
Man that was an epic saw solo if I've ever heard one!
deathcouch 1 year ago
Why is the horn player so off?
4000Wiggins 1 year ago
@4000Wiggins its supposed to sound like that. it sounds cool
WOF08 1 year ago
When they smile during the saw solo. Priceless.
johnmorisi8 1 year ago 83
@johnmorisi8 I love how he starts bouncing right after... and how the next line is "What a beautiful face..." like that one moment lifted his whole spirit up from the sadness of the previous verse
BloodlessToque 9 months ago
@johnmorisi8 You just got to smile when they do ;)
SurfByDesign 1 month ago
dude his eyes are crazy
DoubleLuckyJacket 1 year ago
this was on my 7th birthday!
emelybemely 1 year ago
This song is so sad and so beautiful.
cwelch333 1 year ago
awesome
zahrock12 1 year ago
This album is pure awesome, I don't think I've listend to another album that has touched me as much as this one has
miniraptorX 1 year ago
@miniraptorX "Michael" has touched me more
MEST12 1 year ago
This is the version on Acoordian Peas.
narutoprower 1 year ago
oh just to see them live once... i would be happy for the rest of my life.
annieholm 1 year ago 2
@annieholm
I totally agree... it's tragic that he pretty much pulled a Syd Barrett on us...
Also, I want to learn how to play the saw.
Deadguy56 1 year ago
@Deadguy56 dude, he's back now
Bjarku 11 months ago
anyone know where I can buy that jumper?
Pointbreaker2 1 year ago
@Pointbreaker2 your local hipster emporium
turokcalde 1 year ago 4
anyone know what brand of guitar he's playing?
Allchaos 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrInfiniteSadness 1 year ago
It's so odd to hear him talking in a normal voice and then suddenly he starts singing-- such a rapid transition between a regular voice and the voice of a god.
SenorSlopez 1 year ago
I just realized that I almost played this song out! Aw, shit. I did the same thing to "War Pigs" and "Stairway to Heaven." Now, I need to wait a few years to listen to anything from this album. Fuck!
mussman717word 1 year ago
Looking back, I think i owe everything I have to Jeff Mangum. Up to this point, it is he who taught me to think. and there is still so much more
muse5life 1 year ago
Compulsive listening!
RazedRoof 1 year ago
This music changed my life.
lifetisbutadream 1 year ago
What a LEGEND. Thank you Jeff and NMH for making such beautiful and moving music!
tamaravel 1 year ago
En los 90's, yo crecí! escuchando esta banda : NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL, al igual que JOY DIVISION, que CODEINE; dos discos fueron suficiente para crear todo un mundo increible . . .
LP7SIETE34 1 year ago 2
@LP7SIETE34 i have literally no idea what you've said but NMH and Joy Divison are my two favourite bands, so you autmoatically get a like (unless you're saying they're shit, then you get a 'hit' put on your head)
thomdibble 1 year ago
@thomdibble jajaja! in short, grew up listening to these three great bands, and are part of my obligation to listen, always. Love JOY DIVISION, NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL and CODEINE. And yes, it's fucking not knowing a certain language, and certainly the music breaks that barrier. Greetings!
LP7SIETE34 10 months ago
I love his facial expressions throughout this video.
dethklok766 1 year ago
The gaudiness of the tinfoil '99 and Jeff's loud poncho contrasted against the heartaching delivery of the song is perfect. Just magic.
MitchmastaNZ 1 year ago
Art! so pure!
dolcevespa1 1 year ago
his eyes.
ItTakesII 1 year ago
i would give a foot for another NMH album, and i would sell my soul to marry Jeff (:
"Soft silly music is meaningful, magical"
mudansiedad 1 year ago 2
That sweater.
rayman121212 1 year ago 4
This is so amazing, I don't even know how to comment on it,
wassurping 1 year ago 2
I love NMH, but what's with this performance? There's low-fi and then there's low-talent... and the trumpet player especially comes dangerously close to the latter. Jeff is pretty pitchy too
YTspacecadet 1 year ago
@YTspacecadet I get the feeling that these songs aren't created for other people to listen to. Im happy that somehow they got recorded, released, and made their way to my ears.
But I wouldn't be surprised if he didn't prepare much for his shows. He doesn't seem to be into the whole rock star thing - and as such I am willing to forgive him in areas where I would hold other bands to a higher standard. really, I just feel lucky to have heard anything he's created.
Heffe6 1 year ago 2
@Heffe6
That's a pretty great way of looking at it.
YTspacecadet 1 year ago
@Heffe6 Totally agree....it's an honour and a pleasure to listen to this. Neutral Milk Hotel were unlike anything else before or after...there are imitators but only one Jeff and only one N.M.H.
jwattie 1 year ago 2
@YTspacecadet youre a tool
MyButtStinks 1 year ago
@YTspacecadet This was one of their last shows, I wouldn't be surprised if the sickness was getting to jeff.
Lastscionz 1 year ago 2
I love this guy, I love this song, I wish I could love life the same way :S
FatMikejo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Such a beautiful song! I tried my best to do it justice in my own rendition. Give it a listen and let me know what you think. Just search "Blane Clark."
blaneclarkmusic 1 year ago
Rockin that beard Jeff. I kinda hope that the Whitest Kids U'know would do an NMH based sketch because Trevor Moore looks just like Jeff. That may be a dumb wish, but I'd laugh.
weamdebest 1 year ago 2
@weamdebest holeeee shittt I never thought of that.
extremejon 1 year ago
he looks so ridiculous.
narutoprower 1 year ago
I hate to say it, but Spillane sucked it up in this performance.
totlyepic 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
please tell me what you think of my version of this song on my channnnelll!!
bwaysavvyloves 1 year ago
What I would do to see Jeff Mangum perform one last time.
ALEXAHHHHHHHH 1 year ago 4
genius has nothing to do with perfection..this is pure genius.
dolcevespa1 1 year ago 3
Every single performance, Jeff sings like it's the only way he can control the demons inside him. Every performance is absolute magic.
MitchmastaNZ 1 year ago 2
genius
mnolanporter 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Bros: New Indie right out of New Orleans. Listen if you like Neutral Milk Hotel, Death Cab for Cutie, Belle and Sebastian. We'd appreciate it if you gave us a listen. Thank you!!!!
xMyChemicalxRomancex 1 year ago
@xMyChemicalxRomancex dude stfu you're name is xMCxRx go die or advertise on shitty music
SilentEcho33 1 year ago
Comment removed
ExpectationsShotgun 1 year ago
@xMyChemicalxRomancex Probably sucks, judging by your account name.
reltuButler 1 year ago
Jeff Mangum? what is man gum? hah think about it.
chascoufal 1 year ago