Added: 5 years ago
From: gigglez74
Views: 3,298,820
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,226)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • <3

  • SHES AMAZING. I LOVE HER VOICE! OMGOSH! SHES MY FAV. THIS VIDEO MAKES ME CRY AND GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS

  • god sake with the glitches

  • LEONA LEWIS IS BETTER

  • SIMON WAS BLISS WITH LEONA YOU CAN TELL HE LOVED HER FROM THE BEGINNING

  • Leonas good but Kellys voice is better suited for the song . Here the dynamics are too out of it for the song ... Kellys dynamics were epic there were moments of weakness and then the ultimate strong 'I will not fail you' notes . I really want to hear Katherine McPhee sin this she's the perfect blend of the two .

  • I LIKE KELLY CLARKSON VERSIONS BETTER BECAUSE OF THE TRIUMPH SHE HAS IN HER VOICE AS OPOSED TO THIS ONE SHE HAS NOO VOICE I FIND THIS ONE VEERY RETARTED

  • i like leona lewis better....sooorrryyyy. lol don't bash me for telling the truth...

  • I think Leona has the higher falsetto. Other than that hands down Kelly Clarkson is the better singer. Not hatin but honestly other than that falsetto I don't think Leona can do anything vocally BETTER than Kelly Clarkson. People who have doubts go watch Kelly Clarkson's live performance of "Why Don't You Try" here on youtube. It's absolutely amazing, especially towards the end.

  • I always fall for beautiful voices like Leona Sarah Brightman and Josh Groban though I like other types to but not as much. Leona is by far greater and you all heard her song bleeding love was the biggest love song hit. She had opera training and learned on her own to do different things with her voice. I have never heard Kelly Clarkson go anywhere NEAR that note Leona hit at the end on the word me. If you watch her perform infront of the REAL judges on xfactor they told her she owns it.

  • I live in US too Leona miles better

  • Her voice is so pure, young and melodic she can sing anything and it sounds beautiful.

  • Leona is so much better listen to the finale live version of both kelly forced growls those are suppose to come out naturally and she sounded like a sheep using her vibrato Leona can talk and it would sound amazing she was just born to sound amazing

  • @bigdaddyfranchise haha.. clearly you dont kno about music.. leona is a good singer.. about kelly's vibrato.. it was fast and well defined.. the tremolous switching of pitches notes and semi tones in kelly's vibrato is just perfect.. her vibrato is one of the best ever next to whitney, aretha, patti, toni braxton.. leona's vibrato is slow and wavy.. lmfao

  • @bigdaddyfranchise Powerful voices are better than trying to be like a Mariah Carrie We have to many people that try to do that soft tone thats beautiful. But for songs like this, its about expressing about how much you want it, a song like this is about passion and seeking something, not about singing it like its some kind of pop ballad. Kellys is better cause she showed it all. She did high low, soft and everything. If you want a moment you show all emotions. Leona stuck to just one.

  • leona sang better... i love her voice...i think she's better than kelly... **my opinio** ^^

  • i love u

  • ~$@1432

  • She looks like a lion...nice voice tho

  • i lik kelly klarksons version better

  • Does anyone know where I can download Leon"s version for my iPod. I feel that Leona has better diction than kelly, although both ladies are outstanding.

  • what is happening in the black and white outside when she sings for simon and that women and then hugs him?

  • I wish they wouldn't have carbon copied Kelly's video though. Oh well, both are great singers,

  • ahhh.♥ i love this song!

  • original is always the best therefore kelly's is the best.

    leona lewis has a beautiful voice too. (:

  • I love this version of the song and another good song by Leona Lewis is My Hands if you havent heard it you should seach it now. I <3 Leona Lewis

  • this video is a rip off of kelly's from back in '02. kelly's is and will always be the best version!

  • Did you see her reaction when she won X factor. That must be the best feeling on her life. I defently think she is one of the most beautful voices I've ever heard.

  • i got tears just watching her singing this. :'(( she was awesome!!!!

  • y dey make tha video like kellys tho????

  • i think leona has one of the best voices ive ever heard

  • I strongly believe that Leona has an exceptionally beautiful voice. I feel she is a more talented than Kelly Clarkson because she has stronger vocals and a wider range.

  • you know I think both ladies sang it beautifully and frankly each of their versions is unique and amazing in their own ways so who really cares either way... I truly love both versions

  • Leona's Beautiful!

  • I LOVE KELLY'S BUT DIS VERSOIN IS BETTER

  • Leona sings this song so much better

  • you know guys, ilike this version much better than kellys clarkson, thoug kelly has much stronger voice, but leonas voice is softer

  • i hate that people compare them they are all good obviously if they are famous kelly and leona sang it good

  • Comment removed

  • People who say Kelly is better are deaf and blind.

  • I love leona lewis, i voted for her ;)

  • @EmilynJosie you're so lucky!!! I wish I could have voted for her ='(

  • she's good but she'll never can replace kelly clarkson !

  • leona has a higher key

  • higher key

  • I love Leona's music, her songs like Bleeding Love and My Hands, helped inspire me to write my poem "Glass Houses," I made a clay animation video for the poem. It would be great it you'd let me know what you think :)

  • Kelly's is better.

  • ปั๋มร้องเพราะกว่า 55

  • hmpf kelly is better

  • Thumbs up if you dropped a tear watching this.

  • I love this song so much. And If I ever audition for like X factor or something, I have to sing this song cause I love it SO Much

  • OH CMON.. anybody with half an ear knows Leona's version is WAAAAY better than kelly's, im sorry kelly fans. its the truth. ask any professional vocal coach, they'll tell you leona is better.

  • @hihello121 the kelly's version it's s much cool and enrgic and all kelly is amazing our voice is awesome and kelly¡s sing with more feeling and soul so more pure

    it's my opinion sorry leona fans , people prefer kelly clarkson...

  • Check out my 'Moment Like This' vid - very haunting!

  • I sung this if u look at my vids

  • they both r realli good... they both have a good voice different from each otha

  • much better than kelly clarkson

  • her song is very soft........very comfortable...but kelly clarkson more powerful

    is a different ~~~

  • Her version is good but i must say kelly's better

  • Leona sounds a lil thin.Kelly has more soul and emotion in her singing.Leona hits the notes but thats about it.No power,No soul.Mariah clone for sure...though Mariah place way more emotion and soul in her singing than Leona

  • this video is messed up

  • i like Leoan"s version much much better, i think she is the perfect one on this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Kelly cannot be compared to Leona. It's an accepted fact.  But then, why compare a sapphire and a diamond when both are great gems?

    And please re-upload this video, the middle part is botched.

  • I love kelly better, she doesn't do the high thing at the end, but just goes soft and just kills you.

  • i lyk this version better than kelly's one :P

  • I think Kelly's version is so much better that Leona's.

  • Were having this at our wedding for the first dance.x

  • Her voice is very beautiful, but i think she should have been a little more intense with this song

  • Kelly and Leona are both amazing singers. Both can hit the high notes when they want.

  • imo this ones better then kellys, she got a good voice but she copys Mariah wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy to much

  • leona's version is amazing...the way she sings it gives it more meanin and makes it soo much more touchin and gives me gooze bumps...kelly's version iz great but she sings it with more of a vigor and rage and dat kind of doesn't give that gooze bumpy feeling....

  • i luv both versions of the song. Both Kelly and Leona did a great job singing this.

  • Leona's voice is better for this song because it's soothing to listen to and very angelic. Did you hear the falsetto in the end?

  • i think Kelly's version is better...but i still like this video

  • Wow is all I can say. She made it her song with the ending!

  • Kelly clarkson did a way better job than Leona Lewis.it didn't fit leona's voice in my opinion.but they are both great singers

  • there bolth even good as well

    it is just the differend people

    every person has a diffrend sound

    so is kelly clarkson and leona lewis

    there bolth verry good!

  • Leona's version is much better (if you don't agree, don't reply)

  • i like leona lewis better cause at the end shes got a stronge voice

  • Kelly Clarkson sing's it a lot BETTER.

    In my opinion :D

    But Leona does it well too

  • Wow, so I'm having Kelly Clarkson-related de ja vu, right now...

  • I just got finished listening from listening to Kelly Clarkson's version to only find listeners compare two caliber singers... Has anyone considered that Kelly Clarkson had a sharper tune to the music video? How about the random skips to Leona Lewis? Why compare them at all!? That's just as disrespectful as comparing classics! Seriously... (Next is sarcastic) That is like having the American Idol judge reject every single auditions. Isn't there a difference from De original singer to auditioner

  • This version is a little easier on the ears for me. Her voice is just smoother. It could be the editing, but when comparing the two music videos, I prefer this one.

  • you people are only saying Kelly is better because Leona is English !

  • @MercedesColexx No we are not. But the truth is, Leona IS better. Kelly is awesome though. But, you gotta' stand up for your country!

  • @MercedesColexx and since when (besides the Revolutionary War) do Americans hate the Brits?

  • @MercedesColexx

    If you actually compare the two together Kelly sang this song better, but Leona is a better singer than Kelly.

  • @MercedesColexx Ummmmm No.I live in the united states and i could care less where there from.I love Kellys Version But Leona's Voice is just Amazing and in my opinion Leonas version is better but thats my opinion.

  • @MercedesColexx No people are saying its better because it actually is better. Kelly did it before Leona did. You cant give more good credit to the 2nd person who sang it more than the first. The first person who sings anything is usually the one who is better. And also Kelly puts out way more music then Leona does. And dont say people dont like Leona cause shes not English cause look at Jennifer Lopez or Shakeria, not originally English but popular as hell.

  • @MercedesColexx Both are amazing! Probably they like Kelly better like me just cuz she is our favorite singer. Leona Lewis is my dad's favorite singer and he thinks this is better. It's just a difference of opinion as both the versions are different and their style (unique). They are both amazing! :D

  • she´s perfect!

  • It's the same music video as Kelly!!! But I like the two versions even if Kelly's one was so much better!! shycrewjesusfreak said all I wanted to say!! :D

  • Love Leona but Kelly's version is flawless!

  • leonas is better !

  • @TiannaTorrae defoo!

  • NEXT VID: A moment like this - Kelly Clarkson

  • Kelly's better

  • This is a beautiful song..... it made me cry :'( I wish I will have a moment like her in my life :'(

  • very good BUT kelly is better :)

  • all of u will say differently if this is sang by leona first. ppl always felt original sounds better. and whats the point comparing? kelly and leona's hv different style of singing

  • mn mooie nummer,,

    beste ontmoetingsnummer

  • Comment removed

  • @Alexza0 what are you talkin about? Kelly's version isn't the original.

  • @firestrix10 i can assure you that kelly's version is THE original! Kelly sang it the first time in American Idol and at this moment Leona wasn't famous at all

  • leona can definetly sing, it doesn't hurt one to admit the OBVIOUS, the prideful would only deny such, but however Kelly's version is definetly lol more superior to leona's. kelly just smoked leona on this. It is clarkson's song anyway. Its obvious who is better, but at the same time it depends on your own personal taste in music. Kelly clarkson just brings the song home in a way that is american. Leona is more high and diva-ish. Kelly clearly has my vote on this.

  • I personally like both versions of this song her && kelly's its makes me wanna cry everytime ii hear it! !<3

  • i think kelly's version was better

  • Kelly did it better, but Leona is amazing, but thank god she changed her hair style.

  • Is this really official video? So they didn't even bother trying to do anything different with the video from Kelly's version?

  • I would say that the main difference when they sing this song is that kelly sounds to have way more passion when she sings it... I love both, but i prefer Kelly version

  • Kellys version is SO much better.

  • Para los angeles bellos que me acompañan a lo largo de esta vida hermosa, mía...

    A mi nena preciosa, a quien adoro con todo mi ser, con todas mis fuerzas y por quien me mantengo Viviendo un Cielo en la Tierra...

    Los adoro "A moment like this"...

    *SRD*

  • I like Kelly's more cus she was more emotional and just herself that song fits her a little but better. But don't get me wrong Leona can blow. :)

  • i agree even though i like leona for me kelly got the better version

  • This song is wonderful,No wonder everyone's singin' it.

  • i love kellys better i love her version better it just seems more uuuuhhh how do i put it a original?? ya original

  • Beautiful, love this version as well, I think she sings this very emotinal, and I think that Kelly doesn't do that, thats what I like about Leona singing this song

  • @222Smiley222 in my opinion you're wrong! sorry, but it's the opposite kelly has a more powerful voice and puts so much more passion and emotion and heart and soul when she sings. I don't say that Leona is bad, no, but she doesn't have a thing who really make the difference she try too hard to make like Mariah Carey for exemple , she's not herself and i hate that about her

  • kelly do sing this song better

  • I HAVE TO GIVE HER AND KELLY BOTH TEN STARS FOR THIS SONG, I LOVE THIS SONG IT MAKES SOMETHING INSIDE ME FEEL LIKE CRYING EVERY TIME I HEAR IT. THEY BOTH DID EXCELLENT JOBS WITH THE VOCALS AND THEY ARE BOTH OUR AMERICAN IDOLS SO GREAT JOB GIRLS LOVE YA! BUT I THINK KELLY'S WAS THE ORIGINAL ONE!

  • ive got my eye's mre on kelly

  • who wrote this song??

    leona or kelly??

    srry

    just wondering

  • @bythen123 this song was wrote for Kelly Clarkson during American Idol Finale....she originally sung it.

  • @bythen123 ADAMDASHAWN IS RIGHT THIS IS ORIGINALLY KELLY'S SONG AND NOT TO MENTION SHE WAS ONE OF OUR FIRST IDOLS TO TAKE HOME THE CROWN NO ONE WILL EVER TOUCH HER OR OUT SHINE THAT HONOR, BUT LEONA DID HER THANG TOO THOUGH.

  • dear god shoot me now this song is terrible with leona. this is kellys song

  • The live versions are very different from the commercial release! Live, Leona sings it amazing but her recording falls short! On the other hand both live and recordings of Kelly's version are amazing!! Leona's E vowel sounds so weird!

  • kelly who ha ha ha ha ha haha ha ha ha ha ah ah aha ha ha h ah aha ha!!!!! u people dreaming or wat?

  • Leona is the best!!!! She has amazing charisma!! LEONA!

  • KELL DOES IT HEAPS BETTER 100%

  • Leona in the better, 100 % Leona, Leona, Leona, Leona has magical voice..!!!

  • what a nice song, i think leona deserves to be where she is today!

  • She sings this beautifully :)

  • KC sings it better.

  • @TRISAND I agree, Kelly puts a little more emotion behind her version

  • LOVE that note at 3:00

    AMAZING everytime i hear it

  • @3M1LYx6 agreed !!! :)

  • Eargasm...WHO"S WITH ME.

  • kellys version is from far better , leona can't hold good higher notes

  • In this video she looks like she's in the same place Michael Jackson did his "You Are Not Alone" video. What is that place??

  • @babygurll7 I think it is the same place!!

  • Kelly is way better,im not saying that Leona cant sing,but Kellys version is way better.

  • what happened to the quality lol and beautiful song iswell.. :)

  • love!!!!!!

  • so sweet she is wow 

  • words are useless...the song is just brilliant..

  • Both versions are very good and cannot and should not be preferred over one another. Both singers are very talented.

  • Her voice and beauty are STUNNING !

  • leona's amazing 

  • @simspugslover Kelly's good in a Rock sense but Whitney, Mariah, Celine Dion are WAY more polished all around. Just my two Paise!

  • @jimmyjohnson691 her voice is amazing though remember Susan Boyle?

  • @jimmyjohnson691  Until you become famous and well loved by millions, shut your Goddamn mouth, Asshole.

  • I dunno, both Kelly and Leona are decent singers but neither has the power, body of voice like Whitney or Mariah.

  • I just lover her voice. It's so peaceful and serene.

  • hah!? Kelly is more powerful than Leona? Hey!!! Go check out the longest note that Leona can make compare with Kelly. And try also check out the highest note of leona and how long she maintain the range in her voice. Leona is much more better.

  • I think this version is an epic fail comparing to Kelly's and I am not a fun of Kelly's either.

  • I think this copies Kelly's video way too much.

  • @MemphisGal94 What do you mean? This is the original version. It was released way before kelly clarkson's

  • @MemphisGal94 do your research this one copies kelly lol

  • i love you leona !!

  • i think Kelly's cover is better. just because her voice is a little deeper, wich fits the song better. also Kelly's voice is more powerful as Leona. Don't get me wrong, Leona is a wonderful singer, but has a different kind of voice, wich doesn't fit the song very well.

  • This song was written for the winner of AI that year Kelly won, so she didnt wrote it.

  • Comment removed

  • Sorry but, the original one its the best :)

  • I love this version as well as Kelly. This one is a little bit softer. Kelly's is a little more stronger. I love both!

  • I like kelly's version better!

  • she was on American idol, too?

  • @missey3455

    She is the winner of The X Factor music competition, from UK.

  • i think kellys version is more dramatic, emotional

  • i think kelly's version is better

  • @amb666wicked i think the same no one can do this song like kelly

  • @amb666wicked I agree

  • @amb666wicked FUCK OFF KID WHY U LISTNEIN TO THIS THAN NO1 CAN DO THIS LIKE HOW SHE DID IT AGAIN

  • ryyyser när jag ser videon.