I've heard this studio version a couple times, but I never really noticed how it's different than the live version. If I remember correctly on the live version Jeff says its not finished, so its cool to hear it this way.
Does anyone know if this was recorded recently or back in the 90's?
@DairyKing21 I was there Friday and Saturday! Found that very interesting, personally. What great shows. This song is so haunting it's hard to believe.
@stittdude Yeah, he said something like "this is the second song that fucked me up". Along those lines, at least. Incredibly cryptic, but he wasn't as cryptic as I expected him to be.
@NotoriusPUP Totally. I had never even heard of this guy but my friend wanted someone to go to the concert with, and fortunately, I was free Wednesday.
I have been alive now for 50 years and have heard a lot of music, this is truly a gem that I will cherish forever, I just wish there were a little more of this music available today. Most music today, and I use the term "music" loosely, just has no soul like this does.
This is honestly the best song I have ever heard.
So this is what Jeff has been doing for 13 years?! Releasing a NMH vinyl boxset and announcing some solo shows world-wide! Best songwriter of our times, hands down.
i think he doesnt like to play this song to often b/c he feels it offends some people and is a bit to "deep" for some he used to be very self concious about his work
this is jeffs song not yours so if you have oppinions its fine to voice them but dont belittle this beautiful work of art for being anyway different than it has been experienced in the past.
I never thought I'd say this, but the old live version actually sounds quite a bit better. The vocals aren't as strong, but the old live version sounded quite a bit more unhinged and unsettling.
i had no idea this version existed. you guys can't imagine how excited i am to find this. i don't say this a lot. well, i never say this. BUT THANK YOU FOR UPLOADING.
Oh god. I just stumbled on this inadvertantly when looking for Oh Sister. Can't believe he did studio versions of so many songs only available as bootlegs previously. Life: fulfilled.
@Lennonandcobain4life its easily my one of my favorite songs of all time haha. /watch?v=HIavGD36vtg this is the only other recorded version its incredible!
I was there for it! Nobody could ever ask for a better show. If you were there, you know how it felt. There was such a communal thing happening. I've never felt so at one with a group of people in my life. I guess he just has that effect on people.
Amazing song. I've loved the live recording for the longest time and this is fantastic too. Can't wait to see him on the 29th of this month, and then again on Nov 6th!
I've heard this studio version a couple times, but I never really noticed how it's different than the live version. If I remember correctly on the live version Jeff says its not finished, so its cool to hear it this way.
Does anyone know if this was recorded recently or back in the 90's?
modernsketches 14 hours ago
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bitchesNhoz 4 days ago
*click repeat* DEE DEE DEEE DEE DEE DEE...
Sorrowisapanther 1 week ago 2
i want to get that picture tattooed....
TheLove7391 1 week ago
this song is so fucked i love it
booshisgay 1 week ago
That was absolutely gorgeous.
About4Ducks 1 week ago
i want a tattoo of those birds.
ThisIsPapu 1 week ago
Last night in Athens, Jeff said this was the last song he wrote before he fell into "a black hole of really crazy shit."
DairyKing21 2 weeks ago 7
@DairyKing21 I was there Friday and Saturday! Found that very interesting, personally. What great shows. This song is so haunting it's hard to believe.
nrvfly4 2 weeks ago
1/27/12 Washington D.C. Lincoln Theatre, "This is the song that fucked me up." - Jeff Mangum
Me too, Jeff. Me too.
RadioactiveHardcore 2 weeks ago 4
I saw Jeff in Minneapolis and he said he had a hard time with this song.
InfiniteHoliday 2 weeks ago
He played this Saturday night in Minneapolis. It's haunted me for two whole days. He sounds better live too, which was something I didn't expect.
ziggens66 2 weeks ago 5
SHIT YES
shitgeek 3 weeks ago
Wonder what the first song that fucked him up was.
UtBDan 3 weeks ago
He played this 1/27 in DC and, if I heard him correctly, introduced it by saying "This is the song that f-ed me up"
stittdude 3 weeks ago
@stittdude Yeah, he said something like "this is the second song that fucked me up". Along those lines, at least. Incredibly cryptic, but he wasn't as cryptic as I expected him to be.
jonnysan0002 3 weeks ago
saw jeff tonight in dc, he played this song..... i'm still speechless
sophieelyse2 4 weeks ago
ME TOO!
desperado18t 4 weeks ago
saw him play twice at BAM in brooklyn this weekend - he played this on saturday and i cried my eyes out.
melkicia 1 month ago 2
@melkicia Yes I saw Jeff at BAM too. He played this during his Thursday set as well. He is so amazing live. I got chills during "Oh Comely."
tlb138 1 month ago 2
@melkicia I was there too and it a huge shock he played this and i couldn't believe i was actually there.
Passionoverlust 3 weeks ago
So happy he played this last night at the Shubert
BabySnakesMusic 1 month ago 5
@BabySnakesMusic Such an amazing show
NotoriusPUP 1 month ago
@NotoriusPUP Totally. I had never even heard of this guy but my friend wanted someone to go to the concert with, and fortunately, I was free Wednesday.
campcampingston1 1 month ago
Played it last night in New Haven. Amazing.
MerryPicnic 1 month ago 2
Conor Oberst reminds me a lot of Jeff Magnum.
16mockingbirds 1 month ago
@16mockingbirds WHAT THE FUCK
Circusbreaker 1 month ago
who the hell disliked this video?? amazing song..amazing Jeff!!
NarrowMinded00 1 month ago
This is such a sad and emotional song it's so beautiful
alotofcheese76 1 month ago
I can't believe there's finally a studio version of this. Probably my favorite song by Jeff.
guilhermebaldin 1 month ago
The Bob Marley song wold be three little birds....amazing to hear this as a studio version
DjSublimeslacker 1 month ago
I LOVE THE WAY YOU GO DEEDEEEDEE MOTHER FUCKER KILL ME!
CoqueSpoke 2 months ago
I have been alive now for 50 years and have heard a lot of music, this is truly a gem that I will cherish forever, I just wish there were a little more of this music available today. Most music today, and I use the term "music" loosely, just has no soul like this does.
brwhyon 2 months ago
This is honestly the best song I have ever heard.
So this is what Jeff has been doing for 13 years?! Releasing a NMH vinyl boxset and announcing some solo shows world-wide! Best songwriter of our times, hands down.
ausmariner1 2 months ago 3
@ausmariner1 No.
Clerks0 2 months ago
i think he doesnt like to play this song to often b/c he feels it offends some people and is a bit to "deep" for some he used to be very self concious about his work
kill0ggs 2 months ago
this is jeffs song not yours so if you have oppinions its fine to voice them but dont belittle this beautiful work of art for being anyway different than it has been experienced in the past.
kill0ggs 2 months ago
@AlphaNerd3 i know :)
i don't listen to it often, can't go through it w/out getting all choked up
Fatzers 2 months ago 3
one of my fave songs, otherworldy
Fatzers 2 months ago
Is this an Angry Birds cover?
LepyThedino 2 months ago
um. omg. this is great.
makeitchemical 2 months ago 2
I never thought I'd say this, but the old live version actually sounds quite a bit better. The vocals aren't as strong, but the old live version sounded quite a bit more unhinged and unsettling.
Saraphiel 2 months ago
@Saraphiel i'm sure future live versions will be as awesome as that old one :) but yeah i agree the old recording sounds positively uncanny
Fatzers 2 months ago
Comment removed
AlphaNerd3 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is this a Bob Marley cover?
the4horseman 2 months ago
@the4horseman No.
GivepeaceachanceJL 2 months ago 50
what
fateater77777 2 months ago
@the4horseman lololololololololololololololllloloooooooolllolololololololololoololololololoooolllll..................no
TheJaredsb 2 months ago
@the4horseman LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL.
AlkaseltzerAdventure 1 month ago
Life Meaning +3
SuperduckyHoR 3 months ago
i had no idea this version existed. you guys can't imagine how excited i am to find this. i don't say this a lot. well, i never say this. BUT THANK YOU FOR UPLOADING.
NASTY138 3 months ago 2
Yes! Waiting for this for ages
mrmagpie21 3 months ago
Fuck that one guy.
Clawlyn 3 months ago
Brb Freaking the fuck out.
MaddGiraffes 3 months ago 12
@littlebenevolent agreed, there's something darker and more urgent on the live version...
ryansling 3 months ago
Holy shit. This exists now. I am so floored by this idea. There goes any sleep I was going to get tonight.
pitchfork70 4 months ago 2
I have so many chills right now
miniraptorX 4 months ago 2
Oh god. I just stumbled on this inadvertantly when looking for Oh Sister. Can't believe he did studio versions of so many songs only available as bootlegs previously. Life: fulfilled.
beckonthepaining 4 months ago 3
So is there a listen of songs that were streaming? Or the ones that have been pulled from streaming?
CosmosOfBeauty 4 months ago
live version is so much better
littlebenevolent 4 months ago
Holy wow.
DatDynamiteKyle 4 months ago
Comment removed
DatDynamiteKyle 4 months ago
Jeff played this live for the first time in 13 years last night (second time ever) in Asbury Park.
MrJackscoldsweat 4 months ago 47
@MrJackscoldsweat Amazing night- except for the security pricks, it was magical
ericeskola 4 months ago
@MrJackscoldsweat played it the third time by my request last night in Jersey City. incredible
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago 3
@TendingToTheCorpses I saw him tonight in Jersey City, I'd never heard this song before and it's amazing. Best show of my life.
sk8r4l1fe101 3 months ago 2
@sk8r4l1fe101 sooo incredible! i met him saturday when i was there. he drew me a picture :D
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago
@TendingToTheCorpses Thank you so much for requesting this Saturday. I literally felt my life changing.
Lennonandcobain4life 3 months ago
@Lennonandcobain4life no problem bro! i had to, my favorite song! him playing it was the most incredible thing ever!
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago
@TendingToTheCorpses It really was. I had never heard it before and I was like... gone
Lennonandcobain4life 3 months ago
@Lennonandcobain4life its easily my one of my favorite songs of all time haha. /watch?v=HIavGD36vtg this is the only other recorded version its incredible!
TendingToTheCorpses 3 months ago
@MrJackscoldsweat my friend was the one who requested that shit lol
megad3thmachine 3 months ago
@megad3thmachine
haha my buddy jake did the same thing at loews theater. it was one of the best performances i have ever seen
mopman1337 3 months ago
@mopman1337 im jake...;)
jaaakkke 2 months ago
@mopman1337 i remember that
TendingToTheCorpses 2 months ago
@MrJackscoldsweat
I was there for it! Nobody could ever ask for a better show. If you were there, you know how it felt. There was such a communal thing happening. I've never felt so at one with a group of people in my life. I guess he just has that effect on people.
Thanks, Jeff. You're Brilliant.
mussman717word 1 month ago
@mussman717word Agreed, his shows are defnitely something special.
MrJackscoldsweat 1 month ago
@mussman717word I loved how everyone sang with him and it was just peaceful there.
zboi94 1 month ago
@MrJackscoldsweat I was there for that it was amazing.
zboi94 1 month ago
Amazing song. I've loved the live recording for the longest time and this is fantastic too. Can't wait to see him on the 29th of this month, and then again on Nov 6th!
deadphish09 4 months ago
Oh my fucking god is this real.
Assy8D 4 months ago 5
Thanks @GivepeaceachanceJL ! Was having trouble with the streaming copy on their website
KobraCola 4 months ago 2
Fuck my asshole yes
jonahharper 5 months ago 80
Freaking AWESOME
frannyk100 5 months ago 4
So this is what Jeff has been working on for the last 12 years!
FiveYearPayoff 5 months ago 6