Added: 2 years ago
From: coolmj308
Views: 199,240
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (87)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The O.C <3

    

  • I dont get why it couldnt be a love song....

  • My boyfriend sang and played this song on his guitar for me. It gave me chills. I love him so much <3

  • i like it.

  • music is meant to be interpreted by each person differently

  • this is me and my ex boyfriends song, we were together for 2 years. i just took the courage now to listen to it since we separated, and it brought back so many memories. josh, if you're reading this, i love you.

  • I am not even slightly religous and this is like on of the best songs Ive ever heard. His voice gives me chills. Love sufjan

  • People are turds, don't even worry about it. Thanks for posting!

  • @xLordOfTheFliesx This isn't a love song? I thought it was about Jesus and how he had an intimate experience alone with Jesus. He's saying he'd give anything to do that again, to be alone with him again. How is that not love?

  • "you gave your *goals*" should be "you gave your *ghost*", or am I wrong?

  • <3 couldn't have said it better myself, sufjan

  • It's "you gave your ghost"...not goals.

  • Good job! and keep it going

  • This is sweet - thank you for sharing. I hope no one gave negative comments - you put yourself out there. Thank you!

  • Can anyone explain this song for me ???

  • @PDeepIn It's a song to God/Jesus. It's an expression of Sufjan's love for God and appreciation of God's sacrifice. HOWEVER, you can interpret it however you want. Sufjan's spirituality inspires some of his music, but he says his music is not the place for his religion, and what it may mean to him is different from what it may mean to someone else.

  • @fabulapowers Thank's a lot ^_^...<3

  • It's Should be a love song : (

  • @PDeepIn It is a love song! Just not between two people, but a man, or woman and their relationship with God. It's really beautiful when you think about it.

  • Why isn't this song longer?! ://

  • aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah :D THIS IS THE SONG I'VE LOOKED FOR 2 YEARS!

    and now I watched the older episodes of the oc and they played it there!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Everyone should be allowed to interpret the song for themselves so they can enjoy it too.

    :D

  • This song is a meditation on Jesus, guys, not a romantic song about a woman. I'm not even Christian and it's totally apparent to me what this song is about. Read the lyrics.

  • @soyarra wow, im a christian and here I am thinking sufjann stevens is gay ._.

  • @soyarra You can interpret music to mean a variety of different things. While it is clear that Sufjan himself is writing this song to God, someone may interpret the lyrics to have the meaning of a significant other or even something more abstract, such as peace of mind or even death. Music, especially broad and symbolic such as Sufjan's, rarely just means one universal thing.

  • @xLordOfTheFliesx I just put random pictures to it. I just put it on here to have it on youtube not being sung live. and I know it's not a love song, but it could be.

  • @coolmj308 a love song between man and god, nothing other than that

  • Comment removed

  • @PDeepIn

    No. It's about Jesus. "You gave your body to the lonely. They took your clothes. You gave up a wife and a family. You gave your ghost/host." Not a romance song. It's a religious song on a religious album.

  • @xLordOfTheFliesx No, it isn't a romance song, but it's a love song nonetheless.

  • @TheAqua200

    Agreed. I just find the pictures ummmmmmm silly. and misleading.

  • @xLordOfTheFliesx Haha, agreed. A little bit misleading.

  • i'm agnostic but still find this song amazing. everyone can relate to it on some level (maybe not in the way that sufjan intended it to mean but). if anyone can check my cover on my page that'd be awesome

  • It's a christian song but ultimately very human

  • My fave sexy yoga teacher played this at the end of class one day... ahh brings back memories... shes so great

  • I've only ever heard the live version which I really like. I think I almost like it better because it feels more mellow. This is nice too, though. Thanks for sharing.

  • IS HE FUCKING CHRISTIAN

  • @maryandtaylor1 yep. and this song's about Jesus.

  • @maryandtaylor1 yep. and this song's about Jesus.

  • @maryandtaylor1 Yeah. But although I'm somewhat "anti-christian", if you will, I still love his music. Although we have conflicting view points on spirituality and such, you can't discount the fact that he write beautiful and amazing music. Get over it, my friend. We don't all agree on everything, but music can bring us together.

  • i was thinking about love,too bad it's actually not about it :(

    great song

  • @watarball it is about love. gods love. at least thats what i think

  • whats the song called that says where have your balls gone i think about it now

  • I. Love. This. Song.

    So simple, yet so touching.

  • Comment removed

  • nice song (pretty much an UFO in your musical taste, considering the bands you mention on your channel) and treee kool visual illustrations... Peace !

  • I'd give my body to be back again in the rest of the room, to be alone with you...

    Ahhhhh....<3

  • I'm not religious, but this song's still pretty awesome.

    When I first heard it, I was like, "gay much?" Not that it would matter to me, haha.

  • I love this song!

  • I remember listening to this song at the dead of night with my head pressed into the pillow... in complete darkness, I cried so hard.

  • sufjan wasn't gay...

    this song is about his dad, who hasn't seen in years. Watch the movie 'Crooked River' and you'd understand.

  • @iphicrates123 It's actually about jesus, so more like his dad that art in heaven.

  • God bless Sufjan for writing this. And for the truth that is Jesus Christ lifted high in this song.

  • is this about jesus?

  • @ixeatxbabiesxlol yes, yes it is :)

  • @ixeatxbabiesxlol i don't think so, jesus wasnt married ("you gave up a wife and family to be alone with me") a least in the bible it's never mentioned. i think he might be gay.

    *don't hate me, i love this song and Sufjan*

  • @tegsandsara09 Whether or not Jesus was married is up for debate, so try not to speak so certainly about such things.

  • @tegsandsara09 Whether or not Jesus was married is up for debate, so try not to speak so certainly about those kinds of things.

  • @tegsandsara09 I think what Sufjian meant was that Jesus gave up the chance to be married. So he gave up having a wife and children so that he could devote everything to humanity.

  • @lnrdspns i didn't think of it that way, that's so true :)

  • this is a great song i play it all the time..il seeif i can out a cover of it up soon me my frind like to sing it

  • beautiful

  • Great video, beautiful video.

    Word of advice though, in your video description it's better to put "DISCLAIMER" than "NOTE" I got told off for that once on one of my videos, youtube deleted the audio track to five of my videos that hate "PLEASE NOTE" etc. After I wrote disclaimer and appealed against the removal of the audio track with a fair statement they put it back (: it would save you the hassle.

  • @HeartBreakKidxX thanks for the info :)

  • Sweet video! This song is so beautifull...

  • Love the song..thanks for posting!!

  • awesome video. awesome song.

  • aw this isn't bad don't worry it's really really lovely, good job and thank you for posting (",)

  • Tres Bien!

  • i love this sonq

    thank you so much

  • thank u! finally someone did it!!!!!!!!

  • Thank you! I like this song so much!!!!! It reminds me of my best friend.

  • thankyou for putting this up :)

  • Thank you! I've been looking for this

  • Thank so much for putting this video up! I'd been looking for a non-live version. Such a beautiful song...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more