blue roses - "doubtful comforts" (first 3D camera-shift musicvideo!)

[jejesus]

This beautiful song deserves a good video, no this...

[deyblack9d]

+ -

[heyguitarra]

quiero que alguien me devuelva mis 3 minutos de vida perdidos

[agutolo]

@heyguitarra no podes ser tan down de quedarte los 3 minutos del video viendolo yo solo vi 16 seg

[smitty010493]

i really dig the kalimba

[PS3Gamer360mike]

yea weeds :D

[mikeypimp50]

every strain of weed has a perfect song to listen to on it, i got to say, this is indoor chronic music <3

[trintyprince]

Like if Weeds brought you here...:)

[buffy1445]

Weeds :)

[mermayd37]

how can u dislike this? i think this is one of the most beautiful songs ive ever heard

[scrapriot]

2:34 awesome! good job.

[richievegas01]

Brilliant song. Check out all-girl psychedelic group Stealing Sheep, their pastoral tunes are similar to Blue Roses'. youtube.com/watch?v=WIvFzQjDB0­U&feature=related

[df1phantom]

I LOOOVEEE THIS SONG !!

[skateflip977]

well holy shit that creeped my the f*ck out!

[kidcassidy07]

i love this song and video!!

[DarkBabyIon]

It actually does kinda work, but not enough light for this effect to have full efficiency.

[melissadini]

the video was a lil' bit creepy. or much?

but....what a wonderful voice <3

[erliann]

@melissadini i got another reason to have some nightmares tonight :O

[mirenk34]

please come to indonesia

[Immitter]

Love the Singers Voice! What's Her name? Beautiful song.

[StickssStones]

@Immitter Laura Groves aka Blue Roses

[pwnedmedia]

Damn yall didnt even pickup the artistic value of this video..

Like really.. do you think that your busted ass computer monitor will ever get 3d..

cmon now.

[AwesomeHaHaAnime]

so beautiful

[patronerosegueton]

Yo no veo una puta mierda en 3d

[ploszynski2]

Teledyski w 3D ")

[CubOfJudahsLion]

They tried this back thirty-something years ago, along with several other "3d tv" experiments. It didn't work then, and I'm pretty sure it's not going to be boom now.

[Calidino]

very nice! unique!

/editor

[rnewman]

three minutes of shaking video is a FAIL.

[lapislawliet]

Who filmed this has Parkinson's Disease

[mimimoomoo1]

@lapislawliet GET A LIFE, FAGBAG

[christianesramos]

@lapislawliet Filmed by Michael J. Fox !!!!!!

[giantcandy]

awesome vid but the 3d effect is lost because of th e darkness....but still...this vid rocks

[kidcouger]

framrate needs to be higher which will make it look faster giving it a real 3d effect

[HaneruQi]

An artful execution of a really nice idea. Can't quite figure out how it was shot, or what it exactly *means*. Is that a hazard symbol? Is it all cautionary tale about being too wired? :p

Anyway, very cool.

78UNKNOWN - 'tripling the frame rates' - that would negate the effect, I think? I'm curious about the hi/lo limits of the effect, myself - is this at 5 'frames' / sec?

stefanoazevedo: provenance. Those 2 vids were flickery, but neither had the same effect nor intent - be honest :)

[EoqueE]

i don´t see cleary the effect... 

[derek19062]

I only saw some "shaking" pictures but anyway, if you think it 3D, it would be 3D.

And also, I knew this video from a magazine from HK.

Some suggestion:

If it's brighter, it would be more "3D" and the frame speed should faster.

[pwnedmedia]

you guys posting comments hating on these peoples work are ridiculous.

i would like to see your ass do a ten second video to try to match the editing quality these people posses.

Good work- Pwnedmedia

[BlankoGatillo]

doesn't work =(

[louislouislouis2001]

This effect is well in static images, but moving video at all is achieved the desired effect. Does anyone know if they have the video also anaglyph mode, to view with typical gajas blue and red or green and red? Even with the method of crossing the eyes would have been much better. This is not an video in 3D. What a waste, be able to shoot in 3D with two cameras, and desaprobecharla well.

[BestM8ts12]

borin and not 3d

[Chessyfan]

@BestM8ts12 if you dont like it dont watch it

[NerdyNatalieSD]

cool! I liked it

[trogemp2]

Looking past people's judgement of whether or not they properly did the 3D camera shift, this is still an amazingly beautiful and eerie song, and the video itself plays up both of those elements. I'm surprised I haven't seen more feedback that doesn't just comment on the 3D nature of the video.

[sickofwaitingtables]

@trogemp2

I agree, this is a great music video to a great song!

[AMADEU852]

#OMG

[Troscoman]

You're doing it wrong!

[haynakaw999]

This thing works great on images but kind of very subtle on videos.

Just google "3d wiggle images" and youll see tons of 3d wiggle gifs.

[RedPillLondon]

Some piece, this!!

[pedrogremioo]

tenso

[amielgaga]

how this thing work?

[onetwonine2]

Stupid. It just looks like the left eye view, then the right eye view back and forth and I see no depth. It's like camera #1, then camera #2 over and over. Maybe it's for slow people... 3d stereoscopy isn't about moving from one view point to the other, but seeing both views to each eye simultaneously. Some 3d systems mimick this with super high frame rates. But this isn't going to cut it.

[TasamiOkami]

I don't see it at all.

Really just a gimmick to get more attentions and views.

[mattattack418]

Well, they tried anyway.

[knyaz187]

a girl from Poland, which gave me a link to this clip. Write me. a guy from Russia

[osmala]

hummmmm don't like it... it's annoying too. #FAIL

[TheKaspall]

OMG, it's sooo 3D  =DDDDD

[Flyleafroxxsmysoxxs]

sweetness

[thiagodantas]

Please, someone tells me when the 3D part starts... It's indeed a cool effect, but a way too much calling it "3D".

[rafaeljardimcine]

FAIL!!! But the song is good.

[outcasted77]

where's the 3D part!!!???

[MeisterFalti]

At least I don't get a headache. So by that standart this 3D is way better!

[Jmatta2]

this is not 3d!

[Solutho]

This is a fail 3D.

A big one.

[TheJaviJB]

@Solutho the best 3D without glasses is this: sadpanda.us/images/111535-NEPN­3I6.gif

[Solutho]

@TheJaviJB Have you checked this other kind of '3D'?

It's really amazing, but it hurts my eyes after a minute xD

[TheJaviJB]

@Solutho I've tried, but I can't XD

[kaxtru]

higher rate between the 2 sides would be better... also, many scenes don't have great depth to be shown anyway...

[tomig]

he morons, its not 3D like avatar..

the video is just getting depth! ;) watch @ 2:40 great!!

[Mazzolli]

I'm missing a "D" here

[ocbjoint]

wtf this operator smoke salvia?! :x

[captainpanic08]

Whilst I wouldn't call it 3D, this technique does produce a much greater feeling of depth, I think. The issue is that the nature of the recording method means that only the point which is in perfect focus is represented with the '3D effect'. The rest just shivers around wildly. I'd have thought a higher frame rate would work better, but epilepsy sufferers have to be taken into account. It's certainly a beautiful experimental video and suits the song very well.

[hokuspokuss]

Im going to puke!!! stupid idea to make 3D with this camera shift "vomiting" method!!

[trawnik79]

co za gowno

[Rishro]

LOL! Drunk cameraman xD

[bobszyn]

It doesn't look like 3D, I agree with it, but if  you're watching it in 720p HD and full screen mode then it's awesome.

[aprush]

¿Y esto es 3D? Nunca vi mayor mierda.

[apomovstudios]

Parts of this, especially the high angle shots can give the illusion of 3D. So do some of the closeups on faces. I'm interested in this concept and am looking forward to how it's developed. Well done!

[tourmalineKey]

The video creeped me out, and didn't seem too 3D, but the song is beautiful...

[sh3xbeer]

no 3d for me, awfull to see, my eyes are bleeding

[joeblobish]

it works well if you make it full screen and put your face an inch from the monitor

[TornadoStudios]

I don't know what everyone else is saying but this was great!

[Neatoguy]

works fairly well @ 2:33... other then that, ehhhh

[callycap3]

and people say avatar game them a headache?!?!

[aecid]

it hurts my eyes.

[Glaruf]

Okay, it sort of works (although it is obviously not a viable option for 3D videos), but they should have done this in a video where there are more things going towards the viewer, and most importantly, where the GROUND is not visible at these moments. In a 3D film it is MUCH harder to picture that an object is popping out of the screen when you can see that it is on the ground.

[Aerohix]

I think youtube isn't fast enough...

[Zolofgonnakillallya]

I have an eye diesease called Nystagmus were my eyes shake back and forth.

This gave me a headache, and it did not work at all. D:

[lhong1987]

you are supposed to focus on the stationary object of each scene for the illusion to work better. Some shots are just remarkable. One frame is meant for left eye, and the other for right eye. Think of it something like magiceye and immerse yourself, I think you can see it.

[davim84]

FAIL

[wiccamoon13]

May not be "3-D" but an amazing visual effect, very enjoyable.

[Delus1on77]

wtf?

[VCRRecorded360]

I understand the concept and appreciate it.Nice work

[FinalFragment]

creators must have been high...

[DimitrioLewis]

Youtube converts framerates to 15fps, so it's difficult to tell if this video looks the way it was intended. Perhaps at 30fps or 60fps the effect would be less distracting?

[tor2gonzio]

Pfffffffffff . . . . . horrible . . .

[mdc837]

i wouldnt call this 3d. more like 2d double camera rotation. the constant flip from camera angle 1 to 2 makes this suck. maybe if one is really messed up they wont notice the change, but i doubt it even then. back to the drawing board...

[jeffgooloolie]

This is nauseatingly horrible !  F-

[criscarl0s]

A técnica 3D é sutil, mas o efeito é bem criativo. Poderia ser aperfeiçoada pra criar uma experiência ainda mais interessante!

The 3D technique is subtle, but the effect is very creative. Could be improved to create an experience even more interesting!

[LhArchitect]

Its a good idea, after some second of watching i see it in 3d lolz

[kirkblitz]

this isnt a 3d that pops out its more of a 3d that produces Depth.

[sylvez]

cant see the 3d

[78UNKNOWN]

Try tripling the frame rates

[lagz89]

1:20 feels 3D

[Sogrenals]

nice try, but pretty horrible. and the effect is really poor.

[mumhen]

made in amagine

[HelloNewYorkCity]

ok i was once on a tram, and on my camera i was panning the camera, and i got 2 images slightly out of place, and i got results like this. it wasn't exactly 3d. i prefer those fancy sony tv's instead of this

[garrettcode]

I wanted to like it, but the cameras weren't aligned well enough. It's supposed to be a very subtle shift, not the dramatic lurch that occurs in many of the shots.

I've seen wiggle stereoscopy applied to stills and really liked the effect. Maybe it just doesn't translate to a moving image?

[stefanoazevedo]

You should search for "Harmonic 313 - Battlestar" or "Wang Chung - Everybody Have Fun Tonight". These musicvideos were made before yours and use the same flickering trick. Please be honest and remove the word "first" from your title!

[xenu4life]

Decent idea, shitty execution. Also, the music sucks.

[cwolf]

Hurts the eyes yes. 3d? bite me. I might get an effect then.

[ripper0289]

I imagine the pornographers are all over this already.

[elramon]

Imposible, that needs more fps

[hunterhalo]

oh dear i can see it, dont look too close to the screen or concentrate at one point. Stay as further from the screen as u can, and look at the parameter first and slowly moves inside and u will see it

[nacoran]

@hunterhalo

I see the sailboat!

[jtautiva]

Meh... Doesn't work as advertised...

[latestlovecm]

just 1-4

[Ratocx]

That was a bit weird. Getting a bit tired at first, but it feels like I just need to get used to it. I like it, but I think I need to see more videos like this to get used to the effect.

[wilhelmrahn]

I see what they tried to do here, and the effect starts working on the second half :)

Nice vid, closeups definitely worked best. The song is really nice.

Good job :]

[minhmeo1209]

3d my ass

only hurts my fucking eye

[raishins]

Full Screen HD and still not work. My eyes become crazy after that...

[meshrin]

its a cool video but it isn't 3d.

[oCfuu]

Don't really like the 3d effect, possibly cause it didn't work too well for me.

I do like the eerie effect the shifting images have- And the song is superb!

[CMIRA]

Worked for me, full screen hd and focusing on the non moving objects. But i am sleeping with my gun tonight. thanks.

[funknotik]

Dope.

[jackresurec]

This music video is AWESOME! I really love this band!

[somejackball]

annoying

[iesilav]

SuperLame.

[SiressW]

This is foolish...standard movement of the camera displays geometric relation in a much more pleasing way.

[EthernetKid]

Doesn't even seem 3-d...

[Thassodar]

Yeah this music video is creepy as shit, I'm sleeping with my closet door closed now.

I'm sure there are subliminal messages in there somewhere.

[spidermac]

very nice video and song.. but it's not the first "3D" music video

vimeo(d0t)com/4658601

[youonlydp]

I want my view back Gizmodo

[youonlydp]

Gizmodo lied to me...I want my view back!

[lukeisheredotcom]

Try focusing on the parts that are holding still, not wiggling. Let things wiggle around you...will bring the still parts to 3d view

[Ninkul]

One thing you can also try do to make the effect more apparent is.. alternately wave your hands infront of your eyes at the speed of the "wiggle" (ie. one hand is covering one eye while the other isn't and swap hands every time the wiggle changes frames, so yes.. very fast.)

[Ninkul]

For you that dont understand how this works...

Look at the ground at around 1:40. Your brain processes the depth because of the sudden changes in angles. It only somewhat works since both angles are exposed to both eyes..

[MrMoneyHelper]

I got here following a Gizmodo link. I got the effect very clearly. My screen is 23". Maybe those of you that didn't get it have small screens. The camera focuses on one thing that doesn't move. The other things around the object of focus do move. That movement creates a depth perception around the fixed object. Try focusing on the thing that isn't moving and see how the things around it create the depth.

[Onthealmond]

Full screen HD actually really worked for me. But it definitely hurt my eyes.

[cowbreaker]

Well that sucked! Who was the bonehead who thought this was on 3D? It was barely 1D.

[echelondagod]

What's the hell are you all talking about I don't see anything 3d about this. And I've seen pixel shake before and it worked on me I don't know what this is.

[Fredo5227]

lol wtf, some suicide bomber terrorist in wiggle vision?!!

[AwesomeHaHaAnime]

wow

[brak014]

sweet 3D effect you can really feel the depth :)

[sunnysang]

i lasted about an hour before i got a headache in Avatar... 25 seconds here...

[LeLans01]

i hope ,first and last video-clip in that technology , that technology is simply not good ...i rather wear glasses

[phatcorns]

Didn't work

[lemonkey]

gimmick that doesn't help the song any

[HeckYeahImShort]

that's kind of really crazy.

[eperkutya]

Amazing! The video, the music! Greatings from Budapest!

[xclassxactx]

video makes me dizzy, good song though

[casteeleu]

song is sooooo intense!!

[RennRenn85]

Fun to watch with the song, which i really really like. Blue Roses, awesome.

[RobotsCanNotRead]

I love it!