I'll give a different opinion - to me it's musical genius. I hope you meant that it was "pointless rubbish" to you only, since it's untrue that it is as you state for everyone.
Actually, this piece isn't as difficult as it sounds. It's just all the usual virtuoso tricks. Fast broken chords, chords where you have to play two notes each with your thumb and pinky, and jumping octave notes. All tricks, once you master the little tricks it's not that bad.
@jeremykmartin yes i agree when you break it down just whole tone scales chords, but it's the touch, execution of notes and required speed to get the desire affect, yes simple repeated patterns of whole tone scales chords but it's how the artist performs this piece; anyone anybody can just play this piece but without bringing it alive it's pointless.
@kylelandry OMG, I never checked to see who's comment this was. Your Secret theme and improvisations are legendary. And I subscribed to you earlier today, what are the odds? :D
I guess it's a matter of how experienced a listener one is, but it is difficult to deny that the Winter Wind etude sounds a lot more coherent and its melody is less of a challenge to understand. All while still sounding like wind.
@nahedh There are several distinct themes, the D#-A-G theme being prominent among them. It is pretty difficult to take in at once, though, but if you listen to others (such as Ornstein and other ultramodern composers), this will seem extremely traditional by comparison.
Does anyone know where i can find free sheet music online or is there a club that i can join where people share sheet music if so please feel free to e-mail me site thank you so much
@kratanuva725 O yes! It's not an ordinary one considering its dynamic and its forte and fortissimo! But you can distinguish it actually IS Debussy 'cause of the strong empressionistic image of the wind blowing and generally the distructive force of nature!
@EuphoricDan Can't say I've ever seen anyone playin' this without their nose. If I did, I'd be a bit worried as to how they'd lost it LOL. (Sorry, just me being facetious. Couldn't resist.)
when I tried to play this, I could not acheive the wind effect Pollini plays with, he is a true genius, this proves it being able to play fast does not mean it makes good music
Its so amazing how music can affect our minds. Debussy's use of the Whole-Tone Scale puts on a mood of anxiety and restlessness. It's interesting because that's exactly what this music has, no resting point, no tonal center. Even the layman has a sense of fright, like he doesn't know whats going to happen; well the music doesn't either..
odd duck? I think not. A surreal artist that paints with sound. Close your eyes and let the imagery that your brain conjures from your recesses take over your reality. Then...you will understand Debussy.
the score was certainly helpful :) and you have to admire debussy for being able to freak people out with just one instrument...i swear i'll play this next year
@debussy84 its a tremolo, basically just go back and forth between the notes really fast. its easier notation than writing it out over and over again.
@debussy84 That is called Tremor, kind of like Trillo, except the the player is supposed to play both notes that are stemmed simultaneously VERY fast just like trill. It should make like a rumbling effect on the lower notes, and a cla-a-a-a-a-acking kind of sound on the higher notes.
Decadent Composers such as Liszt, Wagner, Schumann, Jean Sibelius, Károly Them, Giuseppe Verdi, Niels Gade, and Claude Debussy are of little Heuristic Value.
I find it hard to argue (against) Debussy's compositional technique, and I've studied all of his piano works. I believe he was a a powerful forward-thinking composer of the finest degree, regardless of how well I appreciate his works (an mostly I do).
@fabiolima4060 I agree... I cant imagine the thought processes Debussy had during writing such emotionally evocative peices as this. He's an avantgarde genius
i admire people who can learn to appreciate this kind of music.. i never got into it. my cat can walk across my piano and the music would sound about the same to me.
this is'nt really difficult to understand it's impressionistic in that it it sounds like a great thunderstorm buiding then waning,not like some really avant garde rubbish
this is the challenge of debussy, the depth of the content and the images it wishes to portray. ravel is harder technically but debussy is harder to execute in content.
this piece really gives the feeling of someone looking down from high above, frolicking in the wind--like some sorts sprite or fairy or something.......anyway, thats just my impression......regardless, though, its a fun piece to listen to :D
This is simple... I started playing piano last week and so far I've learned this (3rd day). Rach opus 32, 10... opus 23, 2
I haven't mastered all of his stuff yet but I can get through everything Prokofiev has written... granted my playing is only on par with Yundi Li but in another week or so I think I'll graduate to a Richter/ Horowitz level... Maybe 10 days, I have some stuff do this week. Don't have the normal 15 minutes a day I dedicate to the piano.
好難喔!這是誰彈的?
How difficult it is! Who was playing it?
Alan3352 4 weeks ago
@Alan3352 It is played by Pollini.
ansonyeung825 1 week ago
Brilliant rendition.
jhutch1463 1 month ago
God, Is This What The West Wind Saw!?!?
TheFeuillesMortes 2 months ago
amazing
edhastie 2 months ago
un sospiro.
2hyeok 2 months ago
Amazing!!
BlunderCity 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you can find sheet music @ sheetsearch . com
Ir0nman86 4 months ago
Absolutely magnificent...
esplorandogio 5 months ago
Is this even real? o.O
xoxpenguinxox 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"...pointless rubbish." said Kevinastraw
I'll give a different opinion - to me it's musical genius. I hope you meant that it was "pointless rubbish" to you only, since it's untrue that it is as you state for everyone.
ddacaro 5 months ago
Comment removed
ddacaro 5 months ago
Actually, this piece isn't as difficult as it sounds. It's just all the usual virtuoso tricks. Fast broken chords, chords where you have to play two notes each with your thumb and pinky, and jumping octave notes. All tricks, once you master the little tricks it's not that bad.
jeremykmartin 6 months ago 2
@jeremykmartin yes i agree when you break it down just whole tone scales chords, but it's the touch, execution of notes and required speed to get the desire affect, yes simple repeated patterns of whole tone scales chords but it's how the artist performs this piece; anyone anybody can just play this piece but without bringing it alive it's pointless.
petechandanatural 5 months ago 3
If this is what the West wind has seen, it may be a little traumatized.
GerardDumond 6 months ago
Grande Pollini
nonnopirro52 6 months ago
Extraordinarily difficult pointless rubbish.
kevinastraw 6 months ago
you can find free piano sheet music @ sheetsearch . com
Ir0nman86 7 months ago
2:16 is that a part of the song, or a just a mess up
JimmyPage97 10 months ago 2
@JimmyPage97 It's probably just an encoding error.
Though, it still manages to freak me the heck out. o__o;
sssssz 9 months ago
@sssssz haha who knows i guess
JimmyPage97 9 months ago
@JimmyPage97 hahahaha XDDD part of the song??? XD
AkLvKk 8 months ago
@AkLvKk yea, thats funny?
JimmyPage97 8 months ago
@JimmyPage97 oops don't take it personally..... i thought it was a joke..... o_0 :-)
AkLvKk 8 months ago
@AkLvKk ha no I'm not taking it personally. I was just asking.
JimmyPage97 8 months ago
@JimmyPage97 oh okay :)
AkLvKk 8 months ago
haha. my friend`s son is playing this and he is like 12 years old.
supersmallpianist123 10 months ago
@supersmallpianist123 Lol im 12 and im also learning it...failing atm though, cant reach the chords!!!
prestoallegro 6 months ago
and u r obviously stupid.
supersmallpianist123 10 months ago
This piece is famous
majornewb 11 months ago
This makes me think of Hell. . .
Leo7217337 11 months ago 18
@Leo7217337 Lol...I like this comment...
LoSignorino 8 months ago
Absolutely fabulous !!WOW
aaround 11 months ago
Hmm, I liked Chopin's Winter Wind better.The imagery is still there without sounding too atonal.
nahedh 1 year ago 2
@nahedh This is not atonal at all!
kylelandry 11 months ago
@kylelandry OMG, I never checked to see who's comment this was. Your Secret theme and improvisations are legendary. And I subscribed to you earlier today, what are the odds? :D
I guess it's a matter of how experienced a listener one is, but it is difficult to deny that the Winter Wind etude sounds a lot more coherent and its melody is less of a challenge to understand. All while still sounding like wind.
nahedh 11 months ago
@nahedh There are several distinct themes, the D#-A-G theme being prominent among them. It is pretty difficult to take in at once, though, but if you listen to others (such as Ornstein and other ultramodern composers), this will seem extremely traditional by comparison.
drwerewolf217 10 months ago
lmfaooo what's with the 2 highest rated comments?????
4C4rly4 1 year ago
1:50 - 2:02
Debussy non è umano..
eMyZeTa 1 year ago
Comment removed
Nvelopmusic 1 year ago
Comment removed
Nvelopmusic 1 year ago
this is one of my dreams !! ♥
lizzart26 1 year ago
Im listening and crying at once. this is extraorinary.
monteverdi79 1 year ago
Loving the whole-tone at the beginning.
joineecleary 1 year ago
0_0........oh my...... was Debussy angry when he made this music piece? lol
Dante121892 1 year ago
@Dante121892 yea i was with him that day, he was pisssssssed off!
4C4rly4 1 year ago
And remember children don't do drugs or you may end up like this.
FragRaptor 1 year ago 15
@FragRaptor all the more reason for me to do them so i can play this piece.
MrJrd2014 3 months ago
@FragRaptor
Don't you mean do drugs, so you will end up like this? Cause this is some pretty awesome stuff lol
willflanaganmus 3 weeks ago
This is fucking awesome.
fedaykin6 1 year ago 3
Does anyone know where i can find free sheet music online or is there a club that i can join where people share sheet music if so please feel free to e-mail me site thank you so much
LETMEINGUYS 1 year ago
@LETMEINGUYS IMSLP.org
Chopofiev 1 year ago
Je n'aime pas beaucoup Debussy, mais ca, c'est tout bêtement génial!!!!
AlexandreJdB 1 year ago
@AlexandreJdB pareille^^
loboris1995 1 year ago
im practicing this now
abokadoSM 1 year ago
Michael J Fox + Piano= This PIECE
volldegineorigional 1 year ago
@volldegineorigional Debussy + piano= this PIECE
StradAmatiViolin 1 year ago
@volldegineorigional lol asshole
stewpidvideos 1 year ago
I think Pollini's hands would be burning...
ChopinLiszt82 1 year ago
SICK!!
ruslandimov 1 year ago
This is the crazyest shiz I've heard from dubussy!
Not your typical debussy piece.
kratanuva725 1 year ago
@kratanuva725 O yes! It's not an ordinary one considering its dynamic and its forte and fortissimo! But you can distinguish it actually IS Debussy 'cause of the strong empressionistic image of the wind blowing and generally the distructive force of nature!
RavelDebussy 1 year ago
excellent!
debussyman88 1 year ago
*sigh* (!!!!!)
What the fudge-nuggets does Justin Bieber have to do with this!????
A perfectly wonderful moment of artistic bliss just got ruined for me when I read that. =(
NemoProkofiev551 1 year ago
I like listening this while I'm trying to sleep, awesome dreams are garanteed.
Diffomega 1 year ago 3
OMFG!! carajo esto esta muy barbaro... de 10
DiAbLeRoFoReVeR 1 year ago
The west wind saw Justin Bieber...
Symmetryful 1 year ago 2
this piece is unnerving and yet I LOVE IT :D
SuperAaron895 1 year ago
this sounds like somethign from the shining
J4WS1 1 year ago 2
I love composers like Debussy and Scriabin; Debussy truly can set a mood though - this piece especially is so atmospheric and exhilarating!
Symmetryful 1 year ago
I can't even read this thing :)
airva21901 1 year ago
I had absolutely NO idea Pollini was such a great player of Debussy! Thanks so much for posting.
friendant72 1 year ago
Where can i get the sheet music to this?
natetitus52 1 year ago
@natetitus52 Message me your email address and I can send it to you :)
AttemptingToBeBusy 1 year ago
Comment removed
SuperAaron895 1 year ago
I can play this with my nose.
EuphoricDan 1 year ago 84
@EuphoricDan So, this is CN's account?
Laudan08 7 months ago
@EuphoricDan It helps with 11 note chords.
InsertName125 6 months ago
@InsertName125 22 note chords if u use both hands lol :-D
Lennythewinner 5 months ago
@EuphoricDan You're stupid.
JarekMrSupremo25 4 months ago
@EuphoricDan Can't say I've ever seen anyone playin' this without their nose. If I did, I'd be a bit worried as to how they'd lost it LOL. (Sorry, just me being facetious. Couldn't resist.)
Lennythewinner 3 months ago
@Lennythewinner
rofl
EuphoricDan 3 months ago
BOOSH!
drandrummer 1 year ago
i love this!, but i hate to read it!
Jamez5cz 1 year ago
petrified...
Sabbahification 1 year ago
well.... i have no idea if he played any wrong notes xD
dfairbanks06 1 year ago
that was fucking sick
dfairbanks06 1 year ago
This is the first time I've seen the musical score presented along with the recorded sound--I'm very happy with that! :)
ElisabethBaker 1 year ago
when I tried to play this, I could not acheive the wind effect Pollini plays with, he is a true genius, this proves it being able to play fast does not mean it makes good music
AStarri101 1 year ago
holy fkcn sht.. i wish i could play this good ( i am lvl 8 )
sychokillin 1 year ago
holy shit...
EduOrta142536 1 year ago
Wow!
SCordeliaB 1 year ago
Its so amazing how music can affect our minds. Debussy's use of the Whole-Tone Scale puts on a mood of anxiety and restlessness. It's interesting because that's exactly what this music has, no resting point, no tonal center. Even the layman has a sense of fright, like he doesn't know whats going to happen; well the music doesn't either..
ZB510 1 year ago 2
odd duck? I think not. A surreal artist that paints with sound. Close your eyes and let the imagery that your brain conjures from your recesses take over your reality. Then...you will understand Debussy.
Fuerza10 1 year ago
I like Debussy, he was such an odd duck in the composing world.
Selendomono 1 year ago
@Selendomono You obviously haven't heard much from the mid and late 20th century classical music
alciefrederic 1 year ago
amazing
BLOP888 1 year ago
the score was certainly helpful :) and you have to admire debussy for being able to freak people out with just one instrument...i swear i'll play this next year
thesuicidalperson 1 year ago
The west wind must've seen Ke$ha naked...
magicicle 1 year ago 3
I don't... see this music as frightening...
cornemuz 1 year ago
nice Debussy impresiomism at its most
beethomozart 1 year ago
this is definately mi fav prelude by Debussy...but no way to compare Pollini's rendition to Michelangeli....:)
liuketto 1 year ago
I bet the piano was surprised by that!
thisismymoniker 1 year ago 3
What's crap
jaozera789456123 1 year ago
wow it looks very hard to play!
lePistolero 1 year ago
I didn't know Debussy was capable of composing such frightening music. It's amazing in my opinion
CaptainGora 1 year ago
Eeehh!! I like this one!
I'm playing this in two hours in a competition!! AAHH
npelletier89 1 year ago 4
my god..this is so scary! i watched this in the evening when it was dark and i was frightened =//
hotbebimauz 1 year ago 62
@hotbebimauz Did you ever listen to Le Gibet from Gaspard de la Nuit in the dark? That's also a frightning experience ;)
Dennievader 1 year ago
u sound like a wimp
jjbinks3 1 year ago
@hotbebimauz i watched this in the evening and i was enlightened =]
Nvelopmusic 1 year ago
@hotbebimauz ur obviously gay
dnkmerman 10 months ago
@hotbebimauz Then you should try and listen to Penderecki and Xenakis xD
principessadolce22 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This composition is little more than a collection of animal noises.
PrincessShittyBottom 1 year ago
@PrincessShittyBottom a bit like you then=]
browny333 1 year ago
@browny333,
You are an accursed rapscallion.
PrincessShittyBottom 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This composition is a savage senseless vulgar massacre of the Western aesthetic
AnonymousWhitePerson 1 year ago 2
Debussy helps you to know yourself, I think, at least me
KuchikiByakuyaftw 1 year ago 2
I thought pollini and debussy was a combination that just couldn´t work.. I was wrong
ThePhilosorpheus 1 year ago
debussy, always.
lemonxjuice 1 year ago
Dear lord! When it flips to the page at 0:22 what do those three solid slanted bars mean again?
debussy84 1 year ago
@debussy84 (luv the username btw)
it means to alternate between those two notes as if they were 32 notes. if there were 2 solid bars, itd be sixteenth notes, etc
looney1023 1 year ago
@debussy84 its a tremolo, basically just go back and forth between the notes really fast. its easier notation than writing it out over and over again.
rpm4real 1 year ago
@debussy84 That is called Tremor, kind of like Trillo, except the the player is supposed to play both notes that are stemmed simultaneously VERY fast just like trill. It should make like a rumbling effect on the lower notes, and a cla-a-a-a-a-acking kind of sound on the higher notes.
AnAmericanComposer 1 year ago
Comment removed
AnonymousWhitePerson 1 year ago
@AnonymousWhitePerson
No wonder why it's such a lovely piece.
TheWanderingNight 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Decadent Composers such as Liszt, Wagner, Schumann, Jean Sibelius, Károly Them, Giuseppe Verdi, Niels Gade, and Claude Debussy are of little Heuristic Value.
AnonymousWhitePerson 1 year ago
I have no words how I love IT.
monteverdi79 1 year ago
Me too <3
Great piece!!! incredibly difficulty but an amazing interpretation!
Piancello182 1 year ago
q cosa mas horrorosa (no el pianista, la pieza)
turuladeburro 1 year ago
I love how clear those c# octaves are.
123eldest 1 year ago
amazing!
gimichi 2 years ago
Debussy's compositions blow my head wide open, some are so complex and virtuosically demanding but never ever lack musicality for a second. AMAZING
EliotKrupa 2 years ago 3
How can one play 1:25-1:50 at speed without breaking your hand? o_o
In fact, how can the entire piece be played at speed without hand breaking?
Truly amazing - the composer and the pianist.
TheWanderingNight 2 years ago 2
I find it hard to argue (against) Debussy's compositional technique, and I've studied all of his piano works. I believe he was a a powerful forward-thinking composer of the finest degree, regardless of how well I appreciate his works (an mostly I do).
EuriskoLontano 2 years ago
Debussy must have spent his lives earnings on the drugs needed to write this piece!!
How someone could pen something so manic blows my mind, but it is phenomenal.
OnlyPianoLogic 2 years ago
i can follow these fairly easily, but this is just insane... wtf was going through his mind when he wrote this
honkindonkey 2 years ago
probably something along the lines of "HOLY SHIT THESE SHROOMS ARE AMAZING"
Chuckles543 2 years ago
People who admire this kind of music are the same people who are sick of the obvious, normally musicians...
fabiolima4060 2 years ago 74
@fabiolima4060 hahaah:-)
hoeryong 1 year ago
@fabiolima4060 thats an amazing way of putting it
mukeshcuster 1 year ago
@fabiolima4060 I agree... I cant imagine the thought processes Debussy had during writing such emotionally evocative peices as this. He's an avantgarde genius
ScarceOTatties 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i admire people who can learn to appreciate this kind of music.. i never got into it. my cat can walk across my piano and the music would sound about the same to me.
seabrain 2 years ago
-.-
985Carlo985 2 years ago
LOL
BlackCloud21509 2 years ago
Comment removed
lorenzarthur91 2 years ago
@lorenzarthur91 yes they do differ :P
seabrain 2 years ago
this is'nt really difficult to understand it's impressionistic in that it it sounds like a great thunderstorm buiding then waning,not like some really avant garde rubbish
afertyus1000 2 years ago
@afertyus1000
this is the challenge of debussy, the depth of the content and the images it wishes to portray. ravel is harder technically but debussy is harder to execute in content.
libetta 2 years ago
yes i agree
afertyus1000 2 years ago
crikey, that looks difficult!
jazzmunky 2 years ago 4
Marvellous opus. Debussy owes so much to Maurice Ravel for his inspiration. 'Gaspard de la Nuit' and 'Miroirs' spring to mind.
njorl99 2 years ago 2
Well, Ravel and Debussy all a lot a like. When I heard Ravel 3rd Miroir Une Barque sur l'océan, Ce qu'a vu le vent d'ouest poped into my mind.
Starbirdy9999 2 years ago
Debussy, musical genius! Pollini, great pianist!
jbrahms1833 2 years ago 2
I... wow. Just incredible! This one is just all over the place. All I can see is lightning and chaos from this song. It's... I mean, my Gods!
LeoMidori 2 years ago
The west wind saw a battlefield covered with dead bodies
spartan1081990 2 years ago 2
eh..what?
thewritingwriterof89 2 years ago
just listen
spartan1081990 2 years ago 2
Does anyone know what level/type of piece this is?
Lvl 9? 10? and by type I'm asking A, B, C, D, or E? (examination)
xomusicalxo 2 years ago
Do you mean for the Royal Canadian Conservatory?
It's an ARCT piece (Diploma level One - the level above Level 10), and I'm pretty sure it's from List D.
Vook 2 years ago
Thank you!
too bad I can't play it.... gahhh
xomusicalxo 2 years ago
wow...
martaKetamin 2 years ago
this piece really gives the feeling of someone looking down from high above, frolicking in the wind--like some sorts sprite or fairy or something.......anyway, thats just my impression......regardless, though, its a fun piece to listen to :D
Aureneau 2 years ago
yeaaah!! fucking insane..
nomutente 2 years ago
1:27 -1:36 sonds like some kind of video game music
xtukdjss1243 2 years ago 3
Musically this piece looks extremely scary. I would try to learn it for years.
pianist32795 2 years ago 2
I don't know why, but this would sound like what Ravel would compose. It's very mysterious!
jonprak 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great Debussy!It's the most boring thing I've ever heard!
bigcalamaro 2 years ago
simplemente delicioso
Letsrockbitch 2 years ago
1:27-1:36 sounds like Mario collecting coins in super mario world or some sort of video game music, supercrisp performance
jwcho 2 years ago 4
Amazing!!!
namemename 2 years ago
I'm embarassed to say, but I've never heard this piece up until now. It's so beautiful!!
pianochick1 2 years ago 3
@pianochick1 I don't think that "beautiful" is the right word to describe this song..
Sk8er1103 1 year ago
@Sk8er1103 - Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. It may not be beautiful to you but I found it beautiful. To each their own.
pianochick1 1 year ago
@Sk8er1103 - Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
pianochick1 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is simple... I started playing piano last week and so far I've learned this (3rd day). Rach opus 32, 10... opus 23, 2
I haven't mastered all of his stuff yet but I can get through everything Prokofiev has written... granted my playing is only on par with Yundi Li but in another week or so I think I'll graduate to a Richter/ Horowitz level... Maybe 10 days, I have some stuff do this week. Don't have the normal 15 minutes a day I dedicate to the piano.
EuphoricDan 2 years ago
Thats the most ridiculous thing i've ever heard
rhythmatics 2 years ago
totally agree.
Hollygon92 2 years ago
Well, Euphoric is in his username. In a few hours he'll awake from his cocaine-induced stupor and realize his complete dearth of skill.
demosj 2 years ago
Comment removed
skryabyn 2 years ago
lol hahahah
cursestar 2 years ago