I haven't watched this one in quite a while. And just by coincidence, I checked it out exactly five years to the day after it had first been uploaded.
It always seems like all of the celebrities who come on the show are always loving the experience. I'm surprised that Gregory Peck never did the show, seems like something he would have gotten a kick out of.
I don't think Sikel or Ebert ever actually gave a "sideways thumb" review, however I know there were times when one or the other would watch a film and report having mixed feelings about it, and then give what they called a "marginal" thumbs up or down.
After seeing this sketch for the first time in nearly 20 years, I've actually started using "Thumbs Sideways" myself. I guess it would be equivalent to "Rent It/Wait for the Dollar Theater/Wait for a TV Airing".
After having watched a bunch of old Siskel and Ebert reviews, this seems even funnier than before. I especially like the debate on "Cinderella"...It's almost like something from the show itself.
This reminded me of somthing. Thumbs up and down orgiated in Rome with the Gladiator fights and if a defeated Gladiator was not killed the crowd gave thumbs up to signal he should live and thumbs down to signal he should die. Maybe thumbs sideways ment he should be very hurt but not killed. :)
Ah, back when children's television shows used to actually teach you something instead of trying to keep kids as far away from reality as possible. Thanks for the vid!
One thumbs sideways movie I can think of is Lion King 3. I liked it because we get to see Timon and Pumbaa and find out their secrets but calling it 3 outside USA is not neserceriy. 1 and a half would make more sense everywhere because it's not a sequel in a sense.
Interestingly enough, the original Sneak Previews was on PBS. (However, I'm assuming that this was done when they had become more popular with their syndicated series "At the Movies." Correct me if I'm wrong.)
Thanks so much for your comment. What bonded them was a common love, FILM. They both wanted to see the best, they both wanted to share the same awe. When you find someone who is willing and able to share in your search, you have found a brother or sister. GREAT COMMENT!!!! Again, thanks.
I haven't watched this one in quite a while. And just by coincidence, I checked it out exactly five years to the day after it had first been uploaded.
Garrettk41 1 month ago
I think around the 1:40 mark looks like Siskel and Ebert kinda broke from the script.
nightwing01 1 year ago 2
OSCAR: MACHIVELLIAN GENIUS
Brainstrain 1 year ago 6
Oscar the Grouch: one of history's greatest trolls
Subbers 1 year ago 9
"You gonna put up with that?" lol @ Oscar instigating these arguments!
CoolerKing37 1 year ago 2
It always seems like all of the celebrities who come on the show are always loving the experience. I'm surprised that Gregory Peck never did the show, seems like something he would have gotten a kick out of.
woollybully100 1 year ago
oscar you lil sinner
MissAlainey1991 1 year ago
I don't think Sikel or Ebert ever actually gave a "sideways thumb" review, however I know there were times when one or the other would watch a film and report having mixed feelings about it, and then give what they called a "marginal" thumbs up or down.
petercharleskrug 1 year ago
"You gonna take that sitting down?"
"A critic takes everything sitting down!"
Hotshotter3000 1 year ago 2
I can imagine kids doing the thumbs up and down in school
Tommy: Hey Billy I don't like you *Thumbs Down*
Billy: PUNCH!
ConnDevi88 2 years ago 3
Oscar the Grouch is a manipulative SOB
Drac39 2 years ago 5
I've been wondering - why doesn't YouTube allow us to do a "thumbs sideways"?
quizmaster85 2 years ago 42
siskel and ebert must have been high on drugs to do this!! lol.
captainkill1 2 years ago
Well, Thumbs Up + Thumbs Down averave into a Thumbs sideways.
dubs19842008 2 years ago 6
cheesy but cute and funny : }
VegimorphtheMovieBoy 2 years ago
This is so great!! it seems that sesame street had alot of guest stars on the show!!
emoviebuff87 2 years ago
That was awesome. I'm doing my critic exercises as we speak.
NeverHassleTheHoff 2 years ago
this is funny!! i like the critic excerise bit.
emoviebuff87 2 years ago
THUMBS UP THUMBS DOWN
Headbanger142 2 years ago
Oscar was a wonderful childhood memory, too bad he went away for "Influencing Antisocial issues"
Tacom4ster 2 years ago 3
Oh my god, this is priceless!
JoyGrenade 3 years ago 3
haha! I love them.
This is sophistacated humor for kids. I wish kids' TV had the nerve to be this smart today.
Shamborn 3 years ago 7
Me too. A lot of kids' shows these days are really jank.
disneyrangerblue02 2 years ago 3
I have always sided with Ebert on the "Thumb sideways" issue. lol
AJthemoviebuff 3 years ago 21
This is charming. Siskel and Ebert should also have met Waldorf and Stattler, now, that would have been a "sritic tag team match" !
hausgraus 3 years ago 5
man sesame street got the COOLEST guests EVER!
nypad5 3 years ago 4
This is cute, gives a good feeling! Siskel and Ebert should have meet Waldorf and Stattler, now that would have been a tag team "fight"!
hausgraus 3 years ago 3
lol critic excersizes lol
pooperuber 3 years ago
After seeing this sketch for the first time in nearly 20 years, I've actually started using "Thumbs Sideways" myself. I guess it would be equivalent to "Rent It/Wait for the Dollar Theater/Wait for a TV Airing".
FBB87 3 years ago
Maybe you like a "thumbs sideways" movie,but you don't really know why.
spiked200 3 years ago
LOL XD
shedininja001 3 years ago
so charming
standinstann 3 years ago 2
My God, I just dipped very deep into the well of my childhood here.
FAILGET64 3 years ago 4
Its a shame the show will be over next month. Even though its was never the same since siskel died. Coming soon a hipper new movie critic from ABC
Tacom4ster 3 years ago 3
After having watched a bunch of old Siskel and Ebert reviews, this seems even funnier than before. I especially like the debate on "Cinderella"...It's almost like something from the show itself.
retrorocker 3 years ago 3
I remember this clip, I like the part when they say, "Thumbs Up", "Thumbs Down". Oscar's questions about Thumb Sideways made Siskel and Ebert argue.
bubblebear83 3 years ago
I remember this. It was funny when they both Siskel and Ebert both did thumbs down and thumbs up.
bubblebear83 3 years ago
This reminded me of somthing. Thumbs up and down orgiated in Rome with the Gladiator fights and if a defeated Gladiator was not killed the crowd gave thumbs up to signal he should live and thumbs down to signal he should die. Maybe thumbs sideways ment he should be very hurt but not killed. :)
moatguy 3 years ago 3
Thanks so much for posting this; it must've been a great moment for both critics to be joined by two memorable characters from "Sesame Street."
huntress1863 3 years ago
Ah, back when children's television shows used to actually teach you something instead of trying to keep kids as far away from reality as possible. Thanks for the vid!
giantgorillastudios 3 years ago 4
YES! Another long-lost gem I've been looking for! (Especially the surprise from Oscar at the end!)
quizmaster85 4 years ago 4
LOL, Siskel and Ebert looked like they had a lot of fun doing this.
thunderstruck665 4 years ago
Siskel and Ebert were kinda like brothers!
Rkerekes13 4 years ago 4
RIP Siskel :(
This was wonderful, thank you!
urbangypsy770 4 years ago 3
haha Oscar, "You gonna take that?" rotfl
SillyDawnOwnsMe 4 years ago
"Nobody wants to see a thumbs sideways picture."
Yeah, sure, Gene. And I suppose they DO want to see a thumbs down picture?
Garrettk41 4 years ago 3
Well, personally, I go with Roger's opinion, and I guess Roger's the one who invented thumbs sideways!
Rkerekes13 4 years ago
One thumbs sideways movie I can think of is Lion King 3. I liked it because we get to see Timon and Pumbaa and find out their secrets but calling it 3 outside USA is not neserceriy. 1 and a half would make more sense everywhere because it's not a sequel in a sense.
moatguy 2 years ago
I think the idea is that since no one wants to see a thumbs sideways movie, then you might as well put the thumbs down.
TheHumanAdventure 3 years ago
There should be a thumbs sideways rating.
welshuser 4 years ago 5
Wonderful, I think Ropert and Ebert should do this for Sesame Street parts.
Sharptooth007 4 years ago
hahahahahah
derbesy3 4 years ago
I love how Oscar only gives thumbs down. Not surprising really.
moatguy 4 years ago 4
LOL! How cute....
boamuro 4 years ago
ROFL @ Oscar, "Heh heh heh!"
Wiggymaster 4 years ago
hahahaha, niccceee!
pagielme4ever 5 years ago
Nice one, Oscar.
the06bug 5 years ago
siskel is gone but siskel and ebert appearance still lives on in this clip on sesame street.
Gothiczartan 5 years ago 2
What a great way to teach opposites.
Interestingly enough, the original Sneak Previews was on PBS. (However, I'm assuming that this was done when they had become more popular with their syndicated series "At the Movies." Correct me if I'm wrong.)
TServo2049 5 years ago
Far as I know, this was even later, in the "Siskel and Ebert" days.
crescentfreshbret 3 years ago
Famous for arguing. (or at least discussing) that is what makes those review shows so much fun and informative
Teankun 5 years ago
RIP Gene Siskel
sweetrolls 5 years ago 2
Awesome! Good old Oscar pulling the Bugs Bunny routine! LOL :-) This is definitely 2 thumbs up! ;-)
MacLeaper 5 years ago 2
YES! I was hoping someone would upload this.
fango44 5 years ago
The sad part was that Siskel and Ebert were not on very good terms with one another off screen.
I guess Oscar was there because he's good at talking trash.
glowworm2 5 years ago
They didn't get along at first, but they became closer as time went on.
ebrown2112 5 years ago
If I recall, they were close enough to where Roger took Gene's kids to see 'The Phantom Menace' when it came out.
itstheit 4 years ago 2
Ebert has said in interviews that he and Gene were like brothers. They argued a LOT, but it was out of love.
Maarow 3 years ago 3
Thanks so much for your comment. What bonded them was a common love, FILM. They both wanted to see the best, they both wanted to share the same awe. When you find someone who is willing and able to share in your search, you have found a brother or sister. GREAT COMMENT!!!! Again, thanks.
wasteland70 3 years ago 3