Nightwish - The Poet And The Pendulum, live at Artmania Festival 2009, Sibiu, 18.07.2009

[sparklight39]

si, ca sa imi inchei monologul ca un fan adevarat, va urez un calduros "Nightwish 'till death". ori "to hell," cum preferati ;) moartea nu consta neaparat in iad, dar.. nu pot sa-mi exprim aici parerea mea de agnostica, pentru ca youtube-ul a pus limita de caractere prea mica. Nightwish, te urmez. esti prezent mereu in apele oceanului. cele mai miscatoare versuri. "you have so oceans within.. in the end i will always love you." In the end i will always love you, Nightwish!!!

[sparklight39]

e singurul cantec in care toate melodiile, cea a pianului, a tobelor, chitarelor si a vocii ei, se impletesc intr-o armonie de nedefinit. e de departe "the beginning" of "the end" pentru aceasta minunata formatie, care poate sa recreeze lumea prin prisma sentimentelor exprimate, traite, si fara tarja. tarja si anette sunt, din punctul meu de vedere, trecatoare, efemere. versurile si sufletul melodiilor, ceea ce exprima si ceea ce te fac sa traiesti sunt nemuritoare.

[Pulsed101]

The new album shows that Anette is fucking awesome!

[xipitu]

puteti sa ziceti despre fata ce vreti,albumul asta e cel mai bun de la nightwish...unde mai pui ca e fara tarja!

[NWphreek]

@xipitu are dreptate omul asta. DPP este cel mai unic si original album. Care contine cel mai bun cantec, adica asta. es uperb. daca nu va place, nu ascultati.

[Birsan22]

dc naiba nu e in stare sa cante ca pe album nici macar melodiile dp Dark Passion Play?atunci ce pretentii sa mai am la melodiile pe care canta tarja...mai sus de atat nu poate incapabila...

[Birsan22]

si nu ma intelegeti gresit...eu am acceptat-o de mult si poate are voce frumoasa da nu e de Nightwish...

[Birsan22]

privind la celalalte melodii cantate...aici suna f bn!:):))

[NWphreek]

@Birsan22 esti tu mai capabil ca ea? atunci poti sa o faci incapabila cand o sa fii :)

[Birsan22]

acel comment a fost postat acum ceva vreme...intre timp mi-am schimbat parerea...:p...

[DevilBesideYou4Ever]

???Eu de ce stiam melodia asta altfel;-??

[georgeregelejunglei]

I was at the concert ..yes it was wonderful, the boys were awsome but Anette was kinda lame...Tuomas was always making faces when she dind't sing well, and I know that because I was in the first row, face to face with him...so yes Anette kinda sucked at this concert, at other concerts she did well ... I gues she dind't tried 100%...anw the concert was beautiful...and it's metal not pop

[NWphreek]

I DON"T believe tuomas would make ANY funny faces, he is too polite, too controlled, to ... nice to do that. After all he totally supports anette. I think YOU make it up . he does make faces ,, but faces that show you how tired he is.

[anaarkadievna]

"Tuomas was always making faces when she dind't sing well, and I know that because I was in the first row"

atunci de ce a mai ales-o?

[RuiMP]

I understando you guys trying to stand up for Anette's performance, but it still hasn't convinced me enough. Though I have to face no obstacles listening to the studio records(I actually love DPP and its symphonic power songs), the live performances, when it comes down to the main vocal, has yet to impress me. Hope she's getting better over the years. Nightwish is my favourite band!

[crimrose]

Anette has gotten a lot better over the years already, only having had 2 years on tour to improve. She's improved vastly, if you listen to performances of this in 2007 and compare it to now.

[Paulspike31]

OMG PPL !!! Anette is now.. not Tarja !! and she have a amazing voice !

[anja0985]

For spidermangrip:

I feel sory for you..It must be horrible to have life like yours -full of hate and whaever you have! Oh come on!!Becouse you don´t like her it doesn´t mean that you are right and you need to write it here.I ´ve never been on some site just only for pissing someone off! It´s screepy!

BTW:Writing "mental diarea" and disagreeing respectfully are two completely different things.

[nkilin9]

how can she sing so bad???

[spidermangrip]

I know, she is killing the deep meaning of Tuomas's lyrics with her shallow careless singing. She makes me so angry. All she can do is lust after material things and go shopping! Her shallowness shows through in her interpretation of these great songs and in her so called 'singing'. NW get someone who can do justice to your material.... PLEASE!

[MrReason09]

Oh really? I heard only 1 note miss. That makes her shallow?

You know... your assumptions are really fucked up. You can clearly see the emotion in her singing.

You contradict yourself by saying she is "carelessly singing" and right before you say she "she's straining to try to sing the notes."

Make up your mind already...you're just talking shit.

The notes she has to reach here are not easy ones, and she reached each and every single one of them.

Get lost, tone deaf.

[spidermangrip]

You heard only one miss coz you're tone deaf like she is FOOL, that's why you think she'd great! lol

Her singing is nothing but a mixture of carelessness, cover ups, thrown away notes and straining. The only rare bits that sound good belong in pop music NOT Metal. Oh my God it can't listen to her voice, her off pitching, straining and slaughtering of the melody bloody well hurts my ears! NW songs aren't easy to sing which is why they need to get a decent singer to who can handle their songs.

[MrReason09]

stop bringing up the "pop" thing, you're just a fucking poser who think that by listening to metal you're instantly bad and cool.

Either show me a proof of her going off pitch, or STFU. You're just making up nonsense comments.

Stop whining like a fucking 3 year old girl, you're fucking pathetic.

[spidermangrip]

YOU'RE THICK! I can't 'SHOW YOU PROOF'! You have to listen to it; since you're obviously tone deaf like Anette, you cannot hear it. She is off pitch, by several scores of cents all the way through and goes off by whole tones and semi-tones which is outrageous for a so called professional vocalist. She can't hold straight notes to the full measure because she's not a strong enough vocalist so she yodels them to disguise the fact that she can't manage the notes. Frankly, SHE'S OUT OF HER DEPTH!

[MrReason09]

1:51- 1:55, she sings a D5, the original note is D5

2:00 she sings a Eb5, the original is Eb5

2:04 she sings a D5, original is D5

2:06 she does a cadence in (apparently) G minor.

Frankly, you're a complete idiot, and you're just making a fool of yourself, fucking clown.

[MrReason09]

The song highest notes are the ones I listed below, dumbass. And she sang them pitch perfect. So there's no fucking way you can now say she can't reach the notes. Why can't you face the fact that she actually DOES hit the notes.

She doesn't yodel any note, and you don't even know what yodelling is, by what I see.

This is a complete waste of time, you haven't given me a single valid argument. You keep spewing the same bullshit over and over again.

Goodbye.

[spidermangrip]

HITTING notes and singing them are two different things,she has to shout and strain to get up there and it sounds amateurish and horrid. She often misses and it is fatiguing to listen to someone strain, struggle and bluff their way through a song. Face the fact the she isn't suitable for Nightwish.

[1AzureSky]

No, she belts them and does a pretty damn good job at it. Belting is singing.

[cipher619]

I may be no vocal expert, but Ive been a musician for years, and in my opinion she does sound a bit off. I dont think that she was as bad as wrist jizz man over here was sayin, but she did sound a tad off most of the time. Could have been the audio quality of the video, maybe she was sick, I dont know. Again, not a vocal expert haha

[cipher619]

Actually, correction on what I said: She isnt off most of the time, but there are for sure parts that sound off

[soraelegido]

Man!

This isn't pop music...this is metal...Annette sounds amazing!

If you think that it sounds pop, you have got a big problem with the music! -.-

And if Tuomas chose Annette, it will be the right road...

Tuomas isn't silly...don't you think?

[astrolifter]

@spidermangrip So have you gotten over Tarja leaving you cocksucker?

[Caladwen20]

I was standing in the first line and I saw the at the part "long enough to see your friends betray you" Tuomas almost started crying.....

[Glady210]

SECOND LINE. :D

[spidermangrip]

Anette's pop yodelling is ruining these beautiful NW songs. She's so off pitch and obviously straining to try to sing these songs. If she still can't manage it after TWO YEARS practice, she will NEVER be able to sing these songs. This is too amateur for NW, with Anette's out of tune Britney Spears and Mariah Carey yodelling trying to cover up the fact that she cannot sing the NW songs; they are too big for her and she cannot handle them. Hold the notes in pitch as they were written or GET OUT!

[knublbubl]

omg i love this part of poet and the pendulum. this is so emotinal and beautiful!!! =)

[spidermangrip]

Yes, it's really beautiful, it's such a shame Anette ruined it with her off pitch, wailing, straining and struggling. She puts too many jagged lumps into the notes and makes it sound like a joke...and as for the shouting, it looses it's class. " I will always love you -o-o-o-o-o-o-oooo-oo-oo!" Yeah sounds like cheap poppy crap. Tuomas must be boiling with anger and probably can't wait for the tour to end so he can boot her ou-o-oo-o-o-o-out! lol :)

[DominiqueSMP]

PERFEEEECT!

[nic19913]

AMAZING!!!

[mishkyn910]

Awesome!!!!

[mov4k6]

Am fost si a fost super !!!! NW RULES !