I cried everytime i listen to this song. It reminded me of my beloved cat,Ai lynn. She died last year. She's 11 years old. I'd played this song and lied beside her during and until her final moments. So yeah.. I miss u so much Ai lynn!!
I love this song it makes me think about everyone i lost. Her voice is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo amazingggggggggggggggggggg. She is my fav singer.
thank u mariah, i really cried at the part on "i wish u were to celebrate together, i wish we could spend the holidays 2gether" "i remember when u use to tuck me in at night"
this song is dedicated to my dad, he just passed away last june 16, 2008,
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. xSEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS
Noone that im close to have ever died but i know what thiis song is trying to say and it mean's so much i know what she is feeling because i think she is talking about her dad she never met him.
Amazing tune and i love it so much It means somethiing so special.
she is talking about her dad! and too everyone who has LOSt a love one, friend because she understands that pain that everyone goes through and shes just as normal as us ! LOVE YOU MARIAH!
This is the best song ever writen. Its so meaningful and full of feeling. I cry every time I hear it because it makes me think of my grandma. She's right. the hardest thing ever is saying bye to somebody you lost. Thie second verse really touches me. She never did get to see how good I've done. I didnt know I could hurt like this. RIP Rosa Solano. March 2 1925-October 26 2007. We all miss you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i really havent experienced losing sum1 so special to me but i love this song............ mariah is such a brilliant composer......im not a fan of her but she awesome...
this gos to show that life is can change in a flash... this is a showt out to all that have lost a loved 1, dont be as in there passing bc they are in the most precious place that the world has to offer and that is in your heart there they will live on..
i know everyone that lost someone in thier life they will be missed and they are still loved in so many ways ... but thier in a better place and we will all meet again somewhere and some how! LOVE YOU MARIAH!!
im so sorry to hear that!!! i think thats why Mariah made this song not only for people that she lost in her life but for everyone because life isnt something that goes on forever when ur time is up it up and u go to a better place! i know this song is so popular because everyone can relate to this song in so many ways i know i can i cried so many times listening to this song since i lost ALOT of people in my life ... especially my UNCLE and in time i will see him later on in life!
I Never got to say Bye To Grandfather. I will Now! BYE... It Hurts Me Because I dont what made you do what you did. But regardless I Love you & To This Day i Miss running up hugging you & You Sneeking Dollars When Mom Say dont.lol... Bye. I Love you
I love this song and a lot of my family died. This is dedicated to my great-grandpa, my great-grandma, my brother grandma, my cousins, and my grandpa i love all them so very much and i'll never forget ya'll.....(cry)....
R.I.P aunt jullie i really miss you. i wish you was still here. it really hurt when i came and seen you and then i went home and found out you died. we all really miss you.
He was supposed to be my older brother. I never knew him; he died 3 days after birth due to complications with his heart. I never knew him, but I wish I did. <3
R.I.P Jonelle Jenkins....you were too young to go and I know you are in heaven watching down on all of us....I hope to see you soon I miss and love you mama
dedicate this song to all my familr that dead R.I.P ma 2 grandpaz,cous me n u waz clost n kuz ma so kall dady i neva got to say goodbye i love u,big braug dude died at birth and neva got to met hym but we still love hym, Just tinln bou yall make me cry R.I.P pplz i love yall
this song it the best song ever even though it is sad and makes me cry. R.I.P Tyron and Rob. Rob i will never forget you i loves you so much and i know that if you where here we would still have love for each other i just hate that you died and i was so attached because we were dating for 1 year i miss you so much.
lol FOR THE RECORD, it didnt take bye bye more than 10 damn weeks 2 get in the top 20 on the billboard hot 100, it took 5! and its still climbing dude (currently #19) so take your false info. somewhere else
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
the album is quite a success
but bye bye is quite a failure. it takes more than 10 weeks to get only to top 20 in Billboard. I don't even think it can be no.1 coz Bleeding Love and Take a Bow will continue to be at the top until the end of summer!
And Mariah is still going to release a more terrible crap for her old-sister-with-little-brother love story. She will not top anyone in History coz actually Elvis got 18 singles too!
:'( i miss youuu!!
D.Q.W<3
godsvoice100 1 month ago
My cousin's baby just died at birth yesterday and i am so sorry for her loss. I wish she could have seen the world. You will be missed
Aubrey
7/9/11
kissycake13 6 months ago 2
@kissycake13 sorry for your loss. /:
dzenitakostic1 3 months ago
@dzenitakostic1 Thank you. She's hanging there a lot better now :).
kissycake13 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
check out my violin cover for this song :D
Aswhisian 7 months ago
This song makes me cry. :(
I miss my great grandmother and grandfather so much. </3 We even played this song the day my great grandmother died.
DappleDerpy 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Watch;,~Movies;,'Online.;;Here``"
WWW.WATCHFULLMOVIES5.TK
COPY'':THE.:,URL.`.ABOVE;,,
YongHurt 8 months ago
i remember listening to this song in 5th grade with friends that i dont talk to anymore </3 ..
FilipinaAngel 11 months ago
Lovely Song , iLovee Mariah Carey's voice :'(
BritanieJae 1 year ago
A letra é linda demais cara =/
rafajordison 1 year ago
online dating site # lushfmlk.info #
ushananditha 1 year ago
Just posted this vid on my friend's facebook wall...he died Monday in a car accident...not saying bye bitch!
brufanegra 1 year ago
@brufanegra Im really sorry to here that....I know how you feel my dad died last year
landoboo8x 11 months ago
I cried everytime i listen to this song. It reminded me of my beloved cat,Ai lynn. She died last year. She's 11 years old. I'd played this song and lied beside her during and until her final moments. So yeah.. I miss u so much Ai lynn!!
futureanimator91 1 year ago 3
mkes me sooo sad
peanutchez 1 year ago
i love this songg x
jazzyxx13xx 1 year ago 3
i know this is old. but this is still maa song (:
TheDemiproductions 1 year ago
I love this song it makes me think about everyone i lost. Her voice is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo amazingggggggggggggggggggg. She is my fav singer.
18ToCute 1 year ago
She is very perfect *o* Y LOVE M.C.!
Mylla19a 1 year ago
nice face mariah carry......^_^
jovibo006 1 year ago
my grampy just died today so im gonna be listening to this a lot :P R.I.P miss u already :( x
Luke19Wales 2 years ago
i lov this song from her lik the beat to
Sexyanabel18 2 years ago
beautiful song.... makes me cry = (
juicyfrute101 2 years ago 11
i love this song
SuperSGoMeZfAn 2 years ago
this song reminds me MJ a bit :'/
i love this song! (L)
SusanM1995 2 years ago 5
sooo touching... kills my heart so often! :'(
luvmissu19 2 years ago 13
this song is so cute
Showgirls202 2 years ago
OMG dis song is amazingggg
onefriendonelove 2 years ago
nice song from mariah
dancel1998 3 years ago
The Best song
Bastoniev 3 years ago 2
love it!!!
leapachirisu 3 years ago
i really lOve this sOng.. nd nKkasawa
joeypau27 3 years ago
thank u mariah, i really cried at the part on "i wish u were to celebrate together, i wish we could spend the holidays 2gether" "i remember when u use to tuck me in at night"
this song is dedicated to my dad, he just passed away last june 16, 2008,
ashley101ashley 3 years ago 3
....nice song
weeemeeh 3 years ago
haaaai.... biri gud! n_~ yeah, 8 rili touches me so much!
genevievebuctolan 3 years ago
i soo love this song....tho it reminds me of someone i knew....hell,it still hurts...
toshimi09 3 years ago 2
I dedicate this song to Gil Grissom, Warrick Brown and Sara Sidle. So sad they are leaving...
csihardfan111 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
lenkaaaaaa50 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
KingRaffers 3 years ago
i dedicate this song to all who'd lost but still able to stand up...
Mariah...
you are a true inspiration...
onesixteenninety 3 years ago 3
I dedicate this song to my nephew...... sorry for not expressing tt I care for him b4 he went forever
AzleenOthman 3 years ago 5
keep up the good work mariah carey :) your songs are inspirational :) amazing artist xx
xxxtezlaxxx 3 years ago 4
mariah carey sang this song as a dedication to her late father
fightar1 3 years ago 4
one of the best!! A+++.
Grat feedback like on ebay! :))
adydevill 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. xSEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS
gotanyfriendshuh 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A
|
| Click to
| Watch My (Sushi) Video!
|
crazej0ker 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
err
lycosidic 3 years ago
i do love mariah.......whew!
bbuntalan7379 3 years ago
lov it!!!
Misscutie7085 3 years ago
<3 i love da song its so BLOPP
AmyAdamsFanXXXX 3 years ago
i dedicate this song to my loving and caring grandma rest in peace
mihojames 3 years ago
yea dats true
cutiepie71344 3 years ago
luv it <3 x
xraver16x 3 years ago
i love this song <3333
heladochica08 3 years ago
in the video it's almost all her and nick cannon all up on each other
sumpplchange001 3 years ago
i love this song :]
jennisabrinashow 3 years ago
i love this song..
abigailtipton101 3 years ago
lOv3 dIzZ sOnGgGg=]
italybabii1127 3 years ago
Watch mariahs number one fan experience the gratest fall of his life when touch my body goes wrong..on my page!
jamalefisher 3 years ago
Thiis Song Is Amazing i Love it so much
Noone that im close to have ever died but i know what thiis song is trying to say and it mean's so much i know what she is feeling because i think she is talking about her dad she never met him.
Amazing tune and i love it so much It means somethiing so special.
X
MerePie14 3 years ago
she is talking about her dad! and too everyone who has LOSt a love one, friend because she understands that pain that everyone goes through and shes just as normal as us ! LOVE YOU MARIAH!
fernielover03 3 years ago 2
Mooriah Crazey =))
SexWithAnApple 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's a bitch.Madonna is the best
SexWithAnApple 3 years ago
if shes the best what are you doin here>?????
fernielover03 3 years ago
wow....... amzing song!!!!!!!!!
tayona12 3 years ago
aww im real sorry about your aunt babe, i know its hard losing someone u love.
xxx
welshangel13 3 years ago
i love this song. it really means something. its not junk.
HeArTsAnDpEpSi16 3 years ago 2
i LOV3 DiZ SONG SO MUCH!!!iT R3MiNDS M3 OF SOM3 1 R3ALLY SP3CiAL 2 M3 DA PAST AWAY ABT 4 YRS AGO.......=[
princesscute44 3 years ago
this song is so good. it came out on my music channel on my tv wen my bf n i broke up tat day. how weird is tat!?!?!?!
dealingwithoutthem 3 years ago
This is the best song ever writen. Its so meaningful and full of feeling. I cry every time I hear it because it makes me think of my grandma. She's right. the hardest thing ever is saying bye to somebody you lost. Thie second verse really touches me. She never did get to see how good I've done. I didnt know I could hurt like this. RIP Rosa Solano. March 2 1925-October 26 2007. We all miss you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dancingmooses56 3 years ago
This Song Gives Me Goose Pimples, Cos' Of My Grandma.. X[
RosiieG 3 years ago
It So Good Right Avery body !!! I Love It She's Like My Idole !!!!!!
amandamidlak 3 years ago
Madonna is the best
MadonnaOFlClALL 3 years ago
You might want to try typing 'Madonna' into the youtube search engine next time.
People like you who deliberately come onto another artists videos just to make unnecessary comments like you just did are truly pathetic.
Do everyone a favour, GO AWAY!!
welshangel13 3 years ago
very nice song..(^_^)V
toons040 3 years ago
DEFINITELY ONE OF HER BEST SONGS!
sunsetbeauty414 3 years ago
Please subscribe
Adisson2009 3 years ago
Thank you for comments !
Adisson2009 3 years ago
omg i love dis song!!!1
i knew dis song b4 it came out!!!
im like mc's biggest fan more dan any1 in da world i know everything about her!!!
yaligalvan 3 years ago
OMG i freakinn love this song..but i wonder who she wrote it on? o well this is so touching =( OMFg mariah writes the best songs...keep singigng<3
mikedinpa 3 years ago
omg i love Mariah Carey she is such a good singer i loe her voice!!!! Chase ur dreams Mariah and don't quit something ur soooooo good at!!!
italiancutie04 3 years ago 2
thi song is so sad but i love it so much and i m going to lisinto it all day i love miria bye bye
mammajennof3 3 years ago
i really havent experienced losing sum1 so special to me but i love this song............ mariah is such a brilliant composer......im not a fan of her but she awesome...
tayona12 3 years ago
this gos to show that life is can change in a flash... this is a showt out to all that have lost a loved 1, dont be as in there passing bc they are in the most precious place that the world has to offer and that is in your heart there they will live on..
S2Jfly 3 years ago 2
aww that is so true thats how it is one minute ur here the next u could be gone! i LOVE this a song!
fernielover03 3 years ago
this song always gets to me always cry when i har it like right now Im gona cry!!!I miss my siead her baby! R.I.P Heather and Jordn LeftHAnd!!!!
1PrettyEagle 3 years ago
i know everyone that lost someone in thier life they will be missed and they are still loved in so many ways ... but thier in a better place and we will all meet again somewhere and some how! LOVE YOU MARIAH!!
fernielover03 3 years ago
i love this song it makes me cry oh and i luv touch my body but totaly diff. song
gina23hiphop 3 years ago 2
it makes me cry to iv lisend to it 10 times today!
alicia120497 3 years ago 2
this song reminds me of my grandfather
R.I.P Grandad ... I LOVE AND MISS YOU SO MUCH
<3
littlepumpkin09 3 years ago 2
that is so sad im sorry!
alicia120497 3 years ago 2
I just lost my aunt today from cancer...=( *crys*
booksandtoys 3 years ago
im so sorry to hear that!!! i think thats why Mariah made this song not only for people that she lost in her life but for everyone because life isnt something that goes on forever when ur time is up it up and u go to a better place! i know this song is so popular because everyone can relate to this song in so many ways i know i can i cried so many times listening to this song since i lost ALOT of people in my life ... especially my UNCLE and in time i will see him later on in life!
fernielover03 3 years ago 2
condolences my friend...
J3LoCar3y 3 years ago 2
i love this song it reminds me when my grandpa die!!!
& never got 2 say bye so now Bye,Bye
luv ur niece!!
Zompopita 3 years ago 2
I Never got to say Bye To Grandfather. I will Now! BYE... It Hurts Me Because I dont what made you do what you did. But regardless I Love you & To This Day i Miss running up hugging you & You Sneeking Dollars When Mom Say dont.lol... Bye. I Love you
janey657 3 years ago 3
my grandma just died 5 minutes ago :(
i miss her so much, and now this is my new favorite song.
bstawesomeashie 3 years ago 2
Bye Grandma i miss you!!!!!!!!!! I love you!
xoxoxo
Your Nicasia
dancingmooses56 3 years ago 2
for u granddad .....
dcObsessed 3 years ago 2
this song is for luc bourdon who died a tragic death, a great NHL defenseman who played for the canucks.. RIP LUC we will miss you
ghkdxodbs1095 3 years ago
I love this song
cabruny 3 years ago
I love this song and a lot of my family died. This is dedicated to my great-grandpa, my great-grandma, my brother grandma, my cousins, and my grandpa i love all them so very much and i'll never forget ya'll.....(cry)....
Tcutie07 3 years ago
This is an amazing song.
This is my song to my grandma my best friend
(who died of cancer) and my other
friend who had a deathly alregic reaction!
its really touching. And it just means you can still go on. but not forget them
hollywoodbabaay 3 years ago
i love this song..
cuz i lost my cousin a few years ago..and i was very close to her..
keamkjh 3 years ago
That song is so touching! And i`m a guy, even a straight one,lol. Seriously! 5 stars and favourite!
IAmFromNorway2 3 years ago
i just saw him yesterday and today he was gone. he was killed in a car accident. life is fragile. pls cherish.
nicollnick 3 years ago 3
She is so HOT!!! What a great song!
lvs2ride 3 years ago
i luv this song!!
soccerocker17 3 years ago
dis is a shout owt to mi dad and my old boyfriend
reallisassy 3 years ago
this song is for my cousins friend Collin Bare. age 12 he died with an atv accident :( we will miss you Collin!!! WE LOVE YOU!!!!
johnnydeppsbabe13 3 years ago
dis is dedicated to my god-daddy *TEARS*
GONE BUT NOT FORGOTTEN PIERRE
iwannaloveu07 3 years ago 2
This is for my BEST FRIEND's grandma. She died and i love her to death and i always will. I love you sooooo much :(
oi8abug 3 years ago
grandmama daddy n mama diz fa you *T3ARZ* I LOVE YALL
tweetys1021 3 years ago 2
omg my friends mom just died, this is for u!!
IamStEfAniExo789 3 years ago 5
This song is decicated to :
Mario Llanos & Ilia Nourkov
they just died recently all the people who knew them .. keep them in your prayers!
mikay75 3 years ago 3
This song is soooo sad. it reminds me of my daddy who died of cancer when i was three. im now 11 and miss him so much. I MISS U DADDY THIS IS FOR U.
1191957 3 years ago 2
sad :(
trishthuytrang00 3 years ago 2
i sung this for my talt show i won yes and my dad was crying lol
taneesha3 3 years ago 2
rip lovasz.x3
xsmilebabyy 3 years ago 2
R.I.P aunt jullie i really miss you. i wish you was still here. it really hurt when i came and seen you and then i went home and found out you died. we all really miss you.
klisa714 3 years ago 3
i feal sorry for Mariah Carey because her dad died and thats why she sang this song..... and sorry for the people who lost family .... im sorry
musicfreak499 3 years ago 2
i love this song!!!!!!!!!!
417supergirl 3 years ago 2
R.I.P. Daniel Pangaribuan <3
He was supposed to be my older brother. I never knew him; he died 3 days after birth due to complications with his heart. I never knew him, but I wish I did. <3
ruthhsuckahhx 3 years ago 2
thats like my case with my older sister. rest in peace <@
nightales7 3 years ago 2
R.I.P. Grandpa.
Tiffanysuperstar 3 years ago
Rest In Paradise
Seandell Martin Gonzalez
a.k.a
Dellz
July 17, 1992 - June 30, 2006
Almost 2 Years & We Still
Missin You Like Crazy
♥[[Tiara]]
tsg1214 3 years ago
R.I.P NATALY we miss her sooo much she was only 12 n got sht in the head REST IN PEACE NATALY
peace2no1 3 years ago
love this song
SAGURLS 3 years ago
great song
arhenry4 3 years ago
R.I.P Jonelle Jenkins....you were too young to go and I know you are in heaven watching down on all of us....I hope to see you soon I miss and love you mama
RockstarDiva92 3 years ago 3
it is AWSOME!!!!!
kristinalopez07 3 years ago 3
pretty good!
sunsetkitty56 3 years ago
bye grandpa's...i really never get to see u and say bye bye...:'(i love y'all!R.I.P.
h8urvoice 3 years ago 3
R.I.P Christina Jungkans
12.30.90 - 5.9.08
gsexychick 3 years ago 2
i LuV tHiS sOnG! <3 mY fRieNd DoEs To0!!! [ :
luvmom10 3 years ago
Love It .x
carragher23lfc 3 years ago
i love this song it make me think about my granny thelao
lilmisskissmissmissy 3 years ago
LUV iT!
DiS SONG MAKeS U SO eMOTiONAL!
=]]
<3!
brooklynmamii92 3 years ago
they put this song on my bday
mexicandancergirl 3 years ago
was your b'day that depressing?
iddy302 3 years ago
dedicate this song to all my familr that dead R.I.P ma 2 grandpaz,cous me n u waz clost n kuz ma so kall dady i neva got to say goodbye i love u,big braug dude died at birth and neva got to met hym but we still love hym, Just tinln bou yall make me cry R.I.P pplz i love yall
TriniPeachez14 3 years ago 2
this song it the best song ever even though it is sad and makes me cry. R.I.P Tyron and Rob. Rob i will never forget you i loves you so much and i know that if you where here we would still have love for each other i just hate that you died and i was so attached because we were dating for 1 year i miss you so much.
chiefcheerleader 3 years ago 2
R.I.P. Grandpa:'( never had a chance to say good bye:'(
Ragaapoo 3 years ago 2
R.I.P. great-grandma. I miss u.
jessmess95 3 years ago 2
my aunt and my uncle died not that long ago
ILOVECODYNICKLES 3 years ago 2
r.i.p gram...
Ibom27 3 years ago 3
my aunt gracie died in 2004 r.i.p. sweety
trinalilsis 3 years ago 2
My cousin died when she was only 3 months old.
We went to put fresh flowers on her grave today. :'(
R.I.P Victoria [[We Love You Baby]]
ballplayer1195 3 years ago 4
my grandpa just died last week.
we buried him friday and right when we left the funeral this song started to play on the radio..my mom cried her eyes outt.
r.i.p grandpa
1941-2008
inseparable91593 3 years ago 2
i love this song. but its also sad.
yuk3iie 3 years ago
awsome song i love this song sooo much its the best song ever so is touch my body thts a goood songs 2 this song makes me cry sometime
watak0olchick12 3 years ago
R.I.P Mariah Carey.She died last night in an accident
happylemonn 3 years ago
THAT'S NOT EVEN FUNNY.
jessmess95 3 years ago 2
this song makes me cry...R.I.P GUELO(GRANDPA)JOSE I MISS YOU SO MUCH YOUR ALWAYS IN MY HEART..
LOVE ALWAYS YOUR LITTLE MIHIJA (GIRL JOCELINE)
B3S4M3B3TTYB00P 3 years ago 2
im sorry
alicia120497 3 years ago 2
r.i.p michael phillips,michael baldwin,grandma,grandpa,uncle,gram,kevin...i love u guys n u gunna be always in my heart...i miss u
greencrazy531 3 years ago 2
R.I.P my gramndmother.
cmdpinkygurl 3 years ago
lol FOR THE RECORD, it didnt take bye bye more than 10 damn weeks 2 get in the top 20 on the billboard hot 100, it took 5! and its still climbing dude (currently #19) so take your false info. somewhere else
lilcory318 3 years ago
i love this song!!!!!
jojoelover06 3 years ago 2
THIS SONG IS THE BEST YO!
hockeygurl179117 3 years ago 2
R.I.P GRANDPA =(
radiosong12 3 years ago
i like this song is this album already out in netherlands?
LaTiShA1975 3 years ago
dis iz da best song R.I.P my DAD
Kaumakaokalani44 3 years ago
R.I.P grandpa :'(
1Chicana4 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the album is quite a success
but bye bye is quite a failure. it takes more than 10 weeks to get only to top 20 in Billboard. I don't even think it can be no.1 coz Bleeding Love and Take a Bow will continue to be at the top until the end of summer!
And Mariah is still going to release a more terrible crap for her old-sister-with-little-brother love story. She will not top anyone in History coz actually Elvis got 18 singles too!
3yongyuan 3 years ago
uhh...if you hate this song so much, then why are you even bothering listening to this song...?...and for your info...Elvis got only 17 #1s...
nhanv313 3 years ago
wow, that's a beautiful and very emotional song...
I love it (:
charmedmimi 3 years ago 2
Wow this song really like touched my dad just left 5 days ago and this song comes by me.i.......i just love this song.love ya dad i miss you
skinnydaboxbreaker 3 years ago 4
a very touchful song :)
SarahzHere101 3 years ago 2
Love this song! R.I.P. DADDY!
hlkljh 3 years ago 3
i love this song!
bye-bye its really good fa like someone that passed away or ya lost them
ajstlf11 3 years ago
i love mariah carey
koolkylie11 3 years ago 3
what does she mean "we'll never say bye"?
cardtrickboy96 3 years ago 3
it means that that person she is talking about will never go away.
trishthuytrang00 3 years ago 3
this song really helped me out when i was going threw some things, like when i used to like my ex (my bf now)
klisa714 3 years ago 3
great song...this really touched my heart
sara6142233 3 years ago 3
graduation is near too omg although it's a different thing than people that passed away but my friends are leaving and I won't see them anymore
Glass11 3 years ago 2
yeh i agree bexs ily ...x
louiseisthename 3 years ago