This is a wonderful recording, no doubt about it, but to call Rudy Vallee a "class act" was to have never known him. After meeting the man, I swore to never listen to his voice or watch his movies again until after his death.
Rudy was a class act. It must've given many a thrill when he stared with Elvis Presley in "LIVE A LITTLE, LOVE A LITTLE" putting the two showbusiness icons together.
As much as I like Bing Crosby's version of this song, this is a much better arrangement, and then there is the difference in the recording equipment of a twenty year span to be considered also.
A friend of mine once told me that one of the most memorable experiences of his life was listening to a group of drunken Yale boys singing the Whiffenpoof song at Mory's. By the time I got there, Mory's had been turned into a private club and I couldn't get in, but I agree that this is probably the definite version.
Kipling embraced the Jingoism of the British Empire. In his words, one sees disinherited young aristocrats as enlisted men in Her Majesty's forces, heavily drinking, as one of them sings a verse. These new words transmute the cynicism of the Kiplings poem, invoking some forsaken outpost of the British Empire, to the genial atmosphere of Mory's Temple bar. The upper crust effete at Yale in their disdain of common rankers created this parody of Kiplings poem, Gentleman-Rankers.
as on occasion maybe useful, the academic literature of time past sometimes points out that, "young men who are without go to sea", either in the merchant marines or, to war.
And in that same way, had we not a decade of troop mobilization, how much worse our unemployment?
Victor Herbert, who wrote the operetta "Little Nemo" trained in Germany--it's seldom performed these days (unfortunately) but a great fantasy piece! Best,
Thanks for the posting I remember hearing this version over fifty years ago and thought it just perfect and it still sounds great Rudy Valee was ace and it is nice to hear great singing once again.
rready I was wondering if you could help me find another song on you tube called "Forever and Ever' i can't tell you when it was popular other than the forties Thank you
Yes, Perry Como's rendition rose to #2 on the U.S. hit parade in 1949. It was translated from a song by German composer Franz Winkler, "Fliege mit Mir in die Heimat".
Enter that title in the search bar and you'll find the music--it's not yet available on YouTube in the English version.
I am a 76 year old man that listens to songs such as these and my mind goes all the back to the middle and late forties and harmonizing with a great bunch of guys.
My dad (an old Yale guy) loved this recording--preferred it to Crosby's (you'll be glad to hear, genia);)
It falls into that limbo between "silly" and "sentimental" where Rudy's art thrived...that's evidently where America's collective head was at in the Jazz Age.
But yes, the harmonies and phrasing make it a moving performance indeed.
if you want the sheets, they're free on musicnotes in january!!
MrStefanVidovic 3 weeks ago
I would really really enjoy confabulating with a Whiffenpoof alumni. I love Yale history. I am curious if any alumni hanged with my fav Wm Buckley?
LyleLincoln 4 weeks ago
Thank You... For putting the words to the Whiffenpoof song in your posting I've come close to getting it right now I know.
limeliter 4 months ago
This and the Maine song were sung by my Dartmouth-educated father back in the '40s and '50s. I hadn't heard them since then!
FRAGIORGIO1 9 months ago
Check out the Mills Brothers with Count Basie version, absolutely blows anything else away.
spagandtuna 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck this shit
fetusjuicefuck 1 year ago
@fetusjuicefuck i feel sorry for you....
safehouse123 1 year ago
@fetusjuicefuck then why would you be here? Watta moron
blunderboy1964 1 month ago
This is a wonderful recording, no doubt about it, but to call Rudy Vallee a "class act" was to have never known him. After meeting the man, I swore to never listen to his voice or watch his movies again until after his death.
Mendy7952 1 year ago
I sang that song at the retirement party of the former pastor of my Presbyterian church in Kalamazoo!
During the 3/4-time part, when my fellow choir members and I did the sheep sounds, I did frequent vibrato to sound like bleating sheep.
CaitlinBrooksMusic 1 year ago
halooking for a guy who knows his way around a lady's body
AnneAnnalynn 1 year ago
Thanks for posting. There is no one like Rudy Vallee. Always a pleasure to listen.
akarpowicz 1 year ago
Rudy was a class act. It must've given many a thrill when he stared with Elvis Presley in "LIVE A LITTLE, LOVE A LITTLE" putting the two showbusiness icons together.
donn409 1 year ago
1927.......... Amazing!
As much as I like Bing Crosby's version of this song, this is a much better arrangement, and then there is the difference in the recording equipment of a twenty year span to be considered also.
Yep! No two ways about it, Rudy was superior.
SuperCulloden 1 year ago 5
prophetic.
vimzibaiegh 2 years ago
Thank you so much. My mother used to sing this to me 55 years ago, and I never knew what it was until now. It makes me all misty.
298625 2 years ago 2
Enough already with the phony screen jitter and unconvincing scratches.
Thanks for posting.
FreemanZee 2 years ago
5*****!
sbd650 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
people actually bought this record?
anotherjoshua 2 years ago
Comment removed
ardeladimwit 2 years ago
I grew up on rock music of the psychedelic era. Then one day I heard Rudy- he blew me away! Definitely the best of the twentieth century!
steverlfs 2 years ago 2
Don't even mention Bing Crosby in Rudy Vallee's presence. Ever.
SeeburgMusic 2 years ago
the whiffenpoofers are the oldest vocal- ensemble of the world(1909)
GreatMotovaro 2 years ago
A friend of mine once told me that one of the most memorable experiences of his life was listening to a group of drunken Yale boys singing the Whiffenpoof song at Mory's. By the time I got there, Mory's had been turned into a private club and I couldn't get in, but I agree that this is probably the definite version.
safetychoice 2 years ago
As a young ! man I frequented a pub where the regulars sang this at closing time. Magic!!!!
rafhenlow 2 years ago
Love it, what a voice!
robbieware 2 years ago 2
een meer dan schitterende uitvoering!!! This is the way I like the performance of a song!!!
yep i am oldy (no rush no hurry just a peformance from the inside out)
runnrgate 2 years ago 2
Ha ha. Good Old Rudy.
Bennyhill68 2 years ago
wow this song is SICK! i love it!
dindilindi1 2 years ago
Hi: Love this song and Rudy's singing...I play the chorus on nylon string guitar...check it out if you like.....Dan
2142543 2 years ago
I like Bing's version a lot, but this is cool. Rudy was great in Palm Beach Story
Harlequin1998 2 years ago
Kipling embraced the Jingoism of the British Empire. In his words, one sees disinherited young aristocrats as enlisted men in Her Majesty's forces, heavily drinking, as one of them sings a verse. These new words transmute the cynicism of the Kiplings poem, invoking some forsaken outpost of the British Empire, to the genial atmosphere of Mory's Temple bar. The upper crust effete at Yale in their disdain of common rankers created this parody of Kiplings poem, Gentleman-Rankers.
higgme1ster 3 years ago 3
as on occasion maybe useful, the academic literature of time past sometimes points out that, "young men who are without go to sea", either in the merchant marines or, to war.
And in that same way, had we not a decade of troop mobilization, how much worse our unemployment?
phillipgaley 2 years ago
Wow, thanks for the extensive background information in addition to the song, I had never heard of "Whiffenpoofs" before... :-)
Talulah1997 3 years ago 2
Victor Herbert, who wrote the operetta "Little Nemo" trained in Germany--it's seldom performed these days (unfortunately) but a great fantasy piece! Best,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
didnt he sing a song in the sword in the stone? its the beganing song i think. if somone could give me the name of the song
Mayondor 3 years ago
Don't think Rudy Vallee ever worked with Disney...check out the IMDb for song information, they usually provide that.
Best,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
Thanks for the posting I remember hearing this version over fifty years ago and thought it just perfect and it still sounds great Rudy Valee was ace and it is nice to hear great singing once again.
richio44 3 years ago 2
Yes, I like the close harmony and simple instrumentation of Rudy's version best...;)
Kindest regards,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
I had forgotten how close the Lyrics are to Kiplings poem. I enjoyed this immensely, thank you
gentlemanranker 3 years ago
You're entirely welcome. A lot to be said for the tradition of the "Gentleman Ranker" in these times.
Best regards,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
rready I was wondering if you could help me find another song on you tube called "Forever and Ever' i can't tell you when it was popular other than the forties Thank you
motnamegah 3 years ago
Yes, Perry Como's rendition rose to #2 on the U.S. hit parade in 1949. It was translated from a song by German composer Franz Winkler, "Fliege mit Mir in die Heimat".
Enter that title in the search bar and you'll find the music--it's not yet available on YouTube in the English version.
Best,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
I am a 76 year old man that listens to songs such as these and my mind goes all the back to the middle and late forties and harmonizing with a great bunch of guys.
motnamegah 3 years ago
It was a great time in American music. As a people we don't sing together anymore...we've lost something for it. May it make a solid comeback!
Thanks for tuning in,
-RR
RReady555 3 years ago
Now this is the song I always associated Collegiate Rudy with. His rendition is so moving, it has brought a tear to my eye.
Thank you RR for this special Collegiate Rudy.
genia106 3 years ago
My dad (an old Yale guy) loved this recording--preferred it to Crosby's (you'll be glad to hear, genia);)
It falls into that limbo between "silly" and "sentimental" where Rudy's art thrived...that's evidently where America's collective head was at in the Jazz Age.
But yes, the harmonies and phrasing make it a moving performance indeed.
RReady555 3 years ago
thank you so much for an enjoyable night
motnamegah 3 years ago
Glad to have you stop by!
RReady555 3 years ago
@RReady555 Tell dad Happy New Year!
LyleLincoln 4 weeks ago