GH3 vs Rock Band Comparison - sabotage expert 100%

[flores1345]

i like how the charcters on rock band are i used to like guitar hero when it looked better in guitar hero 1 and 2

[Shawnclassic]

If you choose RB you're down with MTV(Rock Band and MTV partnership), and Yall know MTV isn't down with real music anymore. They're on there reality TV shit. So yeah, real music fans choose GH.

[CaptainOlimar247]

@Shawnclassic If you choose GH then you're down with Activision, so that means you must like shitty Tony Hawk games. Just shut the fuck up and don't act like a dick. It's cool that you like music games, but don't bring RB fans down because you like GH more. They're both big games and you should respect that.

[Shawnclassic]

@CaptainOlimar247 Oh so I'm bringing you RB fans down, huh? How about this for kickers. If you're down with RB you're down with MTV who's owned by Viacom which recently sued Google/You tube for copyright infringements and asked the courts to order Youtube to release our [the user] info:[ip addresses and login] so Viacom can sue us for copyright infringements if we upload any of their shit like any thing from: Paramount,MTV,Nickelodeon,Come­­dyCentral,BET,Spike,TV Land,VH1,CMT and various others.

[CaptainOlimar247]

@Shawnclassic Quit being such a fucking bitch, and change your goddamn tampon. Geez, what crawled into your ass?

[linkstorm6]

@CaptainOlimar247but some rb fans are being such douches

[Modderrific]

@Shawnclassic so they have reality tv in rock band?

[iGenerator1]

@Shawnclassic IDIOT!!!

[Shawnclassic]

You want to play pre-school chords go to RB.

[Jonscomin2]

rock band is for pussies

[MegaJecht]

Forget about the arguing! Try picking up a REAL electric guitar and playing this song!

Although Guitar Hero pwns Rock Band.

[halifuckinfan]

@MegaJecht Only Rock Band 3 will be teaching you how to play guitar. Guitar hero will be turning your avatar into a monster?

[bluntman860]

@ronaldroque96799 is it more of a challnge because they add an extra note that shouldn't be there?

[djsid09slipknot]

rock band is way better

[666tarin]

i like gh3 is better

[kingaaron01]

i lik guitar hero 3's sabotage better

[KeyaObie]

rockband n guitar hero are both owned by the same company....ur just makin them more money no matter which u perfer

[LOLfaimlyguyrocks]

@KeyaObie not anymore. one is done by activision and one is done by red octane

[flameburst45]

why do people hate on guitar hero/rock band. they're both fun. they both over/underchart songs. and they both have their own merits.

and LOL at RB hillbilly rapping

[Mandizh96]

Yes, I do. I have notice it.

This is absolutly the best guitar game I've played.

It has not to be comparing with the following games+RB series! :)

But that what I think.

I can inform you that I have played all games.

So I don't guess. :P

[Mandizh96]

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA!!!!

how can you even compare green grass with through fire and flames lol! green grass is soooo easy;o

or it's you who sucks at plastic guitar which think so. >:)

Rockband has stolen the whole idea. Fucking losers!

GH OWNS RB TWICE!

[CaptainOlimar247]

You do realize that the company that made the first two guitar heroes made Rock Band, right?

[ko8be12]

i think in my opinon that GH has more complicated notes, than Rock band a mean, are simple but everyone could be agree or disagree, regards!!!

[slvrbmx12]

gh is harder than rock band rock bands note are all together gh are spread out

[mariobaseball808]

that's why i like rock band better. i'm 11 and a casual gh/rb player

[DaJoker90]

Love the games know nothing of the real instruments. so question: is the sound at like 2:16 made with a guitar and how?

[morlock19]

...its beastie boys. they incorporate scratches with guitar...

you...you know what the beasties are right?

[bond1011]

so all rock band is up a fret and has way more chords then GH3

[igotbragginrites]

Both charts are actually OK, except in GH3, they threw in a note where there is essentially nothing.

I like both series though, but still favor the Harmonix-era GH games.

[zerofeind88]

hah! RB is better cuz u can do drums bass and vocals instead of gh which just do guitars

[riunikia136]

well sure because gh is a guitar "hero" so you only need guitar

[piwoot]

the newest GH (world tour) has included drums and vocals also, so what u said doesent matter :P

[zerofeind88]

but wat about the big rock ending? :O

[piwoot]

thats just for this song i guess :P

[zerofeind88]

no it for more then 1 song man!

[piwoot]

ok lol

[breakthro444]

though then again, even though they may be realistic, the world tour drums are kinda faulty (break easily, dont respond, etc.). rock band drums, or at least the first set, are unbreakable from what ive seen, rock band's guitar is in my opinion easier to use except the strumming, and i think rockband's readout on the song as its being played is a lot smoother than the newest. guitar hero is still a great game, dont get me wrong, but i think rock band is better.

[LadeeRanger]

rock band is a lot more fun!

guitar hero gets very boring.

rock band is just more fun

[GrandTourGoku]

the truth

[mrdude221]

gh3 looks harder

[moneypolo12321]

Harder =/= More fun or accurate

[re5owns678]

How is gh3 better if it's just guitar and RB is drums, vocals, and guitar?

[chrodragon2]

and dont forget what i play: bass :D rock band ftw i thumbs uped ur comment lol

[sheannalynn]

rock band has more to offer then GH because the newest GH's playing charts are to fast or too many dam notes at one time and dont get me started on the cartoonik lookin graphics

[PleasePotato]

Rockband have like 500 songs and in marketplace you can buy 500 too xD and in gh 4 200 songs and in marketplace 145 so RB2 rocks more xD and it is just much funner

[YTPisme]

guitar hero is nicer. when you beat the song it says you rock

[GrandTourGoku]

dumb reason

[lamborghini10101]

wow...

[lamborghini10101]

GH3 uses to much triple notes to be honest.., I like rockband better

[GrandTourGoku]

the truth

[petergriffin099]

gh rocks

[Superchowder64]

the rockband one looks a bit harder, but not by much

[connorman1957]

gutair hero is just too easy rock band is more fun

[R0ckSTARR3LL]

I SAY GUITAR HERO!!!  = )

[LoganCrews]

I like guitar hero 3 better, but rock band 2 owns all of them.

[NICKHAM16]

GH3 has a better chart

[LocustAnarchy]

im gonna disagree and say rock bands chart kicks its ass.

[DoomsdayRolePlay]

All of you guys are wrong. Both Guitar Hero and Rock Band are good. Stop fucking arguing as to which one is better. Who cares? Just play both. It's meant for fun guys..

[spookyman123]

i hate when people fucking say one is better then another...i used to be a big ass GH fan til RB came out and i stuck with them because of the drums...then GHWT and i still stuck with RB2 but as soon as GHM came out I loved RB and GH the same...so for all of those assholes who say RB is better than GH or vise vesa, go break you disc in half and shut the fuck up

[kingprod45]

gh3 is better

[TheTonioXoret]

rockband is too easy!

[pussy555555555555555]

GH3 is such a pussy. They probably looked at rockband and now they put up GH world tour to copy em.

[WalkAroundDude]

Yeah, guitar hero is sorry for keeping up with the times.

[lonnier76]

why does gh always overdue everything im getting rb when i wake up hopefully

[daplayer25]

rockband is 4 pussys its to easy not like gh

3

[dancer7rock]

well thats your opinion.

[PeopleDazed]

RB is for fun get GHWT if you want to wast time learning a fake instrument. Get RB2 with 530 songs for family freinds and parties and learn a real instrument insted

[BSfanboy113]

people like you disguts me. -_-

[PeopleDazed]

if its ppl like you that i digust then i've done my job ^^

[philipkatsotas]

real instrument you fucker is just a plastic guitar

[hotfuzz353]

Though seriously people learning a real guitar can be great fun and can be really rewarding. If you'd rather stick to games that's your choice as they are fun also.

[spookyman123]

whats even worse than playing a plastic instrument and having fun is people like you who go around commenting on RB and GH videos saying go play a real instrument...a lot of people actually play the real deal and play GH/RB for fun. Im a drummer and i love drumming, but it is also fun playing these games with friends who can play the real stuff...

[PeopleDazed]

relax man i didn't mean to upset any1. I often write things on youtube just to see all the reaction that come from ppl dont. sorry again and in fact i love all video games, what a great piece of history

[spookyman123]

kk...just think we are making history by playing games...lol...

[tenaciousD1122332211]

whoever played that bravo brava exelent

and i like rock band more

guitar hero uses bass and lead all at once

and rock band stays true to the irigenal

[Hotsumoto90]

the bassist in GH3 is the best thing in the whole game xD

[ywbjfmproducions]

RB is so easiyer gh3

[sticksarefun13]

gh looks more challenging. Rock band looks so easy on this song.

[Safor001]

Guys, shut yo mouth up. Rock Band is more precise, and GH is faster.

Anyways, the country singer on the Rock Band side is funny.

[thecrazyfamilia333]

wow omfg u people are really wierd do u realize what ur talking bout how bout talking bout somthing else like hw good the people are

[KingdomHeartsFan63]

Play Green Grass and High tides on Expert and tell me rock band is easy.

[vengeance48]

through the fire and flames and devil went down to georgia

[superfly913]

solos hardest part on green grass plus with the stupid rock band buttons is impossible to do it

[GeneralNikko]

yes! i always wanted a comparison of sabotage. could you make a comparison of mississippi queen?

[Metallica1COD4]

yea but less realistic because it mixes both rhythm and lead guitar.

[Cerda81]

and not to mention not guitar perts like say piano like on through the fire and flames

[hardyDX3295]

guitar hero is harder than rock band but rock band is funner than gh3 cause u can hav full rock band like play drums and vocals not only guitar and bass so yeah once u think about it i say they're even

[tomsoist]

GH3 is way more of a challenge. for example in rockband if theres a hard solo or something, they just do one of the things where you can push any button you want....I think GH3 is way better...

[voodoo1993]

Are you stupid?

[Thehiddenllama]

tomsoist, rb is easier for a reason, there are 4 intruments, harmonix expected us to be good with all 4 of them.

[HideogemuMeijin]

haeve you played Green Grass and High Tides?

[Thehiddenllama]

rock band has green grass and high tides and run to the hills, gh3 has through the fire and flames.

[vengeance48]

through the fire and flames, the devil went down to georgia, and raining blood

[tigeryss]

hope all you gh freaks that whine about the second set of frets whine when your new gh4 guitars have a touch pad of frets for solos, if it was such a bad idea I wonder why guitar hero added it???

[noonecanpassme23]

who cares about small details like the touch pad and learn grammer.

[Thehiddenllama]

You say he needs to learn grammar, but you mispelled words and forgot to capitalize.

[yoitzkyleg]

u know there also leting the rockband instrument work with gh4 too so w/e

[gashukun]

GH3 is harder than rockband

[smiely917]

no rb is

[gashukun]

haha lol rock band is the easiest game i've ever play you are a noob its another stuff

[xxshawn]

Guitar Hero 3 does indeed have harder charts than Rock Band. But with harder charts, there's also the fact that they increased the window of time that you have to hit the notes. With Rock Band you have to be more precise with each note you're hitting. Sure Rock Band may not be as "hard" as Guitar Hero, but that's because they don't go charting any little thing that makes noise. See the intro to Through The Fire And Flames for instance, or even the synth part in Knights of Cydonia.

[gashukun]

i know that

[gashukun]

but you know whats really weird

if you put one of those songs as custom song in gh2 you dont play the keyboard parts

[Backfire3788]

0___o

GH=HARD GUITAR GAME

ROCKBAND=NOOOBS VERION OF GH

u noe its ture look at this gh is so much harder....

[girlshot1]

holy fuck you strum hard lol

[Gamecubeguy124]

How Did You Put GH3 on one side and RB on the other

[fenix8582]

using any video editing software. i used adobe premiere

[smiely917]

nice vid the one on the left is GH3 and the other one is RB

GH3 is harder but RB is more realistic

[shoefu101]

this is one of my favorite songs to sing

[mattmanm8]

guitar heroes better! XD

[bocboc23]

I prefer guitar hero, but thats just my opinion, I've never played rock band, people tell me it sucks is that true or the other way around?

[gangster8101]

imo i think rockband is alot better because it's accurate.. if you actually take some of the other songs in both games, and compare them to accurate band tabs of the songs, make your own charts for them, the rockband ones will be ALOT more accurate then GH ones...

example: through the fire and flames has maybe FOUR GUITAR NOTES in the entire intro

it's all a piano.

[link2125]

Yeah, but if you had to just hit 4 notes in the intro it would take a lot of the challenge out of the song.

[stardragon55]

rockbands is definitely more accurate, but i like playing the gh chart better. it kinda depends on what the players looking for. a fun chart or a chart that actually makes sense.

[murdoc111]

Well, both are guilty here for making you play the chorus which is some sort of synth or something. I dunno. I like the rock band charts because they feel like actual guitar playing.

[voltage17121712]

The RB notes make sense, half the GH ones are just there for the hell of it. ROCK BAND!

[GramyBoy99]

How in the fuck do the RB notes make more sense? half the notes u play in this song aren't even on a guitar.....

[Kreigshundun2]

Half of the "Guitar Notes" in this song are Mike on his turntable!!!!!

[Dingoslash]

Yeah. I guess they just wanted to make the song more fun. Although if it wasn't fun to begin with then really it shouldn't be on the game... It certainly isn't fun to sing.

[GramyBoy99]

Rock Band butchered the solo....

[rick2x8]

What solo? r u on crack?

[GramyBoy99]

lord no, after the vocals go " I'll tell u now y keep it on and on

[GramyBoy99]

after the lyrics " I'll tell u now I keep it on and on", there's a guitar solo, listen closely....

[rick2x8]

that looks more like a guitar break to me

[nirvanarox34]

rock band butchered ur mom

[GramyBoy99]

oh nice comeback....

[united768]

is that supporting rock band or vice versa?

[paulsate]

guitar heros fret moves faster than rock bands

[FunguFuFu]

Thank you for uploading this:)

I like the circles for guitar hero better then the rectangles on Rockband.

[rmysterio80]

yeah. me too

[snowshoter]

Idc what better whos better but Gh3 and RB are kinda the same There both awesome so it desont really matter

[stealinghome08]

i like the rock band note chart better. its way more realistic, i mean look at gh3, there is too many 3 note chords which is meant for like that big blast at the end of the song, you know what i mean. the guy who made the note charts for gh3 had a boner for 3 note chords, i mean CMON

[kennydied63]

um can an xbox 360 guitar from gh3 work for rock band or vise versa? i'm wondering

[fubous]

Yeah.

[guapochalupa02345]

no, not really, but i think gh is more of a challenge than rb, but I actually like rock band betr if its at a party or just u and ur friends hangin out. Then, the tables turn. But rite now i like gh3 betr

[Dinkycars]

You Might Like Guitar Hero Better, And Thats Fine,

But There Is No Way Guitar Hero Is Harder.

Rock Band Is Like, Way Hard, And Way Time Consuming.

[fubous]

Rock Bands Guitar Is Easier. Seriusly,you don't need to fucking cap every word. Have you even been to school?

[Dinkycars]

It's A Bad Habit.

And Yes Actually. I Have Been To School.

Would You Like Me To Tell You About It?

[fubous]

Must be a bad school,because you won't stop capping every word.

[pokerguy94]

You must've been to a bad school too because it's called capitalizing, not capping.

[fubous]

Not your fucking conversation,jackass. And I don't feel like typing capitalizing because I'm a lazy bastard. :-)

[reddragon877]

in guitar hero maybe the charts are harder, but thats because they add notes that don't exist or are played with different instruments. like ttfaf intro, it is a keyboard that plays it not a guitar. in rock band they are way more accurate, and it can be harder because you got to be a bit prescise. in guitar hero you hit a note 3 seconds early and it still registers -.- rock band is a way better game in every aspect, except that some people prefer gh guitar and it can be fun cuz it challenging.

[denouement5]

Guitar Hero fucking blows graphical, everyone but the player you are looks like a robot, especially the drummer. I can hardly play GH because when I see him I laugh so fucking hard. Rock Band at least makes the people look real.

[stealinghome08]

i think you're still playing on the ps2, get a 360

[Homepie]

The singer looks like a giant muppet. Seriously, Rock Band has a much better art design.

[Luxord09]

I agree. GH looks really over-the-top, garish and unappealing since Activision got their hands on it. Also, the note charts are so overtabbed on GH you can tell that Activision have no idea what their doing.

[penguinownesu]

Rock Band is way better then gh3 becase is has all the instuments like drums gutar base and vocals but whan gh4 comes out it will be better then rock band because it has all the instruments and u can make ur own songs on there so rock band is better then gutar hero for now

[guapochalupa02345]

gh3 way betr than rb, its more challenging than rb, and theres triple notes which rock!!!

[orochimarugaysociety]

theres triple notes in rock band to. dumbass.

[lilyitch]

There are quadruple notes in guitar hero 3!

[onedudeinthehood]

o yeah GH is better than rock band just because it has triple notes (sarcasm). LMAO r u serious just because of that.

[mcyokey]

gh3

[ricansoilder]

alright i got fuck bag 2 bad one and two were 2 easy anyway but when 4 comes out then compare?

[Raktoner]

Meh. Both charts were good for the song, but rock band made their chart easier because they wanted to showcase all the instruments, not just the guitar.

[HanDaimond]

What's up with the fucking triple notes on GH3?! Inconsistent.

[dotsmagic]

if i play rock band and play this song on expert ill get 98% but on guitar hero try 91 - 96%

[ricansoilder]

ha ha thts wat im talking bout guitar hero is always gonna make rock band look like shit thts wat it gets 4 tryin 2 hard 2 b like it

[ReyesTheROOF]

OH HELL YA

[billie1123]

umm...the people who made rock band made guitar hero 1 and 2. retard. so ur basically saying that guitar hero 1 and 2 sucked seeing as harmonix CREATED GUITAR HERO!!

[hottgamerman]

guitar hero 4 is gonna kick rock bands ass

[DarkOctane]

agreed

[billie1123]

apparently playlist is gonna be shit and it won't have a decent career like rock band does.

[BizCasFri]

GH's chart is inconsistent at best.

[GramyBoy99]

ur mom's inconsistent in bed at best

[griffith94]

how do you h=get those video side by side

[Monkey58451]

guitar hero is waaay better i swear when i play rock band if i dont like hit it percise on the hammer ons and pull offs i miss the the whole damn notes, but in guitar hero if i miss one hammer on theres idk like a space gap to get back and finish that riff or solo

[chekeichan]

i like how all of these comments for comparison vids turn into fanboy flaming.

[xancient]

I hate how they take out the whole damn point of RB for ps2 all it is are songs, i bought it because i thought it had customizable characters and play at venus and clubs and have fans. But no I guess that is only for xbox360... what bs

[LucasBM007]

Rock Band is much better,you can play with 4 instruments,just leave alone the guitar for a time and try to sing or be a drummer,its pretty fun

and a question: Can you play GH3 with the Rock band guitar

[fenix8582]

nope

[xancient]

No. But you can play gh3 guitar with rock band

[theuberchub]

wow, only a 6 note deefreence. I say rock band is a little more practical with its note charts. But Rock Band is a much better game in almost all aspects. GH3 Sux george bushes asshole!

[xancient]

Thank you for being a moron.

[randommanY14]

guitar heros note chart is bass and guitar combined which makes it harder. rock band has just guitar or just bass.

the timing on guitar hero has more leeway than rock band. for rockband you must be very perciese and exact when it comes to timing

RB has an easier way of telling whether you must strum the note or not, guitar hero is harder to tell

[Notyu1459]

rock band PWNS AND THEY DONT HAVE TO USE A PRISITION CHEAT TO MAKE IT HARD!

[vidkidd1392]

imbored52; "rock band songs are way harder the only song that is har on gh is ttfaf and jordan"

Dude you are stupid? Did you even watch the video?

As you can see Guitar hero is way harder then rock band.

And, Jordan isn't even on GHIII retard, its on GHII. Unless you were talking about guitar hero in general. If not you fail. well, either way you fail, but still...

[shobu21]

AS U CAN SEE ROCK BAND IS EASY'R D: try high grass and blu tides on drums ON EXPERT and get 100% if u aint sweating then u bott'ed 0_0

[stewie353]

um it's Green Grass and High Tides

[wthunleashed]

...That song isn't hard at all.