Added: 5 years ago
From: speechless23
Views: 735,316
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (913)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Just because they don't have much of a difference does not mean they do not have an Eating Disorder. Not everyone with an Eating Disorder goes through extreme weight loss.

  • OK i didnt see any difference... only nicole richie.

  • They look exactly the same...

  • being skinny doesnt mean you have an eating disorder

  • i like but you forgot a few celebs, Like Demi Lavoto and Brittany Snow

  • People think they look normal because today's society is already use to looking at women underweight. I understand that a young teenager is not fully developed, which is why they look skinny, but women aren't suppose to look this way. Also, in pictures and in camera, they look normal, but in person these girls are too skinny. A designer could actually make it seem that they are at a normal weight, but you can c it in their skinny arms. Just compare them to a normal girl that is not scrawny.

  • To the video's author, instead of judging whether you think these celebrities have eating disorders or not, you should check your own perfection first. Realize is spelled with a "z", not an "s". That's how simple it is to have flaws.

  • @wilyquilt unless she's British... then it is spelled with an s... Just saying!

  • @wilyquilt The English spell it with an "s". *facepalm*

  • Just because some of them lost like 5 lbs doesn't mean they have an eating disorder ffs.

  • All of these women look better, healthier and prettier in the right hand picture.

  • How dumb you are, you know what is the only problem about them? people like you, if they have one kilo under the right weight they are anorexic and if they have one kilo over their right weight they are fucking obese? only sad thing here is you

  • this is so fucking stupid. most of them are healthy and a good weight. dumb shit lol

  • You should've done a before and after coz i couldnt tell on most of them !

  • Lolwut? Just because you lose weight it doesn't mean you have an ED x)

  • i think they are beautiful even with the eating disorder... but i guess that is mine talking. i know theyre sick but that is my goal.

  • There's a magnificent irony to the idea of the wealthiest persons on the planet starving THEMSELVES to death for the sake of vanity. I'll reserve my sympathy for the millions that have no choice.

  • britanny merphy had cocaine addiction too...

    but nicole kidman was always skinny

  • some of them didnt even have eating disorders..

  • Mary-Kate Oslen looks the same

  • you forgot victoria beckham

  • Maybe theyre just dieting or something. Dieting is not an eating disorder

  • lindsay lohan had no eating disorder ... she had... nevermind.....

  • I hate to break it to u but most if thoes girls dieted and only like 2/3 actually have eating disorder just cuz there skinny doesn't mean they have an eating disorder

  • se ven mejor con mas peso TODAS!

  • This isn't from eating disorders...these people look different because they've gotten older.

  • i agree that people aren't naturally all meant to be the same size, but with that said, the people in this video are ones who lost significant amounts of weight after being in the spotlight, which leads to other assumptions. i don't want to label all of these women as anorexic/having an ed, but i think it's hard to deny societal pressure had a lot to do with their weight loss.

  • so who had eating disorder??

  • To everyone below, every woman in this video has stated that they've suffered from eating disorders at one point in time. JUST SAYING.

  • what the fuck are you talking about eating disorder this is NOT eating

  • Blame Twiggy! She started it ALL in the 60's. Bitch is STILL trying to make everyone look like a stick person.

  • this is a stupid video, you don't know anything..

  • Okay, just cause they had some work done or lost weight does NOT mean they have an eating disorder.

  • they look the same to me too

  • No hay mejor aderezo que la carne sobre el hueso... Sí señor...

  • The before and after pictures look exactly the same in every case. Furthermore, the women you're showing look absolutely gorgeous in the "after" photos just as they did before. They do not show any of the signs of true anorexia and look healthy and fit to me. Also, while I know that you made this video before Brittany Murphy died, it's in VERY POOR TASTE to continue to show her photo. Just thimk if you were her mother or what have you and you happened upon this video. Thank you.

  • is it just me...or are they all the same?

  • @TalkOfTheTown1234 I guess it just goes to show... we're all the same underneath... XD

  • Brittany Murphy definitely had an eating disorder. I don't care what they say her cause of death was, I think her eating disorder helped her life end early. How sad. RIP

  • Just cause you can see their damn bones doesn't mean they got a freakin eating disorder you moron.

  • TLC Unpretty R.I.P Left Eye. And anorexia and bulimea is a deadly disease. People should learn how to accept the way they are. Everyone is beautiful.

  • They look fine both ways?! think your just being picky 

  • There's on celebratory that i know had an eating disorder and that's Mary-Kate Oselin

  • Since when plastic surgery is eatig disorder?? :-P

  • Lindsay has a drug problem that is why she is so skinny,,The olsen twins they look terrible Very sad the pressure Hollywood puts on young stars to be "perfect" I think curves are attractive not bone thing.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Just cause sum famous folk are skinny doesnt mean they have an eating disorder

  • @322Megan ahhhh no, these are actual celebs with actual eating disorders- except nicole kidman- don't think she had one

  • you can usually tell by the skin

  • the only one that stood for me out was Lindsey Lohan but also to she looked better before with some actual flesh underneath her skin =P

  • they don't look that bad. but i get what you're trying to say. =)

  • I like how Nichole Kidman looked exactly the same...

  • I agree that black weon are naturally bigger... simple!

  • @candygurl092008 white women are bigger too, naturally. simple!

  • it u dont have a 6pack ur a fat fuck

  • @jdanielstr that is def not true

  • All of these women obviously knew how to eat at one point. What happened is they caved under the pressure of being famous and being asked to look thinner to keep up with the "jones's"...getting thin was their choice! If they didn't like that they were being asked to lose weight they could have just quit the business. They all have the money to stay at home the rest of their lives if they want. I find it very hard to feel any sympathy for these women.

  • i think that a lot of female celebrities have eating disorders. how can they not when the beauty standard in the fashion industry is a 13 yr. old girl? hell,i didn't look like that at thirteen!

  • Non of those people have eating disorders.

  • it's called botox, for most of them

  • Not all of these women have or have had eating disorders. It's not up to you to take a picture of someone who is skinny and and make the assumption that it is due to an eating disorder, which is a very serious matter and a term that should not be used so casually.

  • you forgot Demi Lovato

  • BEAUCOUP DE FEMME SUR CETTE VIDEO, NON PAS DE TCA. ET PUIS, C'ETAIT QUOI CE " HAHA " SUR L'IMAGE DE NICOLES RICHIE ? TU ES VRAIMENT, PITOYABLE.

  • Errr only like 2 or 3 of those people had eating disorders. Where's kate moss on this list?

  • umm. literally 2 people had/has anorexia on that slide. wow.

  • omfg they dont have eating disorders they are a nice size so shut the fuck up on how they need to relize how beautiful they r.

  • holy cows shit dude! they just werent smiling on some pictures and maybe loosed some weight and your all ''so sad that theyr so unhappy now and they look like skeletons D;'' gash...

  • really?? dont assume that they have an eating disorder because they are skinny. oh and lindsey lohan doesnt have an eating diorder i believe it due to doing drugs. get you facts straight.

  • how do you know any of them have eating disorders? most of the people here look exactly the same just at different angles. madness

  • @dmagalo thats because its called "SMILE FOR THE CAMERA"

  • Effect yourself or others in everyday situations and stop relying on youtube to send a message. DO IT YOUR SELF.

  • is the day ever going to come when we realize that we effect people?

  • I am 20 and 87 pounds and everyone always assumes I don't eat. It's ridiculous how paranoid people are about skinny people. I am naturally skinny and maybe so are these women. Get over it.

  • They look the same to me.. just putting that out there

  • hahahhaa this is funny , cause you say that "is so say to see how stunning they looked and how sad they look now" haha and in almost all the pics they look STUNNING AND HAPPY in the NOW photo!! lol, maeby you are the sad one

  • its called getting old

  • who cares what you look like on the outside! it's whats on the inside that counts everyone is beautiful

  • @teamjacobkg7 Can you get a bit more cheesy?...

    You know very well that society is not like that at all and almost no one thinks like that...

  • @MsJoana111 wow u just keep talking

    and i bet u have an eating disorder

  • @teamjacobkg7 keep on talking?

    Thats how it is.

    This has nothing to do with me,and no,I have no problems with my weight whatsoever.

    What i WAS saying is that your message is the perfect message:

    The one that should be reality.But its not,thats just not how a big persentage of people think.

    People are just judgemental!

  • Plastic surgery?

  • people change, get thinner, born thin- not everone has an eating disorder! i'm naturally thin and tall, and i'm tired of hearing things like "why aren't you eating?" "are you sick?" "OMG, you're so skinny, eat something" i eat, believe me. and celebrities eat too. they also work out, and have good genes bla bla bla- not all are anorexic.

  • @fachefichekuriza But some people are. Just be thankful you don't have to deal with such a disease.

  • I think all those woman are beautiful. It's okay to be thin. There is a difference and some women as they get older loose the baby chub and they just thin out. It happened to me and I am pretty healthy. Most people eat too much. Your body is far better thin than fat......

  • i dont think nicole kidman should be here

  • most of these people do NOT have eating disorders.

    hell, they look the same in the before and after pictures. quit being stupid.

  • people losing weight dont mean they have eating disorder -_-

  • You can't sit up here and assume they have eating disorders cause they've gotten smaller! Some aren't made to be meaty... >,> ...wow..

  • I'm pretty sure only like 2 of them had and actual eating disorder

  • i did not agree with this video....i understand it may seem like they're smaller and skinnier but that doesnt mean they have an ED...

  • @Cherrigrl317

    I agree. It seems they lost weight, but in many cases they look better "after".

    They say that slim artists look more attractive, and t4 make more money....

  • @OCEANQUEEN1 yeah...sadly thats true, which is probably why there are many cases of EDs these days :(

  • None of the 'after' pictures were ugly. They were still beautiful. Nicole Richi looked better after she lost weight.

  • Can't they actually suppress the urge to eat continually? Like, what if they go full, wouldn't that naturally stop the habit because that concerns both the physiology of a person (temporary inability for further metabolic workings) and the mental capacity to do nothing about food than repose

  • Lets be honest, nearly every celebrity has or has had some sort of eating disorder. These women do not have naturally skinny bodies, they eat very little and work out for hours a day every single day. They don't eat burgers, fries, chips, cookies, cakes, beef, steak, or anything but fruit and veggies. They get 1200 or less calories a day.

    They have so much pressure to be skinny it is insane, the stress to be fit is intense. An eating disorder isn't just physical, it is mental too.

  • I can't even spot the differences with some of these pics. Methinks the video be bs, serial.

  • Why don't we just curb stomp every stupid piece of shit that is drawn to this sort of exhibitionistic vomit. All you who are reading this are deserving of at least an hour of my special treatment for those who need to feed off the ones who have some sort of talent. Just let this sort of voyeuristic crap go and lead a decent life. If you can't do that, then know that you are the lowest sort of invertebrate and worthy of nothing but my contempt

  • People really need to stop assuming that everyone who's thin has an eating disorder....people are not naturally all meant to be the same size people!

  • @Kyasurin They are also not meant to be a size 0. Very few people are naturally that small and if you can see someone's rib cage then they are too skinny. If one eats enough, one will gain weight. NO one is magically skinny, they have to eat less to get that way. These women eat nearly nothing and exercise excessively because of all of the pressure they have. Don't be fooled by telling yourself they achieve that naturally. It's called eating disorders.

  • Comment removed

  • @MsAgnosticatheist I am naturally that skinny....I was just born that way. Some people are born small and you can see my rib cage. I eat normally (probably more than I should) and I am still skinny and I have always been that way.

  • @Kyasurin for years, I could eat night and day and still look like a skelleton....till i got older and my metabolism slowed down

  • @Kyasurin yes, i hate that. I am black female, and my friends sit here and say i am too skinny. I am 5ft8 and 135lbs...like WTF......i am healthy. Its ridiculous, i am normal , not skinny. Some people think anything less than overweight is too skinny. My bmi is 20.5....the lowest bmi for my height is 18.5 or 122lbs. I am in the a good place....

  • @sweet8015 i'm sorry, but what does being Black have to do with anything?

  • @nandi2112 well from my experience, previously hanging around alot of black people in general,..black people seem to think that the normal weight requirements don't apply to them because " they have more muscle and bigger bones"...also alot think that anything less than "thick" is too skinny. Not that at my weight and height i have only been labeled as too skinny by black people, everyone else thinks i am perfect. You can think I am stereotyping but it is a fact. I guess its a cultural thin

  • @nandi2112 furthermore even Tyra addressed this on one of her shows. After she lost the extra weight she gained, which now she looks phenomenal!...her family were all on her case piling food on her plate saying she was wasting away. She even admitted it was a cultural thing. Black people for some reason think women should have excess weight on them, and if they don't they must be starving in general.

  • @Kyasurin if you are rich (you can afford food) and underweight- YES you do have a problem....

  • Comment removed

  • I'm very skinny and I eat a bunch of junk food, I have a fast/high metabolism so I never gain weight, I can eat whatever the hell I want to, and it's frustrating that you can't be naturally skinny anymore.

  • @driisfree25 I totally agree, if ur skinny now a days its almost as bad as being fat, people (mostly females) are quick to stereotype us as anoxeric or drug addicts

  • @99BrownDog agreed. most of the US is fat now...68%! Anyone who would even be considered healthy or slender are in the minority and still it's perfectly ok for people to go around pointing fingers? Bullshit!

  • they look the same....

  • :( Don't jugde me /:(

  • lol @the music xD

  • Really? Let's just broadcast eating disorders of celebrities, a MAJORITY that are just skinny an don't have ED. This people, is horse shit and immensely offensive. Get your facts straight before taking the liberty to make a video about false eating disorders.

  • Half of these people don't have eating disorders. Probably more.

  • I don't agree with the end...some people are ugly fat, thin, normal size.....huh Kate Bosworth???:D

  • All right lets cut some slack. In the description they said they hoped they didn't offend anyone. It was a nice attempt.

  • They all look much healthier in the before pictures

  • @XMrsGMerrgoldX Theyre just younger and are naturally more plump. With time they just get skinnier so they can keep up theyre plumpness. Its Hollywood baby. NOTHING is natural. Stop thinking that just to make yourself think that theyre living a smiliar life to ours.

  • @MsKaki25 you still havnt changed my point of view. they looked healthier before.

  • Whoa, damn.

  • Nicole Richie definately looks better without all that extra weight

  • It ruins your face to be unnaturally skinny. When you get older, you need fat in your face to look younger.

  • not all of them have eating disorders, its called growingup! you get grow up and you get skinny and your face changes or you get into a car wreck or you get surgery! back the hell off!

  • @sellura hell yeah! i was thinking more "man, it's called getting old!" but growing up is more... politically corect...

  • i would still tap almost all of them

  • THEY LOOK THE SAME DUMMIES!!

  • yupp, most dont have ed.

  • COKE AND METH ARE POWERFULL DRUGS!!!!

  • All I can say is that's what an eating disorder looks like I wish I had one. I'm a fatty who wishes they had that will power. Having said that if someone has a genuine mental disorder like depression or BPD they have my sympathy.

  • @littlesmew no you dont. you want the willpower to criticize yourself 24/7 and feel dizzy and get heart problems cause of a "willpower". once you start an eating disorder it consumes your life. and it is never enough& you cant even see the difference. and it IS a genuine mental problem- if it wasnt it wouldnt be classified as one. i have sympathy for anyone whatever they may be going through. and also eating disorders come in all shapes and sizes.

  • They look the same exept the makeup

  • I think they look better skinny.

    

  • Damn cheek if you ask me! How dare you assume these people have eating dissorders!  There is hardly too much difference in the two pictures of each celeb and as people grow people change.

  • load of shit ...

  • this is the stupidest video i have ever seen.....

  • just cuz they are skinnier does not mean they have eating disorder

  • i am 5' 4", 85 lbs, 21 years old...and i'm healthy as a horse! sorry to say, but the uploader of this vid is probably a bitter fat chick who doesn't know the difference between a naturally skinny person and someone who has an ED. i'm super comfortable with my size, so FUCK U HATERS!!

  • @plz5430 ok, Im quite thin myself, healthy and athletic (i run marathons-loads of them)....I couldnt weigh 85lbs and i am 5 foot 1.....Im not a hater, I know everyone obsesses with what i eat and bla bla bla, but seriously taller than me and weighs less than I ever could....try gaining some muscle mass or something, its nicce to be thin and all but my life would suck if I didnt have a booty!

  • @plz5430 ok, Im quite thin myself, healthy and athletic (i run marathons-loads of them)....I couldnt weigh 85lbs and i am 5 foot 1.....Im not a hater, I know everyone obsesses with what i eat and bla bla bla, but seriously taller than me and weighs less than I ever could....try gaining some muscle mass or something, its nice to be thin and all but my life would suck if I didnt have a booty!

  • @plz5430 STFU, this is just somone showing concern. How do you think "bitter fat chick" makes you sound, compassionate?

  • I don't understand why they have to go so low.. They got the money to get a lipo. They own their own gym at their cribs . WTF IS WRONG WITH THEM ??? I could understand why a normal person would have an eating disorder . But When you have the money its just asking for attention in my opinion.

  • @batnana3 ur comment is ignorant on so many levels...

  • @clayschocolat Actually, the way you spell "your" is ignorant on so many levels. We learn English in school for a reason.

  • @RainbowNinja2014 why is it ignorant? should I be writing a comment on youtube as if I am writing a academic research paper? yes my grammar is bad...but who cares? its youtube for crying out loud.Maybe you should check a dictionary because ignorance has nothing to do with text message language. C ya l8ter!

  • ......wow...just....wow please dont procreate.

  • 0:33 coke inthe nose!

  • im 5'2 a lady and 165lbs i love me and dont care that bitches who starve try to force their size 0-5 on me.dont care. my heart and body is healthy. i eat right,exercise daily,drink good water im healthier than lindsay lohan and those mary kate ashley chicks and im poor. all that surgery and crap they do. just be healthy.i dont care if anyone disagrees with me you cant say its ok to be like them and their weight. those who have eating disorders need help.or they will kill themselves.

  • @chadmight Not all people think like you, people get eating disorders because of people, I'm fat myself and when other people are mean, it just makes me want to die but i just smile, and have done that so many times that it comes naturally out all the time, i start thinking how gross i am, and that started my bulimia, i've stopped and relapsed but eating disorders are much more deeper than getting thinner or food.

  • who is that at 0:25

  • @DAESHABBY05 Brittany Murphy...she died in december 2009

  • @awsome1014rl ohh thanx

  • @awsome1014rl what happened to her?

  • @xxxkama7xxx its nt definite yet bt i think it was a drug overdose

  • dieting is not an eating disorder, they have lots of money so why would they starve themselves. you're not even a doctor. psychic perhaps? lol

  • sad watching this now that Brittany's gone:(

  • honestly, some look better

  • 0:22 rip!

  • bullshit

  • yea this video was stupid none of them have eating disorders expect Nicole Richie n marykate Olson

  • yea this video was stupid none of them have eating disorders ecpet nicole richie n markate olson

  • all of these girls are fat

  • Most of these people do NOT have eating disorders. Get your facts right!

  • Cocaïne........

  • It hurts to eat :( I try and I try it just hurts

  • @56beautifullybroken hurts physically? or mentally? 

  • wtf the ppl just look trashier in the pic, but not thinner.

  • yeah i mean some people are naturally skinny because they have high metabolism its not like they can do anything about it

  • I'd hate to see Selena Gomez get an eating disorder. She'd be bones. Good thing she knows he's beautiful and a well grounded teen.

  • ...Its just them younger...i don't see there eye sockets pushed deep into there skull...=\

  • At whoever said homosexuality is a disease.... GET A LIFE