Hybrid Tech Energy claims "200% Efficient" water fuel cell by Dr. Steve Eaton

[HHOWatchdawg]

That's nowhere near a good LPM test! You guys are holding the bottle of water above the water in the bucket and flipping it over. HELLO?! Of course the water inside the bottle is going to run out past the hose. That's GRAVITY. Not HHO. You need to displace the water in the bottle under pressure into another container or build a test unit that holds the bottle under water until the HHO diplaces the air/water in it and makes the bottle rise to the liter mark.

[juanpazago]

1 liter in 12 sec. = 5 liter in 1 hour = 0.005 m3 HHO in 1 hour.

Lower Heat Value( 1m3 of pure H2 ) = 2.97 kWh ( kWh = energy units)

LHV ( 1 m3 HHO) = 2/3 LHV (1 m3 H2) = 1.98 kWh  ( HHO = 2/3 H2 + 1/3 O2)

Then: 0.005 m3 HHO ( 1 hour of this cell ) = 0.0099 kWh (LHV of the gas produced)

But:

12 Volt x 23.6 Amp x 1 hour = 283.2 Watt hour = 0.2832 kWh

Then:

Efficiency = 0.0099 kWh / 0.2832 kWh = 0.0349 this is 3,4 % ! ! !

[frank0067]

@juanpazago dude NEver GO TO TEACH MATH AS LONG AS YOU LIVE lol

[juanpazago]

1 liter in 12 sec. = 5 liter in 1 hour = 0.005 m3 HHO in 1 hour.

Lower Heat Value( 1m3 of pure H2 ) = 2.97 kWh ( kWh = energy units)

LHV ( 1 m3 HHO) = 2/3 LHV (1 m3 H2) = 1.98 kWh ( HHO = 2/3 H2 + 1/3 O2)

Then: 0.005 m3 HHO ( 1 hour of this cell ) = 0.0099 kWh (LHV of the gas produced)

But:

12 Volt x 23.6 Amp x 1 hour = 283.2 Watt hour = 0.2832 kWh

Then:

Efficiency = 0.0099 kWh / 0.2832 kWh = 0.0349 this is  3,4 % ! ! !

[CaptainD983102]

the flip empties the container of liquid but it seems suspicious as the emptying container HAS to empty be gravity since it is ABOVE receiving vessel.

[getreal155]

looks like a scam

[offyam]

ok... so what's the damn design?!?!

[Javadavida]

OK, I have a cell for sale. Anyone who wants to run their own test can buy it. If it doesn't perform over unity, I'll buy it back.

[ttsoares]

Anyone with real experience about hydroxy, bubbles, tests of LPM will be very suspicious about this video... The bottle is getting filled of gas in a rate not compatible with the bubbles shown before the bottle is flipped !!

[IM2L844]

My calculations show that actual unity would be achieved with an energy in to production ratio of 0.215 Joules per Milliliter or about 290 MMW. Even if your results were accurate, no credible university would have certified that as over unity. Your reported results are lightyears from unity. Current Efficiency, sometimes called Charge Yield or Faraday Efficiency is another matter. Anyone with a real Ph.D. in Physics would have already known this and made it perfectly clear.

[helzmcfugly]

this is 200% laughable. If you believe this crap to be truth you should buy the Happy handyman CD and put it on your Ipod while you hunt for unicorns..

[Javadavida]

Yours is the best and FUNNIEST response so far, fugly! I should be hurt but that unicorn hunting with an ipod visual is SOOOO hilarious.

Frankly, I'm in shock, too. After feeling performance improve and experiencing mileage go up on my 4runner, I really thought I was getting free energy. Turns out I was ONLY managing my energy resources better. I adjusted the timing and fuel ratio, changed driving habits.

BUT...Doc now has a certificate from CSU with test results on this cell at over unity!

[helzmcfugly]

been doing this a LONG time. I know what .5LPM look like and up to 20LPM looks like. and that looked like about .6LPM in the bucket and the bottle before he flipped it over. it might have been more belivalbe had he NOT cut film right as he calls "TIME" so we could see bubbles comming out of the mouth of the bottle to prove that it wasnt just sucking air from an open air source. I still say this is a unicorn chase. prove your claims with validity. this is nothing but trickery.

[helzmcfugly]

if he has a cert from CSU of over untiy he has just solved the worlds energy crisis. I would expect to see more then a youtube video with very very questionable "proof" of such claims. SO, where does this extra energy come from, an alternate universe?

[buckyohare420]

the aether, duh, lol, its probably possible, just the scientists trying are a bunch of back yard mechanics and universitys are too scared to fund such projects cause oil companies have armies to keep such things from existing

[daobradaloosh]

Exactly, this gas production test is the worst I've ever seen. One small hole in the bottom of the bottle and there you have your scam. Amazing that this video produces so much rumour. We all saw there was probably only 0.5LPM produced.

[h2opower]

From what I see it is not over unity but over Dr. Faradays said maximum results. To have something over unity requires more energy calculation than what I am seeing here. Like how much energy was used to maintain the temperture? What is the energy content of the gas collected? Is it 286kJ/mol or it is higher or lower? What is it's percentage of hydrogen, oxygen, water vapor, water gas, in the gas collected? These are the questions that need to be answered. Energy totals, sum in vs sum out.

[Javadavida]

I posted 4 more tests on the cell on my channel. Thanks for all of the discussion. Challenging test results is a good thing.

[ChrisManzi]

If you took high school chemistry (or physics), you'll realize how completely and utterly ridiculous a self-powering system sounds.

[LiquidChem]

@ChrisManzi that is because old physics is wrong. You would sound just as ridiculous 1000 years ago preaching to everyone about how the earth is a sphere, they would lock you up.  The earth is flat, stupid, and overunity doesnt exist. ok.

[frank0067]

@ChrisManzi don't you mean... if you look at tv and media also..

there is a number of self powered devices

[frank0067]

@ChrisManzi what it shows.. is institutionalize ignorance

[krazeekooladam]

Look at it before they flip it over to time it at :35

It is coming out so slow. It could not fill it up that quick.

[getreal155]

@krazeekooladam I agree. Only slow bubbing and suddenly 5L/min. Suspicious

[nadinka007]

The trick is here: there are very few bubbles coming out of orange tube right before he flips it over and then bottle empties at unrealistic speed for those bubbles. I have 30 amp 12VDC producing ~2.8L/min and if you were to insert output tube into bottle size like he has water would be boiling. Please dfont fool the public

[ttward2]

the bottle has a hole under his index finger thats why they stop the video short because there are no bubbles out the bottom

[cuke8466]

Good eye tt. You can also see the first half of the bottle is empty at 3 seconds, the second half takes 9 seconds. That would be 10 lpm for the first half of of the bottle and 3 lpm for the second half.

[btester1]

The original video is better.

[tfish0]

in your plans it called for distilled water, would that be more efficient? so what kind of royalty are we looking at if we generate energy with this?

[CarbideTip]

0:35 Does that look like 5lpm? No way.

[oystla]

Strange that this efficiency is achieved by pure DC and not pulsed as per Stanley Meyer, since this is very similar to Meyer tubes (if not exactly the same)

[oystla]

Very interesting. Please show us the design details!

12 volts, 23.6 amps and 1 liter HHO in 12 seconds ends up in 228% efficiency, well above what should be possible.

[gatekeeper1006]

Thats very impressive !!!

If I understand correctly he is using stright 12v DC, without pulsing.

I wonder what the temperature of the water is after several hours.