Say what you like about Fall Out Boy, but they shit all over Flyleaf's cover of 'Whats This'.. I mean she sounds like a depressed thirteen year old, sorry :)
the cd is freaking awsome !!!! the only 2 songs that are bothering me are "Whats this" , the vocalist of that song is SO boring !!!!!!!!!! Whats this is the happy song of the movie and she makes it SO boring sjeesj ,, + Oogie boogie song is catchy but no vocals =/ OVerall, Its a nice album to revisited to world of nightmare
Just thought I would ask......did anyone else (besides me) notice the spelling difference on Gabriella's name? It's spelled "Gabriella" ... on the back of the CD case, It's spelled "Garbriella". Where did the R come from!?!? lol. Sorry...it bugs me. And I don't think many people noticed.
Anyway, AMAZING CD!!! :D
Amy Lee, Korn, Rjd2, Marilyn Manson, and Shiny Toy Guns are my favorites. :D
WOW! Awesome CD. I normally don't like The Plain White Tees, but they did a really good job with their cover. And So Did Manson and Rise against and Korn and STG and Amy Lee. But wtf Flyleaf, I love them and I thought this was awful, and AAR did okay but I vocal needed to be lower. AND WTF WITH TOWN MEETING SONG???? I was like Whaaaaaaaa? The Insturmentals were BA!
Wow. Flyleaf sucked, no offense; Marilyn Manson did a great job; AAR... tried, but Tyson's voice just isn't creepy enough; Rise Against was good; Amy Lee's was really pretty; Plain White Tees were okay; and those are the only ones I really listened to, cause I've never heard of any of the other people on here.
And the Plain White Tees one And the Amy Lee one.... KoRn and Amy should have done their songs together for this cd.. their version of Freak on a leash was the SEX!!
I'm really dissapointed with Flyleaf. I'm a fan and they completley turned it around so it's not all "OMG! WHAT IS THAT?!" It's more like. "Oh look....it's snowing...I wonder what that is...I better find out so I can go home...." I'm sorry to say they ruined it like P!ATD ruined "This is Halloween." Korn and Amy Lee are freakin awesome though! =D
I really like the instrumentals. Korn, Rise Against and Amy Lee were really good too. Everything else is crap though. Flyleaf's What's This completely took the wonder and magic out of the song and turned it into something boring and depressing. I'd get it for the interesting instrumental interpretations though.
this video is awesome!!!!!!!!! gald i hear the perview its even better than i thought!!! now i got to have this!!! actually i'm going right no to bye it!!!
LONG LIVE THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
...... sory crazy fan of this,even went to Cali,LA Disneyland for the haunted manson LOL! was awesome though!
HOLY CRAP!!!!! THE VITAMIN STRING QUARTET!!! I LOVE THEM!! man... they're awesome.
to be honest... some of thses(or most i guess) songs have been killed. =[ sniffle.
but some of them are cool. i really don't like MM's version of this is halloween. but KoRN's was awesome!! XD I love the lalala parts XD hahaha!! End title was cool.
wow this is terrible - all of it... this is just a cheap way to exploit a great movie with pop culture....this nightmare trend is going to be laughable in a few years and it sucks cause its such a fantastic movie
Flyleaf were...Alright but in the movie Jack's really like =O OMG WHAT'S THIS and Flyleaf don't sound shocked at all they sound sort of monotone. The All American Rejects' cover is growing on me but still isn't half as good as the original. =)
all of these are good (for the most part) some of the instrumentals were a bit out of place, but it wasn't unbareable. TAAR kinda messed up.. i know their singer can do better than that.. and as much as i hate Fall Out Boy, their version of "What's This?" is better than Flyleaf's. (in my opinion.)
Korn & manson totally owned.The other artists did good.(some not so good) But you gotta notice this video is a responce to korns song, not the other way around.
Am I the only person that thought All American Rejects did a good job with Jack's Lament? It's a sorrowful song, it's not supposed to be hardcore like Manson's or Korn's songs, both of which were excellent. And the Yoshida Brothers? Hell yes!
And I like Flyleaf and all, but I thought their "What's This" was HORRENDOUS, much more so than AAR. And The Town Meeting Song and Jack's Obsession, two of my favorite songs from the soundtrack, were ABSOLUTELY BUTCHERED.
True. But even if it's not the BEST they could've done, it's still better than several other songs on this album, a few I mentioned already. But I DO like this song more than "What's This," which was done too slow and whiny for a song meant for wonderment and exploration.
Amy Lee was was the only good vocalist. The rest have a hate sound that don't bring deliver. The orginal soundtrack (which I have) is my best bet. Danny Elfman and the rest have better voices than these here.
I was soooo dissapointed with the last CD this one is great! Amy lee kicked ass and was the best no doubt! Flyleaf entertaining! korn was fun and awesome! rise againts was great! and all american regects and plain white T's sounded flat and had no emotion :( Im glad they kept marilyn from the last one he was one only one who did a good job! The instrumentals are well done! except i wasnt impressed with nabbed...and since when is the Oogie Boogie song instrumental? But Over all I LOVE IT!!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Nice: "Overture" by Devochka (Stupid but positive )) ) "This is Halloween" by Marilyn Manson "Opening" (Danny Elfman rocks!!)) ) "Doctor Finkelstein" by Amiina (Nice) "Jack and Sally Montage" by The Vitamin String Quartet (I like it a looot!) "Oogie Boogie's Song" by Rodrigo y Gabriella (No singing but not bad!) "Poor Jack" by Plain White Ts "Closing" by Danny Elfman (Of caurse)) ) Normal: Sally's song,Sandy Claws Sucks a lot: Jack's Lament,What's this,Jack's Obssesion.
All-American Rejects and Flyleaf suck anyway. Even in their own songs. Much less screwing up someone else's. Rise Against did a good job with their song and Manson's job was probably easiest since he got the coolest song in the movie. Jack's Obsession made me want to commit suicide. Korn did ok. That song never really was all that good. They did the best with what they had. Amy Lee was perfect for sally's song. Oogie boogie's song sounded good. The finale rocked. Overall it was average.
i think marilyn manson, korn and amy lee did the best on this cd! i heard fall out boy sing what's this n it sounded better evn tho i like flyleaf better.
I think the all-American Rejects totally killed Jack's Lament. Along with Flyleaf's Whats this. They're both just..bad. The Polyphonic Spree Ruined the town meeting song too..and I really liked that song!
Amy Lee's and Korn's cover r brill, sm of the others r alright, i dont know about the rest of ye but i personally thought that Flyleaf really messed up "What's This?"
the only good versions on here are manson's of this is halloween and amy lee's of sally's song. in my opinion the songs come beeter when they're done by goth bands.
OMG!! Amy lee's version of Sally's song is AMAZING!!!! Korn and Rise Against were AWESOME as well. But thats pretty much the only good songs on the CD.
I think Rise Against's version of Making Christmas is AMAZING, but I"m SEVERELY disappointed at the All-American Rejects and Sparklehorse. The music score covers are actually pretty cool.
Amy is my personal favorite of these tracks... and definetely followed by Korn!! But Flyleaf just sucked here...i do totally love them though, but Whats This? is my favorite song, and they just ruined it...!
Yeah, The AAR cover sounds horrible. It's so nasally. And Polyphonic Spree? What was that? Sparklehorse was...odd. But Amy doing Sally's Song in full is fantastic. :D
Wow, I personally think that the original songs are the best but these are pretty good... Except for The Plain White T's but I never liked them anyways... XDXD Yeah.. Well thats for putting this up! ^^
love love love the instrumentals. especially excited about the vitamin string quartet!! a few of the songs stray too far from the original for my taste (the polyphonic spree), but seeing how it is a cover cd i'll give them a fair chance.
I know! I don't know how you feel about HIM or Ville Valo, but even before I knew this cd was being made I thought HIM or Ville would do Jack's Lament SOOOO nicely!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I wouldn't buy it. The Korn and Flyleaf covers are pretty cool. And everybody's already heard the Marilyn Manson one. But, The Plain White T's and All-American Rejects totally kill it for me. I refuse to buy anything with their names on it.
totally agree with you about the all american rejects... they BUTCHERED jack's lament, one of my faves. but the plain white t's cover actually sounds like it could be decent.
Marilyn Manson And KoRn's Are Amazing :}
MeepzioXX 5 months ago 3
i like them...not all but some are actually good covers
richa78595 7 months ago
The movie is a million times better of this fucking cover so is the original songs
AngelOrDevl14 8 months ago
Stfu flyleaf recked nothing they are awesome nd their cover is 10000 times better than the movie
CheeseOnToast4538 1 year ago
@CheeseOnToast4538 i thought it was fall out boy :/
richa78595 7 months ago
they killed...the town meeting song...and flyleaf killed whats this.... *cries*
saisasori 1 year ago
jacks obbsession scared me, but making christmas, emy's lee's and korn's covers were really good, those are my fav
minty409764 1 year ago
I just realized, if Touchstone pictures is Disney, that means 10 things I hate about you is a Disney move 0_o
meganlikepie56 1 year ago
are they remaking this movie or something?
haldo89 2 years ago
I could rock to Rise Aginast. I love it.
Nekozukikyo 2 years ago
they should have put FOB's version of "Whats This?" on the album in my opinion Flyleaf sounds so dead..no pun intended
falloutgirl4lyfe 2 years ago
i luv the vitamin string quartet song!
LuckyAppleEye 2 years ago
the jacks obsession cover is terrible
warlockwolf88 2 years ago 15
I agree 100%
meganlikepie56 1 year ago
@warlockwolf88 it is isnt it? >_>
saisasori 1 year ago
eny1 gt downloa dlink
xxbbzx59xx 2 years ago
whoa! this is halloween is so awesome! gonan have to get this cd just for that song! other good songs will be a bonus
bloodyninja199 2 years ago
i love Mansons, Korn and Amy Lee's cover
flyleaf was..."ok"
it just shows that they cant do covers
ogalagirl 2 years ago 3
hot topic is a good place to start
ogalagirl 2 years ago
Say what you like about Fall Out Boy, but they shit all over Flyleaf's cover of 'Whats This'.. I mean she sounds like a depressed thirteen year old, sorry :)
blackxxxkeyblade 2 years ago 4
the cd is freaking awsome !!!! the only 2 songs that are bothering me are "Whats this" , the vocalist of that song is SO boring !!!!!!!!!! Whats this is the happy song of the movie and she makes it SO boring sjeesj ,, + Oogie boogie song is catchy but no vocals =/ OVerall, Its a nice album to revisited to world of nightmare
justafidemyself 2 years ago
you can get thr cd anywhere best buy , target anywhere!
TheIdioticShow365 2 years ago
.... What the fuck is Manson and Korn doing on a DISNEY album? LOL I'm surprised Disney even allowed the thought to materialize.
swissmongrel 2 years ago
So what ? Disney isnt all about hsm crap you know -_- get real POTC is also from disney
justafidemyself 2 years ago
BLEACH! Sparklehorse!
Everything else was pretty good though... Flyleaf could've been better. AMY LEE ROCKED... and RISE AGAINST
happyplantproduction 2 years ago
I love this!!! Okay some if it are not that good but when I've heard Amy Lee singing Sally's song I as blown away she IS Sally!!!
mcrfreak4life93 2 years ago
ah my gosh! i love this!!
destinygirl8 2 years ago
i like the this is halloween
arlismeandcamela 2 years ago 2
Just thought I would ask......did anyone else (besides me) notice the spelling difference on Gabriella's name? It's spelled "Gabriella" ... on the back of the CD case, It's spelled "Garbriella". Where did the R come from!?!? lol. Sorry...it bugs me. And I don't think many people noticed.
Anyway, AMAZING CD!!! :D
Amy Lee, Korn, Rjd2, Marilyn Manson, and Shiny Toy Guns are my favorites. :D
Heidikins017 2 years ago
I like
Marylin Manson's, Polyphonic Spree's, Sparkle House's, Korn's, Rodrigo y Gabrilla's, RJD2's, Plain White T's, and Datarock's version.
Thought you ought to know! =P
bjd020695 3 years ago
The PWT singer REALLY sounded like a young Jack
SpitFirejutsu 3 years ago
WOW! Awesome CD. I normally don't like The Plain White Tees, but they did a really good job with their cover. And So Did Manson and Rise against and Korn and STG and Amy Lee. But wtf Flyleaf, I love them and I thought this was awful, and AAR did okay but I vocal needed to be lower. AND WTF WITH TOWN MEETING SONG???? I was like Whaaaaaaaa? The Insturmentals were BA!
Funmosh 3 years ago
Marylin manson: Loved it.
Korn: CREEPY AND AWESOME.
Amy lee: The real Sally. I'm serious.
PWT: YES! Sounded like the real young jack
Roselupin13 3 years ago
bloody brilliant
i loved korns song! and amy lee
beutiful
miss5teen 3 years ago
Wow. Flyleaf sucked, no offense; Marilyn Manson did a great job; AAR... tried, but Tyson's voice just isn't creepy enough; Rise Against was good; Amy Lee's was really pretty; Plain White Tees were okay; and those are the only ones I really listened to, cause I've never heard of any of the other people on here.
xxsavethosekisses 3 years ago
I think Amy Lee and Plain White T's did a really good job.
Though I have to admit, I like Fiona Apple's version of Sally's Song better..
FullMetalStar 3 years ago
And the Plain White Tees one And the Amy Lee one.... KoRn and Amy should have done their songs together for this cd.. their version of Freak on a leash was the SEX!!
RandomActsOfAdolence 3 years ago
Odd.....in the 90's Marilyn Manson was practically considered the most evil face in the public eye...
nearly ten years later...he's in a disney album....go figure.
xlixity 3 years ago 4
why isnt the fall out boy version in?
desporf 3 years ago
what the hell happened to the town meeting song and the finale. totally effed up.
km2435 3 years ago
kate mosley let me down harrdcore with "whats this?!"...its more like "ugh...this." lol
LethalDossage 3 years ago
I really like Marylin Manson - This Halloween
KoRn - Kidnap The Sandy Claws
Rise Against - Making Christmas
Amy Lee - Sally's Song
Shiny Toy Guns - Reprise/Finale
xshadowsxbatx 3 years ago
korn one is simply amazing
zonfar 3 years ago 2
I'm really dissapointed with Flyleaf. I'm a fan and they completley turned it around so it's not all "OMG! WHAT IS THAT?!" It's more like. "Oh look....it's snowing...I wonder what that is...I better find out so I can go home...." I'm sorry to say they ruined it like P!ATD ruined "This is Halloween." Korn and Amy Lee are freakin awesome though! =D
GaarasGirlKomishi 3 years ago 2
i liked the fall out boy version better but thats just my opinion
peq2050 3 years ago
the best ones are
korn-kidnap sandy claws
flyleaf-whats this?
amy lee-sallys song
awsome!
grlygrlXnotXhardcore 3 years ago
Amy Lees Version was simply amazing, and so was Rige againt's Version.
The Flyleaf one lacks Enthusiasum.
cocobabby 3 years ago
I really like the instrumentals. Korn, Rise Against and Amy Lee were really good too. Everything else is crap though. Flyleaf's What's This completely took the wonder and magic out of the song and turned it into something boring and depressing. I'd get it for the interesting instrumental interpretations though.
nekonezume 3 years ago
The Polyphonic Spree one sounds a bit like Pink Floyd. My favorite was Flyleaf's and All American Reject's. Oh and Amy Lee's of course. Amazing CD!
JustWatching6 3 years ago
ugh, sometimes I just can't handle All-American Rejects. In this CD, they're so WHINY!
Kristiekins2 3 years ago
Yeah, but there's SO MUCH WORSE on this album. Why is AAR the only band anyone complains about?
Does the lead singer of Flyleaf know you can sing a song with more than one note? Because she sure as hell didn't show it in What's This...
DynamiteRaver 3 years ago
True that. I hate the Flyleaf cover. The cover that Fall Out Boy did of What's This is great.
Kristiekins2 3 years ago 3
i don't care for either of them
ilovkorntool209 3 years ago
this video is awesome!!!!!!!!! gald i hear the perview its even better than i thought!!! now i got to have this!!! actually i'm going right no to bye it!!!
LONG LIVE THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
...... sory crazy fan of this,even went to Cali,LA Disneyland for the haunted manson LOL! was awesome though!
itzybitzysamuria 3 years ago
wow. this cd SUCKS!!
good thing i didnt buy it. haha
the only good ppl on this were Amy Lee(of course), Korn, Plian White T's, Rise Against, MM, and i kinda liked Shiny Toy Guns...
megan248093 3 years ago
you should listen to all of the songs fully cuz in this they showed the sucky sides of it but there amazing mainly flyleaf!!!!
Eye8Cheesypotatoe 3 years ago
HOLY CRAP!!!!! THE VITAMIN STRING QUARTET!!! I LOVE THEM!! man... they're awesome.
to be honest... some of thses(or most i guess) songs have been killed. =[ sniffle.
but some of them are cool. i really don't like MM's version of this is halloween. but KoRN's was awesome!! XD I love the lalala parts XD hahaha!! End title was cool.
xThePianoHatesMe 3 years ago
I really like the remakes of the instrumental songs
everyonesinsane 3 years ago
wow this is terrible - all of it... this is just a cheap way to exploit a great movie with pop culture....this nightmare trend is going to be laughable in a few years and it sucks cause its such a fantastic movie
flippy11552 3 years ago
i totally agree with you! this new CD sucks so much.
i cant believe all of these new "trendy" teenagers are acting like nightmare is different... they need to grow up
onholiday14 3 years ago
it is a really good movie and i like it alot but i also think that this is a good pdate of the songs..most did pretty good..
fakemo21 3 years ago
Holy shit, a Plain White T's song that doesn't make me gag. It wasn't great, but it wasn't too bad.
Some of these songs seem pretty good. The other... eeh. Still, I think I'll have to get my hands on this album.
ComatoseMuffin 3 years ago 3
eww sparklehorse sucked hard.
blackrose423 3 years ago 2
ooooooo i want ;D
xMARKerPENSx 3 years ago
woah i think HIM would of done at least one cover cuz the lead singer, Ville Valo, loves this movie
but i really love all these covers .
xXWilleWaloXx 3 years ago
rise against's is definatly the best on this album...its actually good to listen to
WeeManProduction 3 years ago
The All American Rejects really do mangle it. :-\
mcrispini 3 years ago
Rise Against also did awesome :)
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
Awesomee. I think however All American Rejects and Flyleaf sounded a little flat. But Amy Lee, Korn, Marilyn Manson and everyone else did awesome.
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
I Agree , They really killed Jacks Lament =(
And Flyleaf TOTALY changed the interpritation of the song .. they really shoulda worked on tho's!!
BeenieS7evin 3 years ago
Flyleaf were...Alright but in the movie Jack's really like =O OMG WHAT'S THIS and Flyleaf don't sound shocked at all they sound sort of monotone. The All American Rejects' cover is growing on me but still isn't half as good as the original. =)
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
I MUST HAVE!!!!!!!!!!
devaJugene 3 years ago
all of these are good (for the most part) some of the instrumentals were a bit out of place, but it wasn't unbareable. TAAR kinda messed up.. i know their singer can do better than that.. and as much as i hate Fall Out Boy, their version of "What's This?" is better than Flyleaf's. (in my opinion.)
RogerShadows 3 years ago
AAR ruin Jack's Lament, no offence.
ValkyrieDeath 3 years ago
i buy this cd just for amy lee n korn
shigaara 3 years ago
i like manson's, amiina's, flyleafs, korn's, rise against's, yoshida brothers, and amy lee's
but thats just me
TaiZomg 3 years ago
this is halloween! sick song!
puckupob 3 years ago
Awesome album!
ShuguProductions 3 years ago
Korn & manson totally owned.The other artists did good.(some not so good) But you gotta notice this video is a responce to korns song, not the other way around.
Kornmang 3 years ago 2
I Agree with you. I love Korn And Manson. But, there were other good bands that did okay.
satanicbiotch 3 years ago
Am I the only person that thought All American Rejects did a good job with Jack's Lament? It's a sorrowful song, it's not supposed to be hardcore like Manson's or Korn's songs, both of which were excellent. And the Yoshida Brothers? Hell yes!
And I like Flyleaf and all, but I thought their "What's This" was HORRENDOUS, much more so than AAR. And The Town Meeting Song and Jack's Obsession, two of my favorite songs from the soundtrack, were ABSOLUTELY BUTCHERED.
DynamiteRaver 3 years ago
Your right right. Jacks lament is sorrowfull, but the voice dosent fit!! Listen to when whoever sings "Inside" and "something" Its to nasaly.
Kornmang 3 years ago
True. But even if it's not the BEST they could've done, it's still better than several other songs on this album, a few I mentioned already. But I DO like this song more than "What's This," which was done too slow and whiny for a song meant for wonderment and exploration.
DynamiteRaver 3 years ago
I totally agree
Kornmang 3 years ago
i loved the all american rejects cover it was brilliant
flyleaf did better than i expected, but thats probably because im not a fan
they chose some good bands
:D
korndog111 3 years ago
i 100% agree with you.
tim505153 3 years ago
1. making christmas
2. sally's song
3. kidnap the sandy claws
(IMO)
rez825 3 years ago 5
they should have had a7x do this is halloween or boogie's song
rez825 3 years ago 2
very true:P
korndog111 3 years ago
Korn rocked that \m/ and amy lee is awesome!
ToxicFear2000 3 years ago 3
Amy Lee was was the only good vocalist. The rest have a hate sound that don't bring deliver. The orginal soundtrack (which I have) is my best bet. Danny Elfman and the rest have better voices than these here.
technicolorfantasies 3 years ago
I was soooo dissapointed with the last CD this one is great! Amy lee kicked ass and was the best no doubt! Flyleaf entertaining! korn was fun and awesome! rise againts was great! and all american regects and plain white T's sounded flat and had no emotion :( Im glad they kept marilyn from the last one he was one only one who did a good job! The instrumentals are well done! except i wasnt impressed with nabbed...and since when is the Oogie Boogie song instrumental? But Over all I LOVE IT!!!!
nessag4188 3 years ago
AAR's suck.
Amy lee's Is the BEST!!! by a lot!!!!
futurebroadwaystar 3 years ago 2
i liked the korn song,/./
kornKoRn22 3 years ago
all american rejects did a horrifying job on jacks lament i liek whats this kidnap mr snady claw, sallys song adn this is halloween
FlyleafRox94 3 years ago
Rise against did their cover the best
MTLhcky28 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I really don't like what I'm hearing. Numetal and emo can ruin anything.
gunstar9 3 years ago
Flyleaf rocked!!! :D
RicardoRedefined 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They've made a mess of all the great Nightmare songs......they should have left them as thewy were....
towertooth456 3 years ago
I think flyleaf are great. but FOB's cover of what's this is SO much better
SuperAvarice 3 years ago
Amy's was the best...and plain white t's
violet147 3 years ago 4
i totally agree with you. amy's was the best :D
herochandlee 3 years ago
:D I also like flyleafs and plain white ts
violet147 3 years ago 2
whats this should have been done by fall out boy and this is hollween should have been done by panic at the disco
alphones67 3 years ago
lmfao I can't possibly take the AAR song seriously. Are you joking?!
Raven544 3 years ago
Omg. How much is this cd?
jsaactoabn 3 years ago
someone's ho have the complete disc? load it to megaupload, you do me a favor xDDDD
CabezaKubo 3 years ago
amys is the BEST!!!!! ^^
constantineofdarknes 3 years ago 4
*amy
constantineofdarknes 3 years ago 4
Flyleaf was amazing! I love them,aha,I just wish the rest of the song was happy like the ending is.
spacie21 3 years ago 3
exceptuading jack's obssesion and what's this, i like so much the rest of songs *-*
CabezaKubo 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
MissPumpkinJuice 3 years ago
All-American Rejects and Flyleaf suck anyway. Even in their own songs. Much less screwing up someone else's. Rise Against did a good job with their song and Manson's job was probably easiest since he got the coolest song in the movie. Jack's Obsession made me want to commit suicide. Korn did ok. That song never really was all that good. They did the best with what they had. Amy Lee was perfect for sally's song. Oogie boogie's song sounded good. The finale rocked. Overall it was average.
xXRazorbacksXx 3 years ago 3
Jacks Obsession sucks so much
felipelalo410950 3 years ago 2
i think marilyn manson, korn and amy lee did the best on this cd! i heard fall out boy sing what's this n it sounded better evn tho i like flyleaf better.
SoraxKairiLove 3 years ago 3
theyre pretty cool. Im so gonna buy this
littlefart123 3 years ago
And why the fuck did Flyleaf make "Whats This?" so sad? Its a cheery song when Jack is discovering the beauty of Christmas Town!
RiotMonster 3 years ago 4
they both sound about the same. Both Flyleaf & Jacks sounded similiar.
xtormented 3 years ago
i agree. it should be way more cheery.
SoraxKairiLove 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Rise Against raped "Making Christmas". Worst song I think.
RiotMonster 3 years ago
I think the all-American Rejects totally killed Jack's Lament. Along with Flyleaf's Whats this. They're both just..bad. The Polyphonic Spree Ruined the town meeting song too..and I really liked that song!
digiboy31 3 years ago
flyleaf's rox but all american rejects sux have to agree wif u on the all american rejects
FlyleafRox94 3 years ago
Amy Lee's and Korn's cover r brill, sm of the others r alright, i dont know about the rest of ye but i personally thought that Flyleaf really messed up "What's This?"
Blanka0 3 years ago 3
the only good versions on here are manson's of this is halloween and amy lee's of sally's song. in my opinion the songs come beeter when they're done by goth bands.
NocturnalSlayer 3 years ago 4
OMG!! Amy lee's version of Sally's song is AMAZING!!!! Korn and Rise Against were AWESOME as well. But thats pretty much the only good songs on the CD.
voicesofsolitude 3 years ago 3
Amy's song is the best
darklonleyheart 3 years ago 2
I think Rise Against's version of Making Christmas is AMAZING, but I"m SEVERELY disappointed at the All-American Rejects and Sparklehorse. The music score covers are actually pretty cool.
heatstroke2008 3 years ago 2
I still think Fiona Apple's cover of Sally' Song is the best from the last re-release of the soundtrack
VetTech08191 3 years ago
I agree
juvidoom 3 years ago
Amy Lee is the highlight of this album, its so amazing :D
penguinsrokmawrld 3 years ago 2
Amy is my personal favorite of these tracks... and definetely followed by Korn!! But Flyleaf just sucked here...i do totally love them though, but Whats This? is my favorite song, and they just ruined it...!
xXAkiiXx 3 years ago
Ahhhh to hear Danny Elfman doing the Opening and Closing..unbelieeevable..worth it for just that.
HessKarma 3 years ago 3
Amy and Korn are the highlights.
Marilyn was on the last soundtrack, with the exact same song, so thats not new, but still great to have him on the CD.
A lot of the covers were crap. Flyleaf, AAR, Polyphonic w/e, Sparklehorse...wth?
AussieEvanescenceFan 3 years ago 3
Yeah, The AAR cover sounds horrible. It's so nasally. And Polyphonic Spree? What was that? Sparklehorse was...odd. But Amy doing Sally's Song in full is fantastic. :D
Munchkin619 3 years ago
Wow, I personally think that the original songs are the best but these are pretty good... Except for The Plain White T's but I never liked them anyways... XDXD Yeah.. Well thats for putting this up! ^^
RikaxSetsuna 3 years ago
I think the guy from the Plain White T's actually tried to sound like Jack, I liked that.
PPrucha 3 years ago
Everything on the album I like except for these for songs.
1)All American Rejects cover sucked ball sack bad!
2)Flyleaf did a horrible cover in my opinion (and I like Flyleaf too)
3)Polyphonic Spree-- JUST PAINFUL! Seriously.
this was not a good song for them.
4)Sparklehorse equals Craptastic.
DizzyDarlin29 3 years ago 3
love love love the instrumentals. especially excited about the vitamin string quartet!! a few of the songs stray too far from the original for my taste (the polyphonic spree), but seeing how it is a cover cd i'll give them a fair chance.
vladdy73 3 years ago
The Marilyn Manson cover is my favourite. I CAN'T WAIT TIL COMES OUT!
TheseColdDecembers 3 years ago
All American rejects are BRUTAL at singing Jacks Lament!
CandyCloudsOfLulaby 3 years ago 2
I know! I don't know how you feel about HIM or Ville Valo, but even before I knew this cd was being made I thought HIM or Ville would do Jack's Lament SOOOO nicely!!
Phantomofthe0pera 3 years ago
they started selling it early here!!! omg.. i bought it.
JordiekinsxxReal 3 years ago
Incredible cover by Amy Lee =P
AiiirwaveS 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I wouldn't buy it. The Korn and Flyleaf covers are pretty cool. And everybody's already heard the Marilyn Manson one. But, The Plain White T's and All-American Rejects totally kill it for me. I refuse to buy anything with their names on it.
1Good1Apollo1 3 years ago
totally agree with you about the all american rejects... they BUTCHERED jack's lament, one of my faves. but the plain white t's cover actually sounds like it could be decent.
vladdy73 3 years ago
I need this xD
nikkiroxsox13 3 years ago 7
I want to buy the cd.
^^
elisabethmuniz 3 years ago 5