Added: 11 months ago
From: TEDtalksDirector
Views: 82,490
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (243)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This doesn't really investigate what language is or how people learn language. Unless I'm missing something, it's just recording feedback loops that children use to get the phonemes just right. It seems like the son already had the meaning of 'water' he was just sounding it out until he got the word just right. 'Gaga' can mean water just as much as 'water' means water.

  • outstanding

  • One of the coolest things I've seen on TED. Amazing!

  • that is insane :D

  • Incredible!

    

  • 4:55 for awesomeness.

  • Message; stop watching the TV till they start putting out some positive and empowering subject material.

  • I find this to be the most impressive research being made at this time.

  • JERSEY SHORE. Mainstream people.

  • @Cardister you hipster :p

  • @sqbsbear lol

    

  • 4: 20, 17:20, 18:08. Wow!

  • I do see how this is relevant to anything, hes trying to link media with peoples conversations, fantastic. we know people talk about that's on tele, that's nothing new.

  • wow

  • wow, he videotapes himself. amazing.

  • @scuzzulus lol. at you

  • @localfox1000 lol, i just read the description. this is actually a pretty good study, i take back my comment. i thought he was just creating some kind of family archive.

  • Incredibly dry talk and subject matter. Who _didn't_ know that a lot of people watched the state of union address and spoke about it as opposed to some random TV sitcom?

  • Interesting

  • absolutely profound and will change the world forever.

  • Real life Sims game.. :D

  • i thought the guy was the midget from willie wonka

  • Erm is anyone else taking MASSIVE issue with the maths here? The guy says he's recorded 250,000 hours of video/audio of his child's development. Let's assume for argument's sake that the cameras and microphones were on 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. There are 8760 hours in a year - which means he should have over 28 YEARS worth of recording!! What gives??

  • @hmspinaforethisisspa Maybe he had more than one camera?

  • @dskloet ohhhhhhh..... my bad :/

  • @hmspinaforethisisspa Yes, but you are right that he still took "poetic liberty" with the math just so he could say "almost a quarter of a million"!

    90K hours of video PLUS 140K hours of audio is 230K hours of data (so sometime only audio was recorded). Assume there were only the 9 x cameras and mics that he showed, and that video always had audio, you only need to use the 140K to calculate. ((140K / 3 years) / 365 days) / 9 mics = 14 hours audio per day.

  • @exyex the difference between 230k and 250k isn't that much of a difference

    and he didn't say almost a quarter million. he gave the number estimate for simplicity because a quarter million is easier to imagine than an abstract number.

  • @hmspinaforethisisspa

    he said he recorded 8 hr/day if u listen carefully once agaun u can hear it

  • I don't follow TED talks or scientific research very closely, but to me this just feels downright revolutionary. A truly remarkable (and incredibly personal) exercise in data analysis. Watching this was an inspiring way to start my day, and fittingly enough it was a social media comment that brought me here.

  • I got a feelin somebody's watching me...

  • without a doubt among the most incredible things i have ever seen.

  • Pattie maes and several of her staff were killed in feb 2010 by military personnel tracking her for the electronic harassment of usa citizens when she was caught doing an unauthorized scalar hypnotic session on a usa citizen

  • its a shame that we live in a time when we see something with this kind of potential or a massive node in progress and we immediately fear misuse by govt. or any agency. Its time responsible scientists took over the office (i emphasize 'responsible')..

  • beautiful work in the hands of good, powerful and amazing. In the hands of evil though it will be the same. Wait for mass influence and "programming" done by the governments to instigate huge social movements such as protests and even revolutions in countries they intend to gain control of. Once they learn the cause and effect relationships with all this data, forget about it. It will be down to an exact, predictable science. Be aware!

  • And then the government bought his technology to fight domestic terrorism...

  • OH. my god. this is beautiful.

    See the difference here? I wouldn't let the government touch this data, but scientists, that's prefectly cool.

  • @greengrendel Scientists are usually government sponsored - and clearly part of the education system - thus part of the government.

  • @tokotokotoko3

    but there's a difference between those who actually govern and those who's paycheck also happen to derive from taxpayer money

  • @greengrendel Scientists and Ron Paul.

  • OH. my god. this is beautiful. I'd look at this stuff forever. 

  • Paranormal Activity 3

  • Someone should call a doctor... I believe he's having a seizure...

  • @myassishappy someone should call a teacher..I believe you are an ignorant.

  • tl;dw

    

  • ok, I know Im being pcky, but, if your going to due a seminar like this, at least invest in a proper soundman. The mic is litterally on edge of screaming feedback out throughout the whole video! Message me, Hire me. I can at least tell when the highs need to be cut a little...lol

  • This was mind blowing! Awesome work... from baby's first words to word-of-mouth, to social media. You covered it all from childhood to maturity... the path of communication!

  • how is this not a glorified Big Brother experiment?

  • @Tolstoievsky because this is a guy obsessed with learning how we communicate and learn language through his child and not a corrupt government infringing people's rights to privacy in an attempt to curb thought control and rebellion?

  • @MNSDaz means are the same tho.

  • love how this is shared in the same way as described in the actual clip

  • How can ANYONE dislike this?? Where did the 14 dislikes come from?? 14 people who have a phobia of water!

  • So MIT. How much DOD or Homeland Security funds went into this research?

  • Thinking about speech developing on such way is just amazing; very innovative.

  • lost me when I saw he watched Jersey Shore

  • The feminists keep bringing TED down and the Desis keep pushing it back up again

  • so steady..

  • ted back with a vengeance

  • why does this have so few views? This was freaking awesome! What adds to its magnificence is the very personal and human element that so much research is lacking in today. Bravo sir, bravo!

  • data visualization and analytics overwhelms me ....

  • a new renaissance is in the air :) i can taste it in the air.

  • hahhaha i love the ending! magical indeed

  • if this technology reaches the hands of governments it could be used in ways to impede change.

  • Damn. This is as legit as it comes.

  • I would love to record my whole life! Without those cameras though, haha. My parents did something I love. When I was a kid they would out of nowhere just randomly start recording something every few days. So unlike most families, we didn't just have video of us all lined up and stuff; we had video of me playing with my siblings or my dad talking about airplanes over the dinner table. Too bad most of the tapes are destroyed and cannot be played back.

  • Wonderful!

  • Amazing research, but I hope the practice of blanketing a home with cameras doesn't become widespread. It really would be an invasion of privacy, in my opinion. Small children do not have the ability to understand this, and frequently have no power to change such things if they do disapprove. Any legal recourse by Child And Family Services to prevent such an occurrence, obversely, might easily lend itself to abusive interpretation.

  • Amazing!

  • fantastic

  • Not very interesting at all.

  • BEST TED TALK EVER!!!!!

  • This would be worth it just for the 3D fly-through of the house, but the language part is pretty awesome!

    TED FTW! :)

  • so a quick calculation, he recorded his house 5 years which costs 200 terabytes of storage meaning 100 years would be 4 petabytes of storage... we need bigger hard-drives! XD

  • Hey, any idea how many Terabytes of raw data in these boxes?

  • @kanifoli

    around 2:00-2:05 it says 200 terabytes

  • Wow! He's doing it!

  • The 12 people who disliked this are the ones who ruined TED for a while.

  • Wow, that was amazing.

  • The way the footage was put into a 3D projection is amazing!

  • A very very elaborated way of doing experiment: :)

  • WOW! AMAZING, yet scary?

  • Comment removed

  • @streetstaruk Scary how someone with not so innocent intentions (like a government ), might use his algorithm to collect and use more effectively data from us ,to maybe be able to better control the general public,or maybe for social engineering .

  • @KladionicaCity

    how do you think is paying for mit ? 70% pentagon funding

  • @KladionicaCity exactly why im scared. when does any new breaking technology like this, that has such an insight into how we act, speak, live and generally BE, not end up in the wrong hands for a perverse use?

  • Comment removed

  • @Bc2astThese little sociology experiments like this are just to help us understand more about ourselves.

    It's interesting, for us anyway.

    it doesn't effect you personally in any way. Well other than the fact that people around you who are learning things from this are going to be getting smarter. No biggy.

  • It's really great to see that TED is finally getting back on track with its standards.

    Please TED, don't break it.

  • i bet if you graphed his son on that TV & social-media graph space, he was actually just watching a lot of Lady Gaga.

    And wasn't talking about water at all.

    heh.

    oh well at least he's well hydrated

  • @roidroid  hahahahaha.

  • wow. brilliant.

  • this man is brilliant.

  • Isn't it the longest and most complex experimental research/study in psych field? Pure study!! :)

  • this is called original research. what a commitment!

  • What about privacy?

  • @stephenetienne

    biG brudder sez: priv-a-WUT!?

    :(

  • spastic

  • Social media just hit Mach speed!

  • good

  • Wow! Mind-blowing! Love TED! Keep on!

  • I want this software on Youtube, so I can read 20000 comments at the same time.

  • @coltharpphilip why?

  • just finished reading the 20,000 comments. Good question

  • Get that boy some water!

  • Do they have cameras in the bedroom...for y'know...

  • Best clip ever ... thanks for sharing!

  • I love data but its never been so beautiful until now!

  • holy moly!

  • Fascinating, but also a little unsettling. Seems all to useful for engineering or controlling social dynamics within a society or market.

  • they allow men on TED now?

  • Amazing.

    This actually proves my theory, that if we stop following the mainstream media we stop to amplify and to perpetuate the outdated way of thinking, which is the actual thing that damages the humanity and the planet.

    If we want to evolve we have to accept new ideas and new values. And fallowing tv only perpetuates the old values of egoism, utilitarianism, competition, crave for revange and justice, consumerism, etc, etc. that are desasterous.

  • To Deb Roy, how much did it cost you to install the video cameras and record 90k hours of home video? How much do you think it would cost today? I seriously would like do this in my home.

  • Speachless.

  • Wow this TED was already way over my expectations before it was half way through.

  • TED is amazing!!! It wasn't the firt time I cried watching a TEDtalk.

  • omg it reminds me of when i was a young kid i was imagining that i am leaving a string behind me and when i go back like on my way to school i need to go on the same string and collect it :D but i dont understand the point of the reasearch...

  • this is amazing. if anything it shows the true strength tv/media have over our lives. unplug and lets have those conversations without the tv playing middle man and take our minds back.

  • All that data is really sexy! lol!

    All the new technologies really allow us to collect tons and tons of data. We really need to catch up with ideas like these to find new ways to use them and make sense of them.

    I can understand people who fear this... data understanding is a powerful tool. And it's only realistic to say that some people will try to use it the wrong way.

  • those camera's are incredible, so much data and so many things you could find out about yourself from them.

    the fly-through 3d visualisation is pretty damn cool too

  • Beautiful

  • That is a horrible idea. 

  • great speech. and great visualized.

    finally true sience back on TED

    really a idea worth spreading.

  • that is science

  • "Wow" Now that is devotion to science and research! Amazing piece of work! I cannot wait for a published paper. This is phenomenal!

  • Fascinating stuff. According to my mother, I was speaking in complete sentences by the time I was 9 months old. I was skeptical until I heard a friend's baby speak almost an entire sentence ("I good girl") at 2 1/2 months. I noticed that this baby did what I do - look at people's mouths, rather than their eyes, when they speak - and wonder if there's a connection.

  • Now THAT'S what I'm talking about!

  • Finally a TED talk with technology and engineering in it again.

  • BIG BROTHER IS BORN!

  • @thecritiquestudio Big Brother was born in 1984 [1949] :)

  • can you say....ttthhought police

  • dude walking is so cool lol

  • Finally an idea worth spreading. 

  • to bad dictators use science like this against us ey

  • "Hi NASA I'm Deb Roy, a MIT researcher, can I borrow your computers for a moment, I want to do something actually useful with it"

  • Great. thats the beauty of scientific method, to discern  whats going on. I wonder how much more people would know exactly about natural phenomena that we normally take for granted.we are very lucky to live in times of robust research.

  • TED TALK OF THE YEAR BY FAR...

  • i think this is beautiful. it gives us wonderful insight into how speech works. how important words are.

    Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.

    Margaret Mead

    know we know how tht is possible. since words push people to action.

  • @OldSchoolSkill That sounds more like torture than research.

  • I can't even find the words...

  • Don't see the point of this

  • That was amazing.

  • Wow

  • Awesome science......useless practicality! Dont get too excited folks!

  • @dannywizz By having a robust model of language development, we can derive better methods of foreign language instruction, as well as overcome language barriers for deaf and autistic children. This is ultimately what needed to be done, because, as seen here, a word is developed not just by a history of conversation (so you can't only follow your kid around with a tape recorder) but by space and context. This makes it clear why bilinguality is dependent on the child using one language per person.

  • Holy crap, that's some complicated research!

  • one of the rare videos where i wanted to like it more than once as the video progressed...

  • thats some quality work !! but what will the Govt regulators do ? they will tout this system to be put up in every home, for "our own safety" (of course), at our cost, to monitor us at all times. maybe i m just paranoid !

  • Whats wrong with the video. He looks like is twitching at 7:03

  • i wonder if they recorded the sex...

  • I knew someone could make total invasion of privacy awesome and something people will want.

  • I didn't really get the point he was trying to express with this talk, anyone care to explain it in a few words for me please?

  • 15.08 a piece of poosie

  • he said vertical twice

  • THIS IS TED!

  • THIS is what TEDs all about :D

  • Crap

  • The magic starts at 4:55

  • @TheScienceFoundation Nope. According to him the magic happens then (12:28).

  • Anyone remember that movie 'Deja-vu'? 8:00

    This guy's data is freaking beautiful...

    I love graphs now.

  • Anyone remember that movie 'Deja-vu'? 8:00

  • This research will at some point be used to manipulate and control humanity, most likely to get us to enslave or kill each other.

  • @Bocbo How ignorant and the fact that you 2 thumbs up is sad. This research will help us better understand human minds and the reason for what we do, say and think.

  • @MasterCoolX3 The true ignorance is to believe that understanding "human minds and the reason for what we do, say and think." can and will not be used by tyrants and the enslavers of thier own kind.

  • @Bocbo Maybe somewhat true but I doubt humankind will be enslaved.

  • could this be called meme research?

  • Fantastic talk, definitely one of my favorites to date. Data gathering/sorting/displaying is one of the most important things for technology right now. Keep up the good work, MIT ^.^

  • is it any coincidence that the baby-learning-language-graph appeared more like mountains whereas the tv-content graph appeared more like discrete skyscrapers? 

  • @xjustamem0ryx Not really a coincidence, just the nature of the data. The first graph was based on where the baby was, and in general areas it gradually curved upward or downward. In the second graph, their position doesn't mean anything. I'm sure they could put it in a way so that it looks similar to the sloping of the first graph. For that they'd probably have to make each "stack" the same area (i.e., not based on how long the tv show or whatever is).