Added: 2 years ago
From: nana443
Views: 69,248
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (212)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Judges need to wake up and cop on

  • That was amazing! What the hell judges?!

  • those judges have no common sense that was amazing! keep singing hun :)

  • i thunk she thought all the boos were towards he when they were actually towards the judges

  • Her voice is amazing!I don't understand...

  • HA HA! :D

  • Lol

  • i thought she was good!!!

    mabey the judges didnt like the song choice??

  • @SophLolable1

    trying to be loli when not in Japan is unacceptable.

  • Her voice is perfect the judges buzzed cause of the song and the costume! Who cares!!

  • I love her dress, it's adorable!

  • American children don't cry and American judges have hearts...

  • @1:21 is that the lady that plays Colleen Smart on home and away??

  • Her singing was really good , the song doesn't matter ... Pff... KEEP SINGING LITTLE GIRL :)

  • she wasnt even a bad singer. actuallly, just the opposite. she was really good

  • Poor thing, they probably just made her never want to sing again. and her grandfather who just passed away is the one who taught her how too. YOU WERE GREAT SWEETY, DONT EVER GIVE UP!!!!! xox

  • She seems like a good singer, but I find she shouted the song. That's why the judges X'ed her (that's just my theory). I'll admit, I had to turn the volume on my computer down when she started to sing. If she controlled her voice more, she would have been perfect.

  • lol she went to my primary school, and to all the people that think that the judges are mean...Well there are many other younger childen that get 3 X's but they dont run off the stage and stop the show they take it with pride and dont give up on their dream, plus if they let ever kid under 10 into the competition thats not to fair for ever one else.

  • well,Emma it's your fault that your a bad singer

  • what makes it even more heart breaking is the fact that she was doing it for her grandfather who taught her to sing, and he'd recently passed away.

    They could've at least her finish the performance, give her feedback and give her a simple 'sorry, not today, but keep trying'

  • they buzzed her cos she was singing a sexually inappropriate song. listen to the lyrics: “let me be your loving teddy bear. put a chain around me neck & lead me everywhere”. thats why 1 of the judges asked who chose that song for her, he was worried

  • 1 word RUBBISH

  • That's awefull!! She was really good for a nine year old, they could at least let her sing the entire song!! And the 'did you choose that song' questions... they wanted her to say she was forced to sing and dress the cute lil girl act!! Stupid judges!!

  • O.O

  • Shes real good! :O How...in the world ... did she got crossed??? :O :O :O What the fudge???

  • i like the way she says "I don't wanna do it anymore"

  • that's cruel i dont understand why they buzzed her out she's so good

  • she is so good

  • how old is she?

  • australians are stupid with no talent,stop the show

  • @momaDOOCE20 Shut up racist, if anyone's stupid it's you and the judges

  • she was so good

  • she was so good you such juges

  • nawwwwww. i feel so sorry 4 her. STUPID JUDGES ;p

  • she was really really good why buzz her?

  • she was awsome the judges were kind of hard core : /

  • im cryin my head of :'''(

  • i watched this 8 times, i didnt see anything wrong...someone plz tel me where this lil girl went wrong thank you

  • i watched this 8 times,i really don't see anything bad about her singing...someone please be kind enough to tell me where she went wrong.

    thank you..

  • she lives where i live! i remember singing lollypop in stockland

  • by the way the crowd was mooing on the third judge buzz, look behind him when he buzzed and listen when she started crying all were cheering her lol ...i think thats wat happened

  • i like her voice

  • i actually thought she was really good.

  • poooorr thing!

  • Theyre mean they shouldve let her through to the next round atleast shes got yalent and shes so little give her break

  • this made me cry myself.

    did she try again??????

  • Poor Lil girl, cryin like that, i'd be upset too :(

  • OMG did she die??

  • she wasen't all that bad. :|

  • haha the kid deserved it sooner rather than later i say

  • that is so sad. i watch all the variations of this show from america to australia and australia by far has the worst set of judges. so rude! she's only 9 years old.. my god!

  • she is excellent why the hell did they buzz her ?

  • Poor her

  • I swear the judges have gone insane? So what, she can change her clothes, she can do another song, but are they deaf? She is obviously talented.

  • I no its sad but she has to be prepared for this.

    She has talent and she will be coming across wah worst stuff then this in her life

  • You cant learn to sing, you have to be born with being able to sing

  • let her finish first!!!!! and then say whatever you wanna say!! she is just a child!

  • let her finish first!!!!! and then say whatever you wanna say!! she is just a child!

  • let her finish first!!!!! and then say whatever you wanna say!! she is just a child! 

  • let her finish first!!!!! and then say whatever you wanna say!! she is just a child!

  • let her finish first!!!!! and then say whatever you wanna say!! she is just a child!

  • why didnt she get through! she was great they should of said ur through but wear something a little more ur age or something hoe mean :[

  • I remember this girl , she was so cute, but the judges were so mean. I hope she succeeds in her dream

  • WHY DID THEY BUZZ HER? SHES AMAZING!

  • she is better then me!

  • i'd like to speak with emmas mum please!! ems voice has a good tone.

  • I don't get it, maybe it is because english it is not my native language, but why did they all buzz her????

  • @madridcc the little girl thought she wants good enough and ran offstage upset but mainly the judges just didnt like the song choice and the costume a little bit ... Great Voice but the song wasnt the best choice ... costume could of been a little different to shes got a husky voice but i still liked her attitude and i didnt mind the song

  • I think they should have given her at least some credit because it took alot of courage for her to perform infront of millions of television viewers.

  • She wasn't that bad. But it does seem like she didn't choose that song.

  • Comment removed

  • Omg she was so good why the heck would they buzz her

  • aww tht almost made me cry how rude those ppl need 2 get a life

  • @MusicCRAZY1515 They have a life. They tried hard to get to where they are. They would not be judges if they let everyone pass just because they were young or cute or something.

  • fskdfjswdfoiwdj

  • Red is the devil im not kidding

  • i dont think i would have buzzed her cuz well like for a 9 year that was pretty good i mean really it seams like all the mean judges for these shows are on the sides haa cuz like when simone was on it was simone and pearce and then these two haa

  • Comment removed

  • She was local karoake level good. But her timing was off and she didn't hit the notes exactly. Although quite capable of winning local talent shows, she really didn't have any national level talent. I think it's harsh for her to face the three Xs from the judges, but I do think that they had valid reason for all agreeing she had no special talent worthy of becoming a semi finalist on a national show.

  • omg i actually started crying when she was crying ; that was so sad :( ; poor girl

  • Wow those are some bitchy judges! :-) Not even Simon from American Idol is that bad.

  • she sang very very well!! they buzzed her cuz THEY didnt like the look. thats mean! they couldve told her that they didnt really like it, send her through to the next round, and tell her what they would like her to sing or something like that!

  • i kind of see why they buzzed her off....not to be mean or anything but she was kind o bad... but she was ok

  • She may not have been great, but that was uncalled for. I was so surprised they all buzzed her. I thought she was good.

  • Those judges were awful.

  • OMFG she is really talented I love her voice! she has somthing that the jugdes DONT have and thats TALENT ! (: (Y)

  • why did they do that???? the judges were probaly just jealous.

  • why did they do that???? the judges were probaly just jealous.

  • there so mean wats going to happen to her now

  • i say yes for her acting LOL that was sick :))!

  • i think i cried more then the girl :S.

  • i fell very sorry for herrr!!

  • emma rulez

  • She has talent, but the judges were right. Costume didn't fit with the music, and it wasn't quite what you would expect from a girl in polka dots and curls. Some work needed to be done. I'm glad Danni called time out to explain and encourage the young girl.

  • She has talent, but the judges were right. Costume didn't fit with the music, and it wasn't quite what you would expect from a girl in polka dots and curls. Some work needed to be done. I'm glad Danni called time out to explain and encourage the young girl.

  • they should have let her finish she was not that bad

  • she got more talent then the juges

  • @skateryara the judges are so mean i was going to write that too

  • these three judges should be fired from the show.

  • LAWLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

  • go see emma under emma boxsell singing her own way

  • go and see emma under emma boxsell singing her own style her own way

  • Dannii was jelous, kid was better than her

  • they kind of judged her by how she was dressed and the coice of song..your supposed to judge her by her SINGING!

  • She is too young to handle that kind of rejection, the show annoys me how some ppl suk and get through....they could have atleast let her finish and just say not today. jerks.

  • The judges weren't mean at all, a child should not have cute politics applied at all to competition. I agree completely with them, and you know what? She's not a bad singer at all! She's really good for her age, and she is such a brave little girl. I hope she doesn't quit singing just because of her first disappointment, because she really does have genuine talent.

  • Children shouldn't get privileges but she wasn't bad.

  • it was just the wrong song for her the judges should be able to buzz out kids or people that are appluasing the person , the judges should be ashamed of them selves

  • thats so mean!!! poor thing

  • she deserved it and it was mad funny lol

  • lol thats was funny

  • but she was good!!! why did they buzz her??

  • naww thats sad, im very worried becuase i dont want that to happen to me. i mean i do believe in myself and so does my family but if it does happen ill try to hold myself together (:

  • LMFAOOO :P ahaha poor thing

  • atleast tom gave some constructive critisim and advice and dannii comforted her and told her it not the end of the world! but red was sooooo mean! i thought she was pretty good anyway!?

  • omg! she freakin ran off stage! i feel so bad 4 her! i should feel guilty for it being sorta funny tho. but not that bad. she looks really sad tho.

  • Isnt Dannii the best judge in the world?? :) LOVE HER!!!!!

  • aww so cute..she was really good!!..those judges are soo mean!!!go emma keep singing ure a good singer..

  • i thought she wass very good that poor thing

  • For a 9 year old I thought she was really good! And a hard song to do. She was a gorgeous kid and wish the judges could have a been a bit more considerate of that, even SImon wouldnt have done that!!!

  • they are so mean! -.-

    poor little girl! : (

  • I thought her outfit was cute, her voice needs work. i felt sorry for her. Red was very mean to her, he's meaner they Simon on BGT. Hope she come back.

  • awe, thats so sad

  • She was pretty good!

    at least Dannii showed some concern!!

    x

  • poor thing!

  • i thought that was absolutley adorable i don't know what was wrong with that pefrfmance

  • That was beyond cruel... that poor ittle girl.

  • Australians....what do you expect...

  • well , it is show buisness, but like she sounded very confident, i guess no one told her she will ever fail, but she wasnt a bad singer , the judges did over react , but so did she

  • I think it is refreshing to see a 9 year old dressed like a little girl for once and not done up to look like shes much older. I dont know why everyone is complaining of the costume, it is just that, a costume. Regaurdless of what she wore she has got talent and should have been put through.

  • awe that broke my heart :(

  • ohh. that was so mean!

    poor Emma

  • 2:32 was funny when rede (however his name is spelt) was funny with his face

  • thats mean saying her face is funny she is the bravest girl i have ever seen and i would do the same thing but now i think i will stay rave now she has inspired alot of people

  • 1:25 hahahahahaha!!! her face is the best!

  • that is so rude!!! she's just upset, one becuase they buzzed her and two becuase she thought they were booing her! don't be so mean!

  • im going to be going on australias got talent this year, and i mean like if i dont get through cos im singing.. i mean like yeah it will be hard on me but then ill just go back :)

    but she was pretty goood.

  • go see emma under emma boxsell to see her own songs

  • that was bitchy

  • Wow, buzzing a child ... and then saying 'that's show business'.

    Some people just don't get it.

  • the hair, the costume, silly. The voice was great actually. I hope she comes back.

  • this judges are nuts this girl sing great those judges let pass guys with silly talent and this porr girl not

  • poor little girl

  • that was wrong i thought that judge on talent not what a child wears, i thought she had a good voice

  • omg why did they do that!!!

  • Esta usted con jury es fantastic

  • ok so she wasnt great but u dont make the poor girl cry i mean she is only 9 come on i think she did ok

  • shes good

  • They should have given her the chance to go through and to pick a new song to sing! She looked like she was having so much fun singing that song though!

  • Emma Boxel is the most beautiful, most talented little girl i know. She went on the show to try her best and thats what she did. It's definately a shame that they didnt put her through because she works so hard and would definately raise to the juges expectations. I luv u em, ur my insparation! luv ya..... Nat xoxox

  • You rock, Emma and very nice voice! You do a great job :-) Good luck.

  • You're a great singer ! .. Please , don't stop singing :)

  • shes a good singer!

  • I cannot believe the judges could be that horrible to her! She was great!! They didnt need to 'X' her that's just over the top, she's 9 for goodness sake. Well anyway, i wish I could sing like her!

  • I honestly loved her voice, great work Emma! Hopefully you'll keep on singing! :D

  • she was really good but ddnt like the song much..... nice of dannii to go and talk to her tho

  • Thats absolutely discusting!! Judges...yes thats showbiz and yes shes not that fantastic...however she is only 9...wats 1min!! they could have waited then told her NICELY that it just wasnt her competition......No respect for ALL 3 judges!!

  • Being from a "showbiz" kinda background...yes you can get rejected....I felt that was worse than rejection!! it was appauling! I felt sick watching that clip...they need to remember yes its a comp and yes there is rejection but She is only 9 years old!! My respect for all three judges have gone!!

  • She walked onto the stage, and her parents let her. And they all knew what it could be like.

  • great singer but......

    she should of chosen a better song

  • go see emma under emma boxsell on you tube

  • I love Danni !!!!

  • that is soooooo mean that was good for her age

  • it was alright. but i think they 'x' it cause it was abit corny. and it think cuase it looked too stage with the dancing and the outfit and all.

  • i mean 1.22

  • love the ladies face in 1.33 in the orange. LOL

  • go see emma on you tube under emma boxsell

  • Aww I really don't know why they all pulled the 'x'. I thought she was good. They should have just told her why after instead.

  • shes good!!

  • I know Em have since she was 3. She is a good singer

  • she looked so cute when she stopped singing and just stood there but its true, its part of showbiz

  • lololollololololololololololol­olLOLOLOLOLLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL­LOLOL OWNED LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLOL­OLOLOLOOLlloololololol ROFL ROFL ROFL ROFL LMAAOOOOOOOOOOO

  • go see emma on you tube under emma boxsell

  • LOL @ THIS!

  • Emma is Awesome!

  • ohhk .. the whole point of australias got talent is for talent lol and she has a lot to practice but they still should of let hr sing first and then told her noo in a nice wayy not just imbares her like thatt

  • That's the show though, if they don't think she can go any further there is no point in buttering her up, it is a hard business and to learn that and get back up from it will be one of the best lessons she will ever learn

  • look at emma boxsell in you tube to see her sing her other songs

  • omg that broke my heart </3

  • OMG the poor lil girl!

    They never should've buzzed her, just told her no. Poor lil girl

  • the judges were so mean to Emma i reckon they should bring her back like they did last yr to that 13yr old boy