Telstar

[hsteiner0729]

you got your private answer cs164...

[computersolutions164]

It looks like the bloke here does not like anyone criticising his interpretation of Telstar, which is why he "approves" comments before "allowing" them to be viewed by other, who the hell does he think he is then ?

Sounds like a coward to me, who cannot take criticism of any variety.

[computersolutions164]

No offence but, Why is the tempo, rhythm and key wrong on this. It's close though.

The rhythm is to slow and the treble should be higher, it was deliberately recorded to sound "scratchy". I just checked it on my piano and all the F's sharp which would make the starting key Bb, for a piano.

The tempo acording to the original score is 150 and I can only see 1 key change. the rhythm is described as 16 beat studio beat, very similar to a fast ballad sort of

Hope this helps

John

[hsteiner0729]

It's an interpretation. Do you know what that means? Or are you into just copying or sampling everything with no hint of originality? Spread your wings and learn how to grow!

[hsteiner0729]

Something tells me that your piano teacher cries a great deal...especially when you play.

[computersolutions164]

The drum beat on this is so "synthetic" it hurts.

It's accurate as far MIDI goes but not as the song was intended to be played. I have the full score of it somewhere.

These days I only use MIDI for learning what I am told to learn. MIDI had a baid rate of 9600 CPS, which makes everything too synthetic. No pianist I know plays at speed, with computer accuracy.

[hsteiner0729]

After reading your comments I think I finally understand the phrase "ignorance is bliss." If you knew anything at all about music you would understand what an interpretation and improvisation is; also when a song is done realtime and NOT MIDI! If you simply search on YouTube and find the most recent version of Telstar by the original band and watch it, you'll see how much they suck!!! They insult themselves. Try not sitting on your shoulders and come out and see the light of day.

[computersolutions164]

I know precisely what an interpretation and an improvisation is and no my piano teach never cries when I play. She shouts when I get it wrong but never cries. she also whacks my knuckles with a ruler, but it gets you too play correctly. She is however a professional taught by Joseph Winegarten at Sidney Smith School of Music, London. I guess she knows her stuff. I'm not ignorant either. I have the original vinyl of this tune (Blue one)

This MIDI version does not do it justice. MIDI never does !

[hsteiner0729]

Maybe Ignorance Determines Intelligence (MIDI)...that seems to be your mantra. Some people can't tell real from programmed. Must be the sores from the ruler.

[computersolutions164]

Don't forget the original sound / song / cmposition was dione by the late Joe Meek. The cuurent line up of Telstar as in the band minus mr Meek, will only be able to adapt the tune accordingly as in interpret. The thing is their interpretation is a sight better than this!

[hamesh3474]

sucked yuck

[vudukungfu]

very close to the original, though

[hsteiner0729]

thanx

[g105b]

dodgy MIDI song. watch knights of cydonia video

[hsteiner0729]

not midi

[procrustesuk]

The original is much better.

[hsteiner0729]

listen to them now

[computersolutions164]

Agreed !