@stj2013 she isn't screaming thats called belting, Eden is the best at it. Most of the others don't have the high range that Eden has so they can't hit those notes.
@jewey896 it's about a girl who tried to find her father to finish off the lullaby that her father started to write. I've not seen the show but own the soundtrack. Just buy the soundstrack, honestly it's amazing!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
her annunciations are a little annoying ... SHE sings too BREATHY and Honestly too screamy... its actually worse in Wicked... she sounds sweeter here..
also, its really cool how they show her growth...she puts a youthful tone into her singing at the beginning...then she undoes her hair and adopts her true, mature tone. an absolutely stunning performance!
Eden's actually just amazing at doing character voices have you ever noticed? She has a Glinda impression that could send Cheno running, and in Maureen and Elphaba you can always here in her dialogue moments where she slips into an Idina that's scarily similar
In Diana's version she sings the body of the song in A major with a modulation to Bb major. I don't know if she ever sang it in the same keys as Eden. B'way Divas frequently have their music re-arranged to suit their voice tessitura even if it is only a half step difference. Still both versions (from live shows) are great so pick your own favorite but range wise Eden has the edge. Hope this explains the key issues for these versions.
From what I read in reviews was that the story wasn't very strong and somewhat cliche. They said that the show's only good thing were the singers' powerhouse voices and the creativity of the set and costumes, but everything else was weak. I don't know. I personally love Eden and Karen, but I never got to see the show.
Ive tried to find more about this musical and not found much till now. Apparently it had 27 preview performances and ran for 284 performances. That's not so bad, is it?
Cleaned up some rude comments; they won't be tolerated, people. If you're going to criticize, do it constructively. And anyone who is here for the purpose of flamebaiting is going to have their comments promptly removed.
Okay, she totally beats Diana any day. Diana's voice is still beautiful, but her performance is downright boring compared to Edens! Eden puts in constant emotion, she's a pleasure to watch as well as to listen to. It's a fantastic performance, not just a great voice.
Are you referring to the part where she sings ooo NNNNCCEEEE upon a time.. like.. after the second key change? Because having sung this song... it's an octave jump. F# to F#
I've heard a lot about Eden and her roll in this play. This is the first I've seen and heard a clip of her in it. No doubt she is great but I saw Diana DeGarmo in this play live and Diana can also be seen performing this song on another You Tube channel. IMO Diana delivered an equally awesome performance as Eden's. Go see it, Diana can give you chills with this song as well.
Yes, but that's actually quite standard. It has to do with a person's vocal structure... Every time a new girl goes into Wicked the entire score is completely transposed. And unfortunately Eden got a bad case of vocal nodes after this and Wicked. I'm certainly not taking away from her talent AT ALL -- it's more a comment about how Broadway has become more about who can hit the highest note w/out any regard to vocal safety.
not even nearly. EVERY woman sings it in the original key. The score has never been taken down ever, for any woman, and I know this for a fact. It might be common for long running shows who stunt cast people who can't sing so they transpose the score, but NOT for Wicked.
@kenny6446 LATE RESPONSE, but I have known of ONE Elphaba to sing a part of DG in a lower key, Zoe Gertz. But she's the Australian understudy, and not a lead.
Where did you get your information?Professionals DO NOT transpose the scores when a new person comes in. Compare any professional videos of Wicked. The're all sung in the same key. The only time I've ever heard of this happening is when Taye Diggs filled in for Fiyero for about 2 weeks, and I understand it was an emergency and Diggs filled in on short notice. And where did you get your info about Eden's voice and nodes? I'll ask her next time I see her about it, but I'm pretty sure thats wrong.
I also heard that Diana sang it in a lower key as well. This was a while ago and I don't remember where but just thought I'd back up this person's claim that this is a rumour, at the very least, lol.
I'm not musically educated though so perhaps someone who is can watch Diana's version also on YouTube and be able to tell us if it is in fact a different key.
You sure? I went back and looked at the video and practically every person who had any idea and commented on it said it was 1/2 a step lower.
Apparently, she sang it 1/2 step lower on most occasions but sometimes sang it in its original key (you can find recordings on youtube of her singing that version too)
Here's the story: In this version Eden sings in 3 keys starting in Ab major (the prelude chorus). Then in Bb for the full chorus version with a modulation to B major for the last half chorus.
I wish I could've seen Eden in this role. I saw Diana, and while she was good, she oversung too much. Eden doesn't over sing and she has more control over her voice.
She's amazing but you gotta give credit to the composer too. It's a great song that needed a great voice to sound good, but still composers are always overlooked.
She is sooo much better here than in Wicked.. She cannot do this in Wicked for some reason.. she just doesnt quite connect to it like she does here...
I agree witch wickedLAcastlover. SHe connects with the peice here as she does with wicked. Her wizard and I blows me away every time I hear it. She also seems, to be the charatcer here and in Wicked. She is a true talent and a true talent can be vercatile as she is.
I agree witch wickedLAcastlover. SHe connects with the peice here as she does with wicked. Her wizard and I blows me away every time I hear it. She also seems, to be the charatcer here and in Wicked. She is a true talent and a true talent can be vercatile as she is.
Love me some Karen.
This was beautiful.
ale96000 2 months ago
How she didn't get a Tony nod for this I have no idea.
TheatreFilmBuff 3 months ago
screlt that shit
stewartyu 4 months ago
Eden is a goddess! I get chills everytime i listen to her sing! She makes me smile! (:
TannerAusbun 9 months ago 2
Listen to that gurrrrl belt! Dayum ;)
gracejenkins 9 months ago 2
I think she's great but shes a little to screamy at parts. Natalie Weiss never screams
stj2013 9 months ago 2
@stj2013 she isn't screaming thats called belting, Eden is the best at it. Most of the others don't have the high range that Eden has so they can't hit those notes.
Sharen10 8 months ago
:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D I LOVE HER. The end.
iamclery 9 months ago 3
Eden has CRAZY EYES at 3:37 like she knows we're watching. LOL!
sleepyguy1717 10 months ago
The very end. So legit.
wickedphant0m 1 year ago
she is a goddess
bellarosebisous 1 year ago
Can someone please explain to me what this show is about?!?
jewey896 1 year ago
@jewey896 it's about a girl who tried to find her father to finish off the lullaby that her father started to write. I've not seen the show but own the soundtrack. Just buy the soundstrack, honestly it's amazing!!
minihobo89 1 year ago
That last riff. Oh dear Jesus yes.
theshowtunesguy 1 year ago
OH ONE MORE THING
WHOA. EDEN'S LEFT HANDED. I JUST NOTICED/REALIZED. WHAT THE. I NEVER KNEW THAT! haha, Eden's specialll! <3 ;)
d0ggylover21 1 year ago
@d0ggylover21 How do you know she's left- handed?
tdonset08 1 year ago
@tdonset08 at 0:15 seconds when she starts drawing on the chalkboard you can see that she's using her left hand, not her right ><
d0ggylover21 1 year ago
Will Eden ever tour with this show? Even in small venues?
Oh, and congrats on your Engagement!
randyhingram 1 year ago
TELL ME, WHY IS EDEN SO AMAZING & GORGEOUS? it saddens me :( lol ;)
and she looks hella cute in those little pigtails :D haha i <3 Eden!!! :D
d0ggylover21 1 year ago
She's incredible. Just incredible :D
Merina2222 1 year ago
I cant help but comment that Eden in this Once Upon a Time looked a little like Rinoa Heartilly from FF8. x)
Eden is amazing, eee. <3
nunchakugirl 1 year ago
she has such a powerfull voice! <3 i love her!
MuSiCLoVeR6930 1 year ago
Aw Eden is "wickedly" awesome :D she's so amazing and cute
nothingspecial245 1 year ago
Does anyone know the context of this song in the show?
samerz816 1 year ago
whats that last note?
GirlCalledMike 1 year ago
She has SUCH a great voice.
txtingtbone15 1 year ago
This is such a gorgeous song!!! I love her!! Saw her as Elphaba the 1st time i saw WICKED, her DEFYING GRAVITY made my mom cry, IT WAS SO AMAZING!!
HappyMadisonDude 2 years ago
OMG! her mom is Karen Olivo!!!!
musicdork5 2 years ago 14
@musicdork5 so Karen was 2 when she gave birth to Eden?
tipofmytongue1024 1 year ago
@tipofmytongue1024 noo they mean in the musical Karen Olivo is her mom.
jewey896 1 year ago
@jewey896 oh lol my bad.
tipofmytongue1024 1 year ago
She lookes ridiculously like Idina Menzel here.
I have a theory Eden Espinosa is Idina Menzel's daughter from the future. She's reprised all of Idina's roles, and they look alike.
Roflb3rryPwncakes 2 years ago 7
That's a fun theory if in that Theory Idina somehow passes on to her daughter more talent than she ever possessed herself.
TBon3Supl3x 2 years ago 3
@Roflb3rryPwncakes Hahah and where would you put Lea in the family line?
gabriellecorinne 1 year ago
... Another child. Idina's baby with Josh Groban.
Roflb3rryPwncakes 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
her annunciations are a little annoying ... SHE sings too BREATHY and Honestly too screamy... its actually worse in Wicked... she sounds sweeter here..
syworld82 2 years ago
she is phenominal in this and especially in WICKED!
100Jordy791 2 years ago 5
there will only be one Brooklyn and that is Eden Espinosa
oldfrippy 2 years ago 7
@oldfrippy DIANA DEGARMO
wls250 2 years ago
thats not karen. definitely eden
evennsteven0219 2 years ago
Ok. So I'm trying to figure out how this song was modified for the tour. This song starts in B-flat major and modulates to B major, correct?
bwaygammagurl 2 years ago 2
Yes you are correct. Bb to B major.
braintreecat 2 years ago
Eden is actually my best friend's cousin! :D She's amazing
LeopardMonkE 2 years ago
Vocal damage? I love her voice but I think she pushes it too much sometimes.
Tennisnimrod 2 years ago
Is that Karen Olivo????
Eden is so good XD
TIFTTofficialchannel 2 years ago 17
Yep, that's Karen!
feline0favenueB 2 years ago 6
aaaah cool beans :-)
TIFTTofficialchannel 2 years ago 5
indeed it is.
kernal01 2 years ago 3
also, its really cool how they show her growth...she puts a youthful tone into her singing at the beginning...then she undoes her hair and adopts her true, mature tone. an absolutely stunning performance!
neverdegreenify 2 years ago 8
Eden's actually just amazing at doing character voices have you ever noticed? She has a Glinda impression that could send Cheno running, and in Maureen and Elphaba you can always here in her dialogue moments where she slips into an Idina that's scarily similar
TBon3Supl3x 2 years ago 3
oh my gosh. i'm familiar with the song, and i wasn't expecting that last riff at all. amazing!!! =D
neverdegreenify 2 years ago 2
LOVEEEE HER!!!!!
SillyCruz 2 years ago 3
In Diana's version she sings the body of the song in A major with a modulation to Bb major. I don't know if she ever sang it in the same keys as Eden. B'way Divas frequently have their music re-arranged to suit their voice tessitura even if it is only a half step difference. Still both versions (from live shows) are great so pick your own favorite but range wise Eden has the edge. Hope this explains the key issues for these versions.
braintreecat 2 years ago 4
Does anyone know where I could get the karaoke/instrumentals for this song?
tydotto 2 years ago
WHAT A FUCKING AMAIZING VOICE!!!! LOVE EDEN!!! Love her in Wicked too!!!
chchrj 2 years ago 5
Eden is great
Xeria 2 years ago
It was a great show - it was trashed by the critics but the audiences loved. It didn't have time to get a following.
bsabino 2 years ago 2
i dont understand why this show did so bad
it was absolutely amazing
badaily 2 years ago 3
From what I read in reviews was that the story wasn't very strong and somewhat cliche. They said that the show's only good thing were the singers' powerhouse voices and the creativity of the set and costumes, but everything else was weak. I don't know. I personally love Eden and Karen, but I never got to see the show.
MateoG7788 2 years ago 6
OMG.
Eden is just amazing
i love her
she's the best....
this gives me the goosebumps
sixhuitneuftrois 2 years ago 7
she is amazing!
OceanSunRise4 3 years ago
How well did this show do on broadway since it closed? I'm curious because I'm a big Eden Espinosa fan.
mani1239 3 years ago
It flopped. Terrible reviews.
hateleyfan123 2 years ago
it did indeed flop but i saw the last performance of it on broadway, and LOVED it
sondheimfan088 2 years ago 2
Ive tried to find more about this musical and not found much till now. Apparently it had 27 preview performances and ran for 284 performances. That's not so bad, is it?
perfectestperson 2 years ago
3:42 she looks like shes looking straight at the camera.....
"i see you!!!" lol.
BroadwayGirl939 3 years ago 3
oh wow...
iheartwicked91 3 years ago
I saw this show on Broadway at the Kids Night on Broadway event. I saw Eden as Elphaba when she was the standby for Idina Menzel.
broadwaymike92 3 years ago 3
Eden is my favorite theatre actress!!!!
wickedLAcastlover 3 years ago 7
WOW eden is just amazing in every musical
jdthemindfreak 3 years ago 8
oh yeah
sixhuitneuftrois 2 years ago
wowza! shes amazing!
i loooooooooooooooooooooooove her voice!
so jealous!
sillyjilly679 3 years ago 6
flawless!
JustDANCE9506 3 years ago 4
ugh so good
shorterac989 3 years ago 2
Eden draws a beautiful heart at 1:49 =)
But goodness, this video never gets old! Great.
alynn234 3 years ago 2
i love the clapping with the camera at the end.
awesome stuff.
nashley2867 3 years ago 2
insane!
BroadwayDreamer89 3 years ago 2
It scares me that she hits that note even better than she did on the pro shot video!!!
Eden's the best female voice I have ever heard live! No doubts about that!
greenelphiexoxo 3 years ago
I'm pretty sure Eden Espinosa owns my entire life right now. LOVE.
beautifullytraagic 3 years ago 4
i need this sheet music. like, now. hahaha.
broadwaybabe99 3 years ago
Cleaned up some rude comments; they won't be tolerated, people. If you're going to criticize, do it constructively. And anyone who is here for the purpose of flamebaiting is going to have their comments promptly removed.
EdensLast 3 years ago 7
@EdensLast HOW CAN THERE BE ANY RUDE COMMENTS????? SHE'S AMAZING!!
~Ure
YoUreTube 1 year ago
She's amazing!
I had to sing this at my stage school... she makes it look so easy!... it's not. :P
LauraaaaOx 3 years ago 2
Oh my God her voice gives me chills
SingsterofMusicals07 3 years ago 4
is there any insanely high note that eden espinosa can't belt? :D absolutely amazing!
ajp22689 3 years ago 6
Okay, she totally beats Diana any day. Diana's voice is still beautiful, but her performance is downright boring compared to Edens! Eden puts in constant emotion, she's a pleasure to watch as well as to listen to. It's a fantastic performance, not just a great voice.
WildQueenie 3 years ago 5
She is amazing!!
Sippiforrmysoul 3 years ago 2
wasn't she in wicked?!
she's amazing.<3
broadwaylove52 3 years ago
yes, she was Elphaba in Wicked first on Broadway and then in LA. Eden's awesome!
puppypersonLOTR 3 years ago
OMFG! A flat to F sharp!!!
i think i just died...
gatomusik 3 years ago 3
lmfao
italiaababii13 3 years ago
i completely agree
iamluvele 3 years ago 2
I AGREEEEEEEEEEEE
amazing :)
better than diana sorry
I LOVE EDEN I SAW HER IN WICKED LA SHE WAS fantabulous
shes the best elphie ever. love youuu
iamluvele 3 years ago 8
Are you referring to the part where she sings ooo NNNNCCEEEE upon a time.. like.. after the second key change? Because having sung this song... it's an octave jump. F# to F#
rds020790 3 years ago 2
I've heard a lot about Eden and her roll in this play. This is the first I've seen and heard a clip of her in it. No doubt she is great but I saw Diana DeGarmo in this play live and Diana can also be seen performing this song on another You Tube channel. IMO Diana delivered an equally awesome performance as Eden's. Go see it, Diana can give you chills with this song as well.
snailracer100 3 years ago 2
if diana sang it in the same key, id be impressed...but her version is at least a step lower.
MazoStyle 3 years ago
Yes, but that's actually quite standard. It has to do with a person's vocal structure... Every time a new girl goes into Wicked the entire score is completely transposed. And unfortunately Eden got a bad case of vocal nodes after this and Wicked. I'm certainly not taking away from her talent AT ALL -- it's more a comment about how Broadway has become more about who can hit the highest note w/out any regard to vocal safety.
pildo2000 3 years ago
actually nearly every woman in wicked sings it in the original key...
elphbwckd 3 years ago
not even nearly. EVERY woman sings it in the original key. The score has never been taken down ever, for any woman, and I know this for a fact. It might be common for long running shows who stunt cast people who can't sing so they transpose the score, but NOT for Wicked.
kenny6446 3 years ago
@kenny6446 LATE RESPONSE, but I have known of ONE Elphaba to sing a part of DG in a lower key, Zoe Gertz. But she's the Australian understudy, and not a lead.
She is still phenomenal though. (:
nunchakugirl 1 year ago
Where did you get your information?Professionals DO NOT transpose the scores when a new person comes in. Compare any professional videos of Wicked. The're all sung in the same key. The only time I've ever heard of this happening is when Taye Diggs filled in for Fiyero for about 2 weeks, and I understand it was an emergency and Diggs filled in on short notice. And where did you get your info about Eden's voice and nodes? I'll ask her next time I see her about it, but I'm pretty sure thats wrong.
aelievense 3 years ago 2
People from Telsey Casting as well as Clemmens and Tara Rubin... unless they were making it up, which I don't think they were.
As for Eden, that's just what I heard from people who worked with her -- you're right, I can't claim personal knowledge on that one.
browniiz76 3 years ago
did you ever find out if Eden had /has vocal nodes, I hope she's ok
vangeles 2 years ago 4
I also heard that Diana sang it in a lower key as well. This was a while ago and I don't remember where but just thought I'd back up this person's claim that this is a rumour, at the very least, lol.
I'm not musically educated though so perhaps someone who is can watch Diana's version also on YouTube and be able to tell us if it is in fact a different key.
perfectestperson 2 years ago
Diana was sick at the time.
TheGreenBean14 2 years ago
You sure? I went back and looked at the video and practically every person who had any idea and commented on it said it was 1/2 a step lower.
Apparently, she sang it 1/2 step lower on most occasions but sometimes sang it in its original key (you can find recordings on youtube of her singing that version too)
perfectestperson 2 years ago
Here's the story: In this version Eden sings in 3 keys starting in Ab major (the prelude chorus). Then in Bb for the full chorus version with a modulation to B major for the last half chorus.
braintreecat 2 years ago
wow. Eden is amazing.
This made me cry =P
BroadwayLove727 3 years ago 2
i saw this from front row and it was AMAZING
DOLLYPOPS 3 years ago
She is so great!!!!! She makes me want to see this!!!
alfa8544 3 years ago
Eden is amazing @ playing a little kid! :D
Wicked8DefyGravity 3 years ago 4
LOVE LOVE LOVE the pigtails, Eden!
wickedelphabafreeek 3 years ago 5
I saw Eden in Brooklyn and Wicked during her standby days as Elphaba.
broadwaymike92 3 years ago 3
what a voice eden has!
juliamurneylover 3 years ago 5
I LOVE this show... Absolutely love it. Eden is incredible
BeautifullyWicked23 3 years ago 5
I really wish I had the opportunity to see this show. It looks fantastic.
phillieboy 3 years ago 5
i was just thinking that today when i was watching it
xBarb 3 years ago 3
incredible!
xBarb 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
this video is awesome
ephimer 3 years ago 9
Aww, at the "MOMMY," I just want to give Brooklyn a hug! that breaks my heart!
:'(
ihaveavlog 3 years ago 4
goosebumps at 3:41 looks like she looking right at the camera, man I love this show, thanks for posting
EclecticPkm 3 years ago
I love this song. and Eden even more.
What musical is it from? Is it still on Broadway?
SweetCar0line7 3 years ago
...it's in the video description. and no, it closed.
brucewayne5148 3 years ago
I wish I could've seen Eden in this role. I saw Diana, and while she was good, she oversung too much. Eden doesn't over sing and she has more control over her voice.
entertainer1987 3 years ago
Funny to watch the camera shake/clap at the end! :)
latinhands 3 years ago 2
outrageously breathtaking!
TrinityBR 3 years ago 3
this is beautiful!
I wish I had this voic!!
Feathersandploom 3 years ago
This show didn't stay open long enough
thegreenestgirl 3 years ago 5
I totally agree!!
they totally need to revive it!!!
RE-STARRING EDEN!!!
marysutpassion1 3 years ago 7
She's amazing but you gotta give credit to the composer too. It's a great song that needed a great voice to sound good, but still composers are always overlooked.
jordank23 3 years ago 7
she's amazing!!!!!!!! i love eden!!!!!!!!!!!
forluvabroadway 3 years ago 7
OMG I LOVE THIS SONG! I never knew where it was from though. I love it even more now that I know that Eden sang it.
ChangedForGood94 3 years ago 4
This is great...and of course Eden is great in it, but I think she was almost overpowered by the background vocals and orchestra.
mellybear03 3 years ago
exactly she was over powerd a little
berube4life 3 years ago
FIERCE.
sandcircle 3 years ago 10
GO EDEN!!!
wicked894 3 years ago 3
There are no words to describe her talent.
thegreengirl1 3 years ago 6
I LOVE THIS SONG!
xxhalfbloodprincessx 3 years ago
I love how the camera was shaking back and forth at the end when the camera person was clapping.
=)
greenelphiexoxo 3 years ago 8
woah. Eden is soooooooo AWESOME!
serafimospretense 3 years ago 2
ive seen her in wicked she doesnt connect to the piece as much..
MissSabrinaD 3 years ago
Well she did when I saw her.
wickedLAcastlover 3 years ago 2
She was great whe I saw her.
Maybe it was a bad day, all performers have that.
greenelphiexoxo 3 years ago 6
genius
BKLYN396 3 years ago
She is sooo much better here than in Wicked.. She cannot do this in Wicked for some reason.. she just doesnt quite connect to it like she does here...
MissSabrinaD 3 years ago 4
She can do this like in Wicked.
wickedLAcastlover 3 years ago
I agree witch wickedLAcastlover. SHe connects with the peice here as she does with wicked. Her wizard and I blows me away every time I hear it. She also seems, to be the charatcer here and in Wicked. She is a true talent and a true talent can be vercatile as she is.
childrenschorus12 3 years ago
I agree witch wickedLAcastlover. SHe connects with the peice here as she does with wicked. Her wizard and I blows me away every time I hear it. She also seems, to be the charatcer here and in Wicked. She is a true talent and a true talent can be vercatile as she is.
childrenschorus12 3 years ago 3
The angel was GENIUS!
12bmills 3 years ago
im so madd i dident get to see this!!!
bwaydiva10 3 years ago
im very depressed that this is no longer on broadway!
973420 3 years ago
How old is she supposed to be in this musical (not in the beginning) but like when she competes with Miss Paradice and all?
wickedelphabafreeek 4 years ago
Umm... like 19ish?
bwaybabydezz 3 years ago
do you have Ramona's Raven from this night?
Dancer2188 4 years ago
amazing!!
soccertennant 4 years ago
EDEN=AMAZING! her voice is...wow...i dont even have words for it....it exceeds amazing...
fzaf94 4 years ago 3
Love it! :D
imaginebelle 4 years ago
goosebumps. speechless. tears. Holy wow.
darklegacy416 4 years ago
she's amazing! and not green!
staticoranges 4 years ago
although she is always amazing---even if she is green
wickedelphabafreeek 4 years ago 6
yep
soccertennant 4 years ago
i wish this show was still running cuz i wanna watch it live
musicman1132 4 years ago 7
me too!!
soccertennant 4 years ago
Why does eden have to be so amazing?
kristiroxx13 4 years ago 2
Ahhh! Eden! She continues to amaze me with everything she does. Thank you so much for posting!
smt2662 4 years ago
does anyone have a video of julie doing this?
youprobablysmell 4 years ago
and oh my gosh the ending...
putitdownslowly 4 years ago 3
thank you again for doing this...
putitdownslowly 4 years ago
she's amazing!
cmc201 4 years ago