Added: 2 years ago
From: consumerreports
Views: 368,233
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (755)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Challenger

  • The Chevrolet Camaro is based off of the Vauxhall VXR8...

  • i don't like American cars they're just pure power nothing else is good in it

  • @Megashehri but power is good!!

  • Americans really can't make cars.

  • @NZWolf2 american muscle you can't beat that you are wrong

  • Just so everyone knows. This company is DOT ORG for a reason. They have horrible drivers. Yea, those burn outs and donuts look cool, but these guys can't drive worth jack shit. That's why they think the challenger isn't agile, all their drivers are total pussies afraid to cut lose in a heavy car.

  • Gosh... I love Dodge but this is just embarrassing to watch

  • The dodge challenger hands down looks the best. That rear end takes you all the way back to the 80's.

  • Dodge Challengers are the future... It needs to lose some weight and throw a supercharger on it with CatBack Exhausts and it will scare the Mustangand Camaro away

  • Two boats are not competition.

  • ...'...and even the one that's most practical'... ..the last thought , and no mention of consumption...you guys arn't getting it your still messing round with a dwindling resource ....how the hell are your spanner twidlers in Detroit ment to get feed back if consumer reports only put the pedal to the metal ( you'r not Jez Clarkson ) ...did you look under the bonnet ( hood ) & try and change a plug or a filter or even a fuse? Get with the programme, if it's not the environment it's the cost.

  • WHy are these cars so expensive in Turkey :(( each of them cost at least 150-200 thousand bucks here ://

  • For what I'm looking for, the tank like features of the challenger RT, make it a good daily driver over the camaro and mustang. I currently live in MN and the Challenger RT has the best winter handling out of all three. The mustang and camaro have and always will me winter death traps (IMO) Call me a practical muscle car buyer if you will. Oh and SRT8s are winter death traps as well and it's hard as hell to find snow tires and rims that will clear their brakes, thats why I prefer the RT app:

  • Many people are just saying what they think is the best of these. But, there is more to these cars than looks.......I would say, actually that the challenger is the WORST of the bunch. This is simply because the interior is rubbish, it is massive, it is slow, and the worst to drive. I would say the camaro is second almost completely because it is hard to live with. The blind spots are absolutely HORRIBLE and it's hard to see out of. The mustang is small, agile, and easy to live with. Easy winner

  • 1. The Camaro is a rebodied Monaro, plus it's ugly like the original Camaro. Monaro over Camaro anyday!

    2. The Dodge is just a tank!

    3. The Mustang is a better buy than the other two, and unlike GM, Ford stuck it out while GM wastes taxpayer's money.

  • Why is it every time people have a video comparing the 3 cars, they always show the R/T Challenger and not the SRT8?

  • @HotCet Because they are comparing the v8 counterparts. If they were to use the SRT8 in a test, it would be competing with the Shelby GT500/Boss 302 and the ZL1, as they are all the top-spec models of all of these muscle cars. hope that answers your question :)

  • My dad just bought a toxic orange 2011 challenger with black stripes and the car is amazing! We both love it!!

  • dodge is better than all and by the way the dodge was rt not an srt8 in the vid

  • CAMARO all the way

  • that is a WICKED sick vehicle, buddy! I bet it takes a lot of effort to maintain it.

  • american cars: always over steering. tottaly not for tracks. straight track perhaps.

  • The Challenger are made from Cardboard boxes, and the Camaro is known to Young absent minded idiots of Bumblebee, Mustang wins. Nuff said.

  • LOL the DODGE was RT 370hp and CHEVY was SS 425hp and FORD was GT 412hp..... so dodge had 55hp less then CAMARO and 42hp less than MUSTANG ! thats not fare

  • Mustang has the best bang for your buck. Fast, powerful, great-looking inside and out, and many options. I've seen some Mustangs go for around 60k and I've seen others go for around 20k.

  • Chevy is and always will be the best of the best!!!!!!!!!

  • I think this guy knows nothing about cars because challlenger could smoke camero and mustange by far and two door charger what the heck is wrong with you

  • @jbdodgechallenger62 Speaking of not knowing much about cars, you spelled Camaro and Mustang wrong, dipshit.

  • it looks like the challenger shit the mustang out

  • the dodge chalanger looks stright up mean

  • I rented the Ford Mustang for a week. It's a really nice car for short, in-town driving. Being 6'1" with a medium sized body the interior felt a bit cramped to me on long interestate drives. Even with the seat pulled all the way back, my knees still bump against the bottom of the dashboard, and felt like I was seated in a go-kart.

  • @Phantazmagoriia thats exactly the same problem i have with fords. im 6'2 215 lbs and as far as i can go back my knees or shins bump the bottom edge of the dash and its a bit sharp. i drove my aunts new mercury mariner and i think if i had a front end crash, the dash would chop my legs off at the shins lol. the late 70s-80s and some early 90s fords are fine, its after they redone the interiors i have that prob. just not comfortable in a ford, really no other complaints.

  • im sorry but a baby blue convertible mustang doing donuts and drifting around the track looks ridiculous

  • suck dont say that to the challenger: (bbbbbooooooo

  • The mustang is the best of the best fuk the camero and challenger

  • But Mr. My stock challenger always smokes all of the camaros around my town. And the mustang don't even wanna race. Not sayin anything is better but I think there should have been more time spent on the challenger. That pissed me off

  • challenger is one of the best looking cars

  • did this guy just call that a 2 door charger?!?!WTF???

  • the ford and chevy are both starting to look like pos foreign cars that have a high pitched cry. i would rather have the challenger, keeping it classic and having the roar of an angry lion. lol idk

  • My dad has a 2011 Chevy camaro RS convertible, besides the interior sucking ass and wobbly, its a nice handling, glued to the road, fun car.

  • The Challenger is a beautiful car, it's certainly the car i would pick that is one car they brought into modern times and looks damn good.

  • i dunno why i just dont like the mustang look haha

  • Ok first of all this was a shitty review, 2 door charger? What the fuck?!?! And the camaro a 60's throwback? What the fuck?!?! Nuff said bitches I'm out

  • FUCK YOU the challenger has the most soul

  • The 2011 Challenger is one awesome muscle car.

    I've driven all three. The Mustang is the same old boring car from 1994. Chevy sure made one ugly camaro both inside and out. I have to agree that the 2008-2010 Challenger's handling needed improving. The 2010 felt heavy to drive.

    The 2011 challenger suspension is perfect. This car is in a league well above the camaro and mustang. It's like compaing apples to oranges.

    And no, it's definitely not just a two door charger.

  • tsk mustang a muscle car? they still have a fucking 5 slow!!! and at least in forza 3 the camaro aint too good i dont like it..... the challenger is my best bet.... im a mopar guy..... but im open minded and well it looks and sounds the best, and is still alot better handling than the cars they are meant to tribute to. but id take a ws6 trans am over any of these hey cheap now handles like a dream and fuckin fast! with less hp than most of these..... 325hp ls1

  • @gunny426plymouth

    well right now the mustang has a 6 speed and is fastest of the 3 in both v6 and v8

  • if you got the top of the line mustang?(excluding shelby version) and top of the line camaro, why dont you get the top of the line challenger, srt stands for street and race technology, change the suspension and everything with that package, think about it next time you wana do a comparison

  • Chevy Camaro!!

  • Why is it that "experts" whine about how the Challenger (a touring car) doesn't handle as well as a Camaro or Mustang? Both the Camaro and Mustang are built to be agile cars where the Challenger is built more for comfort so of course it's not going to handle as well as the other two. I say let's compare a Camaro to a Wrangler in the trails and then bitch how the Camaro just doesn't handle the rocks very well with traction control on.

  • @superduperboyx almost every compro test I've seen with these 3 cars says the camaro is hard to see out of and tge steering wheel I've also heard is apperently to big

  • All three are beautiful high performing cars. No true American should dislike this video

  • "392Drags" on youtube

  • I like the Challeneger and Camaro but it looks like it has horrible blind spots....can anyone here confirm? I'm thinking about picking up one of these babies.

  • i dont like rams but i like challengers

  • my top 3 cars is one video.omg awesome.THIS ARE THE BEST CARS EVER!

  • The challenger is sooooo fkn sexy mustang looks okay but for some reason I don't like the looks of the comaro as much

  • Chevy Camaro Baby !!! :) 

  • the camaro and mustang r awesome. i can't decide which is better but the challenger is too sluggish. the camaro and mustang r quick and agile while the challenger is more powerful its too heavy to be agile but its still quick though

  • im getting all 3

  • you are an idiot. how does the camaro look like a throwbackk 60s muscle car??? its the newest looking car there!

  • god the challenger is fUGLY!

  • @CaperWaver not.at.all. but i would still prefer the mustang

  • Yeah I'm sorry but the challenger is the only of the three that actually looks like its ancestor. And I mean come on was there really a need for a test, Challenger all the way.

  • @killertikisurferdude i think you didnt really watch the video did you heard all the bad points he said about the challenger and all the good points about the camaro HELL YEAH CAMARO ALL THE WAY

  • @killertikisurferdude no doubt the challenger looks the best but its the worst performing :/

  • @killertikisurferdude its a dodge. it blows

  • @killertikisurferdude I agree but its not the best...although it does look more classic,muscle car looking\my opinion MUSTANG

  • @killertikisurferdude ya and they didnt even mention the 392 challenger... stupid fanboys

  • @killertikisurferdude wrong Camaro is King!!!

  • @killertikisurferdude Dodge destroyed the look of the Charger. Now its more of a sedan than a pony car.

  • @killertikisurferdude The new Mustang looks similiar to its counterparts from the early 70's.

  • 2:12 wtf? the camaro looks nothing like a throwback. if you're looking for a throwback then take a look at the dodge challenger. mopar or no car!

  • @leprachaunskate thank you!

  • I laughed hysterically when he said "the last couple years, the ford mustang, well was the only game in town". The 04-06 GTO was way more powerful than the Mustang, and an all-around better car.

  • @ryanmg1 Which is why they went bust?

  • I dont care what this guy says. The Challenger is by far the best. I dont know if its just me, but I would assume most people dont get to the track that often. The Camaro is ugly. Sorry. The Challenger is beautiful, powerful, and an overall great car.

  • @stuwip839 It is. They should have reviewed the SRT-8 variant that has improved everything over the R/T.

  • mustang looks shit challanger looks awesome and camaro is a pussy car

  • challenger!!!!!!looks just like the original

  • The Dodge Challenger is a beast.

  • FORD must pay them to lie. I have a new Mustang

    and it is a piece of crap compared to the Camaro

  • dodge challenger, without the disgusting alloys

  • who put this guy in charge..???

  • i like dodge challenger most then mustang hell they are comparing a basic r/t to a ss comaro and a mustang gt not fare dodge chalenger ftw

  • Dodge Challenger SRT8 Stomps Chebby's Top Camaro Offering in a drag race...It;s designed for a drag race, NOT going in circles ya frickin goofball..

  • why do people hate challengers

    I think they're awesome

  • i say, the camaro is the best, BUT, BUT, if any of those cars are in my driveway, i won't even say a word (:

  • just remember, its not the car... but the driver

  • The way i see it, all 3 are good choices. The Mustangs are cheaper and are pretty good for the money. But every other person i see has one. The Camaro's look great and are pretty quick and nice. But there are getting to be alot of them around too, and it seems to me mostly girls want them? Im not bashing on them just saying. My girlfriend is getting one soon too. The Challenger is amazing in my opinion. Its for the people who truely like classic cars. Its big and sounds great. But i like all 3!

  • lmao they wear a helmet in a closed roof car but no helmet in an open top convertible. great logic

  • @hybridman true but all 3 of these cars, if you flip. yer done period

  • Camaro all the way!

  • What the fuck is that guy doing driving a freaken mustang? Mustangs are for girls dude.

  • the color on the mustang is ugly.. and i wouldnt get a challenger even though its a nice car.. so camaro is where its at

  • doesn't anyone here like the mustang the most? in my opinion it's the most classic, it's the highest rated of the three, most agile, best braking, best acceleration, most power, funnest to drive, and got the Best Sporty Car award for 2011. And these guys are the real experts, no joke!

  • @TheBadBuffalo Yep, the mustang seems to be the best for the buck overall. But a lot of people get the challenger bc of its looks and sound. The challenger is the dirty whore u bang once. The mustang u marry. But peeps dont think about pros and cons when it comes to cars. 

  • mustang all the way baby

  • Soooo.... What you're saying is, Mr. Reviewer guy, is that you want the same car every gussied up hoe has or the low-end supercar masking as a muscle car. Got ya.

  • U need to get a srt8 it would kill all it can go about 190mph nefore the shity law making where it auto slows but it could go faster

  • @123bailee123durant12 lmao not even close, even the new 392 is slower than both the mustang andss the camaro

  • Every testing company is retarded... No SRT8s for them. And the 2011 Charger SRT8 is faster than the Camaro, and handles about the same. And neither of tue others have decent sized cargo space at all, which takes a dump on practicality. The Dodge may be big, but it's not wastefully big.

  • @darthgarfield the mustang's trunk space and cabin space dwarf the challengers, not to mention the mustang GT starts at 29k, the srt8 starts at aroundss 40k....so dont even bring practicality into this, the challenger is far from it

  • The Camaro doesn't look like a throw back it looks like a piece of shit.

  • Camaro!!! all the way

  • Yup Challenger is the ugliest car from behind that I've seen in a while. And good luck backing up in the camaro.

  • Chevy blew it on the styling of the camara! It's an f'n toy.

  • American cars are crap

  • They all look like shit compared to old school muscles

  • Ford will always be king. it was the only one not discontinued. it has been the heart of muscle cars. the only one that kept beating, & kept the muscle alive. now, the camaro which is the only other legitimate muscle car took over the throne for 1 year, 2010. then the mustang came back and kicked the crap out of everything all over again the next year. the other brands are once again playing catch up. not only that, but as they chase the gt, the boss is back, get ready. always Ford tough.

  • Chevrolet Camaro Baby xD

  • i have a challenger.... the handling is just fine.... and comparing it to a truck? ya ok...

  • It's embarrassing to own a 6.1L engine that gets you no where. 

  • I fucking HATE the front end of newer mustangs. Old school is best....

  • the challenger is the slowest, ugliest, and most expensive one

  • I LOVE the chevy camaro, LIKE the dodge challenger, and HATE the ford mustang!

  • mustang all the way. the challenger is like a boat. and camaro is okay

  • I bought a Dodge Challenger today in silver...Diecast that is!!

  • Chevy Camaro Baby :)

  • mustangs are better than all of them. challengers cost to much and are to heavy

  • @mustangs4life25 mustang has ruled 47 years, nothing is quite like a mustang. #1 in sales and #1 in this country period! I like the old camaro's 67-69, when they didn't look like full sized cars. There's too much sheet metal on the new ones today, and they weigh much more than a Stang. And the rear of the car is ugly as hell.

  • Every testing company uses the Challenger R/T with the 5.7L HEMI, why? The SRT8 is a better comparrison to the Camaro. What idiot decided to test a convertible against two coupes? However, no matter which versions are tested the Challenger tops the others in looks and is an all around bad ass. People forget that muscle cars are built on personality. Ford and Chevy killed that personality by making "muscle cars" into the 80's and beyond. Challenger was reborn and retains its personality today.

  • dodge challenger FUCK YEA, id rather be driving that then my Toyota supra

  • 5.0 mustang leaves you guys in the back ford the daddy of them all while dodge picked up fords scraps and chevrolet aint all american they need chinesse support

  • Challenger still wins ... i dont care what he says.

  • where is the SRT-8 BITCH !!!!!!!!!!

  • Chevy Camaro is where its at, the dodge is pretty sick, and ford will always be last.

  • what the fuck you expect you got a rt dumbass get the srt10 dipshit damn top gear is a whole better than this shit even though they trash american cars i rather watch them get the srt10 and trash it before see some one get a damn rt in compare it to a gt or ss

  • if this were 1970 id say the challenger looks best, but the new challenger looks fat and like it should belong in a hip hop video.

  • they where driving the hell out of them cars

  • i dont get it...why do u need all that power when u can't even drive at that speed on the road?...unless ur asking 4 a ticket.

  • i see way too many mustangs on the road...and camaros are gettin there

    i never see challengers, that's why im gettin one...it's beautiful :')

  • this guy is an idiot that's everyday driver is a honda civic let someone that knows something about driving hop in there, the camaro inside feels like your in a 70's corvette in fact if you can see that far in front of you it cant be safe the challenger srt8 is where you want to be a for 2011 its nearly 500 horse and ford cant offer that unless you spend 70k canadian dollars

  • Mustang is the best!!

  • I prefer the Challenger for all the same reasons this guy puts it down: I like very old school, American, pure mass. That can work for you if you know how to drive. If you want light and nimble you're better off with a BMW.

  • I'd take the challenger just for the looks.. the Camaro and Mustang just lack that classical look, in my opinion.

  • I honestly love the challenger. but i always hated the camoro but .. dunno

  • Camaro :D

  • 315 horses in the gt? That's nothing

  • Dodge Challenger Baby :)

  • @Jonathan72593 Hell Yeah Dodge Challenger All The Way!!!!!

  • @Jonathan72593 Performs the worst, costs the most, uses the most gas, Baby :)

  • @Jonathan72593 i know it probably looks the best, but it actually turned out to be the lowest rated car of the three. i'm kinda sad about it, since it looks so awesome.

  • i would like all of them + a ford capri mk3

  • Best is the cahllenger... my number 1

  • mustang sucks balls....camaro is nice.....challenger is my choice

  • @strumem90 Challenger sucks, Mustang is the best, camaro so so!!

  • @jvccruz16 fuck the mustang...challenger!!!!!

  • @jvccruz16 challenger biiitttch

  • CAMARO ROX!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • what car would u guys have then?

  • Since when is Consumer Reports owned by the government?

  • I road in a Camaro and its the Best.

  • challenger is the shit man it looks fucking amazing

  • Awesome.For me, Mustang will always remain the best

  • It's ether mustang or camaro

  • weird.........gm is owned by the gov't........consumer reports is owned by the gov't.........and CR says the camaro is best??!!

  • For all that thinks this Mustang is bad ass....well it is....but 2011 brings the new Mustang 302 Boss... Let's see what it will do :)

  • the 2010 mustang looks like shit..

    best mustang is 2005 model DAMN I LOVE IT..

    camaro is a very nice car too, but mustang beats them all..

    the challenger is shit.-

  • We are installing a 4L80E Maddogtransmission in a 2010 700HP camaro just thought you might be interested we will be posting videos.

  • I just love the Camaro...unbeatable style!

  • this is just a bias video about the fucking camaro and personally i hate the new camaro and the mustang

  • i like the look of the challanger and the camaro to me looks to much like an ordinary car and the musting is kinda in the middle. if i was ona buy one tho it would be a mustang

  • american cars PIECE OF SHIT...

  • @allthatmetters for sure,

  • @allthatmetters asian cars = ?

  • CHALLENGER RULES DUDE

  • @crystalsword777 yeah, a canadian built gernam car with a old style body and a mexican built engine is definately the best car here. riiiiiiight?

  • I am fascinated by American car design. Yes, American muscle cars are heavy, have big engines that consume lots of fuel (not really affordable these days) but still, gosh I love 'em.

    The only thing that bother me is the quality of interior materials used. It's a known fact they're poor quality in comparison to European or Eastern cars, but hey, does it really matter? It's a MUSLE car.

    Anyway, I'd love to know if a modern muscle car is so easy to repair as it was in the old days.

  • @compprufus yah also a european or easter car costs twice and much and muscle cars in my oppinion sound way cooler and would be more fun to drive.

  • @compprufus Not really, the Mustang gets up to 31mpg and thats a stock Mustang/automatic for $23,990. It's also got great quality interior, but shit, I'd only care about the seats and the steering wheel. What, are you going to be touching the center console and the padded material covering the door? My grandmother owns an eastern made car and it's cramped as all hell. It put my old Focus to shame despite being bigger. Now, my Fusion Hybrid is just not a fair comp since her car costed apr$14,000.

  • Camaro looks like an oversized HotWheel, but does have the best performance.

    Challenger has the best looks, and usability, plenty of space for passengers n cargo.

    Mustang fits in the between, its got good styling, n got decent usability. only thing holding back its performance is that Live REAR Axle

  • that convertible looks fucked up just wrong 

  • hey guys could you tell me if any of the three is a sports car or an every day use car. I personally regards them as sports cars but I see lots of students in my university drive them every day.

  • The Dodge Challenger SRT8 is the way to go. Performance is important but with muscle cars looks are also key. Seriously, new Mustang looks like crap (05s were better). The Camaro looked good in pics on the street it looks very poor especially from the side and rear. Gotta give the nod to Challenger. The vette is the only chevy I would consider.

  • chevy camaro all the way i have one and if u got the money it is completely worth it they are insanely fast

  • I don't care if the mustang and camaro are faster... The challenger looks the best hands down.

  • WHO THE HELL PUT A CONVERTIBLE IN THERE O.o!!

  • ford mustan