Added: 5 years ago
From: maestro3450
Views: 1,106,282
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,616)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • such a sad and wonderful piece for a sad and wonderful movie...good job.

  • I can't breakdance to this.

  • the left-hand chords are reaching pretty far, almost non-playable for people with small hands

  • @Blinkwing unfortunatly i agree.. i have small hands and i can only reach an octave on piano with them :(

  • @eva93ie i am near to fail at getting the chords, but I am lucky to be able to do it

  • @Blinkwing yeah you are lucky ! id love to elongate my fingers lol .. i have to modify a lot of classical pieces because my hands are simply to small ..im always heartbroken when i have to do that heh : )

  • How many time did you spend for learning to play this song? I can play the piano and I think this song is quite difficult.

  • Makes me wanna cry!!

  • This is an amazon piece of music.

  • @louisehains12 covert advertising for amazon? xD

  • @phrasel14 More like a horrendous attempt at spelling the word 'amazing'.

  • I'm Asian and I say we stop this Asian discussion right now so that we can enjoy this video :)

  • i love how the top two comments just work together like that lol

  • lol was john williams asian......no, so there, he created this amazing peice of music no one else, no asain.

  • their world, not ours. Ours came shortly after and is still present. rkmugen.

  • I'm Asian and I think all these Asian comments are ridiculous and detract from the point of this video of a very heart-felt performance of a most beautiful piece, echoing from a very sad time in our world's history.

  • Looove this song...

  • I'm not asian, so stereotypically, I can't do anything

  • I'm asian, I can't do anything.

  • im learning how to play this. its soo beatiful

  • Comment removed

  • Superbe musique, qui fait pleurer d'émotion.

    Chantal

    (lepianoarcenciel)

  • In 2008 I learned this by watching you, back then when there were no Tutorials. I did it in a month. I was despert to learn the theme, and I don't read music, so you were the very few who actually played the theme with the view of the piano. Thank you!

  • this guy did with for feeling in it..

    watch?v=PPw0B--IBeI

  • hello, i've got a question. could you sent me the music sheet of this music please.

    thank you.

  • i love it!

  • So perfect!! - thank you for sharing!!

  • play this song with "RainyMood" playing in the background, amazing playing!

  • To Theboywholivedlives... thank you! I have listened to this for many years and have always loved it and your adjective... Heartbreakingly Beautiful is the exactly the perfect description!  Such a dark time in history!

  • i'm Indian....can i do anything?

  • Thanks so much for letting us watch the keyboard execution.

  • hahaha he is asian and he can do anything ? are you a female asian?

  • tutorial?

  • I always feel like crying. This song is heartbreakingly beautiful, just read the book. John Williams is the mastreo of music.

  • This is awesome! I love this song!

  • i'm asian and i can beatbox i can play piano so it's clear

  • yeah totally heart breaking......find music...called women of ireland...feeling sad wolftones women of ireland,,,,you think your in a sad mood just not irish,,,,all woman of the world...listen to THIS

  • niuu he's asian 3: lmfao jk :3 first of all im learning this song and surprising my parents :3 and second i luvvles asians :D

  • im glad there is a gameplay trailer for this game cause it is new and i didnt expect what i whas gonna to see

  • So you are Asian and you forgot one important thing: Who IS does not tell!

    If you must tell, I wonder why others don't see it like you do!

    Arrogance in any individual is repulsive!

    I hope one day you will mature and grow into the divinity which is present in the performance of music, one of the greatest art form.

    HagenSara10

  • @HagenSara10 you're taking a joke too seriously.

  • @HagenSara10 It hardly matters, We all are equal when it comes to Feeling the music, what is pride?, a temporary feeling.

  • not fair !! he's asian

  • @timmer7000 I'm human so I can do anything

  • Awesome.

  • :)Very nice!

  • superbe merci

  • absolutley beautiful piece of music.

  • is it really in this key?

  • You inspired me very much! Beautifully played. *****

  • Beautifully played my friend! Please keep the videos coming! I enjoy them very much!

    Rgrds Karl.

  • la musique est ausi belle que celle du film sans commentaire merci

  • Wunderschönes Lied

  • Excellent !!!

  • I have this same sheet music, I'm trying so hard to learn it, but its extremely difficult. Its sooo beautiful though.

  • About reaching keys when the range is over an octave, etc: It's a combination of regular stretching, practice, and natural hand length. For example, I can reach two white keys beyond an octave, but I'm not a giant. The reason is mostly because I've been playing piano an incredibly long time and started young so my palms and fingers are flexible. However,my teacher said he taught Marc Yu when he was 8 and he couldn't play Fantasie Impromptu for the sole reason that his hands were too small.

  • @brp10hotmail Please dont make jokes of that...

  • @MrDavidsitanala not here anyway[s].

  • Comment removed

  • Wow! You really 'play the feelings'!!

  • the best way to reach all the keys is to practice stretching out you hands. that's why most people have trouble with piano when they start at an older age. Their hands aren't used to being stretched out

  • try gluing popsicle sticks to your fingers

  • Comment removed

  • You have to have piano fingers!!! Long and limber....its called a natural talent!

  • cause you play a fantastic song..please don't look all the time the paper and feel it!! keep on!!

  • I enjoyed listing and see you play this music. I like to plat this piece as well on my piano. I checked various sheet music but they are not satisfying. Which one are you using?

  • Hauntingly beautiful. Well done.

  • the most sweetest song ......It hurts your spirit.....wonderful...

  • jadore

    !!!!!!!!!!!

  • whenever i hear this song, i imagine i am the last man on earth and i can never die, cursing me with living with my sins forever

  • If you have small hands and you can't reach all the keys, you need to take the chords by moving your wrist more. Or leave the middle note out of the chord.

  • You need long fingers to play this song. Actually long fingers are actually a necessity for piano playing but you don't really have to.

  • この曲はとてもきれいな曲ですね。大好きな曲です。

  • you are great, this is beautifully played

  • I can't reach all keys, too. My playing including pain, the pain which receive the victims of this dark time.

  • Movie makes me cry and sick to my stomach everytime but this is beautiful

  • @Purplecutie94 "The heart of a fool is in his mouth, but the mouth of a wise man is in his heart." Benjamin Franklin

  • my fingers are to short and my hands are to small, i wont give up though cuz i heard of a guy who plays piano with his feet

  • @sasuke12345671 Yeah he was a contestant on China's Got Talent. Truly amazing :)

  • @sasuke12345671 YOU KNOW HOW THEY PLAY ? EASY VERSION ARRENGEMENT VERSION AND SIMPLE MELODYS . SOME ARE BORN TO DO SOM THINGS OTHER DO . DO NOT GIVE UP MY FRIEND BUT DO NOT CHEER THE INFERIOR
  • this is a beautiful song ...

  • İNSANLIK AYIBI BİLEBİLEN YÜREKLERE!!!... İNSANLIK AYIBINDAN NASİPLENMİŞ... HİSSEDEN, AR BİLEN YÜREKLERE!!!... İNSANLIK AYIBINDA AHUZÂR, İNSANLIĞINDAN UTANAN YÜREKLERE!!!... SEVGİYLE...

  • beautiful my brother. i am watching you and learning to play this by ear and eye since i cant read music. thanks

  • I can play that too ^^

  • I am a Jew, but not more than I am an American. I am a soldier training to lead men into combat as an officer, I fight MMA, I am a student at Babson college, I go sailing, I like to sing in the shower, I play several instruments, I speak arabic and german along with my native english. I have trouble with math. You see? I am none of these things by themselves, or even in all of them in concert. I am just a human being, and that's all I want to be judged as. Identify me and I am already dead.

  • the jews are incessant liars who always perpetrate fraud whenever the nations are embroiled in war. William Dudley Pelley in 1939 wrote "The 45 Questions Most Frequently Asked About the Jews" which footnoted the 8 million euro-jews who were transferred to the USA and Palestine during the 1930s prior to WW2. Perhaps only around 22% of the 270,000 people who died at the network of dissident camps built by the Germans were jews. The real "Holocaust" was done to the Germans, Poles and the Japanese.

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary You sicken me.

  • doesn't change the truth that the jews are liars, thieves and murderers to the bone all of them.

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary Do you have proof that every Jewish person is a liar, thief and murderer? Because that's quite a weighty accusation to place on someone a) when you don't know them and b) when the only thing linking them to the other people in this huge group you're tarring with the same brush is their religion.

  • Hitler in 'Mein Kampf' coined the phrase "The Big Lie" to illuminate how the jews rule over the primitive masses with psychological operations. Usually the broad masses tell only moderate lies while the totally unprincipled jews employ "The Big Lie" method such as "God", "The Bible" and "The Holocaust". The primitive masses are too simple-minded to register how any people could be so wicked to manufacture such massive fraud so the claims become accepted as truthful over time through repetition.

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary I am a Jew, but not more than I am an American. I am a soldier training to lead men into combat as an officer, I fight MMA, I am a student at Babson college, I go sailing, I like to sing in the shower, I play several instruments, I speak arabic and german along with my native english. I have trouble with math and the women I love rarely love me back. You see? I am none of these things by themselves, or even in concert. I am just a man, and that's all I want to be judged as.

  • never forget all of the crimes against humanity carried out by the jew-controlled Soviets. Never forget the USS Liberty.

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary Your groundless hate is a crime against humanity. Much like the hate that caused Chairman Mao's cultural revolution to take so many lives, and the hate that drove the Genocides in Rwanda and Bosnia.You hate an identity, one that doesn't even exist.Why can't you be secure in your own affairs and leave the Jews alone?Are the Jews so much better than you that (assuming they wanted to) they could take enough from you to justify your desperate fear?You hate because you cant love

  • learn about Deir Yassin if you want to know about hate.

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary Could piling more hate on it possibly heal that wound? Besides, it was a group of errant paramilitaries. American generals have done worse to indians in our history.

  • the theft of Palestine in 1948 finalized worldwide jewish supremacism that was funded primarily through the Rothschild banking dynasty which had accumulated several trillion dollars in both the East and West. "Israel" was created to serve as the military stronghold between the East and West that would allow the jews to finally wrap their tentacles around the entire globe. The jews had positioned themselves to confiscate Palestine no matter which side would have won WW2.

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary Listen, I'm not trying to argue facts with you, for one I don't have many, if I did, I would not accept nor deny that those facts might have been forgeries. Instead let me ask you how do you propose that so many people, connected only by an accident of birth, manage to maintain such cohesion in their ranks? How they are able to maintain this single minded hunger for world domination? Also, I've told you already I'm jewish, do you suppose I'm in on the scheme as well?

  • @DamnHistoryYouScary Really? I'm pretty sure that one's religion has nothing to do with being a liar or not. Especially seeing as one Christian can so choose to convert to Judaism, I cannot see how who you pray to changes the truthfulness of one's words. And I'm pretty sure that the Jewish people never would had 'lied' through the bible, seeing as the Judaic Holy doctrine is called the Torah. I would appreciate if you could refrain from spreading the hate.

    Sincerely,

    A Human Being.

  • you're good, but this song reminds me of death :-(

  • if you tink that those people has to know to die then it schould be creepy

  • beautiful... I'm definately gonna subscribe. You should check out my channel when you get the chance, I do some of my own work, and I'm new to youtube!

  • Your rit. / rubato is perfect. Well played.

  • nice!!!!

  • "The list is an apsolute good. The list is life."

  • @jaynoir88 srsly....im just saying my honest opinion..im not a bigger liar like u...piste giatay ka puta ka...PUTA KA!!!!.......PUTA KA PUTA KA PUTA KA MAMATAY KA PUTA KA...

  • @ lalagirl211

    Shindler's List is based on a true story of Oskar Schindler that saved about 1100 Polish Jews during WWII- some 3-4,000 descendants of Schindler's Jews now live in Europe and USA.

    Beautiful story. watch the movie or read about Oskar Schindler.

  • i like it but my ears hurt idk why

  • what is the story of the movie?is it true story?

  • @lalagirl211 Yes it is true, Its about the holocaust, How 6 million jews were murdered by the nazis but 1 of them, schindler an owner of a factory that hired jews decided to save his workers... over 1000 people.

    Its what he have gone through, He and his workers and what the jews have gone through over that time.

  • this is scaryy good :) your amazing !

  • Hate the left hand stretches, gonna take some practise :'( C - Bb - Eb is a particularly mean one...

  • Sheet music please??

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx

    that is why it's arpeggio, btw, I have long fingers but even I can't reach them, what I do is that I simply don't play the highest note out of the three

  • @magicprophecy You should always play the highest note, forget about one of the others instead if you really can't play them.

  • I really like the feeling you play with. It's the very Chopin-like push/pull that makes this the best version posted on Youtube, IMO.

  • Fantastic!

  • thats was amazing! do you have the music sheets? would you be able to post a link or send them?

  • I can't reach the keys :(

  • @TheZakopolis I know how you feel, I have a bent finger from birth. Boy is it fustrating!

  • Good job man. Beautiful! I'm turning it into a metal song with electric guitar picking up from the ending. Ever since the 1st time I heard it all I could think about was this metal song i composed in my head. It's going to take me a year to come up with something good enough to fit in there.

  • HOW DO YOUR HANDS FIT OVER ALL THE KEYS?! When there's like 6 notes at a time, I can never get my fingers to play them all, how do you do it :(

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx It depends on what fingers you use and how deep you put your fingers. It's easier for certain fingers to exert force than others (compare your index finger's force with the ring finger's). It also helps a lot if you move your fingers somewhat deeper, because you can reach all the notes better. The gap between keys is smaller at the piano's side, than the players side, so you can reach further.

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx Well, i have to agree that he played wonderful peace of music pretty good, but if you cannot reach those keys, you might consider you being kinda bad :S

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx he's asian, he can do anything

  • @BillyL6 i'm asian, and i can do anything

  • @geoxyz24 I am not asian, but I can still do anything

  • @geoxyz24 Orlly? What about driving? 

  • @geoxyz24 Anyone can do anything if they put their determination to it.

  • @N1CKF3D Asians don't need determination.

  • @geoxyz24 I'm not asian, but I believe I can do anything

  • @geoxyz24 dude my sister in law is a fail asian to

  • @geoxyz24 dislike

  • @BillyL6 but asian has often small hands ^^ ... most asian are small haha :D

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx He is rolling the chord slightly. You do not need to leave your pinky on the bottom note. Keep in mind that on the left hand the lower notes are of the most importance so if you have to leave out a note because it is too far, leave the upper notes.

  • @Tyrulaan I am a tuba player and i take great offense to that. The bass line is very important.

  • @Jingles94 I never once said the bass line is not important. I stand by what I've said. When playing chords on the left hand which are difficult to reach, if you must leave out a key, leave out the upper keys played by the left hand. That is all.

  • @Tyrulaan penis.

  • @Jingles94 haha that was a win

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx I think they are meant to be broken, like arpeggios.

  • @xXSweeneyLovettXx it's called big hands my friend, grow some.

  • very touching

  • You did beautiful!! Keep it up, you can miss all the notes you want, It Still sent me the same message!

  • Sorry, wrote the comment from a different account that's not mine! :)

    Here it is again:

    Good approach to the piece, but did you notice that you're missing some details? also, some of the notes in the right hands aren't exactly what's originally written, you've got the whole piece in a compilation, but its not 100% accurate, specially on 1:06, 1:20, & 1:46...but again, good job, and respect!

  • Good approach to the piece, but did you notice that you're missing some details? also, some of the notes in the right hands aren't exactly what's originally written, you've got the whole piece in a compilation, but its not 100% accurate, specially on 1:06, 1:20, & 1:46...but again, good job, and respect!

  • just remember why this song is here; because some fucking assholes thought they could rule the world with some racist regime that would have brought an end to our freedom. long live Judaism which has had to put up with so much hatred in history. And all the Nazi fuckers out there; go die in a hole. Nuff said

  • i cried

  • Can you imagine how sad it would be if the there was a piano and violin duet?

  • @ButterNutTea i have a piano and strings version in my channel

  • non male...

  • beautiful

  • @ehhyeth Hmmm...I thought that it was in the movie like that but I guess it isn't, but I feel i've heard it somewhere....Haha im sorry I don't remember

  • @ehhyeth check my own version if u like in my channel u would honor me

  • @ehhyeth violin is by far superior to piano and i play the piano

  • @ehhyeth definitely but both of them together is the best.

  • @ehhyeth definitely but both of them together is the best.

  • la santa ostia

  • i disagree too. piano&violin together r the best !

  • beautifully played sir.