It's crazy how people prefer songs filled with auto-tune and nonsense words just so the verses can rhyme over songs like this one that's filled with meaning and absolute awesomeness.
I love this song! Erin's voice is so pure and lovely and the groove and syncopation just kick! And when she sings the lyrics "Stars feel like knives They tell us why ♫♪ we're fighting" at the 1:50 mark, the chord changes pull hard and just slay me. Awesome song! Thanks, Erin!
Wish I could have worked on this music video...The song just gives so many awesome ideas for a video! Video was good but it could have been better. You sang amazingly :)
I love her because it's actual singing, not screaming or just talking your lyrics. Her song is soo pretty and I love when they play it in the movie "He's Just Not That In To You". Love her. Love the song.
That's why she's not famous. She's actually talented. She's not auto-tuned, can play an instrument and write! The music industry doesn't seem to favor real talent at this time.
@phedre06 i 100% agree with you. I LOVE her voice. i really do not know why people appreciates the REAL gift of voice. like gaga, she is AMAZING at live with her outfit and such. I LOVE ERIN MCCARLEY. Pony loveee
@phedre06 that is sooo true not like the evil tone deaf cow cheryl cole! grrrr i probs dunno who inm talkin bout if ur not english but alll the boys hate her and she makes young girls wanna kill themselves!!! erin is sooo awshums
@phedre06 I don't think it's because the music industry doesn't favor real talent, I think it's just the genre that is more popular nowadays. There are those who are uber popular that don't auto-tune and can play instruments too
@phedre06 You're right! Nowadays music industry favors singers who have NO TALENT and are plastic sh*ts, they get up on stage looking like sluts making slutty moves and BOOM! they have no idea how to sing !! don't know why is this happening ?!
I am not sure at all, but here is how i see it : At the begining of the video, you can see her giving the golden fish its freedom (she throws it in the water at 0:01). And at 3:07, she's watching at the same fish, but it is in a store. So she buys it, in order to set it free... (which also means that the story happens in reverse) =) I can't see the link with "love/emptyness" and the fish though...
The only thing that ruins it for me in the video is the fish being released at the end. Knowing that it's a goldfish, raised in a tank, she practically sent that fish to its doom. o_O
I first was introduced to Erin McCarley by another artist Butterfly Boucher..she and 9 other talented artists took the stage and introduced themselves as Ten out of Tenn (when they came to chicago in 2008)--I was amazed by Erin, and all the other artists..who knew following one artists would lead me to 9 more :) Check out Ten out of Tenn at their myspace... they are all wonderful and I am a fan of Erin McCarley ..still a huge fan of Butterfly Boucher and the rest of the performing artists of TOT
I love her! However, if you really put a goldfish in a closed jar like that it would eventually suffocate and die. I hope no little kids get the wrong idea and try that.
AHAHAHAHA!!! and i was actually thinking about trying it and i'm not a little kid! and if you puta goldfish in a river, it would also be fatal, right? if it's not used to the water...
That would be AWESOME! An acoustic cd would be great, kind of like what Alanis Morisette did with Jagged Little Pill. And you saw her perform? Lucky!!
first, i'm so jealous you're moving there! second, i met her a few months ago. she's an extremely kind person so i'm sure she won't mind you paying homage to her :)
AAAAAAAA!!!!!!!! my turn to be jelous. YOU MET HER?!?!?!?!? Oh, I want to!!!!
I'm going for student exchange. And i bet if you tried, you could find a way to go, too. we could share a cafe au lait... and some goldfish water. lol.
It's crazy how people prefer songs filled with auto-tune and nonsense words just so the verses can rhyme over songs like this one that's filled with meaning and absolute awesomeness.
BryaTea 5 months ago
She is so pretty and sounds amaZing!
ChamorittaMaina 9 months ago
hey! she has the same last name as me!
sargentphycobish 10 months ago
I absolutely love this song.
Stoneripple1 1 year ago
Amazing song I listen to it like evry day ^_^
magicmusicproduction 1 year ago
Great voice, great songs. Keep it up!
tothestars911 1 year ago
0:33 Spazz attack!
xxFrozenintime 1 year ago
I DEMAND a video for either Pony (its OK) or Blue Suitcase. Preferably both.
latinoheat300 1 year ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song! Erin's voice is so pure and lovely and the groove and syncopation just kick! And when she sings the lyrics "Stars feel like knives They tell us why ♫♪ we're fighting" at the 1:50 mark, the chord changes pull hard and just slay me. Awesome song! Thanks, Erin!
joekiddone 1 year ago
Comment removed
joekiddone 1 year ago
Comment removed
joekiddone 1 year ago
I LOVE this song oh and this looks like the video was filmed in Paris.
sugerplum4 1 year ago
i'm going to sing this for an audition :) ill be putting a video up soon of me playing piano and singing it too :)
sparrow4ever33 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and this post is april 6 2010
888tho 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and this post is april 6 2010
888tho 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
and this post is april 6 2010
888tho 1 year ago
and this post is april 6 2010
888tho 1 year ago
wow when she uploaded it was today but a year ago!
888tho 1 year ago
poor fish..haha (L)
claudiavnb 1 year ago
Wish I could have worked on this music video...The song just gives so many awesome ideas for a video! Video was good but it could have been better. You sang amazingly :)
OrangeGirlPublishing 1 year ago
I love her because it's actual singing, not screaming or just talking your lyrics. Her song is soo pretty and I love when they play it in the movie "He's Just Not That In To You". Love her. Love the song.
twinsrocktheworld 2 years ago
the music video sucks..., but the song is amazing..
knowingangelacosta 2 years ago
i saw her live when she opened for Paolo Nutini.
loved her. love her. she's really great and super nice. i got her autograph. it'll be worth something soon, she's going places.
TheKidWhoLived 2 years ago
omg, i never heard of her before but then i randomly came across this song and now im like in love with her. she is amazzing.
tamillavanilla 2 years ago 2
I think if she can continue to write amazing songs like this, she is gonna be huge someday
matchbox1210 2 years ago 4
awesome!
carwego 2 years ago
She favors Ellen Pompeo (aka Meredith Grey).
volcrazy89 2 years ago
I think she looks like Kate on Lost!
2catsilove 2 years ago
thought exactly the same ! ^^
41Blop182 2 years ago
2:32 - she kinda looks like brooke from one tree hill
yes? no?
krisjimo 2 years ago
Why isn't she more famous? Beautiful. Writes music. Sings well live. The music industry continues to confuse me.
15disney16 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
nuriapolcatala 2 years ago
I'm total agree with you!
nuriapolcatala 2 years ago
That's why she's not famous. She's actually talented. She's not auto-tuned, can play an instrument and write! The music industry doesn't seem to favor real talent at this time.
phedre06 2 years ago 45
@phedre06 i 100% agree with you. I LOVE her voice. i really do not know why people appreciates the REAL gift of voice. like gaga, she is AMAZING at live with her outfit and such. I LOVE ERIN MCCARLEY. Pony loveee
MrNceBoy 1 year ago
@phedre06 that is sooo true not like the evil tone deaf cow cheryl cole! grrrr i probs dunno who inm talkin bout if ur not english but alll the boys hate her and she makes young girls wanna kill themselves!!! erin is sooo awshums
sayomi23 1 year ago
Comment removed
kotoneha 1 year ago
@phedre06 I don't think it's because the music industry doesn't favor real talent, I think it's just the genre that is more popular nowadays. There are those who are uber popular that don't auto-tune and can play instruments too
kotoneha 1 year ago
@phedre06 she's not famous because she doesn't want to seel her soul
VickyToriaM 9 months ago
@phedre06 You're right! Nowadays music industry favors singers who have NO TALENT and are plastic sh*ts, they get up on stage looking like sluts making slutty moves and BOOM! they have no idea how to sing !! don't know why is this happening ?!
MrStephanie1212 7 months ago
Sweet song, =)
Solanco9 2 years ago
saw her last night playin back up to Poalo Nutini in the house of blues. Her voice and lyrics were awesome :)
sullyeuroflame 2 years ago
yeah i'm now addicted to her music after seeing her :P
lassy978 2 years ago
she should be waaay more famouss! shes good <3
deathxtoxthexworld 2 years ago
where was this shot?
puffylamama 2 years ago 2
I think Paris because on one of the signs it said "Notre Dame"
TheWritersOfTheWorld 2 years ago
Ya I saw this later... I sat in the same spot on the same bridge as her in the vid without even knowing!!
puffylamama 2 years ago
this song is amazing :)
funkybutt19 2 years ago
Aww! I love the kitty!
Her singing is soo nice!! :) I love this song!
MuzikFreakxoxo 2 years ago 3
i love this music video!
can someone tell me what the fish is supposed to mean? like is there a purpose?
madmonwebshow 2 years ago
I am not sure at all, but here is how i see it : At the begining of the video, you can see her giving the golden fish its freedom (she throws it in the water at 0:01). And at 3:07, she's watching at the same fish, but it is in a store. So she buys it, in order to set it free... (which also means that the story happens in reverse) =) I can't see the link with "love/emptyness" and the fish though...
musiolette 2 years ago
oh i see it now! thank you:)
madmonwebshow 2 years ago
Maybe it was her showing how a small act of love could free something as simple as a goldfish from a store?
I don't know, but this kinda stuff keeps me up at night. haha :)
ScreamItsBri 2 years ago
The only thing that ruins it for me in the video is the fish being released at the end. Knowing that it's a goldfish, raised in a tank, she practically sent that fish to its doom. o_O
LauieChan 2 years ago 20
the beginning of the video is actually the end I believe
she buys the fish and then she throws it into the water
so the video leads up to the beginning
that is my point of view
Johnnywc525 2 years ago
wow i love this song! ive bee a fan since i saw "pony its ok" as the free song on itunes a while ago. your great! =)
emmillyyX6 2 years ago 2
you are georgeous.
love this song.
listening to this song every day. <3
Ssinging 2 years ago 2
wow this video is nice.
much nicer than i had expected it to be...
twoarmpropeller 2 years ago
Love the new video; this song is the greatest. I'll defiantly be voting! :)
MetroStationbby8D 2 years ago
Nice song... superb! Very very uplifting..
xxluvhina 2 years ago
love this video
Genestar12 2 years ago
hey, great video, lovely song but i don't know the location? pls can anyone tell me i'd really love 2 know :)
sfera951122 2 years ago
Definitely Paris.
Pause at 2:39. Look at the street sign.
Notre Dame --> turn left.
=]
xxxBlueRibbonxxx 2 years ago 4
I love this song!
xSophiex600 2 years ago
i love this song and she is also super pretty! does anyone think she looks a little like martina mcbride?
animalgal12 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think she does yea
dancergrl918 2 years ago
i <3 this song
deerhound6 2 years ago
Erin is a very caring and wonderful individual. I had the honor of meeting her in Houston,Tx.
She deserves all the fame that is heading her way!
Chris aka Longbowace
longbowace 2 years ago
This music video is really creative. I love it! Erin, you deserve to go very far with you music career. :)
sarabareillesfanxo 2 years ago 2
love this song - came across it on Grey's Anatomy & He's just not that into you! i love ur music now! a new fan :D :D x
alwaysbwithu1 2 years ago 2
Love this song so awesome
EmoneLake 2 years ago
She is definitely one of my favorite singers.
estrelladebella 2 years ago
This song rox! Cute video too! :) How old is she?
neoninagirl 2 years ago
Shes 30, great song and vid
Kingdavidlee 2 years ago
Oh cool thanks! And yeah it really is!
neoninagirl 2 years ago
She's gorgeous! Great song too! =D
TheBigKx3 2 years ago
canot get outta my head. the lyrics are amazing. love this song absolutly. this is like the 65th time ive listined to this song TODAY.
<3 him so much.
sweetdev97 2 years ago
what;s with the fish?? luv the song alot
MGrammatico 2 years ago
excelent
PersephoneMF 2 years ago
Love your songs, you bring me to my spirit.
please,dont be like the rest of them;empty.
fokus33 2 years ago
It's different. I like it a lot :)
Owlite 2 years ago
love this song...she is so pretty
karmgirlz 2 years ago 2
<333333333333333333333333 XD
rubberducky260 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Could everyone reading this please PLEASE check out my channel and view the video 'peach design'??? It's really important that you do. Thanks!
sarabareillesfanxo 2 years ago
I first was introduced to Erin McCarley by another artist Butterfly Boucher..she and 9 other talented artists took the stage and introduced themselves as Ten out of Tenn (when they came to chicago in 2008)--I was amazed by Erin, and all the other artists..who knew following one artists would lead me to 9 more :) Check out Ten out of Tenn at their myspace... they are all wonderful and I am a fan of Erin McCarley ..still a huge fan of Butterfly Boucher and the rest of the performing artists of TOT
pinayskye 2 years ago
wasnt this song used in a movie
mstwilight2009 2 years ago
yep--- he's just not that into you towards the end
pinayskye 2 years ago
Very beautiful!
Kerry
snowmanwonderful 2 years ago
great music!
CatiTavarez 2 years ago
excelente!!! 10*
LaLi1561 2 years ago
AHA! I've been looking for this everywhere!! Amazing song!!!!
bookworm12895 2 years ago
Amazing song and video!
kecookie06 2 years ago
amazing! so unique! so lovely!
OperaNotes 2 years ago
great video! so simple, great colours, love it.
MacBackwards 2 years ago
Love the lyrics. Cute video.
peppermydog 2 years ago
AMAZING. all i can say. love this song. one of my favorites!
AutumnBlazeee 2 years ago
Such a lovely song.^_^
Maroon5foreva 2 years ago
I love her! However, if you really put a goldfish in a closed jar like that it would eventually suffocate and die. I hope no little kids get the wrong idea and try that.
xLauraC 2 years ago
AHAHAHAHA!!! and i was actually thinking about trying it and i'm not a little kid! and if you puta goldfish in a river, it would also be fatal, right? if it's not used to the water...
OperaNotes 2 years ago
AHmazing video <3
soccerxjb22 2 years ago
i love this song and the video is great!
i ALso love ur voice. and ur so pretty!
an3033 2 years ago
saw her live she was amazing
pinkpotato022 2 years ago
this is like my all time favorite music video and song right now. Erin, you're AWESOME!
sarabareillesfanxo 2 years ago
great song, great video!
georgeb101 2 years ago
wow! this is amazing! i love the song, and the vid is fantastic :]
xoxom27 2 years ago
lovee it
xShAnAyNaYlovesTHx 2 years ago
Anyone else wish she'd do an all acoustic version of her album? I love her live performances. She is even better in person
pengselim 2 years ago 3
That would be AWESOME! An acoustic cd would be great, kind of like what Alanis Morisette did with Jagged Little Pill. And you saw her perform? Lucky!!
neoninagirl 2 years ago
Prodigious video, Erin!
Where did you film the video?
The person behind the camera is genius--I really enjoyed the variation. Congrats on a paramount success.
LeslieRevolutionary 2 years ago
i believe the video was shot in paris
chocolatefire 2 years ago
Thank you. :)
LeslieRevolutionary 2 years ago
you're kidding! i'm moving there in the fall and i am so gonna carry a jar with a golfish around! hehe
OperaNotes 2 years ago
first, i'm so jealous you're moving there! second, i met her a few months ago. she's an extremely kind person so i'm sure she won't mind you paying homage to her :)
enjoy paris!
chocolatefire 2 years ago
AAAAAAAA!!!!!!!! my turn to be jelous. YOU MET HER?!?!?!?!? Oh, I want to!!!!
I'm going for student exchange. And i bet if you tried, you could find a way to go, too. we could share a cafe au lait... and some goldfish water. lol.
OperaNotes 2 years ago
OMG, that's so amazing! I like the camera angle. Good choice! I'd wished I could be the director of one of ur music videos someday. (:
Maddie08209 2 years ago
I love this song! I love this video it is amazing.
Preppi1O1 2 years ago
Nice, really nice.
Guitars4US 2 years ago
yay! my day is brighter now!
13RedPanda 2 years ago
love the song and the video!
both of them ROCK!!!!!
m2dakizal55 2 years ago