The wine was introduced to the greeks again from the ancient people of the Balkan peninsula, who were the thracians, and they never learned to drink it pure without mixing it with water :))) Maybe today after so many years of trying....
And something more, the people in Alexanders army were up to 80% thracians :))
So the question is, who's descendants are then the kalasha?
@dezirra I think they descend upon the persian part of alexander's army. their language is related to iranian and they got the worst part of land at the top of the mountain,meaning they were low soldiers. the pathans say come from alexander's generals but they got mixed with the pakistani people. there are papers though that link the pathans with the greeks.
The story is even more interesting to me. Some may noticed what the narrator mentioned- that even before Alexander comes to the kalasha, they already worshiped Dionysus!!!! This is a great key! Meaning- the mythical story about Dionysus concurring India many thousands years ago might be true. One is sure, Dionysus is NOT A GREEK GOD, but thracian. The dresses of the kalash women are pretty similar to those of karakacani (who are NOT GREEK but thracians too, today greek speaking)
kalash people are live within the geographical boundaries of pakistan for ages , so they are pakistanies NOT greeks or mecedonia......so book closed........however we welcome all people of the world here irrespective to nationality and religion.....we are loving, caring and peaceful people...............mohsin khan from nowshera
@khan4bir You said no greeks or macedonian ,dont you know that Macedonians were one of the many greek tribes,as Spartans and others were?.....Take a look at your books once again and not those make for a fake propaganda by the slavic people of the artificialy named as macedonia,They are a fake multinational State maily composed of Bulgarians and have not anything to do do with Alexander The Great who was purely greek coming from Argos in southern Greece.
@Radamanthos the Macedonians was pure Macedonians not Greeks, you Greeks must too read what say your father of Greek story Herodod, Greeks coming from the (subsahara) Egipt, All know that, but you still wont to steel the Macedonan storry,,because you dont have a story,you call it Mitologi but for you Greeks, for Macedonians was a religion,, and for this you cant to translate the names of goods,, because thay was Macedonain goods, every name have a translation, Greeks stop steel the story
and not only people like alexander the great went east, also people from the east went west, indo-arian originates from the east and was brought to the west. Finnish, Hungarian, and Basque (spain) languages in europe are not related to indo-arian because they lived to isolated to be under influence of the east, they still speak their ancient european languages
i dont know much about this, but is there any proof they are greek descendents? i mean that whole region is full of mixed people, blue eye dark eyes etc. because it simply lies against old sovjet union countries, especially north pakistan afghanistan, and as a whole from west europe to india its all mixed, thats why all indo arian languages have the same origin
Pakistan is beautiful and rich of cultures. It is where traditions meets the modern. We should protect the Kalash culture irrespective of the religion.
May Allah protect my beautiful Pakistan. May Allah destroy the enemies of my motherland.
Pakistan has been at the crossroads of invasions,that is how migrations took place over the millenia. Diversity is the hallmark of Pakistan. Its its strength.
fix ur damn mentality,,,,and then there can be hope of standing against the world power. Look at Iran. They have accepted their ancient history and its diversed background. And just in 30 years, they are on the verge of becoming a nucleur power themself. Allah made all humanity equal. We all are Allah's sign of divine power on this earth. So learn to respect everyone despite their religion, culture and race.
hey you pakistanishaheen...u dont know sh!t......learn to appreciate the diversity of pakistan.....how do u kno for sure tht these are not descendents of Alexander the Great. Were you alive 2000 years ago. u werent! so stfu and try to appreciate pakistan and its mixed background.....and even if Kalash are descendent of alexander's army,,,,then whts ur problem....so r u jus gonna hate them cuz they hav a western ancestry???? this typical desi mentality is da reason why pakistan is left behind.
@awaarabanjara Kallash it's Macedonian/Ilyrian Tribe,but they live There more then 2000 year! The Ilyrian-Macedonian language it is same Albanian languag today!.Ilyrian Macedonian was not Greeks,but greeks occupation the big part of Macedonian and try to steall History!.
desolate to contradict you but linguistic and genetic results attach buruchaski and kalash in the group north - Caucasian as Chechen and Basque circassian more particularly. It is interesting because the Basque language could be ancient of not 5000 years but 7000 years date of separation of the 2 people and therefore the oldest language IE.
Basque indo-european native to Gascony and to Armorique gallic of the family gallo - britanic with Ydna R1b, (Basque, Gascon, Australian, Scotsman, Irish, welsh, Breton, Britton, Dutch), their only one is singularity is their language north - Caucasian close to Tcherkess and to Burush, I see nothing close with Albanian.
The Kalasha have their own gene frequencies, not European and not South Asian but unique.
sure European/SouthAsians may have had whoopy in the valleys thousands of years ago with the Kalasha but the Kalasha were there before that.
kriakraaw 9 months ago
The wine was introduced to the greeks again from the ancient people of the Balkan peninsula, who were the thracians, and they never learned to drink it pure without mixing it with water :))) Maybe today after so many years of trying....
And something more, the people in Alexanders army were up to 80% thracians :))
So the question is, who's descendants are then the kalasha?
dezirra 1 year ago
@dezirra I think they descend upon the persian part of alexander's army. their language is related to iranian and they got the worst part of land at the top of the mountain,meaning they were low soldiers. the pathans say come from alexander's generals but they got mixed with the pakistani people. there are papers though that link the pathans with the greeks.
Katerinoula1980 7 months ago
The story is even more interesting to me. Some may noticed what the narrator mentioned- that even before Alexander comes to the kalasha, they already worshiped Dionysus!!!! This is a great key! Meaning- the mythical story about Dionysus concurring India many thousands years ago might be true. One is sure, Dionysus is NOT A GREEK GOD, but thracian. The dresses of the kalash women are pretty similar to those of karakacani (who are NOT GREEK but thracians too, today greek speaking)
dezirra 1 year ago
@dezirra their dresses remind me of pontian costumes. especially the hats of the women....
Katerinoula1980 7 months ago
@dezirra the highs of extacy = GREEK ahahaha fyromonkeyyyyy
ratzP 2 months ago
wow
imranbmw 1 year ago
beauty
sarahfazee 1 year ago
this is phatan people.
MultiShamali 1 year ago
kalash people are live within the geographical boundaries of pakistan for ages , so they are pakistanies NOT greeks or mecedonia......so book closed........however we welcome all people of the world here irrespective to nationality and religion.....we are loving, caring and peaceful people...............mohsin khan from nowshera
khan4bir 1 year ago 2
@khan4bir You said no greeks or macedonian ,dont you know that Macedonians were one of the many greek tribes,as Spartans and others were?.....Take a look at your books once again and not those make for a fake propaganda by the slavic people of the artificialy named as macedonia,They are a fake multinational State maily composed of Bulgarians and have not anything to do do with Alexander The Great who was purely greek coming from Argos in southern Greece.
Radamanthos 6 months ago
@Radamanthos the Macedonians was pure Macedonians not Greeks, you Greeks must too read what say your father of Greek story Herodod, Greeks coming from the (subsahara) Egipt, All know that, but you still wont to steel the Macedonan storry,,because you dont have a story,you call it Mitologi but for you Greeks, for Macedonians was a religion,, and for this you cant to translate the names of goods,, because thay was Macedonain goods, every name have a translation, Greeks stop steel the story
MkdBad 1 month ago
and not only people like alexander the great went east, also people from the east went west, indo-arian originates from the east and was brought to the west. Finnish, Hungarian, and Basque (spain) languages in europe are not related to indo-arian because they lived to isolated to be under influence of the east, they still speak their ancient european languages
broadcast040 1 year ago
i dont know much about this, but is there any proof they are greek descendents? i mean that whole region is full of mixed people, blue eye dark eyes etc. because it simply lies against old sovjet union countries, especially north pakistan afghanistan, and as a whole from west europe to india its all mixed, thats why all indo arian languages have the same origin
broadcast040 1 year ago
thats is beautiful place!i will visist one day!
SuperHotknight 2 years ago
Pakistan is beautiful and rich of cultures. It is where traditions meets the modern. We should protect the Kalash culture irrespective of the religion.
May Allah protect my beautiful Pakistan. May Allah destroy the enemies of my motherland.
landwarrior82 2 years ago 2
Freedom to the teacher Lerouni
Kalash collect money to
enfranchise Lerouni from Taliban...
Kalash Macedonians of Himalayas!!!
sisman 2 years ago
Pakistan has been at the crossroads of invasions,that is how migrations took place over the millenia. Diversity is the hallmark of Pakistan. Its its strength.
pervezak 2 years ago 4
fix ur damn mentality,,,,and then there can be hope of standing against the world power. Look at Iran. They have accepted their ancient history and its diversed background. And just in 30 years, they are on the verge of becoming a nucleur power themself. Allah made all humanity equal. We all are Allah's sign of divine power on this earth. So learn to respect everyone despite their religion, culture and race.
awaarabanjara 2 years ago
hey you pakistanishaheen...u dont know sh!t......learn to appreciate the diversity of pakistan.....how do u kno for sure tht these are not descendents of Alexander the Great. Were you alive 2000 years ago. u werent! so stfu and try to appreciate pakistan and its mixed background.....and even if Kalash are descendent of alexander's army,,,,then whts ur problem....so r u jus gonna hate them cuz they hav a western ancestry???? this typical desi mentality is da reason why pakistan is left behind.
awaarabanjara 2 years ago 2
@awaarabanjara Kallash it's Macedonian/Ilyrian Tribe,but they live There more then 2000 year! The Ilyrian-Macedonian language it is same Albanian languag today!.Ilyrian Macedonian was not Greeks,but greeks occupation the big part of Macedonian and try to steall History!.
Genti115 1 year ago
@Genti115
desolate to contradict you but linguistic and genetic results attach buruchaski and kalash in the group north - Caucasian as Chechen and Basque circassian more particularly. It is interesting because the Basque language could be ancient of not 5000 years but 7000 years date of separation of the 2 people and therefore the oldest language IE.
polarisreseau 1 year ago
@polarisreseau Basque,from North Spain,and south France have same origine like Albanian.They have Origine fronm Pellasgian.
Genti115 1 year ago
@Genti115
Basque indo-european native to Gascony and to Armorique gallic of the family gallo - britanic with Ydna R1b, (Basque, Gascon, Australian, Scotsman, Irish, welsh, Breton, Britton, Dutch), their only one is singularity is their language north - Caucasian close to Tcherkess and to Burush, I see nothing close with Albanian.
polarisreseau 1 year ago
this is BULL****** these are not reletives of Alaxander. Kalash language is DARDIC related to Kashmiri!!
Typical European propaganda!!
PakistaniShaheen 2 years ago
@PakistaniShaheen So true..
jiggashady 1 year ago
@PakistaniShaheen
it is very strange as countries as usages, people and especially women the sad attitude seems me to have. I would have liked tried them cable archaic
polarisreseau 1 year ago