Added: 3 years ago
From: BBC
Views: 37,062
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (510)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • it still gives me chills when rose turns around and the doomsday music plays...

  • Rose Tyler... Welcome back

  • I LOVE that they played 'Doomsday' when Rose turns and we see that it's her :)

  • i remembering seeing this when it first broadcast, i was like 'what, how is that possible?' and really excited at the same time.

  • Surely it would have been better if Rose had just been trapped in Pete's universe instead of being brought back... given a Doctor clone of her own, (with a bit of Donna too... euww). Having her return just made it clear RTD was in love with the character like Moffat is with River Song.

  • @Traininghopper yea but rose is better :)

  • First time I saw this, my head asploded.

    That was an awkward trip to the hospital.

  • what's the tune that starts playing at 0:12?

  • @3ghproductions it's called Doomsday. It's the song played at the end of episode Doomsday (last one of Rose's series if it helps at all). :)

  • what is the song in this clip ?

  • Doomsday I think..

  • Wat joke tell me??? i relly do hope she cums bak but i wonder how?? wanna be friends?

  • i sed is she!! it sez on sum videos she is on sum it sez she isnt so dont blame mee!

  • GO ROSE! is she cumin in the 5th series

  • Sorry, no. BUT, she will appear in David Tennant's final story, made up of the last two 2009 Specials (2 hours long) in which she will appear in the second part. The Tenth Doctor (David Tennant) goes back in time to see Rose before he originally met her, on New Year's Eve 2004. He tells her she is going to have a fantastic year 2005 and also reportedly tells her he loves her and kisses her. He then has to erase her memory and runs back to the TARDIS where he sees a vision of Ood Sigma and falls.

  • @Kaagh178 ...extremely close. lol.

  • Also, Rose's mother Jackie is with Rose in the town but when Rose sees the Doctor, she goes off to talk to him in the alleyway, alone.

  • Sorry but firstly, she's coming, not cuming. and secondly she won't be in series 5. But she will be in this years Christmas special 'The end of time'. I can't wait. :)

  • I DONT CARE HOW I SPELL ON YOUTUBE!!!

  • Alright calm down love.

  • Comment removed

  • wtf!!

  • how do you know she will be in the xmas special and the title of it aswell?

  • I've looked around on the internet. Theres pictures of her. Try 'Planet Gallifrey', just Google it. And at Comic Con they played a minute clip of the final and at the end it said the titles 'The End of Time'.

  • How do you not know she will be in the final special and the title? Pretty much everyone is aware of her *twisted* return. Her return isn't exactly coming back because the Doctor goes back in time to before he met her.

    Also- the trailer for the special has been released and says 'The End of Time' for the title.

  • ok calm down lucozade lover its only a tv show lol

  • lol I was watching this with my family and just before she turned round I realised and went "That's Rose *she turns*

    it is! IT IS! OH MY GOD!

    It was hilarious we all started shouting at the tv :D

  • ME 2

  • i remember reading a set report about donna putting keys in a bin then talking to rose a few months before this trnasmitted so when i saw this i was going "ROSE IS OVER THERE! SHE'S GONNA TALK TO HER!!". this is my favourite scene from Series 4 because it was such a shock to see her so soon. Possibly my favourite scene from the whole of Doctor Who. =D

  • this scene to this day still sends shivers down the spine for me.

  • did u know that this was shot durin "turn left"

  • no but you learn something new everyday. thankyou.:)

  • how do u no that?

  • Rose is great!

  • hmm.....she's walking/turning right to the paralelle(soz bad spelling) universe and the episode when she comes back to earth is called "turn left". turn right = parallel unviverse, turn left = planet earth.

    also why doesn't the doctor go back in time and say hi to her?

  • do you even pay attention to doctor who? he cant go back in time and say hi because it'll stuff history up...

  • Rose is the best out of Donna and Martha. I can't wait for episode 11. Is it episode 7 this saturday? =]

  • How can she be the best out of Donna & Martha when she isn't listed there. Donna is far superior to all previous companions for no. 10

  • episode 7 "thats like charls dickens hanging around with ghosts...at christmas"so he thinks about rose and him fighting them

  • EATLEAT: knownone cares, everyone loves david tennant and billie piper, besides your "spoiler" is false

  • u fuck off. bitch

  • that's a horrible thing to say....i am sorry for saying fuck off, i didn't relise you have problems. =]

  • lol u r a retard :D

  • Rose spoilers in series 4 so far:-

    Episode 1- Donna talks to Rose and then Rose just vanishes

    Episode 2- The quote that "She is Returning"

    Episode 3- The Ood say that every song must end while rose's song plays

    Episode 5- Rose's face appers on the Tardis screen miming "DOCTOR"

    ...

    Rose Tyler, Welcome Back

  • On the Doctor Who website, if you watch Captain Jack's Torchwood files of the Hath, then Rose pops up again half way through :D

  • episode 6 rose can be seeen on the monster fils

  • Rose Spoilers continued -

    Mid series trail - Donna says "Rose is coming back and even though all thats happening , isn't that a good thing - the doctor grins and says "Yeah"... Rose can be seen with a gun and explosions behind her. Then Rose says " Right. Now we're in trouble." "Its only just beinning". Then finally Rose - "Its coming, Donna. Its coming across the stars and noone can stop it." Donna - "What is?" Rose- "The Darkness..."

  • wat the hell r u telling us that for we all saw it!

  • I was correcting someone who posted it you Noob!

  • i cant wait for the docs reaction when she comes back!what a picture itll be

  • if you look closely you can see rose click her fingers before she vanishes

  • Left or right hand? I can't quite make it out.

  • Right hand because she is walking away from the screen. I didn't notice it. Thanks muffinman for pointing that out.

  • Thanks!

  • she appears in episode 11 i think. in the radio times it was given a synopsis of all the eps and 11 mentioned something about someone whos "thought to be lost"

    omg waiting for it is killing me. but after she comes back i wont want her to go. tho donna makes me laugh. im glad shes not all in love with him cus that was getting boring. their dynamics are really good!

  • when i first saw this all the air went from my lungs and i was nearly blacking out

  • lol bring on the finale!! Loving this series so much. I just love it how they put little clues in the episode, like rose's song appearing in the background at times and rose's face on the tv in the tardis. Sigh its like gathering clues in the harry potter series again hehe

  • ok, so i just saw the othere half of the sontaran thingy, and rose appeared for a fraction of a second when the doctor was talking to them on their ship... what does this mean exactly? plz reply to this comment...

  • i heard darvos (bad spelling!) is breaking the rift..to free the Daleks trapped in hell, thus making the boundarys unstable, so Rose is breaking through to warn the Doctor...thats what i heard!

  • awesome theory

  • 11.

  • did u see Rose in the posion sky! she looked, well, mightly terrified! just for a second, before the doctor's face comes onto the TARDIS screen....this is gonna be some finale? but is this the 10th doctors last? wondering cos of the Odd saying how his song would end soon....any help?

  • yeah i saw that !

    there are 13 regenerations i think... but his daughter. This is insane !

  • not really! remember Fear Her (series 2)? The Doctor says to Rose (can't remember the context)"I was a father once"....so this story has been two years in the making...should be fantastic!

  • its the doomsday song that played... not his song... its on bout rose returning, therefore his song for her ends.

  • I wanna no what eposode she comes back in :S

  • she doesnt look happy.....=S she just whnts to find her doctor as she saw that ship she thought she'd see him but he was on the rooftop and in the adipose building *sigh* wish rose stayed for abit longer so she could've followed donna

    That would've ruled

    GO ROSE!

  • i think what happend was when the doctor put the 2 sonics together it pulles all backround radiation to near where he is but it only last for a min or so

  • i didnt see her in the sontaren strategen but mabey on other episodes

  • The Sontaran episode is a Two Parter so she may be in the end of next weeks episode

  • My brother thinks she is dead

    Ithought it was soooo cool wen I saw her

    I was all alone I was like 'OH MY GOD' and squelling loudly

  • No its not!

  • i agree with Evilgidgit

    no! it so isnt!

  • i now officially understand what people mean when they say that their jaw hit the floor!

    suuuuch a good moment! :)

  • she is, apparnetly all the modern day earth ones we will see her

  • we see her in osntaran stratgem maybe???

  • I wonder if we will see Rose again in tomorrows episode The Sontaran Stratagem.

  • Now that I look at this again ...

    When she walks, she has her head down halfway there and then outstretches her arms ever so slightly before disappearing. Maybe she has some kind of device that allowed her to get there?

    And the bees disappearing must be significant.

  • no. that was just her lil skippy way of walking =]

    and why does everyone think the bees and the wasp are connected?! bees hate wasps! there is no connection!

    it's like saying 'loads of pigeons went missing - it must have something to do with the giant eagle episode!'

  • if you look close at her hands she clicks or does something with them

  • i wonder if... the bees disappearing

    is more significant

    than it's making out to be?

    maybe the blatant arcs (shadow proclomation, missing planets, cascade of medusa) they're showing are to throw us off?

    what a bunch of hooligans.

  • the bees disapering is something we WILL find out later in the series.

    because remember the trailer to the 4th series (which was on at the end of the voyage of the damned)

    it shown a HUGE bee chasing donna ready to sting her.

    =]

  • I think that's a wasp, espicially since the episode it's in is called "The Unicorn and the Wasp".

  • clues for the doc episode 1 this

    episode 2 "she is returning"

    episode 3"every song must end" and then the doomsday music was played

    coincidence yea rite

  • If only the Doctor followed Donna or even Donna recognising her from a picture or something ... gawd. I really CANNOT wait until she returns! *Does fan girl squeak*

  • if only one of them knew.........

    cant WAIT for episode 10

    ROSE WILL BE BACK!!!!!!!

  • I love rose =D billie pipers amazing <33

  • int da music mint lol :D

  • I can't wait for Rose to come back properly! She's the best! If only the Doctor had followed Donna or something and seen her! I can't wait!

  • shes not coming back properally!

    only for 3 episodes

    :(

  • I can't wait for Rose to come back properly! She's the best! If only the Doctor had followed Donna or something and seen her! I can't wait!

  • was it me, or did billy piper not appear in the credits?

  • i don't think she did

  • she did, she was listed third after the doctor and donna at the end

  • she did

  • she did what?

    donna didnt know who rose was

    and rose didnt know who donna was.

  • she did appear in the credits

  • why duz it sound like shes in the tardis?

    Maybe she found the doctor in the parallel world and he looks diferent

  • its the dramatic music

    I think

  • The Doctor is Half Human, Half Time Lord. Hence is love for the planet Earth.

    And as far as I know, the mother of his daughter was a human, so his daughter would be a very diluted Time Lord...

  • no defenately not a picture

  • maybe rose was sending just the image of herself through not her actual self like the doctor did when he went to say goodbeye to her in season 2 maybe thats why her footsteps sound weird...

  • Similar music as 'The Apprentice' lol!

  • that episode were rose got trapped in a parrel wold made me cry! seriusly it did!

  • same here! i told myself i wuldnt cry but.....i did it was soo sad =[

  • I'am not sure but probably the most obvious answer is that rose created a vortex manipulator (allows you to break the rift) but if rose can create one so can davros and the daleks- oh by the way davros is coming back- davros is creator of the dalek-

  • Does anyone reckon rose being there at that time has anything to do with that woman's sonic pen thing? He threw that in a bin too so maybe it'll come to light in the last few episodes whether the doctor sen her back to that time. Just a thought.

  • Ooooh gosh i love how the music repeats back to doomsday music as soon as rose's face is shown.

    A little bit of a coincedence that donna was talking to her and not the woman next to rose lol.

    but very good plot to bring rose back into the fold for a bit

  • The Doctor lied to Rose. There is one small gap left in the universe, and the Doctor is going to get her back.

    But is he strong enough? ANd what wil it cost?

    nahh jus kiddin dis is wot i thought but i dnt kno 4 sueree

  • it mite be sum fing lyk bad wolf...

  • hi ppl i thought u might wnna kno dat on da mag dr who adventures,it gives u da list of the episode in da 4th series! hee u go: 1.Partners in crime 2.the fires of pompeii 3.planet of the ood 4.the sontaran stratagem 5.the poisen sky 6.the doctors daughter 7.the unicorn and the wasp 8.silemce in the libary 9.forest of the dead(previsly called rivers run) 10.midnight 11.turn left 12.title unknown (dats wot it says) 13.journey's end there and really i didn't make these up bye!
  • I highly doubt they will bring in the Doctor's daughter.

    I mean, in his very first form he was a Grandfather.

    Think how old his daughter would be.

    Because when the Doctor is always talking about not being part of events and messing up timelines, if he went back to when his daughter is young, it could screw things up.

    If the episode you mean is the blonde woman.

    That is Agatha Christie.

  • yeah, i dont think he has a daughter either

  • Oh he does have one.

    In the very first series ever, one of his assistants was his Grand daughter.

    So he must have a son or daughter, to have a grand daughter!

  • ah! okay. thanks for telling me XD

    i will tell all this to my friend at school on monday XD

  • but she might hv died in the time war!

  • but she might hv died in the time war!

  • if you talking about the movie called doctor who and the darleks it was made by diffrent people and the doctor wasn't even a time lord, i was :S when i first saw it but i checked wikipidia

  • The strange thing is not that we can see Rose, but that she fades away...

  • That can easily be linked with how the Doctor entered her world through the Tardis, a technology could have been created to mimic that type of travel.

    Possibly?

  • omg i screamed when i saw rose int hat episode

  • i found out ona webby that the ood gonna tell donna that somefinks on her back 2 so itz gonna be lyk bad wolf i think following them everywhere!

  • in fear her the doctor said he was a father

  • There's something on your back.

  • i know what the hell was that bout but it has to lead up to the final gotta!

  • Yeah they are all supposedly in this series.

    Donna, Rose, Martha and Sarah Jane Smith.

    Jack's going to be in it too.

    Does he count as an assistant?

  • hmmm the doctors daughter could that be in cuz that is the 6th episode

  • How could The Master come back =/

    He refused to generate and therefore died.

    Hmmm.

    OOO, Just thought, I remember in those last episodes that the Time Lord's Resurrected The Master to fight in the Time War...

    Possibilty?

  • yh but lucy got da ring so really she couls resarect him coz like if she rubs it like a lamp maybe he can go into uva ppl like casandra did but still anything could happen! imean its dr who were talkin bout and the doctor can make nearly anything happen

    have u watch series 1,2 & 3? are u watchin 4 every saturday like me?

  • That I am.

    I have watched all the series :]

    Watched several older episodes too.

    My little bro is obsessed and has DVDs with older Doctors.

  • its the masters wife. she uses the ring to be posessed by him

  • i think the dead master was a robot nd the real one escaped

  • or that ring had his soul or something

  • it is said that doctor who will have THREE ASSISTENCE!!!

  • actually 4. donna, sarah jane smith, martha, and rose :)

  • are u sure about sarah jane

  • nd dnt frgt captain jack!

  • BILLIA PIPER RETURNS?

  • Maybe she got back via Torchwood in her parralell world

    Because if you remember on the doomsday episode when she finnaly says goodbye to the doctor on the beach she says "The Torchwood over here is just opening o ill probably get a job there, i think i know a bit about aliens!"

    So if she's working for torchwood, or is even head of torchwood, she would be able to have access to their alien tech

    And that tech might be able to bring her back?

  • i gotta say one more fing wen she says "me,mum,dad,micky n the baby" b4 she says its jakies she hesitates n its said that the dr's daughter is cumin back

  • w8 rose is coming back i thought she was in the opposite dimension thingy

  • I lierally started cryin when I first saw this coz I woz so shocked!

    Shez mentioned in fires of Pompei want she?

    the man told the doctor that shed return or somefink lyk that!

  • what?! i dont remember that! :S xxx

  • Woop! rose is backkk

    (finnaly maybee a good figure with poseable arms)

    lol typical me, something great happens i find marketing possibilities!

    dont get me wrong i think rose is fab and i recon shes gona be the series follow through like bad wolf and torchwood and mr saxon :D

  • Also..

    If you remember in the episodes with The Master of the timelords

    at the end of that episode there is a woman holding a ring, according to recent rumours, The Master has something to do with all of this. Why else would they show a woman holding a ring at the end of an episode, leaveing it unexplained?

  • well

    Theres a video somewhere on Youtube

    with Rose saying to the doctor like:

    "Why did you do this to me? Wasnt i kind to you? Didnt i tell you how i felt? I thought you cared for me, and if you loved me you wouldent do this to me!"

  • I think that rose might not be all there that why she just when and also when in fires of pompeii he said donna you have something on your back. that will be something in the last episode !!!!!!!!!

  • Yeah...

    The Doctor pure pooped his pants

  • Yeh i did! Lol, it great! aah their so sweet!

  • Did anyone else notice the rose reference in the fires of pompei. " she will return" said by that dude to teh doctor???

  • yeh i saw that but no-one else did.

  • yh i noticed i was wondering whether he meant rose!

  • He may of, or he could of meant the doctors daughter who is said to be returning this season.

  • IT'S ROOOOOOOOSE!!!!!!!!!! It's guud Billie Piper's cumin back!!!

  • Rose won't e in any more episodes until the conclusion of the series, i don't think...

    And xhi1xhi2xhi3x, I think it's meant to be the same type of thing that the Doctor did to see her at the end of Series 2.

  • i heard she'll pop up now and again

  • Poor Sylvia, She won't get the car keys now! ;p

  • bloody doomsday music . . . *sob*

  • is she like a kind of ghost or something? Cos i cant figure out why she just faded away like that...

  • OMMMGGG i love all the 3 new companions! cant wait to see them togeter....but i heard martha was actuly a clone???? is this true???

  • Nah- It;s probably something that a martha hater has said..

  • sidekick? lmao ... there sidekicks now? ... and the Doctor ... batman? lol

  • DUM DUM DUM!! Thought it would take a lot longer for her to appear but the very first episode!

  • wow imagine all 3 sidekicks in one episode i bet the doctor will feel a bit nervous lol! cant wait XD