@mahela1993 I knew what the answer would be but I just tried it out anyway. I don't get anything different than when the crystal is just sitting there - so no effect.
@RimstarOrg Piezoelectric materials do not generate electricity from pressure but from their change in shape. Applying a constant pressure is no longer changing the shape of the crystal so no voltage is generated.
@aardvarkmikey You create another batch of the solution like when you made the seed crystal. Then you hang the seed crystal from something like a fishing line in this new solution and let it sit. Keep the temperature very constant. I put the container in a styrofoam box in a closet. I'll put a link in the video description but basically that's the idea.
I'd like to try making some using your "previous How-To" video as a reference, but instead of making clumps, to make sheets dried on a copper clad PCB to facilitate soldering. Any reason why that wouldn't work?
I have tested those standard piezo discs glued to the dust cap of a 15" woofer as a motional feedback sensor. It worked quite well, and I was surprised by the response linearity.
@MichaelAChang Interesting. I don't know if pouring the solution out on a copper clad PCB would work. I have my doubts it would work on your first attempt. You'd probably have to do a number of tries to find out. The batch I made this time didn't give as many crystals as the batch I made a few years ago, and yet it was the same recipe. So there are variables to play with, probably temperatures in my case since I didn't strictly monitor and control that.
@MichaelAChang Thinking more of what you want to do - It would still be very hard and I don't know how well it would work, but you could do as in my "previous How-To" video. Then select a flatish crystal that tests the way you want and use that as a seed crystal to make a larger one. The larger one would be made in a flatish container with a PCB bottom. See the last part of the "How to make a Rochelle salt crystal" page on my website. A link is in the description of the "previous How-To" video.
What type of crystals are they? If you have a scope you can always test them. Be sure to test them in different orientations as I mention in the video. I had to rotate the small crystal into a lot of different orientations before finding one that worked well.
Why do I have them, the big one I made a few years ago as a component in a free energy experiment, not that I thought you could get free energy from a crystal alone - you can't. The recent ones I made just to show people how to do this.
What does the reading look like if, instead of tapping the crystal, you apply sustained pressure on the crystal?
mahela1993 2 months ago
@mahela1993 I knew what the answer would be but I just tried it out anyway. I don't get anything different than when the crystal is just sitting there - so no effect.
RimstarOrg 2 months ago
@RimstarOrg Thanks for the reply.
But why doesn't a voltage develop when the crystal stays deformed (due to the sustained pressure)?
mahela1993 2 months ago
@mahela1993 I don't know and can't seem to find an answer. If you find out let us know.
RimstarOrg 2 months ago
@RimstarOrg Piezoelectric materials do not generate electricity from pressure but from their change in shape. Applying a constant pressure is no longer changing the shape of the crystal so no voltage is generated.
TheJoeker001 2 days ago
@TheJoeker001 Thanks! Well put.
RimstarOrg 2 days ago
awesome! Thank you!
aardvarkmikey 2 months ago
How did you use the smaller crystal as a "seed crystal" to grow the larger one?
aardvarkmikey 2 months ago
@aardvarkmikey You create another batch of the solution like when you made the seed crystal. Then you hang the seed crystal from something like a fishing line in this new solution and let it sit. Keep the temperature very constant. I put the container in a styrofoam box in a closet. I'll put a link in the video description but basically that's the idea.
RimstarOrg 2 months ago
I'd like to try making some using your "previous How-To" video as a reference, but instead of making clumps, to make sheets dried on a copper clad PCB to facilitate soldering. Any reason why that wouldn't work?
I have tested those standard piezo discs glued to the dust cap of a 15" woofer as a motional feedback sensor. It worked quite well, and I was surprised by the response linearity.
MichaelAChang 3 months ago
@MichaelAChang Interesting. I don't know if pouring the solution out on a copper clad PCB would work. I have my doubts it would work on your first attempt. You'd probably have to do a number of tries to find out. The batch I made this time didn't give as many crystals as the batch I made a few years ago, and yet it was the same recipe. So there are variables to play with, probably temperatures in my case since I didn't strictly monitor and control that.
RimstarOrg 3 months ago
@MichaelAChang Thinking more of what you want to do - It would still be very hard and I don't know how well it would work, but you could do as in my "previous How-To" video. Then select a flatish crystal that tests the way you want and use that as a seed crystal to make a larger one. The larger one would be made in a flatish container with a PCB bottom. See the last part of the "How to make a Rochelle salt crystal" page on my website. A link is in the description of the "previous How-To" video.
RimstarOrg 3 months ago
What type of crystals are they? If you have a scope you can always test them. Be sure to test them in different orientations as I mention in the video. I had to rotate the small crystal into a lot of different orientations before finding one that worked well.
Why do I have them, the big one I made a few years ago as a component in a free energy experiment, not that I thought you could get free energy from a crystal alone - you can't. The recent ones I made just to show people how to do this.
RimstarOrg 3 months ago