A perfect circle The Noose (LIVE)

[cibisque]

...this is heaven. a sad one.

[MaialynCables]

Is this really a live version? It sounds studio perfect

[broth0076]

so good wow its going off into another place listening to this song, might be my favorite song ever made, love this version also got a totally different feel

[meankhan]

Song of my fucking life... Sung with so much emotions and passion. Maynard is a genius.

[Spieluhr48]

this song always finds a way to bring a tear to my eye

[DeathumusMaxumus]

14 lil wayne fans

[TheMichellemawson]

14 dislikes................i do not understand, is yr hearin aid switched on?

[yeshuaisraeli]

(¬_¬)

[cat1985100]

I heard him sing this song live at the Universal Studios concert and it was just a beautiful experience.

[russellmcmanus]

I'd like to dedicate this song to my former attorney, now linn county deputy district attorney keith stein. As well as oregon department of justice trial division attorney stephen dingle, also a former linn county deputy district attorney.

[Peitzsucks]

one of the best songs ever written!!!!

[CDybs]

Not sure how you can press the dislike button. Great live ver of this song. Love everything you guys do. Keep it up.

[Ch1llma3xtr3m]

HOW can u NOT like this ???? INSANE !!!

[awndriuh]

His voice is simply b-e-a-utiful! I love this song along with the others! =)

[moiUnenlagia]

Where did you get this ?

[crazymiles]

@moiUnenlagia It's from the aMOTION DVD.

[craziestlobo19]

Everything A Perfect Circle puts out is beautiful...

Just beautiful

[thethirdpowell]

Love this song

[chuyin005]

You're more than just a little.. curious.. How you're planning to go about.. makin' your amends..... just epic T.T

[headwork2008]

this song is awesome!



[atennnant01]

crystal castles good job guys!

now what about what's his name devil hell beast or something- that thing I responded with...

?

ok plumb island I will give you a hint. it has a light in a very strange place. and it is not a vagina. it was my wristwatch. brandname. coleman.

where can you go with that? oh and btw I found out about the LOUD thing and the capital letters. has to do with my own and my sister's big black journals that we had in elementary school. I had the 'duh stupid' - actually

[atennnant01]

@atennnant01

nevermind

[lemberalla]

Amazing live performance. Great

[undergroundjackal]

the video is like edited by a retard.

[killerpolla1]

Makes me chill my skin, just perfect.

[Axedrumgod]

Amazing song

[tukoraliczek]

best.

[suckitup1983]

very boring and whiney song... fades right into the rest of the crap that people like you demand and listen to. with the bad taste you make good music look better. but seriously..... why do people like this crap? i love a lot of music and this shit is just miserable. rock is dying, courtney love said it right. rock is dead. this band proves that

[tvdrummer]

@suckitup1983 You've gotta be sober....

[cluSterfUck1000]

@suckitup1983

Do you know how many bands have listed this group as one of their major influences?

Pretty please let me know what you consider good music..

[suckitup1983]

a perfect cirlce jerk with all the fans getting cummed on in the middle by a painfully sounding band

[stnwushu11]

come to chile... 

[deannejahman]

240p we meet again

[XNECROXMONGERX]

@deannejahman i actually laughed pretty loud when i read that haha

[orazz24]

@deannejahman I find this video's resolution easy to masturbate to.

[ReflectioNReflectioN]

4:12 Multiple Maynards. Win.

[Dustin322]

@ReflectioNReflectioN

loop stations are amazing things in good hands

[Epinephrine512]

awesome video!

[sk8swmangos]

Was maynard playing a guitar?

[stevescott1313]

love this song

[hdwddm]

Great vid,awsome sound quality,this song is so pure and clear,unexplainable feelings while listening to it.

[knoehjk]

the best alive song of APC ever!!!

love it!!!!

[ortizfanatic07]

Only voice around capable of causing blissful paralysis.

[DogStreetXero]

13 people were tugged of there clouds

[jazzyfreaky2212]

I LOVE THIS SONG!!!

[toxicdollZoetrip]

This video is such a vision of perfection, that adds to the honey silkiness of Maynard's voice

[3libras1971]

13 people are obviously tone deaf and have no taste in music

[beyoNdHQq]

i wonder how still there's people who cant believe that Maynard is god

[noname91910]

It would have been awesome for him to say "Your halo slipping down, to choke you MEOW" in the end. xD

[naomishaehedrick]

this song is my favorite song. and the live version i mean. thats how talented they are :)

[DreVersion1]

13 people need a 13th step program (O_O)

[IxxXsmXxxI]

there has always been something about the rock greats that has..even though completly depressed me, made me stay true with music. when these guys came out i was in a bad state with rock due to the canadian "cry for your girlfriend" gig

that swept michigan. besides clasic rock i lost hope. these guys revived my depression and let me know its still alive. its better to fell anything than nothing so thanks to maynard and his insperations. as for the drum bass and guitar.. thanks for my life. peace.

[KoriKrazyLoon]

this song is so beautifully performed.

[whatsinmadrid]

i remember one of the interviews maynard had regarding what this song about. he said it was about people who came back from war, e.g. the korean war very proud. they glorified themselves in such a way that they thought they were better than everyone else and the song is about how they shouldn't put such a halo above their heads because it's going to turn into a noose.

[MarbleYank]

Religious faith vs. addiction, eh?

Someone explain how this song couldn't possibly have anything to do with both topics; surely a human being can find themselves addicted to more than just a substance. Granted, too much of an investment of one's self into a certain belief could be just like a drug... altering, euphoric at some moments, and ultimately detrimental to your well-being, whatever. I'm talking out of my dick.

[gazzdog8]

@MarbleYank

I agree that it is somewhere in between. The whole album is based on the 12 step recovery program for alcoholics, which is dependent on faith to get you through.

[johnnyfourhats]

If there is no God,how can a drumkit sound like that ?

[SlamPig84]

" Maynaaard!!!!"

[iWentToNam]

awww, damn he didnt play the open high-hat parts :( the noose has one of the coolest drum beats, very underrated drummer he is

[iWentToNam]

Listening to apc and tool turns people into thinking people, which is why maynard is a fucking legend :)

[FRONADZ]

EARGASM

[IsidorsEyes]

It s just that APC and TOOL changed my life!!!!!! I love everything about them!

[beyoNdHQq]

its maynard, its spechless, its from the gods

[drumgawd11]

Breathtaking. 

[melleutopie33]

I'm so in love with this song

[Stgdemon]

I personally think he's describing a person that has caused deaths through out their lifes and suddenly thinks their "New view" makes up for it (IE a king, government, killer, etc.). It also makes me think of Al Sharpton, that guy needs to be choked by somthing.

[overthar]

@Stgdemon voted up because of al sharpton

[IllusionsChild]

I can only describe this as epic.

[nicknack8401]

13 people need to fuck off

[twowheels808]

My favorite thirteenth step song. This song means anything from the Christian crusades to Duane Chapman. This is about high and mighty "born again" hypocrites that preach, yet they have a nasty past they haven't owned up to yet. Their halo slips down when nobody's looking.

[TheDylan626]

The irony is that God listens to this and says, "damn that's good".

[seanr1013q]

has anyone thought for themselves? perhaps the song is about ANYONE who has changed their life & now judges ALL others! I hope the Halo chokes Those people untill they realize we are all the same!

[Wendeyaho]

Mayndard in this video is more like "an outspoken anti-theistic singer" who sounds like heaven...without going into theological stuff~ watch out for your halo~ this is the best live performance I've watched for this particular track....oh and yeah, fuck you god!

[Vitalino01]

awesome performance:)



[snakegirl46]

just amazing

[stepke2000]

Perfect.

[Aufaugen]

I'm going to see them this summer with some friends, I can't wait ^_^

[uchihapato]

In the olimpus listen APC

[PitBULLY316]

@reedrk88t I agree. I think of the same thing when I hear this song.

[reedrk88t]

I dedicate this to all the troops who have lost their lives fighting a war that only the politicians can cause. They have no f..... Idea what its like for us to do their bidding.

[knoehjk]

I Imagine myself making love or laying on the grass smoking a cigarrette watching the clouds move when I hear this song

[ovech4pres]

This song sounds like it should be in Donnie Darko

[sessomaru888]

"I'd like to dedicate this song to George Bush!" Your halo's slippin down to choke you now!

[lazorman8]

It's not about God, it's about addiction.

[Snakepit4321]

@lazorman8 Its about whatever it means to the listener, bromosexual.

[faustus83]

@lazorman8 my understanding is that there was a lot of conflict within the group regarding the direction of the song... like a whole heap. whereas someone (can't remember who) wanted it to be about addiction, maynard wanted the song to be an ode to his late mother, who was a strict baptist ("making your amends to the dead"). the final product is essentially a marriage of both themes. and brilliantly done, methinks.

[Kkempinski]

@lazorman8 God is an addiction for some.

[therastagista]

best song ever!

[paintedtrue]

that was exceptional, especially for a live performance

[StreetSpiritKidA]

Maynard James Keenan = Most hypnotic voice ever

[jayandtay09]

12 people are child molesters

[poontang3zizo]

12 people apparently like squares

[Kris9540]

So glad to see you well, now i'm a stranger for you...

[TousAlbanousgamw]

I love A perfect circle!!!!!

[PalmDesertRock]

I saw APC in 2002 or so in Cologne, Germany. The Club was pretty small, around 200 people there. Including festivals I've heared around 200 Bands playing live and none of them came even close to that experience. Not even Tool themselves a couple years later. I remember this concert to this day every now and then and I'm glad I've been there.

[EvilToastbrot]

every time i go to sleep (well.. at least very often) i listen to this exact live version of the song. i would spend millions just so i could have been there in the moment this perfect piece of music was played.

<3

[DoeBoi2525]

10 people are orphans

[EbonyFaery]

How can ten people have given this a thumbs down?!

[Peacesells699]

10 people don't know shit about good music like this masterpiece! :D

[RosAutomatic]

@Peacesells699 I'M ONE OF THEM. DOWN 4 THE DRUMMER!!! THUMBS UP FOR THE SONG-MASTERPIECE!

[oscardelarosapineda]

Great smooth song

[aMUSEdxxXx]

The perfect voice, the perfect band, the perfect circle of musicians.

Thanks for making good music possible.

[LaLune44]

more than just a little curious, how your planning to go about making your amends........to the dead.

[ONtheAtty]

Ooooooh! AMAZING! 

[girlburn]

una maravilla de canción y de directo. os amo! VENID A SPAIN!!

[morganbuckley101]

my older brother just showed me this band yesterday i'm in ♥ to say the least

[extralarge096]

who are the 9 bone heads that didn't like this video?

[ChipFinnigan]

@extralarge096 

[herpiede]

WOW, I wanna see them Live, I have all CDs but I haven't seen em live yet.

[linkamus]

Wow.. enough said.

[Baritji]

This song is to music as to what I am to mankind... Perfection...

:P

[joaoluizsn]

it's about the song and not the guy singing it, so as long as he keep bringing it...damn i just thought of Lady Gaga now...anyway, Maynard Rules and i miss him.

[Judas714]

9 ppl r gonna die by my hand

[andrey3722]

brasil na área perfeita!!!

[CellpanTV]

cant wait for both albums

[a1dra]

They played this at the Palms in Vegas 2 nights ago and it was magical. Magical.

[herraage]

Nothing else makes my day like hearing Maynards voice at it's best! (:

[thegrungewave]

idk if it's a good thing or a bad thing that u dont c Maynard in this video. i kinda like it tho. it gives the video more of a mysterious & artsy feeling. it's pretty fuckin cool. \m/

[300sooks]

you never see maynard anymore, every damn concert hes always behind the stage. Don't know why, its kind of like he doesn't give a fuck anymore. The last show i went to he just left and nobody knew it was over.

This song is the most amazing song I've ever listended to though, and the best live performance ever. Lyrically its so beautiful

[BABOS1974]

@300sooks I know i think thats kind of weird to man! It sucks actually

[mlowery4602]

@300sooks this is one opinion. Maynard is an artist. What he creates is art. The music, the voice, the lyrics. It's not about him. It's about the beauty of the music and the art that he wants to take center stage. Not himself. Then again that's just me and I could be wrong. But I do doubt it isn't because he doesn't give a fuck.

[Tearion]

@mlowery4602 No you are absolutely right. That is what Maynard has said for years. It's not about him, the music is his expression. Just listen to lateralus it's a musical masterpiece.

[mlowery4602]

@Tearion That is without a doubt one of the best albums that has ever been released. Tool seemed like they tapped into a certain kind of spirituality with that album. It's very powerful.

[anthonyergo]

@Tearion i totally agree with you on lateralus. 

[toobakedone]

@300sooks its because maynard is not a glory hog, Without his friends there would not be such a unique sound. I can honestly say i have not heard any of thier songs that i didnt like.

[MrBILLHICKSdeadhero]

Amazing & Beautiful

[therastagista]

that's the best...all the best.

[mstr454]

Top video on YT of this song has 2 mil+ views. This should be the one. And only...

[imballn247]

@VerveVixen This is on the Amotion DVD...it's the only one of it's kind. Supposedly there is more professionally recorded stuff...but it's up to them to release it.

[VerveVixen]

@imballn247 Aahhhh! Thanks for answering my question! :) x

[fiyapickles84]

I am obsessed with this song!!!!

[dcsg026]

best song everrrr

[masondarko]

i'll just have to throw that old same phrase, Why are'nt kids into this song/band as much as they're into Jonas Brothers, Lady Gaga, or U2 ?

Why God?

[theburningfield]

@masondarko it's the all in the marketing

[SkittleZombie]

Fuck thats a nice sounding drum kit

[rjsk8fast]

@SkittleZombie agreed i believe he plays dw drums

[JW32584]

@SkittleZombie

A nice sounding Josh Freese! I've only seen him live in APC & NN-Completely accurate n crisp the Whole time! Amazing drummer, glad he chose the right bands to play with!

[JimB667]

@SkittleZombie yeah dude nice and crispy

[theshannonscob]

epic!!!

[VtheArcher]

APC are incredible and this song has always been my fave, but live this is just mindblowing stuff.

[TheyCallHimYazan]

this is amazing...heaven sounds just like this!

[ganyawee]

@TheyCallHimYazan the whole meaning of this song is so anti God and especially those who believe in him I can't believe the irony!

[killer268]

@TheyCallHimYazan You do realize the absurdity of what you just said right? "Heaven" sounds like a song asking jesus how he plans to make his amends to the dead? By a band, led by an outspokenly anti-theistic singer.

[iWentToNam]

@TheyCallHimYazan this is heaven

[askesis]

I love pretty much the entire 13th Step, even more then Mer de Nom. I cant wait for APC and Tool's new albums that are both in the works.

And since I'm pretty confident this will be the final albums for both bands, I recommend everyone be sure to see them [again] this tour, as it may be your last chance.

[danilynoliver]

@askesis Why do you think these are final albums? Not arguing...just curious.

[danilynoliver]

@askesis why do you think these will be final albums? Not arguing, just curious.

[vermilionxxx]

@askesis be patient

[gazbostuart]

@askesis I'm pretty sure Tool are signed for two more albums. I don't think APC are ever going to release a new album, Maynard has talked about singles and movie soundtracks though.

[jenniereynnie]

gorgeous...

[mioloki73]

epic



[stevo18ck]

this puts me in the zone right here. I love Maynard, great lyrics

[drunkship12]

EPIC!!

[TravisMac42]

definitely one of the best apc songs

[jonnyrocket70]

I would love to think that this song is about former President Bush and his completely inexcusible invasion of Iraq and all the fine men and women who were killed for nothing!!!!

[utyiortungheiske]

i love this

[daron55]

Proshot ? Is that coming from a DVD ?

[butyoucancallmenny]

@daron55 I'm prettive positive this is the live version off aMotion.

[nemesiswontdie]

@daron55 Its from APC's aMOTION DVD.

[2001lateralus]

beautiful.

[ReaderOfHearts]

Hell yeah amazing vocals, a voice I'd like to f@ck! :O Lol

[roflmao88]

I love this live version.... Even better than the CD version.

[todster145]

This is Genius MAYNARD I FUCKING LOVE YOU!!

And @NyXaR18 You should thank you're brother for the gift of Tool he has given you.

[TheGuanche88]

Best song of APC

An amazing voice and deep lyrics, I also like the drums, great rhytm.

[damnbassreznor]

Very dream team rock band!

[mashed715]

3.50 gave me goosebumps, what a voice