Added: 5 years ago
From: quadrophenia718
Views: 30,263
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (89)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Really an excellent video and I was quite sceptical. Excellent use of clips and transitioning and I loved the ending.

  • James/Sirius never liked Pettigrew no sure about remus and lily was nice toe evryone., I love Pettigrew and this video is amazing love it.

  • Ooh, this is quite good. I always sort of wondered why Wormtail decided to go dark, and this is a really excellent explanation.

    PS: Robert Sean Leonard?! YOUNG Robert Sean Leonard?! Praise the Lord for this casting decision! :)

    PPS: Some seriously excellent manips in here. :) NEED TO SEE "MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING". And hey! Lockhart made it, and everything! There are connections EVERYHWERE. :)

  • Brillant idea and I liked your take on Pettigrew.

  • Aww, what a good song for Peter! Nice vid, I like RSL for Remus, people tend to use him for Sirius if they're taking clips from Dead Poets, but he's more Remus imho! I'm not fond of Peter but he must have had some regrets and issues, he was a Marauder for all that time, can't have been an easy choice.

  • He's VERY Sirius in Dead Poets though. Ethan Hawke's character is more Remus in that, which is why there needs to be video with the both of them. Sheesh. :)

  • It's good to see a video on Pettigrew. So many people ignore him in their videos. As if he was never part of the Marauders. Its as if they just want to remember the good. Heh, good to see some folks still recognize the fourth marauder, and one of the marauders we can learn the most from, in my opinion.

    Good Vid.

  • I agree!

  • maruders RIP

  • that was beautiful. ^^

  • This is seriously brilliant! My all time favourite song mixed with my all time favourite books.  Very touching!

  • Wow, is really a great video. And I think that describe all that happens =)

  • cool taht you used Robert Sean Leonard as Lupin. I always pictured Lupin like him.

  • i love this song. but whats that movie called with the kids.

  • Stand by Me

  • I know I was the last one to comment, but I was just watching this again, and the line "trying to keep up with you, and I don't know if I can do it" really hit me as fitting so well. It's like Peter always wanted to be a hero like his friends but he didn't know if he really could

  • I love this video, great job! I do feel sorry for Peter. What he did was unforgivable, but understandable in a twisted way in my opinion. The books seem to give the impression that he was allowed to tag along but not really considered on the same level as his friends. That always reminded me of the Trio and Neville. Only they eventually realized Neville was more capable than they had believed and accepted him more fully, while Peter was just pushed even further away.

  • Wow! Awesone video, man. It really does fit, 'cept Jackie's hair in state of grace drives me crazy. It's filthy! What's 'Much Adou About Nothing'?

  • Ha ha, yeah. "Much Ado About Nothing" is my favorite Shakespeare play. Kenneth Brannaugh made it in to a movie in the early nineties and it really is totally entertaining. If you get a chance, you should check it out!

  • I forget what movie the clips of the little kids is from, but it was brilliant that you used it! The kid with the glasses and then pudgy little Peter! It never before struck my mind, but it's perfect!

  • Thanks! Stand by Me was one of my favorite films growing up. :)

  • Truly amazing! I've been a fan of this for a while now.

    Great job!!!

  • Thanks! Glad that you enjoyed it!

  • This video is absolutely amazing. It makes me almost feel sorry for Peter/ Almost.

    Especially when I read your description. Interesting to see you think that Rems, James and Sirius grew closer whilst Lily pushed Peter out. Great video

  • Ha ha. Yeah, it was an idea I was playing with, and it just seemed like such a natural occurrence in adolescent friendships, and yet I hadn't seen anyone take that view of Peter before, so I just figured what the hell. :) I'm glad that you enjoyed the video!

  • That... was absolutely brilliant. I'm just... wow.

  • Awesome Video

  • Thanks!

  • Any true HP fanatic could really appreciate how well you did that. Amazing!

  • Wow, thanks so much!

  • What an amazing video! I absoloutly love it. Great, GREAT job.

  • WONDERFUL!!!!!!

  • wonderful wonderful video the editing is really good, esp with James dieing and the ending it all goes so well with the lyrics. Makes me feel sad for peter which doesn't happen often. this will go in my favourites

  • Thanks! I'm glad you liked it. I was always curious about why Peter chose to do what he did, and I always thought JKR did kind of crappy job explaining it away. Not her fault really; it IS kind of a sprawling universe. Thanks so much for your compliments and I'm glad you enjoyed the vid!

  • Good job on using 'Stand by me' It's one of my favourite movies of all time. :)

  • I hate Peter... how could he dare to betray his friends... without him every one had stayn alive... james, lily, sirius, dumbledore, (cedric)

    ~.~

    by the way i adore this vid!

  • ha ha...thanks!

  • Woah that was a very powerfuly video, I like how you incorporated different movies to fit with the HP universe, stand by me was a perfect choice! And your choice of ending it with Harry being brought to the Dursely's was a nice touch. Very nice job, I hope your proud of this 'cause you should be.

    Keep up the great work!

  • Thanks!

  • yah chicago! <3 that movie ;)

  • nicely put together,it seems ashame that Peter threw it all away for power.Liked your video and music,you realy captured it,peter realy is a character,i mean that in a good way...

  • This was Brilliant!!! Best marauders-thing I've seen so far... Thank you for using Stand By Me... thank's for making this <3

  • That was amazing I really liked how you added videos of people who could be them when they were younger it really works 5*

  • P.S. I really didn't mean to sound so pompous in my previous comment...

    Great film. :-)

  • You didn't sound pompous! Thanks for your compliments, though. I once responded to a flamer with "your criticisms echo those of pater and ruskin. i feel honored." THAT'S pompous. Thanks again and I'm glad that you liked the video!

  • *Very* creative! Also extremely coherent, which I believe is a real challenge when mixing sources. Excellent concept, executed very well indeed. :-)

  • This is a rather smart combination of movies! Well done!

  • Excellently done :D I'm such a Peter fan. Beautiful treatment, and I love the chronology.

  • That is probably one of the best uses of multiple movie footage for Harry Potter. How movies that have nothing to do with Harry Potter, fit nicely and you can still follow who is who is great!

  • this video is great! it' like to watch a film...and the song's beautiful, well done!

  • this is really good the clips you used when they were younger looked really good there faces adn things looked really like the characters well done on this one

    keep up the good work

  • what is that movie when RSL(Remus) and Sirius are talking?? I want to know, please tell me!!

    I like this video.

  • Thanks! I actually spliced RSL in to that clip. I'm glad that you liked it.

  • of couse I like it!

    I always thought that Viggo is Sirius, and RSL is Remus! maybe I had been affect by 'House" 'cause Wilson there are so foxy, and always remind me of Remus in fanfiction. XD

    I don't know if you know that or not, 'cause when Lord of the Rings are filming,

    rumors said that Ethan(Todd Aderson in DPS, RSL's friend) and his wife would be Farmir and Eowyn. funny really

  • and also, that is "Much Ado About Nothing" that you put RSL into, right? I think er... A Painted House or Swing Kids will more fit with others, 'cause RSL look er.. to noble, :blush: I know I had no right to say that, but still....

  • ha ha. no, go right ahead.

    I would have loved to have used "swing kids", but i was going for footage i knew that i had. it was the pre-netflix days for me.

    thanks for commenting, though!

  • That's definitely the best marauders video I've seen yet! It was so cool, well done!!!

  • ohmygosh that is.. wow.. I don't know what 2 say.. it's just.. wow!

  • thanks!

  • *almost crying* AWESOME! *hugs you*

  • it was perfect! it fit together nicely great job

  • Awesome, it all worked together so perfectly!

  • it's almost like a prologue...now I want to go watch all of the movies or re-read all of the books! It was amazing because though there wasn't much Harry Potter in it, the video was still easy to follow. This was a really good idea and a really good video!

  • thank you so much! i'm glad that you thought that it worked so well as a prologue. thanks for commenting!

  • This was an excellent vid with the perfect song choice for Peter. The storyline was easy to follow, and your choices for representing the younger Marauders (plus the older ones) were spot on! The editing was wonderful, and I liked how you went to Harry in the end. All in all, five stars and going in my favorites!

  • thanks! i'm really glad that you liked the storyline!

  • Its kind of creepy in a good way to watch them be friends and then Peter betraying them. Its really good!!

  • btw, you made me cry my eyes out T_T

  • I'm glad that you liked it! It's probably my favorite video I've done, because it is so sad...and I loved being able to use "Stand by Me", which is one of my favorite movies. Thanks again!

  • Haha. loved how you used Stand By Me. I swear, when I saw it recently(Hadn't seen it in what, 10 years?), I literally screamed "OMG! Marauders!" hehe. Amazing video, perfect song for Peter.

  • Bravo!

  • Thank you kindly!

  • Increíble.

  • Glad you liked it!

  • I really love it!!! It's good,I think it's a good representation of the youg friends! I LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!

  • Thanks!

  • wow, I love this, great job! and I think you chose the perfect people to act in this, very nice job!

    love it! and it's already a favorite!

    Mia

  • thanks! glad you liked the casting; i was a tad worried about it for awhile, so i'm glad it worked out well!

  • simply fantastic! or in my mother tongue: extrem geiles video!!!!

  • me encanta este video!!

  • Oh my GOD! This is awesome. It's casted perfectly and not to mention it's one of my all time favorite songs. *applauds wildly*

  • Brilliant video! I really respect all that hard work what making that has been! Touching, heartbreaking and beautiful result!

  • Creative and really well done! 5/5

    I always thought Peter is one of the mor mysterious characters in the books... What do we know about him? Not much, really not much. I'm sure we'll see more of Peter in book 7.^^

    Thanks for the video!

  • Love, love, LOVE!!!!

    Five stars, m'dear.

  • Well, I admit: I LOVED it! Now, do you want me to feel sorry for Peter? - - - Oh God, I actually feel a bit sorry for him! All your fault!

  • By far the best Marauder video I've seen! =)

  • ITS AMAZING XDD Fantastic

  • i love it!!!

    you spelt ralph fiennes wrong in the credits though

  • haha, yeah i know. i noticed after i posted it and watched "the english patient" again. there it was in big letters. but at that point i'd moved all of the files off of my computer, so there was no way to actually fix it. anyway, thanks for commenting!

  • o well, we all make mistakes at one point

    i'm a klutz, so i make many

  • whered you get the black and white fottage from i dont remember it in the GOF. But IN the final book harry will

    not regret saving his life be prepared for next year july

    will be the month of spending for it has been fortold!!

  • Oh wow. This was bloody incredible - five star favorite.

  • Five stars and and saving this to my favourites. TKS! es maravilloso, me ha facinano , el cast, el acomo venga! hasta la cancion esta buenisima ! GOOD JOB!

  • Wow.... one of the best vids I ever saw....

    The Idea of using John C. Reilly was really good, it fits that well!!

    I loved it!

  • WOW!!! This is a classic! One of my all time favorites now! You captured the relationship between them all perfectly! Well Done!

  • That was wonderful! I absolutely loved it... it actually makes you feel a bit sorry for Peter, even though he is an evil wanker. It was awesome I really liked it!!

  • WOW!! I love this video!! I can't believe I never thought of using John C. Riley as Peter!! I may just have to use him in my next video... :D Excellent work; Five stars and I'm definately saving this to my favourites.

  • Thanks! John C. Reilly is a tad too tall, but he's so good at looking unsure and kind of weasely. Absolutely one of my favorite actors. Thanks so much for your comments!

  • OMG WHY hasnt anyone commented or facorited this because this is bloody amazing! i love the whole concept to this video! The casting is just perfect! welldone *saves to playlist*

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more