Hadn't seen the DHP version before but I have to say that I liked Clay Aiken better. His voice was better suited to the singing parts and although I love DHP, I think Clay bested him on this one. To those who say Clay can't sing, I suggest you check out some of his you tube videos. That guy has unbelievable pipes!
a song like this has to be played completely straight, as though the caracter really believes it, or it just doesnt work. david hyde pierce does this perfectly but Clay was frankly too much. he hams it up and makes a good joke of it, but takes it too far out of the context and plot of the show. it ruins the atmosphere and illusion
@FlawlessBeauty97 I agree, it's such a downgrade. They traded DHP for a guy who came in second in a competition that targets 13 year olds. Aiken can't sing for shit, he can't hold the same key. AND he can't play the piano. Really is a downgrade.
Loved this show. Great number. Thanks for posting.
abruzziboy2000 6 days ago
Wonderful!!!!!!
rockandroll4evermore 1 week ago
the piano teasing lightens up!!!
Emminhah 3 weeks ago
what an amazing number. agreed!
jjjcc3 1 month ago
best number of the show. period.
mchammar416 1 month ago
Is that really DHP playing the piano at 5:14?
NoGoodDeedWilliDo11 2 months ago
@NoGoodDeedWilliDo11 yep.
pmoguyperson 1 month ago
@NoGoodDeedWilliDo11 Yep, he studied piano at Yale for a really short time until he decided he'd rather act ;)
CoraLysAnne 1 month ago
@CoraLysAnne That's awesome! I must say, he is a fantastic pianist.
NoGoodDeedWilliDo11 1 month ago
WAY better than the Clay Aiken version! :D
David Hyde Pierce= amazing actor/pianist/singer
pianoking53 2 months ago
Even Tim Curry had to take a minute before trying to follow that! lol
This song is so wrong on oh so many levels, but I can't say it isn't funny.
oscarphile 2 months ago
is that? TIM CURRY!!!
Vampericlegends 2 months ago
@Vampericlegends Oh yes indeed it IS! Delicious, isn't he!
pixietwitch 2 months ago
This is the BEST-quality video of this scene I've found in these fair Youtubes. Thank you! This is one performance I didn't want to forget.
spookymoose 2 months ago
Hadn't seen the DHP version before but I have to say that I liked Clay Aiken better. His voice was better suited to the singing parts and although I love DHP, I think Clay bested him on this one. To those who say Clay can't sing, I suggest you check out some of his you tube videos. That guy has unbelievable pipes!
CaroleKH 3 months ago
Comment removed
SnJester 3 months ago
HAY!!!
Bluebaritone 3 months ago
What did the Knight of Ni say they were going to do on the internet?
Fromundra 4 months ago
@Fromundra They were going to go book seats.
waterwind2266 3 months ago in playlist waterwind2266's favorites
@waterwind2266 Thanks. There weren't subs on when I watched it last. :)
Fromundra 3 months ago
a song like this has to be played completely straight, as though the caracter really believes it, or it just doesnt work. david hyde pierce does this perfectly but Clay was frankly too much. he hams it up and makes a good joke of it, but takes it too far out of the context and plot of the show. it ruins the atmosphere and illusion
Mikazukiful 5 months ago
cant believe they went to clay aiken after DHP
FlawlessBeauty97 5 months ago
@FlawlessBeauty97 I agree, it's such a downgrade. They traded DHP for a guy who came in second in a competition that targets 13 year olds. Aiken can't sing for shit, he can't hold the same key. AND he can't play the piano. Really is a downgrade.
hevblade 4 months ago 2
@hevblade You are forgetting that he cannot really dance either.
stillts151 4 months ago
@stillts151 Right on!
hevblade 4 months ago
Is The lady of the lake one of the musicians?
musicalfool 6 months ago
@musicalfool I think so! I think I saw her... The one next to him in the green at 2:43 I think...
KateEllen2793 6 months ago
@KateEllen2793 Good thats what I thought too!
musicalfool 6 months ago
@musicalfool No, it's actually Emily Hsu - but they do look similar!
TrpleThreat22 3 months ago
i guess now having seen clay akien and DHP it is definately DHP who trumps the top place sorry i do love them both but
meluvspringawakening 7 months ago 4
I finally understand why everyone hates spider-man now!
themusicalfan 7 months ago 5
LOL I <3 the audience :)) haha
FluoroGirl 7 months ago 2
what's with the wagon at 4:18?
gumbymaster 8 months ago
@gumbymaster
HAY!
hwicki 8 months ago
Comment removed
Tyrura95 8 months ago
@gumbymaster fiddler on the roof spoof x
myloverisbillmurray 7 months ago
HAY!
gunwallslizzie 8 months ago
I guess that's really him playing, then. He was a concert pianist before he became an actor.
TendancyToFloatAway 9 months ago
This is amazing. When they start the Fiddler dance, I die laughing no matter how many times I see it.
Chivalryaintdead 9 months ago
LOLOLOL
BrokenDoll2 10 months ago
The patter song: Alive and well, and flowing from the demented pen of Eric Idle!
passionofpersephone 11 months ago 3
How did you get it in hd? I have the same performance only blurryish
XXmrsXXshadowsXX 11 months ago
Love the bottle dance....lol
grimalover 1 year ago 19
Thanks for uploading this! :D I love Spamalot and DHP is the perfect Sir Robin!
lovestanlaurel 1 year ago 31