Amelie Soundtrack Si Tu N'etais Pas La

[aergemlidze]

omg.. does anyone know if this is edith piaf?

[smartass931]

i've always found it quite entertaining to watch people criticize each others' cultures when in fact they're just a sad bunch of ignorant monolingual narrow-minded simpletons.

Les français, vous devriez arrêter de recracher toutes vos idées reçues et les jolis petits clichés que vous vous êtes inventés sur les états-unis.

And you americans, should stop acting like smart asses, correcting every tiny mistake most french users make while making the tremendous effort of speaking your language.

[gqui45]

Mais oui c'est Fréhel notre chanteuse des temps anciens!!!

[Rufflesguy]

Stop saying "Piaf" please ppl ;D

[Janneinwonderland]

It's awesome. (And that's not a singer.)

[VampiressKarmina]

Uhhh, it's not Edith Piaf, you guys. It's Frehel.

[ismary26]

I would have eaten my head it was Piaf :O

[audreire]

C'est ma foi une bien belle chanson!

[xMORGUi]

It's not EDITH PIAF !! It's : Fréhel, an other singer ! (a woman)

[graceveronik]

Edith Piaf ♥

[jbricandy]

@graceveronik it's not Piaf

[prttygracie]

I'm pretty sure it's Edith Piaf.

[Rubyaome33]

@prttygracie It is :)...aww J'adore Edith Piaf C'est un Grand et belle Chanteuse :3

[jbricandy]

@Rubyaome33 it's not Piaf. This is just not her style.

[2emma1]

@prttygracie It's Frehel :P

[FractalFeline]

lol some people get so riled over movies and music. This movie isn't about America, the Natives, racism, or France even. It's about Amelie, and how she came to learn to live and love without fear.

A beautiful song to accompany a beautiful movie. Nuff said.

[otherwheregirl]

My grandmother used to sing this song when I was little. I've always loved this song =D

[Rubyaome33]

@otherwheregirl hahah Mine too :P

[quierounusuariolibre]

Bravo

[laurence29g]

Damia ou Fréhel ?

[Christlicious]

@laurence29g Fréhel

[Mako21Azuma]

I also thought it was Edith Piaf, but ir Frehel :(

But both singers were awesome! :)

[shibori8]

hmmm sorry people but i don,t see any links of your arguments about natives and america and all the tralala and Fréhel's song...sorry ! could you just try to enjoy and leave all your differences aside.

[yunahera]

Ooops. Nvm. It's Frehel! Wonderful voice.

[yunahera]

It has to be her. It's her voice! French ppl please tell us the trush!!!

[nagasachichan]

@yunahera

Si tu n'étais pas là = If you weren't there :)

[jonprak]

This does sound like Edith Piaf! It's just that Edith Piaf is just a bit more powerful and this chanteuse is a bit soft and more relaxed. At 1:45, she looks like Edith Piaf in her late teens and early twenties!

[ikkeeeeeeeeee1]

this sounds just like is Edith Piaf

[liarosalia1]

it does!

[puneio]

its so 20s......macaroons, accordions, parisians whispering into each other's ears, putting hands in each other's pockets, with the occasion birds' melodious chirps, and the waving eiffel tower smiling on:)

[Knerdzilla]

Wow. Way to turn the comments, which really should be about the beauty of the song, into a pitiful argument over American culture. Can't everyone just appreciate the song without getting fussy over nothing but a few words?

[MrsLorelay]

I dare to say that Americans haven't got any self- developed culture, most of them are just the descendents of the criminals, sects an nerdy people that either fled Europe or were sent over to America.

They also are kept uneducated from the american governement, many don't even know that there was something like natives...

I'm really wating for answers, even the pissed ones, I can handle it.

[Knerdzilla]

I'm sorry you feel that way about America. And why, if I may ask, do you believe that most Americans do not know 'that there was something like natives'? I believe basic history of the Native American culture is taught throughout the country. Lastly, it's 'waiting', dear. :)

[SocraticApostle]

I five for longest flamewar I've seen on Youtube with no one besides yourself talking

[YAFL23]

i agree with you!

[thothaurus]

All civilizations rise and fall. I think your disdain for the United States stems from a brand of intellectual incest that may be called "nationalism." Ruffling feathers during such a lovely piece of music is hardly romantic, but I understand your defensive attitude.

[Machetazo1]

So when's 'america's' turn? Cuz it NEVER BELONGED HERE IN THE FIRST PLACE!! Face it. I know it's hard for euro-mericans to, but it's THE TRUTH. THAT'S what's wrong with most americans.

[kekabandeira]

You Americans are jealous because you can not produce a film as beautiful and complete as that. The only thing that do you know is make silly and sensational movies. Critique yourself before criticizing others.

[andrzeita]

cute :-)

[viclarap]

Si tu n'etais pas la

Comment pourrais-je vivre

Je ne connaitrais pas

Ce bonheur qui m'enivre

Quand je suis dans tes bras

Mon coeur joyeux se livre

Comment pourrais-je vivre

Si tu n'etais pas la

.....

Me deja helada

[viclarap]

Me encanta

[TheSokrata]

J'aime cette chanson ;)

[Indeed999]

It's one of the best films ever made.

[LazlosPlane]

Yes, if your twelve and have seen only two or three films.

Please.

[viclarap]

if you don't like the film, i understand it,but i like it so much, it's my favorite film and I have seen hundred you should be more respectful

[Indeed999]

It is a very beautiful and well-made film. It makes me very happy to watch and it far better than most of the tripe that is made nowadays.

You need to consider that most people listening to this song will like the film a lot. Your original comment did not respect that fact.

[viclarap]

I'm spanish and I'm not english and I don't know very much English, this way that I don't know if your commentary is directed me. I agree in that it's a very good movie, minimalist and that doesn't stop indifferently

[Indeed999]

It was directed at the person that made the comment, but I still agree with you :)

[viclarap]

Ok!!thanks for the clarification :)

[stradrools]

or if you are an uncultured american..go see transformers or something..

[LazlosPlane]

Nice try. Your attempt to pidgeon hole me failed, miserably of course.

What I've FORGOTTEN about cutlure, films, art, music, etc, you never knew.

And,

THIS MOVIE SUCKS.

From a country of "collaborateurs" cowards, dilletentes and snobs, you have nothing to say.

[stradrools]

If I had tried, be sure I would have succeded.Before talking about my country learn our history or don't talk at all.I have nothing to say to you because you don't worth any of my words.I am a European snob and proud of it.

[LazlosPlane]

Wow. What rhetoric!

I know more about the history of YOUR country than you do. I actually and very fond of your country and have spent many happy summers there. Particularly in the South-West.

But really, what's this got to do with anything? Euro-snob? What does THAT mean? Nothing.

"Amelie" is a cute film--that's it--it's for those under 20. It's manipulative and rather empty. Lets' end this pointless discussion.

[stradrools]

how could you know what i know?I actually study European history, but, hey, that's just me..Consider this discution over, your blah-blah-blah is making me tired..Good day to you.And remember, people who claim that know it all, are those who know nothing really.Ciao..

[mogartus]

hmmm... wtf did u say.? lol ... educate sir :)

[KingdomHeartsStorm]

C'est très belle!

[theHoneyMonth]

quand elle chante "quand je suis dans tes bras" elle a l'air d'Edith Piaf avec La Vie en Rose

mais c'est quand-même une jolie chanson :)

[jazzyveee]

C'est tres magnifique<3

[ANFeuerstahl]

I don't know why, but this song makes me cry whenever I listen to it.

[hardstyLepuppe1]

me too! ...and I always get gooseflesh when I watch that scene at the metro, when the old man is playing this song ..

[monahgrethe]

no its Frehel. see Wikipedia.

[monahgrethe]

no its Frehel,- not Piaf

See Wikipedia

[strawberryredcolour]

gran musica te traslada a un mundo imaginario genial que transforma toda larealida i cambia el transcurso del tiempo

[k4nuto]

Es la cancion de blancanieves!! mi sorbina me ha hecho ver la luz jajaja

[AMeLyE]

la voz de Piaf es inconfundible ;)

[Feharim]

Is it Edith Piaf ?!? ^///^

C'est Edith Piaf?

[Hasfast]

C'est Fréhel.

Actress and singer. Her voice is very sweet. Merci! D.R.

[GingerAutie]

Yes, I think so. :)

J'aime Edith Piaf et aussi Amelie!

[porkyrom]

quel merveilleux univers!

[Garkin33]

i love her smile

[bernardo1487]

que musica linda

saudade dos tempos em que a musica era feita com amor

beautiful song