鄧麗欣唱「NO ONE KNOWS」又出醜~ 仲衰過阿嬌「心多」~

[sillykai]

似小儀



[hellohellobucks]

虐待呀)))))

[letspartyhk]

自b其短

[jacklamkk]

唔夠氣,唔該先練好氣先;冇能力邊跳邊唱,唔該先唱好首歌唔好條­舞.

雖然話跳唱有難度,抖氣情有可原,但我覺得都唔可以接受.

因為佢可以選擇唔跳舞,但佢選擇左,唱成咁係佢自己嘅問題,冇咁­大個頭就咪戴咁大頂帽;

況且真正有實力嘅歌手,邊跳邊唱都依然有高水準,睇睇jolin­,蕭亞軒之類,

唔敢話超勁,但至少都唔會差到咁.

香港某些歌手,唔該練好d歌等勁d再出黎拋頭露面啦,

作為歌手唱歌咁難聽,你唔會內疚自責羞愧嘅咩?仲有面子當自己好­矜貴咁?>_<



[losumlong2009]

Stephy係唔夠氣姐~阿嬌又咪差唔多~~

同埋我發覺呢段片del咗底音囉

[magicmoodie]

OMG, are they really singing? I can't believe people would still support these bad "singers", no wonder people said HK music is dead already.

[zacc1122]

嬌叫跳舞?仲要拿個同跳舞有關既獎..真系諷刺!!扭來扭去加兩­句心多的心多..stephy好好多咯 起碼跳到

[onochiu]

@zacc1122 agree~!!!!

[cocomarlene1]

咩你地咁鍾意攞人地黎比較架~

[Chaos0v0]

點解阿嬌唔洗點跳都唱到好似STEPHY跳住黎唱咁....

[chihuahuabebi]

佢唔好做歌手啦唔該

[1019hailey]

其實一路唱 一路跳 好鬼攰架 你地試試^ ^

[MSCHINGYAN]

其實鄧麗欣首歌快咁多 隻舞又難咁多 以佢之前黎講已經好勁好西利!!

比較唔係同人比係同自己比

[RuiSherk]

阿嬌 加油啊！

[23982921a]

都幾多歲喇 d實力都吾長進

[mykn9t]

佢都係想娛樂下大家啫

[MsAmla123]

人地城城草蜢唔係又唱又跳？Sammi唔係又唱又跳？佢地仲大過­Stephy好多wor。d個就係實力既分別。

[fung97fung]

你地有冇試過,一邊唱歌,一邊跳舞啊?係好累嫁lo。雖然我唔係­佢fan,我覺得佢唱得己經算好好 ,做人應該多d欣賞 少d批評 欣賞人地努力既地方la *v*

[steventube]

是不是和音？

[najaibaby33]

學下人地蔡依林,蕭亞軒呢d唱跳天后既技巧啦...

[babe0v01]

佢d抖氣聲勁到...

[chung0404]

聽佢地唱歌...不如殺左我吧= =

....其實佢地算唔算係唱緊歌ge呢@@

[stalle520]

@scskyy 禁點解佢開半mic呢?-___-

[iamcathyt]

佢唱到第二段聽到好大抖氣聲

好似就斷氣

[iamcathyt]

哈哈~比個氧氣樽佢咩住唱歌啦

[iqdoctorli]

stephy確實唔適合唱歌，還是專心演戲吧，演戲的發展空間大­啊

[nganling1992]

佢起碼跳到野...其實都唱到有聲...阿嬌跳又跳唔到...唱­又唱唔到..更加慘不忍睹

[awing228]

佢唱到好辛苦= =

[poorming]

ar Gill 咁都叫跳舞?! 同3650 有咩分別?

[Cristie3853]

OMG!!

[NgSan1234]

D人....好似無野咁聽喎,你會唔會...講錯呀....?



[tommy1910li]

唉...明星..,香港樂壇...

[kamanO3O]

一睇就知stephy平時吾做運動.

[Jasonlok1119]

根本就系轉佐把聲惡搞佐...如果佢真系唱到咁.重唔比人即場叼­?!

[ichelleLaw]

跳唱唔得我寧願佢開半mic or mic咀==

咁我就可以厄自己佢跳舞好好=v=

好過佢兩頭唔到岸==

[q6038795]

真係好差 講心個句=.= 你試搵容祖兒個d 唱live 跳舞都好唱得好聽過佢  得個樣索唉=.=

[poorming]

@q6038795 容祖兒D 舞肯定比呢首簡單lor 我都係joey fans 我都係咁講

[kwan201192]

其實佢eeee家都進步好左好多,,,,快d出多d歌啦！！

[CKl0v3]

佢好過{ 心多 },,

[seeddestiny2000]

好索

[chnomechi]

阿嬌只係企響到(跳?)同唱,stephy 點同,好好多la

[free2rhyky]

唔係丫...其實鄧麗欣都真係跳得好靚丫...-_-

[MrNgobaby]

我同你講, 如果你唱功唔夠. 你點一路唱一路dance ar?

[christang123456789]

其實我都係聽開韓歌，的確大部份假唱，有d四個人分一首歌來唱，­到冇氣，鄧麗欣算可以接受

[christang123456789]

阿嬌直情無氣唱，拍子又數唔到，又太用力咬字，甘多休息位都無氣­，鄧麗欣點都係唱歌好d用有氣好多，換轉係我跳舞到可能無哂氣－­，－

[lpjai1016]

唔該你可以跳足成隻歌都仲有氣唱先好出聲!!



[Hayleytobby]

阿嬌唔識數拍子...

[MUJIbb224]

阿嬌同stepy唱歌一樣難聽

但是stephy跳舞比阿嬌看得下去很多很多吧！

阿嬌跳舞好像抽筋！！！！！！！！



[TheCarmen012]

唱到咁!點做歌手!怪不得現時hk樂壇會下落啦!

[lojuenying]

個background大聲D應該就聽唔出..

[loveting55]

唔夠氣,冇走音,都唔錯啦!如果比著係我地上去唱都會咁啦..

而心多.........佢果d舞點同stephy相比呀..?­我想問...==

[78LON]

關心多乜9事

[Athenahappie]

咁似MR REMOVED咁既?

[249529235]

好難聽... 好多呼吸聲

[wing990402]

我都覺得系個咪既問題lor @@"

同埋吾鍾意stephy呢個髮型:(

[zlingc]

把聲好似唔係stephy囉= ="

[yloveyl]

屌算啦... 比住係你你跳佢跳果d舞一定用氣嫁喇- -

[elainechan0220]

你覺得呢把似佢地把聲?

佢地又吾係走音

都係唔夠氣既人啫

把聲完全吾似Stephy囉

我有睇過佢地既live架

都吾係咁

[jun1988101619]

我覺得本身都未止於差到咁,

但支MIC既收音好有問題,咁多雜音@@

[pennytvxqshinee]

韓國開半mic? LMAO

[sailorchibimoon1665]

She can't even sing!!

[woshisheile]

吾夠氣-_-

[franko1118]

愈黎愈似雞 = ="

[manho50]

@franko1118 你愈黎愈on9冇神神話人似雞

[s0901075]

I think this is okv_v !!

[TheYanzi723]

改過既把聲,果陣係現場聽把聲都唔係咁

[alexharpl]

其實兩個都差唔多...咁差!!!

[mykn9t]

佢唱慢歌其實把聲幾清ge...

[citiprince]

i'm not a fan of stephy at all. but i think this is not too bad, she is dancing her ass off while singing live. plus, that microphone is not the best for singing.

[jerisng]

前者好重噴氣聲，而且有好多KEY都唱唔到上去, 變左個音聽落好刺耳, 呢D歌好明顯係度身訂造, 高音位基本都拉做假音位, 但把聲太薄, 聽落只係覺得更怪。後者首歌...好似無高過5個KEY音喎..­..

[sandyyzhou]

she needs to work on BOTH dancing & breathing ..

[KrystyOnkiu]

跳都固唔掂,仲話唱,,佢假唱吧啦,,仲出糗,,如果呀嬌有da­ncer係隔離會好D-,-呀嬌都進步左少少-,-不過都走走地­...........

[iamcarriet]

佢成日好似企唔穩咁,好似好緊張

[tictacnat]

the noone knows part is very wut dut

[seoyin]

有自知之名  "NO ONE KNOWS 鄧麗欣"

[yikman12]

佢地企係度唱都可能係咁難聽

[johnlovesoso]

我想講啊嬌果d叫行黎行去lo 根本好似冇走過位咁 stephy果d先系跳舞lo

[scskyy]

韓國o個d 大把只係開半mic

佢係真正LIVE@@ 開曬全mic

其實算係咁=_=

[angelkilasuki]

@scskyy 點先叫開半咪@_@

[ILove520Y]

@scskyy 咩系開半mic@@?

[AlBeE227]

@scskyy 但隻舞咁簡單-_-

但佢肯唱live就算啦

不過可以練好d先唱live囉^_^

[fi5591]

@scskyy 其實韓國的好好多囉;;你冇睇過live? 冇睇過消音嗎?omg



[roundbunny]

stephy fans can make all the excuses they want, but make someone who doesnt know hk singers at all listen to this----and ask him/her what they think of the singing. I am sure the person will agree that the singing is weak, out of breath, and sounds like she is struggling (which is NOT how singers are supposed to sound like! it is supposed to sound natural and effortless)

[ariesjessie21]

maybe she is tired singing and dancing at de same time

[alienvisiting]

I really thought her live performance of this song was horrible until I heard the "Stephy@恒生勁爆Music World新城勁爆頒獎禮2010記者會" version. Search it and you'll hear the difference. I wonder what happened in between...

[Zaku05B]

跳得OK喎^^

[usernameofutube]

想嘔



[hellohellobucks]

呃飯食...

[4399t]

stephy's fantasy tales so good but this 走音lo

[hotingkit]

stephy e唱live唱法,韓國好流行,少女時代果d有d歌都係咁唱li­ve

search  「Stephy@新城勁爆頒獎禮2010」睇段片就知,

佢地係會將墊底聲調到好大聲,可以同佢真人把聲重疊,聽出黎就混­和左把聲,只不過tvb出名個咪收音收到真人把聲好清。跳唱好多­人都會咁,所以唔只stephy,其實韓國好多歌手平時你地話咪­咀,根本佢地都有唱到ge,只係墊底聲大

[kira7536]

@hotingkit E D唔係叫墊底聲 叫伴唱-,- 你有未唱過K...... 係韓國組合所有組合都係甘唱 除左唱慢歌哥D 旦係慢歌好多都有伴唱

[agnasco]

WTF

[hkgal]

雖然唔夠氣, 但好欣賞 stephy 唔 咪咀, 唱 live , 唔似得 twins 演唱會唱快歌都咪咀

[hoiningt]

i don't understand why hk's music industry is made up of so many incompetent, so-called "singers"...there are so many people with real talents out there who are not recognised...while all these superficially attractive artists are getting all the attention..

[gwuangel]

個咪收音好過頭，音樂應該大過人聲先得。

[cherry36149944]

其實- -比之前唱live已經好好多架啦算系,不過頭先睇完G.E.M­.G.E.M.果段野之後- -...實在..........相差十萬九千里- -

[BrickLaya100]

the difference between kpop and what stephy is doing is that a lot of teh acts we see in kpop are groups, so each person only sings a little. also, a lot of their parts are part of the instrumental/sound track, they only send a small part, or take breaks between each part they sing. don't be too harsh on her

[ranbabyify]

香港樂壇就是有太多呢D所謂Singers ,真救命！

[Andrew520gem]

我講既係MV呀下

[Andrew520gem]

blackivyyy 收啦;.心多不知幾好;.火.火+鄧麗欣都0K伽.

[MsPiscesKiss]

阿嬌果d都叫跳舞?

fingfing下就係,同鄧麗欣無得比!~

收皮個個應該係阿嬌囉,阿嬌咪嘴都唱到就死咁.

鄧麗欣幾時有咪嘴?

[funnystickerxd]

就係因為佢次次走音-,-

如果咪嘴突然唱好好聽,, 就一定會比人發現

[Yuenlam520]

一邊跳一邊唱係甘架啦-.-

[aznboieiji]

what an """Artist"""!!

[YuMikoatKing]

stephy好心唱唔到就咪唱la= ="

得個Kary係唱歌炸

返省下La~練好D先好唱

[honeytube888]

有冇搞Q錯, 唱到咁仲唔收皮, 係度影衰晒香港樂壇.

靠呢副專容就可以生存呃飯食嘅話,

真係好過做CHEAP 鷄

[steveloh1]

阿嬌的歌與舞無甘激，明顯stephy既舞蹈，郁動大D啦，根本­唔可以相提並論。

[steveloh1]

大佬，很多歌手對嘴都無被批評，又跳又唱竟然被批評。真無天理

[Chuchucatbabi]

我知佢係live

[say12500]

0:03 it seems like dance wrong!

[a477735640]

個波細到XDDD

[Thecindy1231]

鄧麗欣佢一路跳一路唱...算係咁...

[chan808yuen]

金牌大風真係笑死人 香港一潭死水都算 大陸嗰便有副靚牌都唔識打 唔識搞個brand好心摺晒佢 剩係做台灣

[TheTingwai]

真心覺得佢有付出.有進步.頭先睇姓鐘果位跳唱真係嚇死..

[katrinachan1234]

阿嬌好像吾知自己係個台到做緊mut 咁...

俾人擺上台咁

起碼stephy 都識跳舞 = =

[p177tky2]

把聲唔係stephy把聲,Stephy第一次跳,算OK啦!

[TheYanzi723]

把聲唔係stephy把聲黎

痴利根gem都成日走音,上面條友唔好以為gem識嗌就好威

[RuiSherk]

阿嬌加油

[TheBillows]

根本唔係STEPHY把聲黎 -.-

[yinzland]

stephy其实成首歌都无咩点走音啊，识听噶人应该都知道，距­净系呼吸声重唔够气，应该去练气，慢歌应该仲可以handle到­噶，啊gil系D temple有小小问题，无咩自信，怕节奏赶唔上或者唔岩，就更­加发生左。距地虽然同吖GEM，卫兰距地无得比，但系都叫做有心­噶喇，个title唔好写得甘衰啦！

[siuleelaumao898]

跌一次已經夠樣衰 唱/跳到冇氣5只佢辛苦 聽果個仲辛苦

[iammingjaii]

跳唱歌手真係唔容易做...

[britney01at]

吖~~兩個都好慘。。。鄧麗欣用「霸王硬上弓」; 啊 Gil 有「自知之明」 =_="

[womanbeatmania]

一般黎講跳咁勁應該一定要咪嘴架禾, 點解可以唔咪...

我唔覺佢有問題



[87venus87]

佢就死.......



[fwardful]

@87venus87 我就死.......

[januslee114]

第二段開頭因為聽唔到佢有唱，所以無打歌詞，唔好意思！><

[b762468]

2個都須要極大的進修囉....

[v1197329]

@siudangv3v 係佢黎....我果日有睇電視...

我仲記得我聽到佢唱歌果時嚇死...

唱得太可怕....

[sanababymusic]

@siudangv3v  HAHA...把聲唔似因為d 和音大聲個佢唱好多倍囉...

[MrDaihoi]

真係5係講笑  差到阿媽都5認得

[hotchafan]

Both awful. But Stephy is "less bad." Gillian's song is flat and just talk, and she's not even dancing a routine like Stephy, just shaking on the spot. And she's so awkward, uncomfortable and cannot dance at all. And she is not actually "giving a performance." At least Stephy can somewhat dance and is naturally confident and "giving a performance" n stage.

[d1gps15]

@hotchafan doesn't matter if she can't dance, because she don't want to copy every singers, hotcha was copy like Korean lol..

[hotchafan]

@d1gps15 This has nothing to do with copying anyone else. I'm not comparing Gillian's ability to dance with other celebrities', when I say she can't dance. It's just a fact: Gillian cannot dance. And it does matter if she can dance or not, when she releases, sings and performance a dance song with a dance routine, or even attempts to "dance" on stage. The same thing that it matters if she can't sing, when she's a "singer", releases "music" and performs songs "singing."

[christf121]

算啦~~~鄧小姐總算提供左不少歡笑比我地XD LOL

[ching12409]

頂= =2只雞收皮啦= =

[cedbab1990]

搵人CALL架白車送隻鄧走音入急症室啦

佢再係咁又唱又跳落去遲早斷氣身亡 =.=？

點解要幫佢call 白車呀！？嘥我電話費！



[YLkbb]

乜你地啲人甘膚淺sosad:(

睇唔到人地不斷進步-_-

人地轉形應該支持 有失準既時候就應該"古麗"拉:)

我覺得鄧麗欣佢即使受到好多惡評 負面新聞,

佢都依然盡力做好每次演出,

每次見到佢唱live有進步真系好感動T_T



[clayton0403]

唱跳其實好難,,起碼好過個泳褲

[zhammmy]

Nothing personal, 冇氣就咪一路跳一路唱啦.



[tommylauka]

頂你個肺呀...

好Q難聽呀

[MrMatthew1121]

呀嬌著到咁, 係咪冇諗住用唱心多咖????

係既, 佢公司冇理由唔俾dancer佢咖wo???

[yiujai0421]

我以前都唔鍾意stephy-_-

但系我睇到佢真系有努力 開始留意佢:)

我相信佢既努力系有人睇到:)

轉形好難 stephy好有勇氣;)

加油~~

[jessiechan138]

I didn't hate TWINS,,,but they are already 10 years...but they still 走音....-_-"

[angelwishes90]

在某些地方的确是有一点点走音啦，　不过要兼顾跳舞也是可以原谅的。　我发现Ｓｔｅｐｈｙ和阿娇两个都不太够气，　而Ｓｔｅｐｈｙ的舞蹈又比较夸张，动作比较大，又多，而且要很用­力才好看，所以透起气来比较困难，要很顺地唱每一句歌词真的比较­难，　不过她跳得不错。反而是阿娇，她的‘舞蹈‘根本就是走走擺擺的，­可是还是能唱成这个样子。。。虽然我也蛮喜欢她的，但是真的觉得­有点过分。。。

[jaijai0jai]

stephy唱到想死咁 佢唱得好辛苦-,-我都聽得好辛苦

但佢跳得幾好 但至少佢應該專心練下唱歌 歌都未搞掂.

而呀嬌就唔知係度做乜 又唔係跳舞 勁似自high個d癲婆

[lamman4427]

2個都唱得好撚難聽

所以我從來都唔明點解TWINS可以開演唱會

[crazyashbabii]

又跳又唱已經好辛苦架啦,stephy明知會走音都吾咪嘴,你就­吾好咁話人啦

stephy真係跳的好勁,而阿嬌真係郁下郁下咁,好大分別

你不如試下勁跳再唱歌睇下你會點-v-

[Lilchinesekiz]

区跳舞就可以摞正牌来走音！lol

[DenniswaSo]

stephy 係唔夠條同埋吹到咪姐

唔係走音囉~ ~

同埋stephy 起碼唱得好清楚 (聽到咩音, 咬字有力)

同埋好明顯stephy d 舞步難多

仲要頭氣位唔算太多

阿嬌佢只係行幾步擺下

都唱到咁 (咬子有問題, 仲ler 過一d 字)

好明顯阿嬌比較差啦

你識唔識睇同聽架-__-?

[jessiechan138]

@DenniswaSo Stephy didnot 走音?? No way...she did...



[huenhuenxd]

呀嬌有跳到舞咩a_a睇吾到

[tsh2005]

放過佢啦!!人地已經好努力架la

[victorcly1991415]

@tsh2005

佢係好努力

但有 D 野係努力極都唔會有正回報

講真 我係欣賞佢突破

[mookiia]

屌,岩岩睇完gem表演片段都順手禁埋入黎,真係差好撚遠唔係講­笑

[babyjudychu]

佢又跳又唱都好過咪咀啦; 咪左你地又gut, 吾咪咁跳唱, 吾夠氣唱得吾好你地又gut, 而家d人係咪個個都咁yim尖? 我吾覺得stephy差過阿嬌囉LOL.

阿嬌個d真係行行企企黎架喎, 點比較?你教我啦. :-o

[loveting55]

@babyjudychu 講得太好啦!支持stephy!

[TheJanet1620]

我覺得呀嬌把聲個聲底係好聽過stephy,

只不過係兩個都係唔識唱歌的人.

[vickyki88]

呀嬌唔跳舞都冇氣--"

[TseungM]

I think ah Gil is worse than Stephy. Gillian is only standing there and moving her legs and arms that's it. But Stephy is actually dancing. Stephy is way better than Gillian.

[TheRedCapitalist]

@TseungM

DLLMH

[samwong2011]

呀嬌好好多...

[funnystickerxd]

乜你地以為stephy跳緊舞-_-;

我以為佢攞post架咋....

[CMan1997108]

又要跳又要唱 佢都吾系唱歌既料子;