@meplayin If you play the two tunes without the lyrics, I think you'll easily see that the two tunes are quite distinct and recognizable, even though the chord patterns are the same or similar (which happens with a lot of songs) and a couple of melodic phrases are shared between the two songs.
Another Carter Family song that sounds like "This Land is Your Land" is "When the World's on Fire". Just wanted to note the comparison in the music in all three of the songs ;)
@sandyjo55 "This Land Is Your Land" also sound a lot like "You Are My Sunshine." But the only melodic lines in TLIYL that are very similar to Little Darlin' Pal Of Mine are the first two, and the first lines of the 2 songs are the same only on the first 6 notes. There the melodies depart strikingly.
The Carters first recorded this in Camden N.J., May 9th 1928. On the original recording Maybelle played her guitar in the fretted Hawaiian style for both this song and "Meet Me by the Moonlight".
It is possible she picked that style up from a 78 record of Vernon Dalhart's "The Wreck of the Old 97".
Maybelle also gave writing credit of this song to A.P. Carter.
I had heard that Maybelle played "slide" on some songs but could never get anyone to give me a title....thanx much....pax doug
dstrobel3 3 weeks ago
The wanabees of today will never sound like this.
nexwaval 1 year ago
i have this 78 sounds really good
aberdurant 1 year ago
this and Woody Guthrie's "This Land Is Your Land" sound very similar.
aguerrero1 2 years ago
You are right about that, Woody took this music added is owns words for This Land is Your Land in thr 1930's
meplayin 2 years ago
@meplayin If you play the two tunes without the lyrics, I think you'll easily see that the two tunes are quite distinct and recognizable, even though the chord patterns are the same or similar (which happens with a lot of songs) and a couple of melodic phrases are shared between the two songs.
WildeNotesMusic 1 year ago
@aguerrero1 yes indeed they do, that's because he borrowed the melody from this song, which he did in a lot of his songs
This Land is Your Land was actually written as a political response to God Bless America, which Woody didn't like, and thought it was unrealistic
williestratton 2 years ago
Another Carter Family song that sounds like "This Land is Your Land" is "When the World's on Fire". Just wanted to note the comparison in the music in all three of the songs ;)
sandyjo55 1 year ago
@sandyjo55 "This Land Is Your Land" also sound a lot like "You Are My Sunshine." But the only melodic lines in TLIYL that are very similar to Little Darlin' Pal Of Mine are the first two, and the first lines of the 2 songs are the same only on the first 6 notes. There the melodies depart strikingly.
WildeNotesMusic 1 year ago
"Take Me Back" by Frank Stokes sounds like this also.
catgumart 1 year ago
Apparently the melody of "This Land Is Your Land" is based from this song.
proceedapathy 1 year ago
nice song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bentoast99 3 years ago
One of the very few Carter Family recordings featuring Mother Maybelle on the Dobro.
dtoddmiller 3 years ago 2
that's an interesting fact that i never knew, thank you for that
bigjaw1 3 years ago
@bigjaw1 Sounds LOUD enough to believe.
hulud99 1 year ago
The Carters first recorded this in Camden N.J., May 9th 1928. On the original recording Maybelle played her guitar in the fretted Hawaiian style for both this song and "Meet Me by the Moonlight".
It is possible she picked that style up from a 78 record of Vernon Dalhart's "The Wreck of the Old 97".
Maybelle also gave writing credit of this song to A.P. Carter.
SettlersMuseum 3 years ago
@dtoddmiller good to know. Thanks!
naicisumeht 1 year ago