不能說的秘密：宇豪周董鬥琴

[ga288520111]

不能說的秘密>< 沒看過的去看看吧 ( 讚)= 鬥琴聽幾遍都不會膩

[man763004]

有沒人可以告訴我, 什麼時間彈的是什麼曲嗎?

[wer520025]

如果把不能說的秘密跟海上鋼琴師比的話 就是小 巫 見 大大大大 巫 哈哈哈哈不好笑

[wer520025]

海上鋼琴師太強了啦 根本不能把海上鋼琴師來跟 不能說的秘密比嘛!

你看人家還把香菸很帥的插到她嘴吧裡(然後是如雷的掌聲)

結果不能說的秘密是 自己拿香菸  還自己點哩(校園 禁 止 吸 煙 ! )

[seeyouinthenextone]

因為小雨一開眼就見到個個女仔吧？

[fung19880426]

點解開頭個女仔會見到小雨.................

[hebe200210]

拜託!!海上鋼琴師 整個 不要拿來比好不好? 音樂的等級差很多耶。 劇情跟分鏡等等的意境!!!!也差很多耶

[firefrankful]

@hebe200210 你只是外國月亮比較圓吧 不覺得海上鋼琴師很扯 還會點煙 如果是本片那樣一定被你這種人酸吧

[hebe200210]

@firefrankful 哇!! 把黑鍵變白鍵耶~ 有機會你應該去數一下鋼琴有幾個鍵 黑鍵跟白鍵各有幾個與他們的關係 去好好讀一下譜 什麼叫做Vivace  四分音符等於116 等這些東西 你都了解了，那外國的月亮是否比較圓，再由你來說吧。

[hebe200210]

@firefrankful  點菸是很扯，但是你在還沒看之前你有想到那根菸會燒起來嗎? 但這就是別人的點，別人想出來的。 是一個有戲劇張力的一個想法。 音樂是見仁見智 你要是說 不能說的秘密聽起來就比較好聽 那也是你的觀點。但我想好的東西是受的起大家的考驗的，有機會等­這部片子傳到歐洲 美洲 不只是華語國家 若還是得到如此的評價 那也就是不爭的事實了。

[a150237]

@hebe200210  這部片子早就傳到歐美了，評價普遍也不錯。說真的這段鬥琴只是用­有趣且讓人印象深刻的方式讓觀眾知道小倫有聽一次就能彈的功力，­而在表現和編排上也與海上鋼琴師有很大差異，可以說相當用心。周­董也大方承認了他有參考海上鋼琴師了，當然拿來跟海上鋼琴師比是­難免，不過這兩部都各有優點和創新，我想這是需要肯定的。

[s0955565676]

我和朋友聊即時通時也差不多那樣( 笑

[francoisyip]

很多情節都是學海上鋼琴師的吧?

我也有看海上鋼琴師喔

[betty11728]

最後一段用單手彈真的彈到手抽筋

[jct18118]

超屌!!! XD

[Jenniferqiu]

超級超級超級厲害！

[joyxie1122]

兩個人的實力真是旗鼓相當，不分上下，平分秋色，超酷。

[joyxie1122]

第三首和第一首是什麼呀?

[wing87318]

不能說的秘密很好看,杰倫好厲害喔!



[ChewyChocs]

里头的音乐好好听呀！  ^_^

[candy861017]

杰倫真的很棒....每次看都會看到熱血沸騰= =(啥?

[Skywalk66666]

雪糕好欠揍喔-.-

[showenergy0204]

一個電影

都能靠腰成那樣

會不會太無聊了?

[creidefy]

holy crap.. the comments look so cool. i wish i could speak...some asian language and write it and stuff

[DragonBonder]

what are all the pieces featured?

[he01675232]

雪糕那樣子好欠扁



[Lisa24i0103]

@he01675232 好想打他XD

[flycindysky]

天下文章一大抄

電影又何妨？

鬥琴很精采阿

[killer5530]

這就好像跑步遊泳一樣 還不是你做什麼他做什麼 電影仿來仿去都是正常的...

[patricknet1]

小弟第1次看這條片...

想不到原來周杰倫的琴技這麼西利

周杰倫單手的那段...看呆了......

但我還是覺得雨豪彈得比較帥...

雙人合奏的那段...最帥  讚!

[cyrusrayray]

非常西利入^•^*

[1227caesar]

仔細聽幾遍

單手那段真的很猛(自己試試手指都快打結了)

後面合奏也很精采

[as24519855]

電影都會仿來仿去ㄚ

如果都不能有一絲絲的模仿，那電影怎麼拍

你們怎麼會看的到，如果電影拍的不好，被你們罵，拍劇情有點像的­右被你們念說仿造，那就乾脆別看了~

[vampie134]

恩恩..."不能說的秘密"拍的還算不錯拉~

看的出周董有花功夫在上面

不過"海上鋼琴師"是經典中的經典阿~

[randstandu]

他沒有說彈的快就是好的演奏阿 純粹是展現個人彈功...

[lennonsfoot]

一帮傻逼

[hjhnlkj]

好看就好了，你們在那ＧＧＹＹ什麼？

海上鋼琴師怎麼了？裡面有兩人合奏嗎？

一堆電影還不是模仿來模仿去，囉唆個屁啊！

我看的很爽阿，一堆人就喜歡骨頭裡面挑雞蛋，低ｘ！

[serene06]

the last piece sounds a bit like Petrushka (becuase of the glisando stuff)

[jimmychuang]

鋼琴較勁是學海上鋼琴師的沒錯, 有看與鋼琴有關的電影的人, 一定都會看海上鋼琴師, 周杰倫是絕對有看過, 海上鋼琴師的教勁好看得多, 是古典vs.爵士, 兩個不同style的較勁, 不能說的秘密基本上還是屬青少年愛情片, 海上鋼琴師是比較深的劇情片

不過兩部電影的較勁都是比速度, 感覺好像速度快就是好的演奏, 根本是錯誤的, 有些以速度聞名的鋼琴家, 根本彈不出曲子的原味

[wwppffmano]

@jimmychuang

同感 !

[lippowing]

@jimmychuang

但速度的確能使人心跳加速 像是被音符帶著走

[jimmychuang]

@lippowing 我覺得沒有配合電影, 一般沒幾個人會有興趣聽, 也可說是事實, 相較其他音樂, 古典鋼琴是冷門音樂, 但因為冷門所以有神祕感, 放入戲劇才有戲劇效果, 真的古典鋼琴就和流行樂一樣, 不同作曲家各有風格特色, 各有好聽的地方, 但一般人聽起來都是差不多的

[libraken1016]

是很快....

很厉害....

但有时候太快也听不到音乐吧.....

[chinghsu19]

大概我不懂音樂吧~

我還真聽不出來兩者有哪裡幾乎一樣

[libraken1016]

一个快一个慢.....

你想说这个是吧？

[hazelmint]

thats because hes not an actor! hes xue gao.. jay's dance tutor or something like that..

[GLlynn]

他是特意念得这么不自然，这样才够嚣张

[jimmychuang]

我知道啊

但還是念得很不自然, 而且很多台灣演員念台詞都差不多是這樣的語調, 平平的, 節奏沒有變化

以前的演員就比較少這樣, 或些老演員, 他們念台詞就比較被要求自然

一般年輕演員演戲都很做作, 就是很假, 都演給青少年看的, 比較不在乎演技

[yao7947n]

@jimmychuang

幹說出我心坎阿

一堆偶像劇 神韻出不來 一開口我也是直接轉台....

[qazjonny]

their school uniform looks a lot like mine...haha

[a12196935]

第三首

單手那段

真的是很強吧

[sinkertw]

樓下專業

[vincentws03]

第一首蕭邦練習曲Op.10 No.5，又稱黑鍵練習曲，tempo mark為 Vivace，他彈的大概只有Allegretto而已，而且最­後還把難按的黑鍵升了一個半度成為全白鍵....還耍什么帥？第­二首蕭邦圓舞曲還加了一段的"Wrong-notes"練習曲，­最後一段簡單的是自己弄的.....沒練過蕭邦曲子立刻彈出來是­沒可能的

[AA8352]

這是電影 電影

[fk9599]

I hate to say this, but I think they are about the same. No one is better than the other. And they both are excellent piano player!

[swordyboyakon]

有真人能做到那樣嗎................

[iluvapple06]

故事真的很好耶!!! 你門一定要看喔!

[michelleandyck]

I think 宇豪強D!

[BettyKelly1314]

Jay is very good~

[gamekua]

很棒(⊙o⊙)哦

[okokcoco]

屌!!!

[qaz555070]

Jay好強 宇豪也不錯

good

[46212187]

庫ㄟ竟然2個人一期談一首曲子而且還沒談錯(我知是戀很久的

[jamesyau0829]

good

[royaltrash]

Jay is a songwriter/artist (who was taught to play the piano). It's not fair to compare him to a pianist because that's two different field of music. Just like you can't compare a manga artist to Picasso. That being said, he might not be the greatest piano player, he is quite good, or better than most people. And i find this scene to be one of the more entertaining scenes in the movie. Thanks for uploading

[CK2083]

Com'on you guys, just a high school movie...why you guys take it so serious. The roles they played are just high school kids. I think they're good, but my piano teacher think they are just so so... Is it metter? I don't think so.

[enunciability]

.__. are you serious -.-

[a22642272]

can u do better than him? stfu bitch

[ntl730]

我想問佢地鬥琴最後嗰隻歌叫咩名？

[bryonyE836]

i <3 the last song!

but it seems really hard to play it D:

they're both so good at playing the piano0.0

[repeatasd]

I don't like the guy who sitting in the middle

[angelxun2007]

周董王子ㄆㄆ哈哈神

[jamesleung006986]

我連續睇左幾十次喇..停唔到 有無人救到我

[fanfanchau]

救你唔到...因為我都係咁!!!

[Adiwod]

雪糕学长太SB了吧

[hunniebearu]

sorry to spoil the party

but the excerpt played by jay chou and yuhao are actually the exactly same clips!!

if you have any music editing program like cakewalk/logic/pro tools, you can try superimpose the excerpts on top of one another

and you'll find they're just using the same clip twice.

so then the question is, who played the excerpts? or neither?

didn't do that for the second piece, cuz jay's obvious playing at a faster speed, I might try Yu Hao's playing tempo x 2 and see how it goes

[hubhikari204]

Do you have proof that they are playing the same clips? If they were actually playing by their own skill, don't you think that you'd be disrespecting them by saying one of them can't play? They're both great piano players, and it doesn't really matter even if it is the same excerpts. There are other videos that prove that both of them can play the piano very well, so there is a possibility that they played according to their own skill. If you support your idea, show some proof? No offence btw.=)

[hunniebearu]

well I can bounce the resulting tracks in which I put the clips on top of one another

you can decide for yourself how similar the two excerpts are.

just private message me your email and I'll send it to you in mp3 format.

well I never said they are bad pianists. They are both respectable artists IMO. In fact, if there were any criticism to be made on my part, it would be towards the movie sound engineer, who didn't even bother recording the playing twice to make the plot convincing.

peace

[chlohxo]

haha you're right! I was interested and actually did this myself.. and yeah, nice observation. I agree with you on the part of the sound engineer... but then again, I guess the producers of this movie weren't really interested in these little nuances.

[Crossovahh]

they only have the same audio, watch this clip in slow-mo they're obviously hitting the right keys. All movies are re-dubbed over in an audio mixing room anyways, Yu Hao Played it for the piano battle according to the OST, but both were actually playing, its just a matter of who did the dubbing.

[chlohxo]

Of course. They're both excellent pianists.

[mjsstar]

I think both of them are capable of playing the piece. Think about the practicality of having live recording of this scene. With the camera panning like mad unnecessarily they will need to repeat the recording a few times, with the presence of temporary actors and actresses for ages. So it is quite logical that they did the actual recording in the studio, with better quality recording and less ambience noise.

[ilovelespauls27]

im pretty sure this is a fukcing movie and not an actual piano battle..stfu and enjoy

[amdk2007]

經典, 我看原版DVD十多廿次還要上youtube看... :P

[chungcf2006]

雪糕學長好睇小周董喎~

[tidus1804]

雙方高手過招

才會有如此有完美的演出

真搞不懂的是為什麼就會有不少人會把雙方拿來做比較呢

難道就因為他們(她們)做同樣一件事情嗎

[waterleo1]

好

[Chokopoky]

OOOOOMMMMMMMGGGGGG.....

i can't believe how amazing YuHao actually is... he was my piano teacher 5 years ago.... xP

[siu20051777]

就是別有用心,

雖然我也覺得那人很煩

[unilee0109]

恭喜周董~ 電影裡曲子很好聽^^

[miszj0Jo008]

我想你们是嫉妒他们吧！！他们还没有现出真功夫！ 你们只是看表面！ 不会去看多一些其他 他们弹的！ stupide...

[WHOGoTMYTMC]

李雲迪是鋼琴家

他琴彈的好又如何?

這不過只是電影裡的片段...

請別拿他們兩個來做比較~幼稚鬼

我相信在亞洲的名氣...周杰倫一定遠遠勝過李雲迪

即使周董鋼琴彈沒他好

[Platformer]

if you don't know yundi li well enough, don't assume nobody else knows. according to Forbe's report of 2008 annual income. Yundi did make more money than Jay Chow (unaccounted for jay's income from his own businesses)

[shiaopang01]

Shut up...

[PsychoSuo9000]

you are so retarded.

[yvonnelaiZER]

no wonder jay and 宇豪 are such good friends!

:)

JAY <3

[matthewng911]

第145次睇lu= =

[firefox050]

wow really is 百看不厭

[puresniper]

visit welovejaychou^blogspot^com

[xCresSoul]

Isnt jay supposed to be the only one who is able to see Xiao yu? =.= how come she talking to another student @@..

[Rachymeow]

because that day xiau yu messed up on Seeing jay chou first instead of seeing jay chou first she saw that girl, if you knwo what i mean

[winter5184]

oh that explains the counting of steps and opening of her eyes. Thanks

[UniversallDream]

so can, Jay Chou actually play piano this well??

[abzo]

yea...he got famous because of his piano skills, some ppl say

[winter5184]

oh that explains the counting of step and opening of her eyes. Thanks

[karhoe750813]

so, nobody knows the third song title?

can somebody help me to search? thanks so much...

[autumn0113]

根据野蜂飞舞改编的

[cdefgqqq]

no, this song has no title, coz it should be created by the people involved in this film...

[heartgrey]

it is a piece composed by 宇豪, probably inspired by the flight of bumble bee

[honkigirl]

我有1個問題耶...

故事不是說路小雨, 只有周董看到她的嗎?

為什麼在00:14 ~ 00:17的時候, 那個女的可以看得到她,還要跟她說話的呢??

[klaimck]

路小雨當是第一眼是見到那女孩,所以可以跟她說話

[honkigirl]

那如果路小雨第一眼看到的是那個女的...

不就是說周董看不到她了嗎??

[alexNCS]

小雨每来回一次就只有她看到的第一个人能看见她

而斗琴的那一段小雨见到的是那个女的

所以她们两个才能交谈

您注意的话，故事继续的时候周董会说"斗琴时你在吗？我怎么没看­见你？"

[albertsquare87]

这问题我也想了好久，你好厉害啊竟然回答了我好久以来所要找的答­案！！

[hitmancn01]

好厉害，这个细节你都注意到了！！！！我刚才看到这个片段的时候­也突然想到这个问题。因为舞会的时候明显晴依没有看见小雨

[waterleo1]

嗯

[albertsquare87]

还有的是，那段0:14~0.17的对话我好像没看过。我只看过­那个女的对小雨说:"他很可爱吧！" 这是什么会事？？

[albertsquare87]

哦哈哈是我不对，有那么一段对话没错没错！honkigirl 你仔细看那部电影，就在这段clip的 1 或 2 分钟前，小雨开眼看见的第一个人是那个女的，所以她们便可以对话­，以那个女的也当然可以看见她咯。。。

[honkigirl]

哈哈...謝謝大家的回答啦！辛苦大家！

現在我明白囉！嘻！^.^

[012JL]

他們沒說錯, 因為這一次小雨108步之後第一眼看到是晴依, 所以她們兩個可以對話

[ryomapple]

對嚕- -

劇情不是交代得很清楚了嗎...

這套劇最後部分小雨有說喔

[xuningsoser]

Joy Chou is the best songer !~~~~~

[sioudon]

字幕有錯....

是"即興"不是"琴技".......

[bightf01655]

恩對押哈哈

[blackred2007]

apparently guitar is much easier to pick up than piano, I guess that's part of the reason why so many guys know how to play the guitar today. Both are very attractive but I personally prefer piano.

[antimage27]

guitar is not easier to pick up...ive played the piano for 8 years and the electric guitar for 3 years..trust me guitar is hard to pick up but im not gonna debate over which is harder to master casue its not possible

[carefreemusic]

Well, guitar seems to be easier but for ur inofrmation, to pick up a classical guitar most ppl have to spend months to pluck properly. There are lots of unseen technique that u need to acquire. I play both instrument.

[bightf01655]

uhhh..... so? piano has a lot of different kinds of method the play it okay? the voicings the key positions al that kind cross over the freakin pluck, there is no way how to "properly" use it okay? the greatest artists dont even use the correct method

[carefreemusic]

yaya... did i ever say piano is easy to play...? chilled...

[r215666f]

oh gawd, you are so wrong, i found guys who play the piano cute!!

nowadays, too many guys know how to play the guitar...too typical

[bightf01655]

that makes me feel good lol i play the pianoXDD

[antimage27]

piano is such a lame instrument to get chicks ....try the guitar

[huibin1986]

So u are learning an instrument to get chicks?

[bightf01655]

lol no i like playing the piano for fun because i like to hear it

[nicemocha]

Shut up you dumbass. Piano is an elegant instrument, if you don't know how to appreciate it, fuck off. Dun come and insult it.

[antimage27]

woah..someone is mad LAWLZ

開個玩笑..那麼認怎幹嘛

[MonkeyBuzz99]

Does a anyone know what the title of the 3rd piece?

[PopeForADay]

Yeah, totally agree.

[DevilBesidesYou]

And thats YOUR opinion.

you may keep it to YOURSELF.

[g125]

So, I should keep my opinion to myself because it is my opinion....great logic lmfao. Do you even know what the fuck you're saying?

Damn, what a twat.