Are the Wives of the Prophet part of Ahlul bait?

[gytruf360]

in the ayat vefore for womens of the prophet it used the letter N ( nun) in arabic because the nun is for feminin and then when it goes to ahlulbayt there is no nun that means its not the wifes of the prophet

[MosesAbbas]

YOU NEED TO STOP FOLLOWING HADITH AND LEARN ARABIC AND READ THE QURAN PROPERLY! STOP SLYING 2 PEOPLE ABOUT "THIS VERSE MEANS THIS" U GIVE YOUR OWN TRANSILATION OF THE QURAN! HADITH IS NOT QURAN I CANNOT GO BY HADITH! I CAN ONLY GO. BY QURAN!

[MosesAbbas]

This person who posted this video is blatantly a Zionist agent! He forgot 2 mention how ALLAH flips on the wives of the Rasool in the quran ! WHY DIDN'T YOU MENTION THAT????? STOP THE HATE ON IMAM ALI (AS) ITS NOT OUR FAULT UR FOREFATHERS WAS IDOL WORSHIPPERS AND WERE SLAIN BY IMAM ALI(AS) IN WAR! THAT'S YOUR FAULT NOT HIS!!!! SO STOP THE HATE BECAUSE U HAVE ISSUES WITH YOUR BACKGROUND! U PRICK MAY ALLAH CURSE YOU AND YOUR PARENTS FOR YOUR CRAP!

[iglebanon]

Sahih Muslim Book 031, Number 5955

'A'isha reported that Muhammad went out one morning wearing a striped cloak of the black camel's hair that there came Hasan b. 'Ali. He wrapped him under it, then came Hussain and he wrapped him under it along with the other one (Hasan). Then came Fatima and he took her under it, then came 'Ali and he also took him under it and then said: Allah only desires to take away any uncleanliness from you, O people of the household, and purify you (thorough purifying)

[jojolocad]

what is this ? who said we have two ahel al baits its one ok!! am sure ur sunni like to destroy us but whim the prophet gave his daughter to ali and what does that mean he is part of the family thats ahil al bait any one whos desendent to the prophet family members wifes daughters sons every one from the fa,ily so please go read it more and more to understand the aya

[RoseBlossomGarden]

mashallah, a wife is more part of mans household than there married daughters family, it common sense, and allah tells it like it is. idiots, all you need is a quran and dictionary

[Biankoneri]

Shias are such hypocrites and murtadds. Whenever it fits them, they will refer to muslim/bukhari like madmen. But otherwise they reject any reference from the same sources. They spit on bukhari/muslim when there is proof against their filthy kufr. Tfou!

[lebmo]

may god curse you for the fitna you incite. you are victim to the ummayeh propaganda, so you claim alla purified ayesha with a thorough purification and yet she went on to fight the calipha of the time Ali, leading an army to kill muslims (battle of the camel) to which the punishment in islam is death, who is the hypocrit my ignorent brother? are you claiming allah failed? are you now gonna deny the testiment of all the islamic scholars recognition of her crime and add on new bits to your faith?

[Biankoneri]

Do you believe in bukhari/muslim or not? Why do you curse? It says in Bukhari:

312. 'Abdullah reported that the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, said, "A believer is not a defamer nor a curser nor coarse nor obscene."

315. 'Ubayd al-Kindi al-Kufi reported that he heard 'Ali ibn Abi Talib said, "The cursers are cursed."

313. Abu Hurayra reported that the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, said, "A person who is two-faced cannot be trusted."

:):)

[IMExtremist99]

@lebmo

May ALLAH Curse you ... and everyone who deny any verse of Quran...

[SalawatSalawat]

this guy is stupid ali hassan hussain and hassan are the family of muhamad.. we say allah huma sali 3ala muhamad wa ali muhamad.

peace be upon mohamad ( and the family of muhamad) and the family of imam ali a.s and the family of muhamad s.a.w are the same family..

[Biankoneri]

If ahl al-bayt is only the immidiate family of the prophet, how weird is it that the daugher of Ali was married to Omar?

[lebmo]

Zaid said: "No, by Allah! A woman lives with a man (as his wife) for a while; he then divorces her and she goes back to her parents and her people. The Ahlul-Bayt of the Prophet are his lineage and his descendants (those who come from his blood) for whom the acceptance of charity (Sadaqah) is prohibited."

[reloadedgenius]

video made by wahabi`s. no doubt whatever wahabi say doesnt affect shia`s and the REAL RESPECT of AHL UL BAIT a.s. which includes PANJETAN E PAK a.s.

wahabi`s doent want to respect even RASOOL SAW so what do you expect from them. RASOOL murda shaheed zinda, shia aalim have real knowledge that`s why they hate shia`s.

dushmanyan e ahl ul bait per lanat beshumar.

wahabi`s are nasl e yazeed o mawia o abu sufiyan ( lanat beshumar).

YA ALI MADAD a.s.

[Biankoneri]

yeah yeah, you paki son of a mutaa bitch. what do you know about sunni love for ahl al-bayt. thing is we love all of them, its the shia that hate ayesha amongst others.

[dandannoodles]

You need to learn some basic Arabic grammar. When Allah SWT talks about the verse of purification, there is a switch in gender. This is accepted by mainstream (non-nasibi) Sunni scholars as well, that the Ahlulbayt refers IN THIS CASE only to the holy five. Moreover, as you are apparently Sunni, you should check your own sihah books and see for yourself the tafsir of this verse. Many times rasul SAWA defines ahlulbayt as ONLY the holy five. Nice try though.

[Biankoneri]

definition of ahl al-bayt is the HOUSEHOLD of the prohet. That includes his wifes. Nice try nitwit

[LebIbrahim]

Am i among them, Of Prophet of Allah? He replied, You have your own position; you are in a good standing

[iglebanon]

@LebIbrahim

Masha'allah, proved this guy wrong with no problem at all. keep it up brother. salaam

[LebIbrahim]

(Sahih Al-Timidhi VOL.2/902) When the verse Surely Allah desires to remove all imperfection from you, of family of the house, and purify you completely [33:33] was revealed to the Prophet (S) in the house of Umm Salmah, He called Fatimah, Hassan, And Hussain, and coverd them with a cloak. Ali was behind him and the prophet covered him as well. Then he said, O Allah! These are the family of my house. Remove all imperfection from them and purify them completely! Umm Salmah said,

[LebIbrahim]

Ali Fatima hassan hussian are only ahel biat its know

[lebmo]

The Glorious Quran Chapter 2 Verse 207

And among men there is one who selleth his self ( soul ) seeking the pleasure of God; and verily, God is affectionate unto His (faithful) servants.

It is held unanimious by the Scholars of the two Islamic schools, that this verse was revaled for Imam Ali ( as )

[lebmo]

Sunni references

- Ghayatul Maryam, p 300

- Sahih Muslim, v 4 p 1285 ( English Edition), the tradition is as follows:

...( The third occasion is this ) when the following verse was revealed : Let us summon our children and your children. Allah's messenger (pbuh&f) called Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Hussain and said : O Allah, these are my family ...

[lebmo]

Glorious Quran Chapter 3 Verse 61

And unto him who disputeth with thee therein after the knowledge hath come unto thee, Say! ( O' Our Apostle Muhammad!) (Unto them) come ye, let us summon our sons, and (ye summon) your sons, and (we summon) our women and (ye) your women, and (we summon) ourselves and then let us invoke the curse of God on the liars!

[Lebanese28]

I have made a video explaining who Ahl Labyt are, according to Suni Traditions.

I hope you except the video response i posted..

This video that you have up, is in complete and shows no information or Tafseer concerning the Ayas that you have put up, you didnt use hadeeths to explain on when or why these verses where sent down, which is very esential to understanding the meaning behind them..

Except the video response I posted, and see who Ahl Labyt really are according to Suni traditions..

[Lebanese28]

I posted a video Response to your video...

SAlam

[AbdullahSaggaf]

this is the Wahabi view of ahlulbayt in that verse. and not the Sunni view.

[Biankoneri]

its the official view of the ahl al sunna. who are wahhabis?

[alhaqeem1]

Have quoted Hazrat Salma,Ayesha and Prophet's pbuh sayings,but u r calling them followers of Saba. Do not get angry,u have proved u r followers of muhayia'teachings so its hard to explain u. About muhayia, Ali a.s said he is Fitna on earth.

about wives,daughters r not added just ask Allah Tahalla or Prophet pbuh. Just read Hazrat Salma and Ayesha sayings.

This is very sad u r ignoring Sunnah.

Brother this is reason we muslim can not unite by calling each other kufar,what message we r giving?

[alhaqeem1]

Sahih Muslim about the saying of Hazrat Ayesha towards Ahl-ul bait. Only these r few narrations for Ahl-ul bait from Sunni scholars.

Quran does say about,Namaz,Fasting,Hajj etc but to perform all these farz,when,how, u need to see the sunnah of Prophet.

Quran does say Ahl-ul bait but u need to know who they referred to by reading the Hadiths of Prophet.

Also 4 ur knowledge,Ahl ul bait,means Muhammad,Ali,Fatima,Hassan and Hussain.

They r Prophet'sAhl-ul bait not Ali's one.

[AbuAbdullah11]

LOL >> the Quran made it clear in the ayah it says O Wives of the prophet >> and it refers to them as ahlul bait, what problem do u have with this regard? huh the hadith and the arabic langauge backs this. its ur beleif that is keeping u from accepting the truth. becuase the lies against these pious people are making u blind. u need to stop getting ur infos from followers of Abdullah ibn saba>> and what he said regarding them.

[iraqpride]

What do u have to say about Hadith al Kisaa' brother...

[Biankoneri]

what do you have to say about the ayats in quran al karim, brother?

[lebmo]

Sahih Muslim, Chapter of virtues of companions, section of the virtues of Ali, 1980 Edition Pub. in Saudi Arabia, Arabic version, v4, p1874, Tradition #37

[Biankoneri]

i thought shias dont believe in muslim/bukhari. arent all those hadith wahhabi false hadith? furthermore the text of the hadith you have given reference to, isincorrect. shias exchanged "sunna" with "ahlalbayt":

"O People, no prophet or apostle will come after me, and no new faith will be born. Reason well, therefore, O people, and understand words which I convey to you. I leave behind me two things, the Quran and my example, the Sunnah, and if you follow these you will never go astray."

[lebmo]

incorrect meaning u knw full well muslim and bukhari write them but you just dont agree with them? so were does it say sunna, oh bukhari?? ahlul bayt are only sunnah, as a wahabi u reject "sahih" bukhari/muslim? sunna is mentioned 1 time in all the sahih combined, ahlul bayt is mentioned numerous times, in one sunni hadith the prophet repeats my ahlul bayt my ahlul bayt my ahlul bayt, this you reject also? u want to pick and choose ur faith, Allah alone will and can judge you.salam

[Biankoneri]

i just gave you the whole hadith. i am not a wahabi you idiot. i dont reject any sahih hadith, only false hadith produced by shias. give the correct reference and text next time. why all of the sudden shias are such fans of bukhari and muslim? dont they know that ayisha" is the source of thousand of the hadith?

[lebmo]

you mean the same ayesha that fought the the calipha imam ALi (As) and ended up killing thousand of muslims? the same ayesha that alla threatend with divorce in sura 66?

Sahih al-Tirmidhi, as quoted in:

al-Durr al-Manthoor, by Jalaluddin al-Suyuti, v5, pp 605-606,198 under the commentary of Verse 33:33 of Quran

Sunni reference: Tafsir al-Tabari, v22, p7 under the commentary of verse 33:33

Sunni reference: al-Sawa'iq al-Muhriqah, by Ibn Hajar, Ch. 11, section 1, p220

[Lebanese28]

I posted a video Response to your video...

SAlam

[mdhussam]

@alhaqeem1 According to Quran Allah says ahle bait of prophet saw r only his wives... And married children will not come under a man's ahle bait.... So Allah dint include his married children i.e fatima r.a... But prophet saw loved his daughter so much tht he wants to include her in his ahle bait too.. And similarly prophet saw included family of aqeel r.a, abbas r.a in his ahle bait too...And alos sons of abu lahab in his ahle bait too...But true ahle bait as per Quran refers only to his wives.

[alhaqeem1]

U r not accepting both sunni &shia point of viiew about the true Ahl-ul-bait of Prophet pbuh.Who u believe muhayia,yazid,and their followers who tried their best to belittle the Ahl-ul bait by negative means,but they could not succeded.

Why u have ignored the sunnah of Prophet pbuh,which will explain u everything.Just READ THE FOLLOWING:

Imam hanbal in his book Musnad,229/2 about Umma Salma'saying about Ahl-ul bait.

In History of Baghdad by Ahmed bin Ali,about Ahl-ul bait. Cont...

[AbuAbdullah11]

haqem1 brother > do not throw accusation, right and left, the above was nothing but the ayah from the Quran. it seems u have somthing against the ayah which is clear as crystal in who ahlul bait really is. the arabic word ahlul bait is very clear, the sahabah were very clear in this mater, that the ahlul bait of muhammad saw, are his wives, sons and daghters. but u say the ahlul bait is only Ali, fatima, hassan and hussien, WHAT ABOUT THE REST OF HIS DAGHTERS AND WIVES?

[acquireNur]

shia think the mahdi is over thousand years old like prophet Noah

[AbuAbdullah11]

Akhi the so called mehdi of shia, is not the mehdi what muhammad saw said. thier mehdi is the dajjal. that he would kill the muslims, he would speak hebrew, that he would follow the law of david, he comes out when he gtes angry, he rather fights with Ahlus sunnah those who follow Quran wa sunnah. not against dajjal. thats why shia and jews in isfahan in iran, are waiting for thier masiyah, for shia its thier mehdi and for jews its thier misyah at the end of the day shia orginated from the jews

[acquireNur]

I love you ahki

[ibnarab]

JazakALLAH bi khair akhi, May ALLAH (SWT) reward you for your efforts!

[AbuAbdullah11]

barak Allahu feek ya akhi Ibnarabi. insha Allah we would be together in defending the um ul mumineen and the sahabah from these Rafidha. May Allah swt increase our knowledge and our ability to serve him in his deen ameen.