Interesting that they would change the original song structure slightly. I mean ... those little rhythmic touches were what made it interesting in the first place. 1:20 mark ... 2:00. Well, it's a live version after all.
There are some old Nightwish songs that Anette can sing. This isn't one of them. This song was specifically written to take advantage of Tarja's unique talents as a vocalist. There are songs like that, just like there are songs on Imaginaerum that would sound terrible if Tarja tried to sing them. Just appreciate them both for what they do, and enjoy their music.
im not even taking the time to talk about anette just because...she doesn't deserve my point of view...im pretty sure she doesn't even need my opinion as you all do....but whatever.....we all talk...IN MY OPINION....she is not the type of singer that nightwish needs...im pretty sure there's better singers...related to metal.I only can say that...NIGHTWISH...is not nightwish anymore...without tarja's voice...the whole band changed.
I'm done discussing this, we are clearly not going to agree if we're only insulting each other and not talking rationally. You clearly have your opinion of her awesomeness, I have my opinion of her queerness. That's that. If you still want to talk and do it rationally, you may message me.
You can't judge every fan on what you see. You think Tarja could do them? I don't think so. She's done songs that weren't operatic yes, but she turns them into operatic songs. Hun, no one cares how long ago the comment was made, you still said it. And I'm not telling you not to reply- I'm telling you that when you said, oh this is a shitty topic I don't want to talk about it- THEN DON'T TALK ABOUT IT. Easy as that. Learn how to read and write the English language if you're going to speak it.
Pop? Seriously? You're right, "7 Days to the Wolves" is a pop song. Up to me if I'm smart on whether or not Anette can sing? Okay, whatever. Do you sing? Do you teach it? I don't know how many of those you answered yes, probably not many. "Logically" Tarja couldn't do the new songs. And when I said crap- that ISN'T being disrespectful to the band. That's saying people need to get the hell over it. I wasn't calling the music crap- I was calling this behavior crap. Don't want to talk? Don't reply.
I don't care about this argument at all, but don't bring up Anette. Number 1- she has never sang this song and according to Tuomas, never will. Number 2- Why even bring up Anette on a Tarja video, honestly?
I don't understand why people can't love them both?! I loved Tarja with Nightwish, but face it- she's doing damn good on her own. And Anette isn't bad, she should get credit for putting up with this crap- remember: she wasn't the one who fired Tarja!
ahi que tener una muy buena voz para cantar esta cancion solo tarja lo puede hacer y es una muy buena persona nadie se queda 2 horas firmando y sacandose fotos con los fans(todavia no lo puedo creer)gracias tarja!!!!!!
Yea, I wonder... We can all agree, that the cooperation between Tarja and Nightwish ended very sudden (I don't want a discussion about this matter), and if that was me, then I don't think I would like to perform any of the songs I used to sing in that band. Performing a NW song live would probably involve getting in touch with some of the NW guys again, and for some reason, I can't imagine it happen. I guess I'm confused...
A part of me really hopes she sings this at the concert I'm going to, and another part of me is afraid I'll be sick if I watch her hired band slaughter the songs the NW guys do so well.
Yeah I know when i hear her voice i still miss her old one with Angels Fall first and Oceanborn....it is sad how it changed so dramaticly but it seem like it has been for her own best
Yes I agree..but her old voice sounded a bit more classical at least in the studio version...Tarjas voice is more clearer now and I think she still can grow much better if she take some more classics lessons and hire someone to help her practice her English because she deserves to be in the top not only in the Female Metal genre but with women like Sarah Brightman
Maybe thats true but Tarja deserves the amount of success that Sarah have reached in the music industry..Now since Tarja have a record deal with Universal Music I think she will be more known if she practice her english because bad english is something many americans and other people finds irritating..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
=( I was so happy to hear she was doing this one live... but it just doesn't sound as good as it did with NW... and by that I mean HER voice, she's lost the operatic touch that made her special. And that makes me really sad because I love her voice =(
@navinkc5 That "presence" you claim Sarah Brightman has is due to her being loads to full of herself! I like Brightman's work but I honnestly don't like her atitude and presence. Tarja is much, but much more humble what makes her shine in stage and on her videos. As for Sarah Brightman... well, look at her videos... they're more focused on herself then on the songs.
@raven333666 and tarja would fail like hell at singing "bye bye beautiful" every singer has their own pros and cons. dickweed.
metalkingdom100 2 weeks ago
Interesting that they would change the original song structure slightly. I mean ... those little rhythmic touches were what made it interesting in the first place. 1:20 mark ... 2:00. Well, it's a live version after all.
Loomr 1 month ago
She cannot sing Queen of the Night at all.
Supernature06 1 month ago
There are some old Nightwish songs that Anette can sing. This isn't one of them. This song was specifically written to take advantage of Tarja's unique talents as a vocalist. There are songs like that, just like there are songs on Imaginaerum that would sound terrible if Tarja tried to sing them. Just appreciate them both for what they do, and enjoy their music.
derkommissar1917 1 month ago 2
simplemente espectacular!!! =)
Juliblack88 5 months ago
wow! is she coloratura soprano?
777jokonda777 9 months ago 2
@777jokonda777 actually, she has a very wide range & can reach coloratura notes, too. But she is a lyric soprano, as she says in the interviews.
potterclubtv 6 months ago
Comment removed
jhjkhkjkjhjkhkjk 10 months ago
Her voice is so enchanting.
UihaAkiko12 1 year ago 3
I LOVE IT
SSALOLE 1 year ago
She sounds so good in this perfomance!
MsKanpan 1 year ago
AWESOME!...
never one rock/metal/symphonic singer like TARJA... her voice in this song is simply PERFECT!...
UltravioletSlave 1 year ago 2
She rocks in this song. Damn, she rocks in all songs!!!
hellclaw2 2 years ago 5
@ VIVODYLANGEORGES
Why did people give thumbs down to this comment? You were obviously continuing from your last post.
Next time type "continued" when you write a long response so people will know better.
PUFFYsaidgo 2 years ago
@ VIVODYLANGEORGES
"with this "crap!" wow you really respect the band"
That comment wasn't refering to the band. The "crap" was talking about all of the negative things said about Anette. Way to misinterpret.
PUFFYsaidgo 2 years ago
Супер видео! Nightwish лучшие!!!!
2:25 - 3:35 !!! ваще класс!
MyHeckfy 2 years ago
@MyHeckfy ну вообще-то это сольное выступление тарьи,а найтвиш выступают с другой вокалисткой
DrBlackra1n 1 year ago
im not even taking the time to talk about anette just because...she doesn't deserve my point of view...im pretty sure she doesn't even need my opinion as you all do....but whatever.....we all talk...IN MY OPINION....she is not the type of singer that nightwish needs...im pretty sure there's better singers...related to metal.I only can say that...NIGHTWISH...is not nightwish anymore...without tarja's voice...the whole band changed.
1Monikah 2 years ago 3
Well it's clear your opinion hasn't changed.
I'm done discussing this, we are clearly not going to agree if we're only insulting each other and not talking rationally. You clearly have your opinion of her awesomeness, I have my opinion of her queerness. That's that. If you still want to talk and do it rationally, you may message me.
LovingLife411 2 years ago
You can't judge every fan on what you see. You think Tarja could do them? I don't think so. She's done songs that weren't operatic yes, but she turns them into operatic songs. Hun, no one cares how long ago the comment was made, you still said it. And I'm not telling you not to reply- I'm telling you that when you said, oh this is a shitty topic I don't want to talk about it- THEN DON'T TALK ABOUT IT. Easy as that. Learn how to read and write the English language if you're going to speak it.
LovingLife411 2 years ago
Pop? Seriously? You're right, "7 Days to the Wolves" is a pop song. Up to me if I'm smart on whether or not Anette can sing? Okay, whatever. Do you sing? Do you teach it? I don't know how many of those you answered yes, probably not many. "Logically" Tarja couldn't do the new songs. And when I said crap- that ISN'T being disrespectful to the band. That's saying people need to get the hell over it. I wasn't calling the music crap- I was calling this behavior crap. Don't want to talk? Don't reply.
LovingLife411 2 years ago
Let's not get too excited now children.
I don't care about this argument at all, but don't bring up Anette. Number 1- she has never sang this song and according to Tuomas, never will. Number 2- Why even bring up Anette on a Tarja video, honestly?
I don't understand why people can't love them both?! I loved Tarja with Nightwish, but face it- she's doing damn good on her own. And Anette isn't bad, she should get credit for putting up with this crap- remember: she wasn't the one who fired Tarja!
LovingLife411 2 years ago 2
that's so true...
govnetina3 2 years ago
ahi que tener una muy buena voz para cantar esta cancion solo tarja lo puede hacer y es una muy buena persona nadie se queda 2 horas firmando y sacandose fotos con los fans(todavia no lo puedo creer)gracias tarja!!!!!!
neliperes 2 years ago 2
love this version
Legume666 2 years ago 4
The best voice in all this fucking planet!
XvampireXcarrieX 2 years ago 17
she's really good also at live!!! really fantastic!!!! i love her voice!!!!
4eSaintSeiya 2 years ago 43
This has been flagged as spam show
Yea, I wonder... We can all agree, that the cooperation between Tarja and Nightwish ended very sudden (I don't want a discussion about this matter), and if that was me, then I don't think I would like to perform any of the songs I used to sing in that band. Performing a NW song live would probably involve getting in touch with some of the NW guys again, and for some reason, I can't imagine it happen. I guess I'm confused...
TurtleofRhoar 3 years ago
Comment removed
TurtleofRhoar 3 years ago
A part of me really hopes she sings this at the concert I'm going to, and another part of me is afraid I'll be sick if I watch her hired band slaughter the songs the NW guys do so well.
blackirises 3 years ago 6
i love her voice...
i really love her!!!!
the goddes of the music
moised96 3 years ago 10
wow!!!!!!!!! listen the voice of this woman, she is very good, very powerfull and full of passion love her..
maartjaana 3 years ago 6
Tarja the best
DarkPassionPlay74 3 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and she would do that for loving the fans and singing? of course she is doing it for money!
or do you, dear youtube fan, mail her food every week?
userneime 3 years ago
Yeah I know when i hear her voice i still miss her old one with Angels Fall first and Oceanborn....it is sad how it changed so dramaticly but it seem like it has been for her own best
Epica90 3 years ago 7
i personally find her better now...the old voice was amazing too but it was not so clear and not versatile
kotopoulo13 3 years ago 2
Yes I agree..but her old voice sounded a bit more classical at least in the studio version...Tarjas voice is more clearer now and I think she still can grow much better if she take some more classics lessons and hire someone to help her practice her English because she deserves to be in the top not only in the Female Metal genre but with women like Sarah Brightman
Epica90 3 years ago 4
but she's already better than sarah!sarah has only good voice in contemporary music!her classical techniques suck ass...
kotopoulo13 3 years ago 7
Maybe thats true but Tarja deserves the amount of success that Sarah have reached in the music industry..Now since Tarja have a record deal with Universal Music I think she will be more known if she practice her english because bad english is something many americans and other people finds irritating..
Epica90 3 years ago 5
and Sarah sings spanish too, i herard her first in a Mexican soap opera xD
lpevanescence 2 years ago
tarja rocks!!!!!
amy26250305 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
=( I was so happy to hear she was doing this one live... but it just doesn't sound as good as it did with NW... and by that I mean HER voice, she's lost the operatic touch that made her special. And that makes me really sad because I love her voice =(
cuddlykraken 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sounds out of breath here...
or is that just me?
Infinitypart2 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yea!
its not just you
she fitted with nightwish, right?
of course she did! with edited album version helping her!
she is not a godess...thats blasphemy
she is not a "siren"
nor an angel of music.
userneime 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Of course she isn't.
The Angel of Music is Sarah Brightman.
navinkc5 3 years ago
The Angel of Music Sarah Brightman? Tarja's MUCH better than Sarah Brightman.
Don't get me wrong, I like Brightman, it's just that Tarja's better. ; )
inukikyo89 2 years ago 2
@inukikyo89
i agree. tarja's voice is divine.
clintdiamante99 2 years ago 3
To each his own =). I personally prefer Brightman, I think she has a better stage presence too.
navinkc5 2 years ago
There's no need to bring Brightman up. Tarja has a great stage presence...
Despite the fact that Tarja totally killed her on Phantom of the Opera, there aren't too many comparisons.
inukikyo89 2 years ago 2
Haha..like I said, we're entitled to our own opinions.
navinkc5 2 years ago
@navinkc5 Stage prescence? No way, Tarja owns her in that category.
Fucklesticks 2 years ago 2
@navinkc5 That "presence" you claim Sarah Brightman has is due to her being loads to full of herself! I like Brightman's work but I honnestly don't like her atitude and presence. Tarja is much, but much more humble what makes her shine in stage and on her videos. As for Sarah Brightman... well, look at her videos... they're more focused on herself then on the songs.
YouAreLost2 1 year ago
Wonderful!! colaraturas!!! Tarja rulezz!!! listen her record in 3:27 minute!!! she sing a mi5 in stacatto!!!:O
liricobarroco 3 years ago 5
tarja always giving your best she is wonderfull...congratulations....
this yeah.......the perfect tarja
hanzzke 3 years ago 5